Dominated. Got there at 4pm for dinner so service was great, wouldn't expect that to change with the crowd. Food was FANTASTIC! We didn't have drinks but would assume they would match everything else. Worth it! read more

Delicious drinks and food! Service was good! Visited around 6/15/23. Atmosphere was AMAZING. Went during a "slow" time for them only 15 tables max during our visit. Very wonderful, will definitely be back when we revisit the area. read more

Service staff were great. The presentation and quality of the food were fantastic. Ate there for breakfast and dinner both days of our stay at the renaissance hotel. Have nothing negative to say. On the pricey side but the quality of the dish and presentation were what you would expect at that price point. The decor is nice and great for couples. read more

Two words for this place: bad management I made reservations for Christmas dinner here and chose the 4:30 seating time. The menu looked great and I was excited for the dinner. However the minute we stepped into the restaurant we knew we would be in for a bad time. The line to check in at the host stand wrapped around the bar. Given that it was Christmas and we were unlikely to get in anywhere else we got in line. We waited over 20 minutes in line. As we neared the front, I noticed the host stand was handing out green tickets to each party. I was puzzled as to why a restaurant would be giving out raffle tickets for a Christmas dinner and I really never got an answer after I approached the host stand due to the confusing interaction I had. We gave the host our name once we got to the stand. She told us we needed to pay before we were seated and that gratuity would be included. I was a bit annoyed because this was never mentioned to me while I was booking the reservation. She gave us the green tickets and set our card in a line of 4 other cards waiting to pay for the dinner. We then were told to wait for our card to be charged before we could be seated. By this time, it's 5:00 and we are still nowhere near being seated for our 4:30 reservation. As we're waiting, we overhear something about alcoholic beverages not being served in the dining room. We ask the hostess who says she's not sure but she thought that we would need to leave the dining room and go to the (crowded) bar to order alcoholic drinks with our meal. Again she said she wasn't sure but I could ask someone (not specifying who). At that moment we decided that it wasn't worth paying nearly $200 for this dinner and took our card and left. After reading reviews from the unlucky diners who stayed, I am so glad I left. Luckily, I found a bar that was selling burgers otherwise I don't know what I would've done for dinner as I was on vacation and was not in a position to cook. Management so clearly needs to be replaced or retrained. I felt bad for the hostesses who really had no clue what was going on either. Suggestion for next time: take payment information on the phone at the time of booking or hire more servers to handle the busy day. Might have gone smoother if they treated the dinner like a buffet and had normal reservation times throughout the day. I will certainly not be back. read more

Absolutely in love with Castillo Kitchen Bar. Great service, location, food & they always have seating available. Very accommodating.

We loved Castillo and visited it more than once during our visit to St. Augustine. I highly recommend the smoky blackberry margarita and old fashioned. They have the best cocktails we had during our week long trip. Also, they cook the salmon absolutely perfect and it is delicious on the stone fruit salad. April is a delight and made us at home and helped provide entertainment for the kids. We cannot wait to return. We loved Castillo. Be sure and tour the beautiful hotel while you're also there. read more

We had the best meal here and fantastic service the entire evening. The cocktails were delicious, menu had something for everyone, and we really enjoyed all of our appetizers and meals. Everyone was so friendly and helpful throughout the night and we will definitely be returning again! read more

We enjoyed Friday - Saturday and Sunday Nigbt ! Amazing Craft Cocktails and Wine Options ! Fun Cozy Atmospher and Friendly Staff Food was amazing the Olives - Hummus- Lemon Chicken - Bone In Ribye - Truffel Fries - and the best desert ever - Pretzel cake !! read more

See all

Fantastic Cocktails and atmosphere. Don't let the outside of renaissance hotel fool you. Very modern inside.

Perhaps one of the best meals have had in Florida... Honey Glazed Salmon hats off to chef Michael! Absolute return to.

Had a good time with good food w my family, def will come back , the service was good and the ambiance was nice!

WOW, just happened to walk past this place last night and decided to have drinks and dinner. Had a very great time. Food was fresh and very good, drinks excellent, and our waiter William was outstanding and very professional. He really made sure we were relaxed and he was on point throughout our dinner. The 8 years in the dessert Red Zen was an added bonus. Very interesting wines on the list. Great selection of Spanish wines with a great selection of interesting bottles. Great rustic and modern decor. It was also interesting to see fresh grown micro-greens on display!! A+ guys! read more

Food & service were excellent. Husband ordered the swordfish tacos. They came loaded with swordfish, which is not typical for fish tacos.

Horrible breakfast experience. First, the breakfast menu tried to be something they are not - special. We ordered the " Breakfast Sandwich" that was a biscuit sandwich with eggs, cheese and ham, which some apple butter. The sandwiches were impossible to eat as a sandwich because the biscuit disintegrated when you touched it. The ham was over cooked and so salty it over powered the whole sandwich. The worst breakfast sandwich I ever purchased. It was a mess in the first 5 seconds and not edible. We asked for a different menu item "avocados toast". This was loaded with avocados, mix of cherry tomatoes and what looked to be red sweet baby peppers, topped with some sprouts. The peppers were not sweet they were habaneros! First bite put me into a pretty good sweat. We picked them out and finished the sandwich. I could help but think these were put into my meal on purpose after complaining about the sandwich. Peppers are not listed on the menu and certainly not habaneros! Very disappointing service in general and would never recommend. read more

Had a bridal brunch here and was so thankful I did. The server was prompt and kind, he catered to all of our needs. The food was delicious and everyone had the best time! read more

Most hotel connected restaurants never make the the cut - and this one doesn't either. It simply fails on so many counts. On arrival should have been our first hint - plenty of tables on a Saturday night in the height of the season. Our second hint, their computerized beverage menu . Please, separate your wines by glass from bottles. Secondly, when viewing by country you say you offer Italy and Spain- but you offer a French selection . ok not a big deal but speaks to attention to detail. Third hint, no champagne so we order Kir Royal. The nice young waiter, has no idea what we are talking about. He offers to check with bartender and yay , they have it. we can doctor their two poor sparkling wine selections. We order steak Satay with peanut sauce , we get Shish Kabob with roasted peanuts . Tough unseasoned meat . It gets returned. Following is pork belly bao buns. The buns are toasted - not steamed , the sauce obviously canned . This is by no means a scratch kitchen. This is a " Sysco" kitchen - pre packaged food and sauces . Unfortunately, even this was not executed well. All and all it's just poor menu execution. All and all this is a typical hotel restaurant from food to service. There are very few hotels that exude rest prowess And this one doesn't either . read more

Absolutely outstanding! If you love short ribs, OMGoodness these are among the best I've had. The key lime martini was a delish accoutrement to the whole thing surprisingly. Chef said it's a two day process! This is one I'd come back to eat. What a great surprise in St Augustine! read more

Had very good dinner today. Food was served hot and was very tasty with some creative twists. Service was excellent. Drinks were good and fairly priced. Overall much better than typical restaurant associated with a hotel. Highly recommended to non guests as well as guests. Five stars read more

When I asked a friend for recommendations of where to eat in St. Augustine this was one of her top choices and it was perfect. My daughter and I shared the fried green heirloom tomato salad and the almond and coconut crusted mahi. Both were absolutely delicious. I especially loved the roasted tricolor cauliflower that was served with the fish. We also requested a side of cilantro rice which was the best I've ever tasted. It was a beautiful night so we chose to eat on the patio. The service was excellent. read more

We stayed right across the street. We wanted breakfast and used Google to find a place. This had amazing reviews from the staff to the food. Our experience was anything but what the reviews said. We sat down(5 of us-1 being a 7yr old who gets his order placed for him). Ordered drinks. Water and OJ came out within 5 mins. No coffee or sweet tea for the guys. Ask waiter, yes its coming. 10 mins go by and nothing. Ask again and find out their coffee pot is down and has been for 2 days and they're getting coffee from next door at starbucks(but it only takes 30 seconds according to waiter). Finally coffee comes, we inquire about sweet tea..well we don't have any cause our coffee pots are down so we don't have tea either‍ . We order our breakfast. 2 eggs, sausage, bacon, RED SKIN POTATOES, and toast. One of our party asks for scrambled eggs. Waiter asks if she wants cheese. Reply is no thank you. Also asks for toast on separate plate due to gluten allergy(not gf lifestyle). Food comes, scrambled eggs WITH CHEESE, hashbrown patties, not RED SKIN POTATOES. Hashbrown patties contain gluten. The waiter insists "their potatoes do not have flour in them and its fine to eat" Ask for ketchup for my hashbrown triangles. Wait patiently for 10 minutes and then another from our party asks again. It finally comes. For the $70 for 4 eggs, 4 pieces of sausage, 4 pieces of bacon, 2 pieces of toast and 4 mini pancakes(kids menu), a coffee and an OJ it was not worth it at all. Next time we will walk a ways and find a chain or a gas station and eat a muffin sandwich that has sat under a hot lamp for a few hours. So disappointed. And no we didn't reach out to manager, we just wanted out of the chaos. Also if you do visit..OJ is 4.50 and a soda is 5.00 so get the OJ! read more

I've been to the bar a few times and have loved the interaction I've had with the bartenders. The guy that works there is not as friendly, especially after I heard him talking bad about other customers, commenting on a woman's weight and appearance is not cool. The other problem I have is with a male manager, Lane, I believe. He's very disrespectful to his employees, verbally, in front of customers. Makes very.. should I say.. unsavory.. innuendos to customers and staff. This has happened every time i've been in, not just once. Customers have complained to him directly about the male bartender and he just blows it off.. doesn't do anything about this guys comments. If i was in human resources with Marriott, he would have been gone a long time ago. I honestly don't see how he keeps employees. The only saving grace at that bar, and the reason i've gone back, is the younger woman that works there and the taller blonde guy. I really enjoy the interactions i've had with them. If neither of them are there, i just don't bother staying. read more

We had a date night mid-week for the first time at Castillo. This is exactly what St. Aug. Needed in an upscale restaurant. Valet parking only, superior appetizers, ice cold, top shelf beverages, decadent main dishes-- we had coconut shrimp for app, i had the honey glazed salmon! We're going back! read more

Excellent dining experience. The food and drinks were incredible and our server William was warm and friendly.

We came to visit St.Augustine. We have been here several times before (14) we were looking for a new places to visit. We found this restaurant it has been open for around six months according to what they told us. The food is just amazing. It is a place you must visit when you come to St. Augustine. Start with complimentary valet parking, Very courteous welcoming service. Our waitress did a fantastic job and to top it up the food was just out of this world, the taste, the texture everything came together for an amazing and delicious food experience. Prices are a lot less of what we expected I will definitely come here again and highly recommend this restaurant for everyone coming to St. Augustine read more

See all

While looking for a place to eat we accidentally ended up at this place and we were pleasantly surprised with the ambiance, warmth of welcoming staff and specially the food. Some of the items were unique in preparation and better in taste. read more

Nice atmosphere, decent service, limited menu, ok food, for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Nice bar with good, large screens for watching sports events. Right next to Renaissance hotel. read more

What a fun place!! The food is amazing and the female bartender is young but makes an amazing drink! Not sure where you found her, but she's definitely a talented person. Really nice, polite and makes great suggestions for both food and beverages. Great atmosphere and comfortable place to hang out after a long day of exploring. read more

One word:wow. Really good food very good service. This place is new but very clean. It's on the high side price wise but if you leave hungry it's on you. We tasted several dishes which jacked up the price but the flavors were outstanding. The ribeye was very tastey. They have a decent range of various meals. Again it's not cheap but you get what you pay for. Kudos read more

When people come to St Augustine and look for restaurants, they don't think of those restaurants located in hotels. Today we went to Castillo located in the Renaissance Hotel on San Carlos. What a hidden gem. Great craft cocktail menu and reasonably priced compared to other downtown St Augustine restaurants. I had the old Fashioned which was a good pour with a dirty cherry- highly recommended. For dinner we selected the bucatini pasta with clams and mussels. The pasta was served Al dente and loaded with fresh seafood. We also selected the fish and chips, as recommended by Will our server. I am so glad. This is the best fish and chips I have eaten in St Augustine. A nice light batter coating a thick piece of Cod. Yummy. The portions were large so no room for dessert. However, the manager described them so well I wish I had ordered. Next time I will make sure to have room. We will definitely be back again. Great food, beautiful ambiance, I highly recommend. read more

See all

Located inside new Renaissance Hotel. Valet parking available for bar/restaurant. First impressions based on high-end dinning expectations were not good. No table covers, poor acoustics, no complementary bread as typically expected in this market. Appetizers were great; taste and quantity above expectations. Entries included burgers/sandwiches. Actual meal selection is limited. Quality is good and adequate portions. Dessert menu typical. Service is above-average which is expected. Overall very adequate, but disappointing due to location in high-end Marriott Hotel. Suggest one fills up on appetizers! read more

Dinner service was great, and the food was well prepared. Sylvia was a phenomenal manager. -- I can't say any of the same things about breakfast the next morning though. Our waitress rushed us to order as if we wouldn't get food unless we spoke immediately, and then we found out that at 8:30am the kitchen had already run out of sticky buns. The breakfast was subpar and disappointing- as was the service. Honestly, only go to dinner here- and make sure Sylvia is working. read more

I went to your place with my family last night to try a local venue. I should have walked out when I encountered the owner/matre de at the Restuarant desk. The man was as rude as they get, especially considering that the place was almost empty. That man's attitude alone will kill the Castillo soon. Maybe his bad attitude it works in elite places in New York or LA. But here in St Augustine we like pleasant attitudes where we spend our money. Nevertheless me being an adventurous, open-minded man we sat down for your food. The steak had lots of gristle, the burger was horrible. your Italian pasta chicken dish was too tough to finish, Your french-fries were frozen crinkle cuts with a bunch of seasoning. Your only redeemable dish was the salad. Your drink were light weights for the price with very small glasses .You had no basics like cherries or fresh fruit cut for your drinks. Your a poor quality place, way over priced with a manager with a bad attitude. You do not like locals eating at your place, Good luck with your business model of a bad attitude with cheap food and drinks way overpriced. I will never return. I advise other locals to follow my lead. read more

We made a reservation for brunch and found out they don't serve brunch! Thankfully we had arrived about 25 minutes early and asked to be seated just for breakfast. They cleared a table and sat us after about 6-8 minutes. We were never offered coffee or water. No one ever came to the table to check in with us. A couple who was seated after us was immediately offered water and a server checked in with them. We realize the restaurant was short staffed, but it seems they could have done much better. We waited another 8 minutes and finally just left. We were disappointed and hungry. read more

Went here for dinner on the 31st on New Years. Service was good, until the end! We were a party of 10, spent over $600 and were denied dessert because it was 10:15, and it closes at ten. When we requested a desert menu, the waitresses response was "the kitchen will not be happy." Then, we asked to see the manager and they had no manager on shift. So then we asked to see the chef, and he said "We could only offer cheesecake and ice cream." Needless to say, we will no longer stay at this property and we will be taking our business to the Casa Monica Resort. read more

What a great place to have dinner! Food was fantastic, service was absolutely great! The Staff and Chef were amazing!! Loved dining here will absolutely be going again!! read more

We enjoyed having drinks at the bar and moving to dining room. Olive appetizer was tasty, unique and more than enough for two. Mussels came in a hearty broth. Good entree options at reasonable prices. Friendly staff throughout. Good price points on the wine list. read more

As a local, we try to visit all the newest of restaurants. We have held off on this one because typically as a hotel restaurant we are not pleased. Boy were we wrong on this one! My girlfriend and I decided to try this one out. We had a wonderful evening with Kristen as our server. She was very helpful and put up with a million questions and concerns. The food was incredible! With 6 of us there was a wide variety of options. The favorite was the Brussel sprout app and the roasted red pepper hummus! Generous portions amd very tasty! I had the fish and chips! Cooked to perfection served with house made cocktail sauce and ruemolade and cole slaw...each one so yummy! I was quite jealous of the pasta dish...bucatinni with clams and seafood with a beautiful sauce. I am going back just to get that! Then the 2 shared deserts....chocolate pretzel cake with vanilla ice cream and a chocolate lave cake with a chocolate chip ice cream sandwich on top! Very dedicate! So good, but we couldn't finish them! Loved every dish, salmon, burgers and fresh grilled veggies! Can't wait to come back! read more

Had dinner. Both had the salmon, it was perfect. I also had the wedge salad it was very good. Had 2 dirty martinis, Titos they were perfect. Service was quick and friendly. We ate in bar area. read more

Came here the other night with my girlfriend, beautiful interior design. Menu is versatile and not what I was expecting out of a hotel restaurant. She ordered lobster Mac and cheese and I went with the espresso rubbed bone in porkchop, we both loved our dishes. Will be back soon. read more

Great food and service! We went there for dinner and it was amazing, will definitely come back!