We had a wonderful dining experience at Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen. The prime rib was cooked perfectly and absolutely delicious, and the Caesar salad was excellent as well. For drinks, my husband enjoyed the Smoked Old Fashioned, and I had the Maracuyá Margarita. Mine was a little on the sweet side, but still very enjoyable and refreshing. Our server, Grayson, was attentive, friendly, and provided outstanding service throughout our meal. The manager also stopped by our table to check on us, which was a nice touch and showed that they genuinely care about their guests' experience. He was very friendly and welcoming. Great food, great drinks, and exceptional service. We will definitely be back! read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

My sisters and I had the pleasure of dining at the beautiful restaurant inside the Renaissance Hotel, and it was such a wonderful experience. The space itself is stunning--spacious, beautifully designed, and perfectly lit, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that immediately sets the tone for a great meal. What really stood out was how fairly priced everything was considering the quality of the food, presentation, and overall ambiance the restaurant provides. It truly feels like you're getting a high-end dining experience without feeling overcharged. The service was excellent--our server was kind, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the evening. We started by sharing the fried Brussels sprouts, and they were absolutely delicious. They were perfectly al dente with just the right balance of heat and sweetness. Honestly, they were so good that I left thinking I need to learn how to make them myself. For our entrées, the truffle chicken was incredibly flavorful and well prepared, and the braised beef was an obvious winner--tender, rich, and perfectly done. Overall, it was a fantastic dining experience with great food, a beautiful atmosphere, and attentive service. Easily a 10/10, and I would absolutely come back again. read more

See all

An evening at Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen felt like stepping into a refined culinary escape right in the heart of historic St. Augustine. Tucked inside the Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel, this beautiful restaurant pairs warm, elegant ambiance with attentive, welcoming service that immediately sets the tone for a memorable dining experience. We began with cocktails that were as thoughtfully crafted as they were visually striking. The Smoked Gold Fashion delivered deep, smoky bourbon notes from Elijah Craig Small Batch balanced by house-made simple syrup and bitters, finished with a fragrant orange peel and cherry that rounded every sip with warmth and complexity. The Citrus Grove Margarita was bright and refreshing, built on Corazón Blanco with freshly squeezed lime and a vibrant house citrus simple syrup, gently sweetened with agave for a clean, sun-kissed finish. The starters arrived and instantly impressed. The crab cakes were beautifully seared with a delicate, sweet crab interior and a lightly crisp exterior, paired with a creamy, spicy remoulade that added just the right kick. The Castillo shrimp cocktail elevated a classic with plump, chilled shrimp served alongside a bold datil pepper cocktail sauce, silky remoulade, and a charred lemon that added a subtle smoky citrus pop. Entrées continued the indulgence. The steak and frites featured a tender, perfectly cooked steak draped in a rich port wine demi-glace, its deep savory sweetness complemented by golden truffle-parmesan fries that were crisp, aromatic, and impossible to stop eating. The dry-aged duck breast was luxurious and deeply flavorful, its confit richness balanced by a velvety potato purée that soaked up every drop of jus. Dessert sealed the evening with elegance. The chocolate mousse was airy and intensely chocolatey, layered with tart raspberry coulis and delicate raspberry caviar that burst with bright fruit notes. The key lime cheesecake was silky and vibrant with citrus tang, finished with graham crumble, pistachios, whipped cream, lime zest, and glossy key lime gel that delivered the perfect Florida-inspired finale. From cocktails to dessert, Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen delivers elevated coastal dining with polished service and a sophisticated atmosphere that makes every course feel special. A must-visit when exploring St. Augustine's historic district. read more

See all

Lovely restaurant located inside St Augustine's Renaissance hotel! Beautifully decorated with an incredible bar. Service was extremely attentive and kind. Loved the seaweed salad with the shrimp cocktail and our Chardonnay was delicious as well. Hope to be back soon to try more of their menu! read more

See all

I don't normally write reviews for special events such as Valentine's Day as I don't feel like they are representative of the entire experience on a regular day but I had such an amazing experience at this place that I have to write about it. First off, parking is impossible lol. This weekend there was no parking at the hotel and no valet parking so we needed to park across the street at the garage, which was fine and even though it was so busy we were still able to find a spot and walk back over. When we walked in and were shown to our table, I was handed a beautiful rose. The napkins were formed so that they looked like rosebuds as well. How cute! We weren't sitting far from the kitchen so we could see all the comings and goings of the server and watching the food come up. Our server Angelica was fantastic! Not only did she recommend some wonderful drinks she kept checking on us and kept us informed on any small delays in the food coming out. We decided on getting the special Valentine's Tasting Menu since it was for a limited time. We started with drinks, a West Indie Sour for me and the Sweetheart Spritz Sampler. My drink was tasty and I nursed it the entire meal. My fiance was very satisfied with the other bar drinks. The meal was awesome. I thought that the food would be too much for me to eat but it was actually just right. My favorite item? I wanted to say the Tuna Tartare (wakame salad, tuna, wasabi aioli, wonton crisp) but I think it was the Surf & Turf (1855 Kansas City Strip Steak, prawns, potato puree, broccolini, chimichurri, datil cocktail sauce, spicy remoulade). The manager visited our table 4 times and shook our hands on our way out. What an amazing dining experience. Definitely recommending! read more

See all

SO and I stopped here for an amazing breakfast. Our breakfast was made to order with great ingredients and presented well. The coffee is pretty good, too. read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We were staying at the hotel and came to the Castillo restaurant for breakfast. It was a nice place. Service: Our waiter, Frederick, was excellent. There was a large, private party there and he apologized for the longer than usual wait for our food. He provided great recommendations and checked in on us often. Food: I had the old fort breakfast Sammy, my husband had the buffalo chicken bowl, and my son had the kids pancakes. Frederick recommended I get the sandwich with the apple butter on the side since it could be overpowering. I'm glad I did, but it was nice to add some to the sandwich. The biscuit was a bit dry without any type of sauce or butter on it, so I did feel like it needed something. Otherwise, the sandwich was good and the roasted potatoes were crisp. My husband enjoyed the flavors and textures of the buffalo bowl. read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Old Fort Breakfast Sammy - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Went there for valentines day and from beginning to end we had a wonderful experience. Food, service etc. All was fantastic and had a really nice vibe. Try the valentines day menu and it was wonderful. All the food was great and very satisfying. I look forward to going again and enjoying the other meals and beverages they have. read more

See all

First Yelp review of 2026!! Always looking for new places to eat. I am apart of a group on Facebook and this was recommended. The food was well cooked well seasoned. The service was extremely helpful, the food came out on time. The ambiance was amazing. I ordered the short ribs, the award winning short ribs, they were great. My wife ordered the blackened flounder, also great!! 5 stars!! read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - First "Yelp" of the year - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We were unaware when we made the reservation that this restaurant was inside of the Renaissance hotel so when we discovered this we honestly weren't expecting the fabulous meal we had. We ordered the birria braised short rib with street corn risotto and seasonal vegetables and the spinach & artichoke stuffed airline chicken. I switched out the polenta cake it came with for the potato purée and I'm glad I did. It was delicious and the perfect complement to the chicken. My only complaint is the portion size. I don't eat a lot so it was fine for me but if that were my daughter or brother, they would've been left hungry. My wife said the birria braised short rib was one of the best meals she's ever had in her life, and that's saying a lot! read more

See all

this place was great had some drinks before venturing the town this place is really cool and has that fun old feeling because it really is! Will go back here every time I come back to Sf. Augustine read more

Great service. Amazing Christmas decorations. Stand out drinks and appetizers. Enjoyed the crudo and tartar especially. read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Smoked Old Fashion - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

This was a classy hidden spot in St. Augustine. You are able to park free in the garage if eating in the restaurant which is ideal for downtown. We had a nice spot close to the front. I will say the lighting was a bit dark which would be great for romance but we were having a girls night. Service was nice. We did the charcuterie board and Brussels which were delicious!! I had the short rib which is what they are known for. Amazing!! Melt in your mouth amazing!! Will come back for a date night soon. read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Braised Short Ribs - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Delicious! They were very accommodating for our large party and the service was still great and fast! Located right before downtown, this place was very nice and the food was great!! All of the food and drinks we ordered were amazing! Would definitely recommend! read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Bourbon Glazed Salmon* - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We were walking around d before doing an evening tour and found this place to eat. We had zero expectations before trying it out and it wasn't bad. The place is very cute sort of modern Spanish-ish vis I think they are going for. It was Avery quiet inside and not very busy. We had the Spanish French onion soup which was okay. Not that memorable it it had a twist to it. We had the Spanish Cesar salad with shrimp and it was okay. The shrimp had tails so made it a little more difficult to eat the salad. Finally had the streak frites. The steak was no cooked medium rare but it had a great sear on it. The fries were good so not bad. Overall it is an a solid 3. I think it is isn't bad, it isn't a chain and the food is fresh. Would I go back right away naw. read more

Terrible experience. They were out of the duck, artichoke dip, AND chimichurri. 4 of us ordered the steak + frites which comes with chimichurri, the plates come out and the chimichurri is missing. They were all out and we were not told, we asked for any sort of substitute or even a discount and they gave me a bottle of A1 steak sauce. My girlfriends steak was also half the size of mine. Despite a portion of the menu not being available and one of our friends hating the papperadale pasta, they did not offer any comps or substitutions. Highly recommended looking elsewhere to eat. read more

We booked dinner here and were coincidentally staying at the hotel. I saw that this restaurant had great reviews and wanted to check it out before I realized it was attached to the Marriott Renaissance. It was delicious and I would recommend it even if you're not staying at the hotel! We started at the bar and got the smoked old fashioned and the Matanzas Mist! Both were equally delicious! When we sat, our waiter Graham, was so helpful! He helped us pick out the Spanish Onion Soup, the Chopper Caesar del Castillo, and the Citrus Slow-Braised Short Rib. The croutons on the Caesar were some of the best we ever had, as they were perfectly crunchy, but still soft enough to cut. Then the short rib is award-winning, and it was easy enough to see why! It was amazing! We mentioned in our reservation that it was our anniversary, and Graham brought us out glasses of champagne to celebrate! It was an amazing evening and we will definitely be back! read more

Food was ok. Service inside great. Ambiance kinda cool. The bad part. Bad signage for parking. Parked in valet only. No valet. Oh wait another entrance for valet. Nearer the restaurant. Asked the hostess went back out. Your keys. Um no I parked and then walked here and I don't want you driving my car. It isn't the tip either. More than half empty everywhere. My partner said don't make a scene the manager I guess overheard. Is there an issue? Yeah I don't want valet. Oh you can park in the garage. Welll garage ain't free and we dropped over $200 on your empty mediocre restaurant. No matter not coming back. Valet boy telling me he can't let me get my own car. He didn't run to come park it. Menu pricey and very limited I settled on fish and chips. They were good but not $30 worth can get that anywhere. read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Dining toom - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Very cool place located in a hotel across from the parking deck in downtown st Aug. I loved the decor! We had a big group reservation come in one night and got wonderful service. We all loved the cocktails (we literally had all the cocktails on their menu between everyone and they were all good). Our food was good too. Forget what everyone had for their entrees but I had the salmon and my husband had the short rib. read more

Nice modern restaurant with a good vibe. Food quality very good and won't disappoint. Waiter was attentive to all our needs. read more

See all

The Costello's idea of Christmas cheer is charging a $6 service fee on top of a $15.00 bowl of soup (no rolls, more like a cup of soup) and a $15.00 glass wine. Shame on them. Will never go back. Disappointing. read more

This restaurant is located at the Renaissance Hotel in St. Augustine. A little off the main drag of bars and restaurants, but a higher end option. We were there for a friend's birthday with a party of 7. The service was excellent, especially for our group size! We ordered: The calamari and the brussels sprouts to start, both were excellent. I could not believe how massive the order of sprouts were so keep that in mind when ordering apps. Then we ordered several cocktails. The lavender bee's knees actually had no lavender in it, which seems misleading regarding the title and was not the most balanced cocktail considering the strength of the gin and elderflower flavor. Riesling, Moscow Mules, and white tea shots were also ordered and were great. For entrees we had several orders of the Salmon, the short rib and the bao buns. Everything was incredible except for the bao buns and the truffle fries. I was disappointed with the truffle fries as there was no flavor and they were quite bland. Overall good experience and would dine here again. read more

See all

Staying at the Renaissance hotel, we received breakfast at this restaurant. Nice atmosphere and vibe. Friendly servers. Not super fast food but very accommodating staff. The menu was very appealing and had some tempting choices. Omelette with spinach and tomatoes was large but overcooked and dry. The toast came unbuttered and they had to bring the butter, so it didn't melt. The Huevos Rancheros was different, no tortillas and no sauce. There were two eggs on a bed of chips with black beans, pico, and guacamole and oddly also came with buttered toast. French toast had the butterscotch syrup (extra sweet) and strawberries on top. The blueberry pancakes were thick and large (couldn't finish them) but a bit dry. The blueberries helped. So, solid choices, not perfect but worthy. read more

See all

We came in for a drink and an app. The bar tender, Johanna, was so friendly and made us both a great drink. Photo of his old fashion shown but my peachy keen was long gone. I would come back. She told us the dinner portions are large so be prepared to share. read more

Staying at the renaissance hotel, so decided to try this place since it's downstairs. The reviews and food pictures looked great. But I didn't share the same experience. For starters they didn't have the fried fish. They said they only had 2 and ran out. I then asked for the ribeye and they said they were also out. I was appalled at a restaurant being out of their main dishes on a Saturday night. The watermelon margarita was too spicy, didn't really enjoy it. I ended up ordering the NY strip, which was ok. Dinner for 4 was north of $200. Major disappointment and waste of money. If it wasn't because it was raining, I would've gone somewhere else; I left this place hungry. Don't let the pictures fool you. GO SOMEWHERE ELSE. read more

See all

Had breakfast here every morning for 5 days straight! Breakfast was always cooked to perfection and their breakfast potatoes were to die for! It's connected to the Renaissance Hotel and was never busy for breakfast. We were seated right away every time by the friendly staff. While we ate they gave us plenty of helpful recommendations of what to do and see around town. The restaurant was always clean and the environment was relaxing. We never felt rushed and it was a great spot to sit and enjoy a peaceful morning. Came back for drinks in the evening at the bar for a lively crew. They too gave us all the info for night life fun. Highly recommend the Espresso Martini. Started two evenings out with one of those drinks and it made for a fun evening! read more

My husband and I visited the Castillo Craft Bar for an after dinner cocktail experience, and they definitely delivered. Our mixologist warm and friendly. She took our first drink order of the two smoked cocktails on their menu; an old fashioned and margarita. After that she made us a couple off menu cocktails or customized a cocktail on the menu. We even received a complimentary lavender infused cocktail they are planning to add to their spring menu. Everything tasted great, and we would definitely come back. Thanks! read more

See all

I am a brunch snob and this is literally the only place I would go to in St Augustine for WEEKS in a row for Sunday Brunch. Great ambiance, service, and food. Unfortunately, they removed the nutella french toast from the menu though. I'm so disappointed. PLEASE BRING IT BACK!!! read more

Service - 5 stars Food - 1 at best We tried the ribeye ($65) and it was disappointing on an unexpected level. From the gloopy potatoes to the curdled mushroom sauce, definitely not a place I would revisit. read more

We had a really great bartender but they definitely didn't staff properly for how popular this spot gets. All our drinks were really good but there were some big question marks on food we ordered. We got the steak satay app and it comes with a salad... however the salad was saltier than the Dead Sea. It was inedible which for the price point was tragic. Overall there were high and lows but they need to help their bar staff out. read more

I hate it when the place is almost empty and they don't offer me a nice table. I get it that servers have sections but it was a very small place. We went there because it was raining and we didn't want to walk far. The eggs for omelettes were watery and possibly from a powder mix. The coffee drinks come from the Starbucks next door which is kind off putting. The potatoes were excellent. Disappointing and over priced. read more

New place since we were here last so we had to stop in. Really nice place! They put a lot of work into this place and it shows. Sat at the bar. Bonus they have outlets to charge stuff right at the bar! Deb Ordered the smoked margarita. Very tasty and well made. I had the house old fashioned. Well made. Nice pour. For food we tried the chips and salsa at the bar. Really good salsa. Once we got our table we ordered Jalapeños Rellenos. Really good and spicy! Then we had the Chicken La Reina. Had to try their namesake dish. Very good loved the sauce. We had a great experience here. Food was awesome and service great. read more

See all

Excellent chicken cacciatore and salmon meals. The service was also excellent. The owner and owner chef came over to chat with us. What a lovely experience all around. Thank you!! read more

Excelente lugar ,deliciosa comida ,los cócteles y postres espectacular. 10 /10 Sin duda volvería !! read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Castillo is an excellent place to kick back and enjoy a succulent meal My wife had the braised ribs and I had the confit duck - both were beyond outstanding!! Service was professional and fast - a wonderful atmosphere to enjoy a great dinner read more

Beautiful venue, top notch drinks, amazing food! Would highly recommend for a night out! We are local to St Aug and went here for a special occasion. Management was over the top accommodating and the food was incredible. Our server was attentive and great. We had appetizers, entrees, dessert, and cocktails and loved every bite. Our appetizer was the calamari and we ordered the fried green tomato salad to eat as an app- amazing! Entrees we ordered were duct breast, BBQ duck flat bread, and pork boa buns (added white truffle fries)- we all fought over who ordered best so kind of just shared it all. The dark chocolate pretzel cake WAS AWESOME- reminded me of a fast break candy bar YUMM. We had planned to go out later for cocktails but my husband loveeeeed the smoked old fashioned so we stayed here and he had a few- very nice presentation with table side smoking! Yes yes and yes!! read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Pork bao buns entree- added fries :) - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The menu is eclectically, European and very well prepared. Everybody is very friendly and Jacob was our server two times and he was just terrific in both cases Daniel the manager stopped by to make sure everything was fine. Just a very nice place to have a nice meal. read more

I have to hand it to Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen in downtown St. Augustine... not only was the service great, the place beautiful and the food top notch, but they did something NO other place has ever done! Any time we place reservations anywhere and they ask if we have any special requests, we make them. And they are usually outlandish and ridiculous. Well, my friends, this reservation was no different- this time Nicole requested a picture of Steve Buscemi at the table.... They did NOT let us down! In fact we were told by service that the manager himself took up the task because he was so excited to oblige. Five stars , my friends. 5 stars read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Smoked old fashioned - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Had the braised short rib sando. Was very tasty and not too much! The fries are the best!

I'm often suspicious of restaurants attached to hotels. Sometimes that can lead to them realizing your choices are limited and therefore, you get what you get. In the case of Castillo Craft Bar & Kitchen, that would be an unfair assumption. While it is attached to a hotel, it doesn't imply that in its service and food quality. The menu has good variety to fit multiple tastes and cravings in terms of cuisine and size. My mom and I decided to share a salad and a burger. The Spinach & Pear is presented beautifully with goat cheese, dried cranberries, watermelon radish with candied pecans. It was the perfect size for us to share as a starter and certainly would have been good for a meal with a protein topping (chicken, shrimp, salmon, scallops are the choices). We then split the G.O.A.T. Burger. It is an incredible blend of flavors - tri-blend angus beef, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, bacon, chef's secret sauce, toasted brioche bun, and fries. It's clearly prepared fresh to order with fresh ingredients that balance each other out in terms of texture and size. The service was a little slow to start, but it could have been because other tables were seated around the same time as us. Overall, the service was attentive and friendly. I would absolutely return to Castillo Craft Bar & Kitchen - the menu has other interesting options that seem to celebrate local ingredients well. read more

Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen - Spinach and pear salad - Diners Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida