In town for a visit and having lunch about 2:00 pm and very short handed on staff. Took awhile for a server. Room temp was very cold inside and especially in ladies restroom. Food was definitely the highlight but atmosphere was a disappointment for sure. read more

They have great pizza, very similar to pizza kings pizza. The wait was a little long, but once I had the food it was so worth it.

This has been one of my favorite restaurants for years! I miss the days of the nostalgic resturant on W. 86th but the location on E. 96th offers a great atmosphere and dining experience! The Arni salads are awesome!!! And the pizza is spectacular!! read more

Very nice restaurant. We've visited Arnie's several times when in Indy. We all like the food. We've tried pizza, burgers, breadsticks, wraps, and salad. Nice atmosphere. Good hostess and management. Management seems professional and involved in helping others as needed. Looking forward to return on our next trip to Indy and try other menu items. read more

Love their pizza and the Arni's Jr Salad! I've been eating at Arnis since I was a kid. It's a treat when we make the drive to eat here.

Had dinner here last week, and the experience was less than stellar. The first problem was with the service. We were seated, only to wait for over 10 minutes for a server to acknowledge us. To make matters worse the server had a handful of dirty dishes. Things only went downhill from here. The pizza was bland, crust doughy and chewy, and the server was fairly rude and disinterested throughout the meal. I'm sorry Arni's, but I'm not sure I'll ever be back. read more

Apps good, bread and stuffed mushrooms. Server was a train wreck, our food sandwiches took 9ne hour. Manager would not make eye contact with tables. Do not eat here, please!! read more

I came it to Arnie's with a open mind and a strong craving for some pizza. What better want to enjoy a quality pie than in the stellar atmosphere they create. If you are a tea lover try their sweet tea with raspberry syrup it is indeed fire. But not near as fire as their pizza. I ordered the BBQ Chicken 7" pizza. It was just right for me. The service was nice and friendly making sure I was well hydrated when I was low on my drink. Once I peeped their extensive dessert menu I was sold on the Apple Pie. The pie was served à la Mode, meaning with a scoop of ice cream, with caramel drizzled over the top. I would say this is a great place to go out with some friends and share a 14" pizza made to order. read more

Arni's has the BEST chicken quesadilla I have ever had. I work down the road and we order out a lot and I must say that this is my go to most of the time. read more

Love that pizza and salads. Don't tell anyone I told you but this is really pizza king pizza. It started as Arnie's pizza king in lafayette

The deluxe pizza was great as usual but the side Caesar salad was weak. The dressing wasn't real Caesar and the cheese was a powder instead of the real Parmesan. Will definitely go back for the pizza but will pass on the salad. read more

Really happy that I could get a reservation via Round Table. Our table was ready when we arrived! Courteous , knowledgeable waitress waitress. We did not feel rushed in any way. A very relaxing evenig. Food was great-always enjoy the Pizza King pizza! read more

Ordered a medium Maui zowie. It literally had no crust at all. It was just cheese and other toppings. Super greasy. I wish I would have ordered anything else. Don't get pizza. In other words go to chipotle or 96th street steak burgers across the street. The table next to ours also had the same complaint. We were going to say something to but felt so bad for the server who had the entire outdoor patio and bar area. read more

Arni's - Pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

In my opinion the best pizza in Indy. I drive quite a while to dine here. Delicious and great service.

We stopped by Arni's after church. After much complaining by the kids on the way there, it ended up being a hit with the whole family. Delicious pizza!!!!!! My wife loved the salad dressing. Fast friendly service! read more

Casual dinning with updated decor. A nice family restaurant that isn't too formal. The junior salad (which isn't very junior in size) is a favorite. We also enjoy the pizzas and traditional American food. read more

I was disappointed in their Arni Junior salad today. I lived in Lafayette for 4 years and ate at those Arni locations a lot. In comparison to the Lafayette junior salads, the Indy location is lacking in size and cost more. The garlic bread that comes with it also was not "grilled" like the Lafayette locations, it was basically well cooked frozen garlic bread. The pizza was on par with the other locations. The service was good. I would stop by here again, but would just expect less for more in comparison to the Lafayette locations. read more

Excellent food and excellent atmosphere. This is the Arni's pizza that I grew up with 100%. Restaurant is very nicely decorated in modernish decor. Overall great place to eat in or carry out read more

Great pizza! I ordered white wedding pizza n garlic bread. Omg awesome! Good service too :-)

We just moved here from NYC and Arni's is literally 2 minutes from our gated community. So far we've ordered the Chicken Parm dinner and the thin crust pizza. Both times the food was amazing. Coming from NYC I know a thing or two about good pizza but the pizza at Arni's is just as good as some of the best pizza I've had in Brooklyn. I definitely recommend trying this restaurant if you live nearby or are visiting the area. read more

Food is always awesome. Best pizza,best salads. Been going for years. Never disapoints.

Unpleasant food, loud atmosphere. The pizza tasted burnt. The atmosphere left me with something to be desired. I would give it less stars if possible. read more

I've been coming to Arni's for a while now. The managers are great the take out is great, Antonio the kitchen manager is very helpful. The other day I visited the restaurant I was sitting with my friends in the bar, Jillian was my waitress. She had an attitude when she talked to us and was just rude. We have experienced this with her before. I went to the restroom to blow my nose and saw Antonio using the urinal. He finished and walked straight out of the restroom WITHOUT WASHING HIS HANDS!! I left following him thinking surely he will in the kitchen. Nope he walked straight to the place where they put toppings on the pizza and started making pizzas, with DIRTY HANDS, and WITHOUT GLOVES. I just about vomited in my mouth when I saw this. I got my friends and left. I will never come back after this. read more

I love love their pizza. I visit at least once a month! It's great food and atmosphere for adults and children.

I'm originally from Indy but have moved to FL & no place compares to Arni's. Every time I come back this is a MUST HAVE! Great atmosphere & great service read more

Great pizza that tastes a lot like Pizza King, amazing chicken Alfredo, professional staff. When they do make a mistake they fix it fast and make up for it in the transaction. I love to eat outside on their patio...those days are coming to an end unfortunately. read more

Had dinner there ordered sandwiches!! It was terrible. Had 2 pork tenderloins ( they were frozen like the ones you would get from Kroger ) and fries $9.99! NASTY!!! Had a Ruben sandwich ( it was made from lunch meat) $9.99! NASTY!!! Waitress was excellent!!! WILL NOT GO BACK!!! read more

One of my favorite family dining options. The decor of the new location is top notch, which is nice because the old location was absolutely hideous. The pizza and salads are their staples. Arnis Jr and Sr salads (Jr feeds two easily) are fresh finely cold chopped lettuce, ham, mozzarella - simple, but delicious. The pizza is super thin crust with fresh finely-chopped ingredients. You can't beat the sausage or pepperoni. Its simple but delicious. The sauce is not sweet - a gimmick take out chains use. People either love it or hate it. I love it. I can't stress enough this is not gourmet or upscale -- its just simple, fresh ingredients and hits the spot every time. Service is always excellent. Prices are good. read more

So disappointed. Drove out of my way to stop here, especially for lunch. Usually good but, this time I was seated but no server. Waited 10 minutes then left. read more

Best meeting place on 96th Street ... no need to leave my neighborhood ... favorites: Arni's - JoElla's and Stacked Pickle (especially on $5 Monday Burgers) read more

Same food as the Lafayette original. Great pizza and better salads.

I decided to take my family here as this is something that is unique to Indiana. My family was in town from Ohio. Granted the place was packed and we had a party of 6 people, but it seemed like it took a really long time to get our food at lunch time. The burger was just ok, tasty with bbq sauce, cheese, and fried onion straws, but it seemed like the bun really dominated it. One thing I can say is that I think the waitresses should mention that there are other types of buns available. I really wanted mine on an onion bun, but forgot to ask. Also, my Mom's A1 burger said right on the menu that it is served on an onion bun, and her's didn't come with one either. I don't know if they were out of them, but it would have been nice to know. I hear that they are famous for their pizza. My uncle ordered it, but it didn't look that impressive to me. Overall, just an ok place. Nice decor on the inside, but I doubt I would return. read more

Are you a fan of Pizza King pizza? I'd have to do some research to figure out if there's any connection. But, if you're looking for a great thin crust pizza, look no further. I grew up in Indiana, where Pizza King at one time was the ONLY place to get pizza and we would go and order from the telephone at the table (love that...how times have changed and now we use iPads!) So when I heard about this little gem of a pizza place and that it was serving this style of pizza I was intrigued! I can't comment on any other foods besides the pizza and breadsticks, but in my mind I'm not going for any other reason! The things I like about this place are the location, the atmosphere, and the service. The pizza is absolutely delicious! The BBQ sauce pizza is a favorite of mine! I've never had an issue with orders or a long wait. The are also on Open Table and you can make reservations that way. This may sound like a review for Pizza King, but it's not. Someone has taken a great idea or recipe (or close to it) and put it into a more contemporary restaurant and bar. read more

Good food for a cheap price. Pizza reminded me a lot of Pizza King but it's way cheaper. Service was a little slow but we sat outside and I think the waiter had tables inside too so it was to be expected. read more

Simply the best Pizza in Indiana or anywhere for that matter. I frequent Arnis at least once a week and every time I get excited as I walk thru the door. I have never had a bad experience in the 100+ times I have been there. It is very affordable and I mean very. The secret of all secrets is to order the Blue Cheese salad dressing and dip your pizza in it, as weird as that sounds, you can thank me later. I do however recommend sitting in the Bar/Lounge area if you do not have kids. It offers tv's and just better overall dining experience. Management gets to know there frequent diners and pays special attention to them (never had to wait more than 5 minutes when the place is packed, servers are college kids who work hard to save some money for next years tuition and other college shenanigans. Oh and did I mention it is extremely affordable. Overall, it just doesn't get any better than Arnis Pizza! read more

This place is huge! Friendly and fast service. I had the fried chicken salad and my sister had the breaded pork tenderloin. Mine was great and so was hers- and we are very particular about our pork tenderloins! Both had great milkshakes! So many options on the menu. SO GLAD they will be participating in Dining Out For Life on April 28! read more

Arni's is a family tradition we always enjoy. Food was great, would have preferred our server offer water.

Best cheese fries ever and great pizza! I'm only giving them 4 stars because while I like their pizza it's not my favorite thin crust in the city. read more

I haven't eaten a bad meal here, although it's not mind-blowing. Usually a solid pick for food, but the service can be inconsistent. Lunch seems pretty packed every time I've been, which may account for some of the service issues. read more

Arnis pizza is great, one of the best in town. We went there for dinner last night, but the service was not great. We were seated immediately, which is always nice. 10-15 minutes we finally ordered a drink and were acknowledged for the first time. We were only acknowledged at that time because we flagged someone down to get water. 20 minutes after sitting down our waitress finally acknowledged us and took our dinner order. She apologized saying they were busy, but personally i feel like she could have at least brought us water within 20 minutes. We received our food and my fiancé asked for a side of ranch. That took about 15-20 minutes to be brought out. At the end the waitress brought us our check and apologized for the wait and said to try the restaurant again. She gave us our drinks free and all was redeemed. Then we asked for a few boxes, which she brought out and set on top of the pizza :| Overall, we will go back again because the pizza is awesome. Maybe just carryout next time. read more