Ordered a pizza to go with an order of the 5 cheese- cheese bread. The order was completed in about 30 min for pickup and looked good but....someone seriously messed up the cheese bread. They covered the cheese bread with like crushed red pepper or some spicy seasoning. My family all took a bite and our mouths were on fire! And I like spicy food--and the bread was $8.99, it came burnt, covered with the spicy topping which it's not suppose to and really small. Not worth the price even if it hadn't been destroyed. Also how does one mess up cheese bread?$ it's just bread and cheese?! A manager should be doing quality control before things go in the oven and out. The pizza was okay, it was actually decent and good but very disappointed in the $9 cheese bread. Never again. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Garden supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

THOSE BREADSTICKS THOUGH! They're truly my favorite breadsticks I've ever had. They have some type of delicious flavor without being greasy. The cheese dip is a bit spicy but good and the marinara dip tastes fresh. I'm a big fan of Greek's pizza as well, but that's not what we got this time around. We were attempting to make our own pizza at home, and Greek's was one of the spots that allowed us to buy a chunk of pizza dough to go. The man behind the counter even asked what size I wanted and when I was planning on cooking it so he could give me dough that was properly proofed. We brought the dough home, made our pizza and it turned out SO WELL. Greek's dough is simply the best. (TBH I'll continue to just buying pizza from them instead of making my own, but I wanted to try it at least once!). This little spot in downtown Carmel has seating inside, but now has an outdoor front patio that you can eat more safely at. The staff were wearing masks and the food smelled great. Parking is easy and free and you also can't go wrong with their $3 slices at lunchtime. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Pizza dough for my attempt at making pizza at home! - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Honestly used to love Greeks. Went to the one in broad ripple all the time and never had an issue. This is Carmel. I ordered a pizza for pickup on a Monday evening, was told the order was ready, walked in and 3 people are standing around doing absolutely nothing just chatting. Not a single customer in the establishment. The order was never made. I saw them rushing to make the order and try to pretend it was "still in the oven" no, you are just lazy and didn't make it. I don't know who runs this location but definitely needs some management tips. Very unprofessional and embarrassing and will not be eating here again. read more

Arrived to pick up my two pizzas and it took them seven minutes to figure out that I was missing a pizza. They proceeded to make the other pizza which took 12 minutes and then handed me my original cold pizza plus the pizza I was missing was comp to nothing And not even sorry for screwing up your order. Total lack of leadership in there. It's a bunch of kids. I won't be back. read more

Tasty pizza, terrible delivery and customer service/manager response. We ordered 10 pizzas for my son's third birthday and they arrived totally desecrated. I mean, the pizzas are tasty but it was pretty embarrassing to serve pizzas that were violated to the max. Okay, so one bad delivery guy? Well I called for a manager (to be fair, they called back once during the party, but I was busy) but the other 4 days that I called, no one ever returned my call to make this right. I'd also like to add that Greeks failed to deliver pizza at another party we were at because they lived in a gated neighborhood and did not call to figure out how to get in. This resulted in some very cranky toddlers and young children. Moral of the story: if you want to feel confident about feeding a crowd you are hosting, DO NOT order from Greek's. Terrible delivery and terrible customer service. Hope y'all at least get some laughs from some of these effed up pizza pics. It's just too bad that yelp doesn't have a Live Photo feature- the cheese swinging from the top of the box is a fun effect. read more

See all

I live within walking distance and get something about once a week. I've had different pizzas, Stromboli sandwich, Stromboli Shell, bread sticks, and Bruschetta! All were outstanding! I strongly recommend the Stromboli Shell, it's like a Calzone. it is packed with deliciousness and it blows the competition away! The service staff is always polite and friendly! Highly recommended! read more

Just tried to order from Greeks four times. Card declined then gave me a website error. So I thought I would call ... nope got a recording said we are busy call back later. What business operates like that????? read more

Simple and unbelievably delicious! We were casually walking around Carmel during a festival and stumbled across Greeks Pizzeria The hubby and myself had a slice of pepperoni pizza each and it was sooooo good. This is what it must feel like to be eating pizza in Italy II'm sure. We also had the pleasure of meeting the owner and he was the nicest and sweetest person ever. Support the locals and enjoy a piece of Italy/ GREECE Such a fun causal restaurant that's great for all ages. They also have take out too. Do yourself a favor an order a pizza today you can thank me later read more

Was in Carmel at a friends at we decided to get some Greeks for the kids. Good pizza. I really like their sauce. read more

I had my pizza delivered there was such a rage in 3 different employee's voices over some miscommunication. I will never eat there again and wouldn't advise anyone else. I call there all the time atleast once a month they should've known by now our order and how we like it. Pizza was cold and burned and I had 3 people just go off on me like wild cats all 3 were women. I'm done with them. They did this to me in public too when I was super nice about it. read more

Either my husband and I have tired or don't agree (most common) on pizza places. When we can agree or decide we each want something different we order for carry out - as has always been our way even prior to Covid. We gave Greeks a shot last Friday and again tonight and it's still our favorite! I've included a picture of our Gourmet Meat Pizza (what's left of it). I love everything about it, the quantity & taste of the toppings, the pizza sauce and the crust. Last week I ate so much I was uncomfortable - lol - tonight I held back...a bit... read more

Greek's Pizzeria - What's left of the inside of the box - Gourmet Meat Pizza. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

SECOND VISIT Employee wearing mask + gloves brings it to my vehicle for curbside! Ordered way too much food Wife's veggie pizza was awesome My calzone/Stromboli/whatever meatball goodness is awesome What makes everything awesome is the bread/dough/crust. Guys this is the real deal. When you want that thick looking, fluffy crust that the chains make look so good in commercials but fails so fard? Don't go there. Go here. Prices are really reasonable, and the food is really, really good! But uh...easy to order too much. Like I love my vegetables and all but I am just eating my first vegetable as I write this at 11pm. And I ate my pizza at 3! Go Greek's and go Bob! read more

Ordered sliced pizzas. One looked like it was cooked previous day and reheated. The other two looked like they added the toppings at the end. All were very dry pizzas including the toppings. Got to be the worst pizza I have ever had. We also ordered boneless wings. These tased and looked like frozen nuggets. On a positive note, the servers were awesome. This will be the last time I'm coming here. read more

The pizza was good. The chicken Parmesan pasta was horrible. It looked like chicken breast lunch meat on pasta. The chicken sub was the same chicken. Stick with the pizza! read more

Stopped here after a run and the food was on point. The breadsticks were delicious. The pizza was dynamite. Just the plain pepperoni was our first one and I couldn't get enough of the sauce. Great atmosphere and workers. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Such an underrated spot. We got pizza by the slice ($3 a slice). The slice isn't huge but was very good. Notably, the garlic on the crust alone was worth going to try. The arcade games and casual ambiance is perfect for a family outing, group setting, or casual date night. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Arcade - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Pizza by the slice is just the best. This no-nonsense pizza joint on Main Street is somehow eluded my husband and me and we finally went in for a Saturday slice. Fast, delicious, and a great 'after school' hangout type feel with the booths and arcade games. The best of both worlds with awesome pizza and a chill, laid back atmosphere. We will definitely be back! read more

Greek's Pizzeria - $3 slice baby - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Our door dash driver marked our order as delivered but never delivered it. We called the pizzeria and the girl working stayed open for us after hours to make our order right. We were here from out of town for a baseball tournament! I've never had a restaurant go above and beyond like that! Amazing customer service and the pizza was delicious. Thank you so much! read more

We moved to Carmel from the East Coast and have been searching for our go-to pizza spot. We tried a bunch of spots around town and this is our go to! A great low key place to bring the kids (good selection of arcade games), relax and enjoy great pizza. The sauce is phenomenal. Owner is also a really good guy, spends time talking to his patrons and cares about his restaurant. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Arcade area - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Best ingredient quality pizza. Def not cheap though. All in all, one of the best pizza places in all of Indiana.

Wandered in here one day while we were waiting for the library to open. I think today marked our fourth visit since then, in under two months. I like that they have cold beer, music playing from my childhood (70's) and foosball, table top Ms. Pac-Man and Galaga to share with my daughter. The pizza is pretty damn good. You can't beat a three dollar slice - and it's huge. I always enjoy chatting with the owner, too. Overall we always have a perfect casual & fun experience. read more

See all

This is our go-to pizza place! The pizza is amazing, crust is awesome! Breadsticks are a big hit here too. Always great customer service - they are kind, accurate and friendly. Love Greeks! read more

We really love Greeks. On most Wednesdays I enjoy their pizza with the runners club but lately we've been getting some takeout during these crazy times. The food is always tasty and the pizzas are loaded with cheese and toppings. We had the baked spaghetti and meatballs too and wow. Listen. This is a great small business to support who has supported the local community for years. Go get some great food and friendly service from here today. read more

Was told pizza ready in 15 minutes. Got there and had to wait an extra 15 minutes 15 minutes pass their estimation to pick up a pizza seems like a long time read more

This was an absolutely fantastic pizzeria we found in Carmel Indiana. Before we get to the food I must mention how awesome the restaurant itself is. A few arcade machines, a foosball machine, and a vintage Pacman machine (!). That makes me a happy guy without even having taken a bite of food. As for the food that was really great too. Starting with the breadsticks they were nice and flavourful with a nice texture but the cheese dip was what really put it over the top for me. As for pizzas we got 3 different ones with the Gourmet Wing Pizza, The Greek Special Pizza, and the 5 Cheese Pizza. The wing pizza was my personal choice as it came with bbq sauce, grilled chicken, and some different herbs and cheeses. Very good take as I appreciated the not taking the traditional Buffalo chicken route and doing something unique. The bbq sauce was great with a nice tang to it and the chicken was plentiful and perfectly cooked. The 5 cheese came with roma, parmesan, mozzarella, and a couple other cheeses that I couldn't identify along with a really good red sauce. Simple and delicious. The last one was their take on a supreme pizza with green pepper, pepperoni, sausage, onion, ham, and mushrooms again with their red sauce. As delicious as it sounds. All in all this was one of my favourite pizzerias I've ever been too and even though it's a two hour drive I will definitely be back. Great food, great people, and a fun environment. I couldn't ask for more. read more

See all

Greek's Pizza for the win! It was a dark and snowy night, I was starving and I didn't feel like cooking. Enter Greek's: a chipper young man answered the phone and swiftly took my order, and 20 minutes later I was leaving Greek's with a medium Roma pizza pie in hand for a delicious dinner. Greek's is probably one of my top local pizza places in Indy - the crust, the crust! I've made a mental note to take advantage of their lunch special - $6.99 medium pizza ordered between 11-1, M-F - to save some dough (pun intended). My medium pizza ran about $17 after tax and tip - a little steeper than I hoped. read more

We've heard so many good things about Greeks, we knew we had to check it out! We ordered the classic breadsticks with cheese and a medium pizza with pepperoni and banana peppers with cheese dipping sauce. We were most excited about the breadsticks since we've heard so many people rave about them. But ours were definitely over cooked. The pizza was incredible though! It's VERY cheesy! It also has a unique homemade pizza sauce which is very good. I'd say this is some of the best hometown pizza around! read more

We typically love this place but our entire order was incorrect and there were zero cares by the management. Once home with the wrong pizza, wrong salad and wrong sauces (with our name on the order) we called to get our $ back. It seemed to be a huge hassle for them, they didn't apologize and we were also told they would refund the total amount (which they never did.). We spent our time driving the food back and simply asked for a refund, including the tip we left. They stated that they couldn't refund the tip until the end of the night. We checked and it was never refunded. With so many wonderful pizza places around, I will not return to this one due to their terrible customer service! read more

This place has really gone down hill with quality measures and general experience. Last time I ordered from here my order was wrong three separate times. I first got home and realized they gave the wrong order. I called and they had me return the pizza to the restaurant. When I went to the restaurant they said they had my order ready. Again they hand me the wrong pizza. As I was waiting they then gave me another pizza which was wrong again so again I waited and finally they gave the correct order with a free small version of my pizza as well as that would meals up for the wait. Today I tried it out again as I wasn't home yet and ordered as my wife was home and received this text from my wife " Just an fyi i found a thick most white but some black hair on your pizza". At this point I'm done with Greeks. read more

If I could give this zero stars, I would! I ordered for delivery. Was to be delivered at 5:00. Not here by 5:25 so tried calling the restaurant. No answer. It went to a generic voicemail that didn't even mention the restaurant. So I canceled through the delivery service Slice, that was supplied to me when ordered. They said they talked with the manager and that the pizza had just left and should be at my house by 5:45. When it wasn't here by 6, I canceled again. Slice said the manager wouldn't give me a refund bc it was delivered. That was a lie! I have left two messages with no return call. And I've been charged for the pizza! I will be going into the restaurant soon and they will not be happy. Might even contact Better Business Bureau. read more

I used to love Greek's Pizza and I feel kind of bad complaining but the last several times have been a disaster. Tonight we spent $33 for a medium pizza, breadsticks and 2 cheese sauces. The pizza was so underdone you couldn't pick it up and we only received 1 cheese sauce despite the extra charge for 2. I know it seems petty but it was $33 and not right or good. And it has become a pattern. Bummer, Greek's used to be great. read more

Barry gave us the best service!! He's amazing and the food is even better than the service :) I brought my sister and brother from Hawaii and they loved it!!! We will definitely be back no question about it!!! We had to get the extra large cause we love this pizza!!!! Yum yum yum!!! Plus they sell pizza by the slice all day long!!!! read more

See all

Bought a Groupon to support a local business. Pizza is okay. Bread sticks are very good but very, very buttery. A good but unhealthy thing! We will ONLY be doing take-out from now on to use up the rest of our Groupons. Management needs to train their staff on basic customer service. We never got eye contact from our server, had to ask for menus, had to ask/remind her for drinks, had to ask twice for silverware (ended up asking another server), never had a follow-up "how's it going?", and waited 15 minutes for our check. I've never worked so hard for a 90-minute dinner. We weren't the only ones as we watched other patrons suffer as well. We still tipped 15% because these are high school kids earning a wage but we're standard 20% (or more for great service)) tippers since I've worked food service before. Training is the responsibility of Management. 3 Stars for food 1 star for service read more