The pizza was great. If you can, make sure you can get Asher to make your pizza. He is the Picasso of pizza. I really enjoyed my service my the general manager Owen. read more

The food was amazing. Would recommend to anyone who wants good pizza. The service was amazing. Especially with the girl at the counter. She was very pleasant and did a good job, taking care of us and the setting pizza. The ambience is not very high end but if you want a cozy feel I would recommend the place. read more

Best pizza in all of Carmel!! Highly recommend... a little pricey but delicious .. their cheese dipping sauce is outstanding read more

You continually put out coupons but they don't work online although they say only usable online. The kids at the counter cannot do anything once you've ordered so the coupon is more of an unusable switch and bait tactic. The pizza's are very good when done right but it's 50/50 anymore on how right they are. The last XL had 3" of crust around the outside of the pizza with no sauce or toppings. I'll be going to the Zionsville location from now on to see if they try to maintain some quality controls. read more

The chef was amazing man! Just working in this hot heat outside, he walked out and we sparked a casual convo while I'm finishing my work. I said "Wow the pizza smells good in there" Next thing I know He asked me if I wanted one and Asked what toppings i wanted. I've never tried Greeks Pizza before but when I took the first bite I knew my new pizza place out here lol! Awesome Chef man! read more

Stop by late this morning for a quick personal pizza with my wife and a Greek salad. The girl at the counter was very pleasant and did a good job, taking care of us and the setting pizza and salad was very good. All at a fair price about 30.00 plus tip read more

I ordered a pizza to go. Was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. I arrived 20 minutes after ordering. Was told it would be a few minutes. Saw 2 people who ordered after me get their food. 30 minute later got my food. Oh and they weren't busy read more

Always a solid pizza and salad option, vs their franchise brothers they always rise to provide fast accurate orders. Thanks to you! Greeks has a unique style of hand stretching and tasty american style pizza. We like ours extra done, which helps crisp up this thinner crust structure. Always like this pizza. Higher quality toppings and more than competition in this craft pizza style. read more

This is one of those times when I wish Yelp allowed half stars, because this Greek's Pizzeria is better than OK but a smidgen less than great. Three and a half stars, for sure. Greek's is super supportive of the community, and I love supporting businesses that are so invested in the neighborhood. They are also very fast, and their online ordering system is super. The kids who work behind the counter are very friendly and professional, and the restaurant looks clean (and there's an old-school Pac Man game in the corner!) However, the pizza is not my jam. The sauce is very sweet, like Spaghetti-O sauce. If you like sweet pizza, then this is for you. It's just not for me. The breadsticks are also also not for me -- they taste like the kind that Little Caesar's makes. Which again, maybe you'd like. I'm trying to be diplomatic here and acknowledge that everyone has different tastes. (Is it working?) There are people in my life who love Little Caesar's and I'm not going to yuck their yum. So all this to say that you should totally try this place and determine for yourself. read more

I got a free bag of chips at the Greeks 's pizzeria team members. Jules and Hazel harassed me twice.

Pizza was great but they didn't deliver the sauce I ordered and paid for. Figured it was in the box but when opened the box no sauce to be found. read more

When our weekly trivia night spot, Danny Boy's (across the street), stopped selling food for a few weeks, we started ordering from Greek's, and man is it good. Greek's is one of the few local pizza joints that sells pizza that's on the thicker side and oh-so cheesy. Our new favorite find is that they also sell sauces that you can order on the side to dip your crust in. Garlic butter? Yes please! There is usually a team of high schoolers working at this location, which I think is great. There is also often a jar for Riley Hospital Dance Marathon donations and I like to see that they're involved in the community! read more

Simply put, everything you would want in a neighborhood pizza parlor. The pizza is dependable with fresh crust, flavor in the sauce, great toppings and they are generous with them... read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Greeks Greek's Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This is my favorite Greek's location - everyone is so nice and the food is fantastic. The grilled ham & cheese sandwich is my favorite - totally addictive. The last time I was there my server recommended the Chicken Parmesan pasta and it was incredible. Speaking of servers, my server was Ainsley and all I can say is give that girl a raise! She was totally friendly even though they were swamped. She was working super hard helping the other server and cleaning tables and taking orders, all with a smile on her face. Definitely recommend this place! read more

Sodas are overpriced. $3 for the equivalent of a small drink. They try to "get you" on the reasoning behind "it allows for refills" but you are screwed if you are getting take out. read more

Greeks pizzeria as a Hidden gem in West Clay. The pizza and breadsticks are extremely fluffy and melts in your mouth. We will continue coming here when we are craving wholesome pizza with fresh ingredients. read more

Overall, I enjoyed the food (stromboli) I ordered from here. I stopped in for lunch (to go) and after a short wait at the order counter, I was able to place my order. This Greek's is much smaller than most of the franchises I've been to. They don't have a featured bar area like the ones that I've given 5-star reviews to. In fact, there are just a few places to sit with most of the seating at long tables. Seems like this one prefers to be a carry out restaurant. It took just over 20 minutes to get my order. The stromboli is served as an open face sandwich with the meat on one side and the veggies on the other. Both had red sauce. The bread was crisp on the outside and not so thick that when I placed the halves together that it would cause any trouble eating it. The flavor was good, but a little mild. No punch to it or anything to get raves for. The sandwich also came with a side of chips in the listed price. Overall, it's a good place to get some pizza or sandwiches, but not a destination place to dine in. Review #3165 read more

See all

I do like Greek's Pizzeria. I was disappointed in the service this time. The location is in a very nice area with great parking. It took a long time for someone to come and take our order. The herb and parmesan breadsticks arrived hot and warm. They were excellent. We had to ask for our drinks which was about 15 mins we were waiting. Then we had to ask if our slice of pizza was on its way. At that point it was definitely around 20 mins. The pizza was ok. I feel like they needed more help up front. I don't know I wasn't impressed tonight. :-( read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Zionsville Indiana iconic pizzeria. If you love garlic try the garlic butter mozzarella bread. It's memorable, the pizza has homemade crust and it's better than most. Is it the same thing as New York pizza? Sadly no, but better than most places in Indy. Definitely worth a try! read more

Super unreliable. This is the second time this has happened where we place an online order that somehow they have no record of. Tonite we were hosting 6 little girls, put in an order shortly after 5, called at 6:30 and were told our order was out for delivery. Called back at 7 when it still hadn't arrived and somehow there was no record of it. So hubby drove to Donatos while I tried to tied them over with microwave popcorn, and while waiting at Donatos he called back to Greeks and miraculously they found our order, and said they left it at our door. Lo and behold there is no pizza to be found. Terrible on top of terrible, will never order (or allegedly not order) again read more

Another west carmel go-to Za spot. Big fan of the sweet pizza sauce and dough. Always quick and easy in and out.

My intent was to eat at the West Clay Pizzology, but then I discovered it closed...good thing Greek's is right around the corner! I hope Greek's has better luck and can stay open, as that seems to be an issue with businesses in this neighborhood. I've had Greek's from the Carmel location on Main Street and I love the crust - like a breadstick. My party and I got a Greek's special and Roma and loved both! The interior is small and could easily fill up with neighborhood kids and families - in fact, it favors family-style dining with larger round tables. They do a big carry out business, so there was a constant line. I was confused if we were supposed to order at the counter or be waited on - there was only one girl working the front, tending to the tables, phone ringing and carry out orders. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - Greek's special - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

We ordered take out on a Saturday night and it was really quick. It was ready in about 15-20 min after we ordered which was much better than the 1 hour to wait for delivery. They take down your name and phone number to correspond with the order and you tell them that when you pick up. We ordered Breadsticks with nacho cheese, Garlic Parmesan wings and a medium Pepperoni and green pepper pizza. The nacho cheese with the breadsticks is probably my favorite thing about Indy food. I have lived a handful of other places in the country and only have had my breadsticks with marinara sauce until now. Nacho cheese is a game changer! The wings were way better than I expected and would definitely order them again because they are good for sharing with a crowd. The pepperoni on the pizza is really crispy and quite delicious. Our medium pizza fed 3 people so we had plenty of food leftover. read more

Food is mid but I am waiting 45 min for pizza and wings the pizza is good an wings needed help looking like wings.( I hate to have to shake up my own wings looks like a little kid drizzled sauce on. It ) today was not there day it is Saturday dec 3rd 3:45pm cooks an waitress need to grow up. read more

I ordered a large pizza with a lot of toppings. so the order was pretty big and might take a while to make. I was told the wait time was 30 minutes since it was super busy and there probably already a lot of orders they need to finish. But I was gone for only 15ish minutes and my pizza was already done. I was surprised and shocked. Customer service was amazing and I will come back again! read more

Greeks has been one of my favorite pizza places since I went to Ball State and would buy slices at 2am outside the college town watering holes. Moved into the village last year and would order once or twice a month. This location wasn't great to begin with and has gone way downhill. Over the last two months I've ordered a few times and it is terrible at this point. The pizza we received tonight was not edible at all. Soaking wet crust, dough was clearly not done. The edges were burnt and the middle was raw. Let the manager know and they took off a few dollars, didn't even come out to apologize. I've noticed a huge drop off in carry out as we usually eat in. Absolutely a shame since the location is fantastic. Won't be back to this store again, too many bad pies. read more

Love Greek's Pizza. Highly recommend their breadsticks with either cheese sauce or garlic sauce. In addition to pizza, their salads and sandwiches are delicious. read more

You get what you order! Local! Sometimes the wait is long... but due to Covid, I hope people find a way to stay supportive and patient.

MID. Went there to go and get something at 9:45 and they were closed when the hours were till 10!

Even though I'm not a huge fan of their pizza (indifferent towards their pizza sauce). I decided to try their subs and wings. The wife and I got a submarine and wings to share for lunch. I ordered for carry out and it took on 15 minutes to prepare everything. The sub was perfectly toasted and the spicy wings (Franks red hot) was delicious and had great flavor. I would definitely order lunch again especially being located a minute from my house!The have a pretty good seating area if you're interested in dining in. read more

Greek's Pizzeria - "Submarine", FYI Italian sauce\dressing seems to be their pizza sauce - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This is our favorite pizza in the neighborhood. I read some of the other reviews and geez folks, it's a pizza joint. It gets slammed on Friday nights. Plan ahead and call your order in advance. Pro-tip: pizza sauce for dipping breadsticks. read more

Phenomenal food, stellar service. Just ordered pizza and breadsticks and everything about the experience was amazing. Keep it up

Ordered two slices. The kid in the back managed to burn them. Asked for them to give me two more slices and they didn't have any left so they suggested making a new small pizza for me. I told them I didn't want to wait and they didn't refund me for the original slices. The manager at the front had a terrible attitude as if we were bothering her night. Never coming back again. @greg just saw your response. Yeah she has a terrible attitude you probably already know that. How do we take you up on that offer for the pizza dinner?! I actually love Greeks from btown. read more

I liked their pepperoni sausage pizza. Near my house and the price is reasonable. I definitely recommended this restaurant to everyone.

Great pizza, reasonably priced and so convenient! Pepperoni and jalapeño is my favorite. Best nacho cheese sauce too! Some places miss the mark on the nacho cheese! read more

First off the pizza here is great! But that's where the positivity ends. Service is awful- they have a handful of high schoolers working here and they have been rude and unfriendly all 3 times I have visited this location. I'm not expecting great service but a little smile and not a grunt when I ask a question would be nice. Pizza is also a bit expensive for what you get. Sizes seem smaller than other pizza joints and it's a few dollars more. I'll go back because it's in the area and it does taste good but it's not for sure not going to be my go to spot anytime soon. read more

Convenient to have a place in the village of West Clay, but the pizza is really just so so. However, the people that work here are very nice, so it's a good vibe to hang out. read more

After trying this yesterday, I can honestly say this location of Greek's Pizzeria is by far the best in the Indianapolis area. The new owners have really done a great job at revamping the place to give customer's not only great food, but a cozy restaurant atmosphere and great customer service. The breadsticks are super flavorful and I love that you can customize them with different spices! They also offer feta as a pizza topping, and as a Greek girl, that's a huge bonus for me. Make sure to get the garlic butter for your pizza crust too - so good! read more

I like this place for a quick carry out pizza! Almost as convenient as a Little Caesar's hot and ready except better quality pizza. I have only tried the pizza and breadsticks on a few occasions, but it definitely hits the spot for a pizza crazing! Also, it is under new management and seems to have better costumer service. We called 10-15 minutes ahead for a carry out and it was coming straight out of the oven when we walked in. Overall, id recommend Greek's! read more

In terms of go-to pizza, we'd always been a Bazbeaux household. When we heard Pizzology was coming to West Clay, we figured that would be our new place. But then Greek's moved in and we had to try it out of curiosity. It doesn't replace Bazbeaux's gourmet options, but Greek's might be my favorite "basic pizza" in Indy. We always get a cheese pizza with breadsticks and cheese sauce. The breadsticks are always warm and fluffy, and the sauce-to-cheese ratio is always spot on. The servers, most seem to be high school kids, are very friendly and helpful. Bottom line: don't expect the options of Bazbeaux or the frills of Napolese or Pizzology, but this is just really good pizza! read more