Best pizza in the Indy area, I like in north Indianapolis and it is always worth the drive to get takeout.

Why was this pizza crust crispier than the nyc pizzas I've had Crust 9/10 The amount of toppings is balanced for me. Just wish there was more hot honey and their proteins are on the salty side. Overall, it was yummy, and I like their tomato sauce a lot, very tangy read more

Brooklyn Char - Bee Sting - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

This is a very good pizza. Absolutely nothing wrong with this pizza. I ordered it well ahead of time. When I got there the sign on the door said "sold out. So for all the reviews where they complain about not being able to get a pie. Read the website, it says they sell out - order ahead. Pizza was ready right on time. It's a large pie. So don't complain it's too big or you wanted smaller. It's one size. No the price is not too high. It's in line with every other real pizzeria. My personal complaints are my personal issues. Absolutely nothing to do with the quality or taste of this pizza. I prefer a sweeter sauce and a thinner crust. That's me. The sauce is fresh. The cheese is real and despite those who complained about the finishing cheese, I like it, as well as the fresh basil. Appropriate amount of pepperoni. Staff was busy when I came in but still very friendly. Pizzeria was small. Let me say this again. Pizza was very good. Crust had the right amount of chew. Was I expecting Lucali or L'Industrie or Ceres. No. That's why there is only 1 of those pizzerias. This is nowheresville Indiana and yet they are making an extremely good pizza. read more

Brooklyn Char - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

We really enjoyed our pepperoni pizza from Brooklyn Char, possibly our favorite pizza plug Carmel! The pizzas are huge, giant slices. This place was busy with to go orders, we felt lucky to be able to place our order and get it as soon as we did! This is more of a grab and go spot but I believe they do have a few tables there as well- we enjoyed our pizza at home! Give them a try next time you're in the mood for pizza!! Cheers! read more

I love a good New York style pizza so I was really excited to try this place. Our first attempt was a few months ago when they were sold out on a Wednesday night. We actually took that as a good sign of small business success and planned to come back more prepared. We finally ordered for the first time a few months ago and tried the Sweet Pig. It wasn't my favorite. I enjoy all of those ingredients individually and even together in other foods, but on this pizza it just didn't work for me. That part comes down to personal taste rather than a flaw in the restaurant. We gave them another chance tonight and ordered a half cheese half pepperoni pizza along with garlic knots and all three dipping sauces. Overall I would still say the pizza is just alright and not really worth the price. Our vodka dipping sauce was ice cold, and the cheese was also surprisingly cold. We used our microwave to heat them up, then they were great! Our pizza arrived lukewarm. Also, it was inconsistent throughout. Some areas were over sauced while others were under sauced. Cheese coverage also varied a lot, with some slices heavily topped and others nearly bare. The slicing was uneven as well, with some pieces noticeably larger than others. We really wanted to give them a fair shot after the first visit, but this experience felt like it reflected more of a consistency issue. When everything came together in one bite it could be really good, but the problem is that the quality changed so much from bite to bite that it was hard to enjoy the pizza as a whole. The garlic knots??? PHENOMENAL!! I'm not sure if we will give them another try, but based on other reviews it seems like our experience is not uncommon. read more

Brooklyn Char - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

We literally had to plan in advance when to get this pizza. Like we ordered it a whole day in advance to pick up at 5:30 PM the following day because it's such a popular place right now. Even before the barstool review this has been on my list to try just from the tons of positive Google reviews. The people that complain about the wait time are missing the point - it's that popular and in demand and a small pizza shop. If you have any ounce of patience, use it and order ahead so you can try it. It's on the expensive side. All said, it's still well worth it. The pizzas are huge and very authentic New York. Hamilton county has tons of pizza places with brick oven doughy crust, but not like this New York style one. It's crusty and thin, but not doughy. Super airy and flakey - by the time you get to the last bite of the crust it's honestly messy and crumbs are everywhere. You could scrape the bottom of the pizza and hear that crackle.The tomato sauce seemed like true tomatoes, not a sauce with a bunch of additions. The Parmesan on top gave it some saltiness too. We had onions, sausage, and pepperoni toppings - they don't overload them, it's like the right amount to be able to appreciate the pizza as a stand alone and the toppings. It's locally owned too and from the interviews I've seen, you can tell they just care about making great pizza and keeping it as simple as that. Overall, I'm impressed. I'd recommend if you're a foodie and appreciate good food. read more

Love NY style pizza and miss it in Midwest. Ordered take out after hearing the space inside is small. It is small with 3(?) tables inside and a few outside. Walked right in as my order was called out. Perfect timing. We just got a cheese pie. Smelled delicious. Pizza more than enough for 4 of us in our family. We enjoyed the pizza. Crust a little chewier than I like, but would come back. read more

Brooklyn Char - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

This is an overglorified thin crust pizza. Slap a New York name on it and burn the edges and they think they can charge $35 for one size of pizza. It tasted OK. It's not great. It's good, but it's not great. There's no reason for this pizza to cost $35. That's just some ridiculous Hamilton County bougie spending. For that amount, I was expecting a pizza that would knock my socks off. That didn't happen. I have been to New York many times, and didn't really get that vibe from their pizza. Sure, it's thin and crispy... but some things you just can't replicate. It's close, but I can get a better slice in NY for $2-5. They need to drop their price point to about $25 for this pizza to make any sense at all. You can get a massive deep dish at Giordano's for $26... This is a super thin pizza with hardly any toppings, and it's $10 more. On top of all that, just look at any review that is 3 stars or less and you'll probably see a snarky remark from the owner. Not the kind of guy I want to do business with. If you're going to run a business, you have to be prepared for some moderate and negative reviews... but this guy can't handle it. Instead of learning and improving he wants to argue about the experience people had and make it their fault. (Look for the review where the guy got hung up on and was called a liar... he even posted his phone log!) You probably would have had me as a repeat customer at a reasonable price point and some manners, but it's an experience I don't need to repeat. EDIT/ UPDATE: There you have it, folks. The angry, snarky response from the owner that we all knew was going to happen showed up in record time. He can't take any criticism at all. Take his advice- please DO read my other reviews. I'm very fair, and tell it like it is. My point stands- $35 is robbery for a thin pizza with a moderate (at best) amount of toppings. It's kind of a unique pizza, but it's also uniquely overpriced. read more

Brooklyn Char - Sausage and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Walked in tonight to place a carry out order. The service was helpful and friendly, and my wait for the pizza was only about 20-25 minutes. The ambiance is that of a busy pizza shop with a few tables for eating in. The pizza in my opinion was good, flavorful New York style pizza. They have some signature pizzas on the menu. They did not have a meat lovers pizza, but they were flexible to fix me a pepperoni and sausage pizza with mushrooms on half. The pepperoni was spicier than what my husband likes, but I thought it had good flavor. I liked the crust under the triangle of pizza, although I found the crunchy crust edge to be too crispy and chose to not eat much of it. The char flavor is delicious. Pizzas are large--each triangle slice is similar to the single slices I used to see in the mall at Luca Pizza or like the slices from Bella Pizza. One or two slices will fill you up. read more

Easily the best pizza in Indy. I'm usually not a fan of honey on pizza but they do it right. Not too much just enough to add the flavor. The crust and dough have an incredible texture and crunch. The sauce was fantastic. They sprinkle on some of the topics (basil) after it's cooked to make sure it stays fresh and not soggy. The seating is limited so make sure you plan ahead for that. I will be back. Great service, good vibes. read more

Brooklyn Char - Charmander - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Brooklyn Style Pizza - can't say that I've ever had a Brooklyn style pizza...until now! Apparently a Brooklyn Style Pizza is characterized by a thin and crispy crust. Crust edges are "sturdy" so it's foldable and the toppings don't fall off. Slices are cut so each is very large - to fold of course. The volume of toppings are "balanced" to not dominate the taste nor appearance. The sauce is designed to be more tangy and less sweet. Lots of fresh mozzarella cheese to pull everything together! This Sweet Pig pizza was delicious! The sweetness comes from a honey drizzle. It is aided by the sweet fig jam. Applewood bacon provides the "pig" flavors. There aren't many other toppings by design. The pizza has a nice bed of mozzarella with dollops of ricotta cheese. The crust is almost wafer thin and crispy - if you like that. I ate my slices straight up without folding them. Overall...a Brooklyn style Sweet Pig pizza was really good! The cheese sticks were outstanding. A thick stick with a slight buttery-garlic baste. It's baked to a slight crisp. The inside is stuffed with deliciously stretchy mozzarella cheese. The garlic knots are very similar. Just smaller and no cheese filling. read more

Keep in mind: It takes a while to get your food here. At least, it did on the evening that I visited. We waited about 50 minutes to get our pizza. People who came in after us were told an hour and a half. The solution, if you're dining in and starving and can't wait, is to order an appetizer, because those come out relatively quickly. We got the garlic knots: 8 delicious bread balls covered in garlic and butter, which come with marinara sauce. These were so delicious! It was so satisfying to pull apart the knots and eat the layers of bread little by little. We ordered the pepperoni pizza, and the pepperoni they use here are my favorite kind -- the kind that turn into little, crispy cups that hold the pizza grease. Even my pepperoni-hating son likes these kinds of pepperoni! Another thing to know: There is one size of pizza. It's extra large, with 8 huge slices per pizza. Even though it took a while for our pizza to be ready, the wait was worth it! This is the kind of pizza that I like: The crust was slightly charred and crispy from the oven, and the cheese was nicely melted, and had that satisfying pull. It's the kind of pizza that's best eaten at the restaurant, because you want to bite into a hot slice as soon as possible, even though it burns the roof of your mouth. Speaking of dining in: Brooklyn Char is tiny inside! There are very few tables at which to sit. Because the interior is so tight, it's a little difficult to navigate -- you're maneuvering around seats to get to the ordering counter. We visited for dinner on a weekday around 5 p.m. and we found a table, but an hour later, there was nowhere to sit. So, you might want to consider getting your food to go. read more

If you're looking for New York style pizza in the Midwest look no further. Keep in mind, they do take close to an hour to prepare but they are well worth the wait and you can order online to plan ahead. We had a vodka sauce pizza with pepperoni and mushroom. The pizzas are large with 8 big slices. We have been struggling to find a really good pizza spot on the north side but we definitely found it! Will definitely be back when wanting pizza again! read more

Brooklyn Char - Vodka Sauce with Pepperoni on half and mushroom on the other. - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

This pizza is the best NY Style pizza.- in indy! The garlic rolls were delish, not too oily and fantastic flavor of garlic and Parmesan. The pizza had a very solid undercarriage and healthy amount of parm and basil. Would come back here everyday if I lived closer!! read more

Brooklyn Char - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

Easily one of the best pizza places in Indy! Definitely the best New York style pizza in Indy! The restaurant is hidden in a plaza in Noblesville, so it's not easy to see if you're driving by. It's mainly a take-out restaurant, but they do have a few seats inside. They have a few classic flavors and usually a special each week. Highly recommend the classic pepperoni, garlic knots, and stuffed sticks. Everything is so delicious and full of flavor! It is a bit expensive, but the pizza is huge like Costco-sized big. I love this pizza place, and everyone needs to try it. I promise it'll be your go-to pizza place. There's also a big free parking lot right in front of the restaurant. read more

Brooklyn Char - Half Cheese and Half Bee Sting - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

I was so excited to try this pizza! Unfortunately it was not worth the ride... They only serve beer and soda and it is by no means a sit down restaurant. There are limited tables which most are used for waiting customers because you will definitely wait! The cream soda and stuffed sticks were 10/10 and the sauce was superb! I get one of their selling points is "char" but unfortunately my pizza was overcooked. It was dry and barely had any sauce. I was expecting a flop, but that didn't happen. It could have been because we asked for extra cheese, not sure. Also, we dined in and my pizza was warm when it came to the table. If it weren't so far away from me I would try again because I did someone else's pizza that was smoking hot and looked amazing, nothing like mine. I hate to mention the customer that requested the cashier to move the table that was attached to ours because we were just too scary to sit by. Definitely killed the vibe. read more

See all

I've never had the chance to visit New York City, but I've enjoyed plenty of New York-style pizza in and around the Orlando area over the years. There's usually one feature that stands out in those Florida pizzerias: a prominently displayed New York Water Filtration System, a nod to the belief that it's the water that gives New York pizza its signature taste and texture. So when I walked into Brooklyn Char and didn't see the filtration system showcased, I was a little skeptical. But after the first bite, all doubt melted away. The crust had that perfect balance--chewy yet crisp--and the sauce was flavorful without overpowering. Honestly, their pizza stacks up surprisingly well against the ones I've had in Florida that go all-out to replicate the NYC vibe. The dining area was clean and welcoming albeit small. Definitely geared for carryout. Staff were friendly and efficient, and service was prompt even during the Friday dinner rush. It's clear they take pride in their product. Whether you're a pizza purist or just craving a solid New York-style slice, this place delivers. I'll definitely be back for more--and next time I might leave the friends so I don't have to share. read more

Brooklyn Char - great pizza. Just missing the NYC water filtration system. - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

After hearing lots of great things about this place, my friend and I thought to carry out from here and wow, we were shocked at the size of the pizza! This is the Godzilla - jalapeños, Serrano, hot honey, a spicy lovers dream! I wished if they had smaller sizes but the pizza was absolutely amazing! The restaurant itself is kind of small so definitely getting take out! read more

Brooklyn Char - The Godzilla - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

A bit overpriced for the quality but not bad. This just isn't my favorite pizza joint but we are desperate to find one close to my son's home (and grandkids!) I'm not sure why the 'char' is a thing. It wasn't mine and I like most anything slightly burned. read more

Best pizza we've had in metro Indy since moving here 9 nine years ago. We moved from Scottsdale/Phoenix (home of James Beard-nominated Pizzeria Bianco) to Carmel-Westfield, Indiana and have been searching for the best pizza nearby. Brooklyn Char hits the mark for New York City pizza. Thin, chewy, yet crispy crust. High-quality tomato sauce, cheese, and pepperoni. They do not offer olives, so we sauteed some at home and sprinkled over the pizza. A smaller size would be appreciated for my kids who don't eat leftovers but want just cheese pizza. Two big pizzas is a lot of pizza. Pricier than most pizza places but it is worth it for the quality. This will be our new go-to pizza place. read more

See all

TL;DR: It's an ok pizza but not a great value for what you get. I probably won't be back. Food: So let's get right to it; no flop (good), sauce was just ok, cheese was too thick in places, and had a sad amount of toppings. Cost: It is a large pizza but the average person would eat 3-4 slices (so one pizza would feed 2 adults) making it a mediocre value at $30 for a pizza. Service: Service was good, no issues there. Ambiance: Not much to the restaurant, definitely more of a takeaway place though there were 10 or so seats inside and about the same outside. Overall: I really wanted to like this place, but the taste/quantity to value ratio just wasn't there for me. read more

See all

Best thing in town since sliced bread. Great service. Hubby loves the garlic knots and we all drool over the pizza. Spectacular addition to the neighborhood! read more

OK, first things first. This is not a $7.99 pizza at Domino's. This is not Papa John's. This is an East Coast style pizza! Its pizza is covered in real quality ingredients, a unique mozzarella that has a great flavor to it and a ridiculously awesome amount of Parmesan cheese! The pizza itself will cost you probably between 20-30 dollars. But it's big enough to feed a family of four. Or if you're like me and you're in bachelor mode for the weekend you've got dinner or lunch for the next four days. I had a chance to meet with the owner for a few minutes and talk to him about why he started this restaurant. He's got a passion for East Coast, Pizza and quality ingredients. And I think once you try this one you'll be hooked just like I am. Get over to Brooklyn, Share and Try a phenomenal pizza. You won't be sorry that you did. read more

Brooklyn Char - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

We've been looking forward to trying this place and showed up at 5:30 on a Saturday. We didn't realize it's mainly to-go, not really having much in the way of seating. When we went to order the young lash told us the soonest we'd have our pizza is 7pm. We left disappointed, but hope to try it again sometime making sure we order a few hours ahead. read more

My experience was not an 8.1. Had the cheese pizza. The taste was dominated by the "charred" crust. I'm really hoping it was just overdone. The sauce was impeccable and the best I've ever had. The cheese also great but less noticeable than the sauce. Either that level of crispness did not work for me or the dough just isn't that great. I'll try it again to make sure I didn't get a bad pie and adjust the review if needed. read more

Brooklyn Char - Gorgeous - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Hold the phone. This pizza was INCREDIBLE. Someone recommended it to me and I tried it out with some of my Yelp friends and it did not disappoint. Hugeeeee slices! True New York style. Char and everything! A must have if you live nearby! read more

See all

My family and I decided to try out this new pizza spot off of the recommendation of social media and were pleasantly surprised! First we noticed their very small menu, we knew with this small menu it had to be good and so we ordered their whole menu. Literally! I have to say it was BOMB! All of the pizzas were very tasty, tomato sauce tasted really good and so did the sticks and the garlic knots. This might be one of the best pizza shops in Indiana. Seriously! The service was also very friendly - ambiance/vibe was nothing special, just another pizza shop, but isn't that the charm of pizza spots? We will be back here for sure! read more

See all

Pizza is awesome, but the new customer experience is a bit lacking. It's impossible to get an order in here on a busy night without ordering at least 6 hours in advance. If you're trying to order food here on a weekend night you will probably have to call as soon as they open or order online during the morning hours. They are just so busy that they won't fit you in otherwise. There's not much of a way to know this without going in and just trying to order which will probably result in failure the first time, which is a little frustrating. Not sure what can be done to improve this. The pizza is incredible though. Some of the best crust I've ever had, and the flavor is a bit of a craft experience. It's worth trying, you just seriously have to plan ahead to be able to eat here. read more

The pepperoni pizza was great. I loved the sauce and the crisp crust with a slight pull to it. I will definitely be back. I really like how they topped the pizza with fresh basil. read more

Brooklyn Char - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Great pizza compared to all of Indy area. Do a pick up order. Just beer and soda. No wine. No ice for the soda . And yes, when asked, not even a knife to cut the very big slices. read more

Food. Service Atmosphere Pleasantly surprised at the Chicago style pizza and all the food was tasty. read more

Wow! This place is phenomenal. We are so fortunate that we live in Lochaven and can eat here a couple of times a week! Plan ahead! Due to high demand, you need to call ahead as its often 1hr+ wait time. Also, a big surprise to us, was that they have great ice cream and no wait for it:) We've had every pizza and even hosted a party where we got 8 pizzas for our office staff to try it. Everyone really liked the authenticity of this local gem! Congrats to a small business thriving!!! read more

See all

Today we stopped in to check out a new pizza joint. Brooklyn Char has it down from tasty top pies to crispy crust. It's likely one of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. The stuffed breadsticks were garlicky deliciousness full of cheesy pulls and flavor. The ONLY negative we found was that they don't have a menu posted, on paper, or even a website that details what speciality pizzas have on them. Having to ask about them was a thumbs down from us, as we couldn't quite hear the description over the kitchen noise and loud tv. We'll definitely eat there again, so here's to hoping they post a detailed menu somewhere! read more

Brooklyn Char - Stuffed breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

I've been wanting to try Brookyn Char for a while and so when my husband and I got back to Indy after a long flight from the west coast, I finally got around to it. I tried calling the shop first because I had a question about customizing an order. They answered, put me on hold for 13 minutes, and then I hung up. When I tried calling back the phone didn't ring and it just kept saying the voicemail hadn't been set up. Because of this, I ordered through their site. Once we arrived we were immediately greeted by a friendly employee. I told her I was early and didn't expect my order to be ready and she let me know it was still being worked on. We took a seat, and our order came out about 5 minutes after the expected time, which was no biggie. The slices on this pizza are huge, and truly NY style. We had the Godzilla and I loved it, but be aware, it is HOT, and my husband couldn't handle all of the peppers so he took them off and I ate them. The pepperoni are cupped and top quality. The peppers with the hot honey is the perfect combination of sweet and spicy. I also really liked their sauce and cheese quality. While I enjoyed the crust, I would say it's a bit on the chewier side for me, making eating multiple slices a bit laborious after a while. I wish it was a tad bit lighter/crispier. Overall though, great pizza and service. The space has a decent amount of seating, but the tables could have used some cleaning. read more

See all

I'm an East coast transplant, grew up in Philadelphia and 10 years in NYC. I've been disappointed in the pizza selection around Indianapolis and was excited to try Brooklyn Char, especially since I live near the new location. After three visits, an honest review. The two fundamental parts are pizza are the dough and sauce. Here they really hit the mark. Dough is great, light, crispy, and a really nice cook. The sauce is also right on, tangy, not too sweet, fantastic. Then there's the cheese. The only thing to get wrong here is the proportions, and they miss the mark. Before the oven it's hit with both shredded and cubed mozzarella. It's just too much and weighs down the beautiful crust. The real sin though is after the oven. They fresh grate an egregious amount of Parmesan on top. Not only does this slow down the expediter, it all just melts down on the already too much cheese and makes the pizza almost unpleasant. I asked for "light Parmesan" upon ordering, but of course the expediter didn't look at the ticket. I was watching so was able to stop him from implementing the parm downpour, toning it down to a light mist. Pizza was much improved without it. My advice to the owner, cut back 30% on the mozzarella. Have the parm pre grated and give the pies a one hand sprinkle. You'll cut down on food cost, expedite faster, and put out an amazing pizza. Probably should figure out a way to prep the basil better too, watching the expeditor snip snip snip snip snip snip snip snip snips snip on to the pizza is torture. All in all I'll keep going back. I'll be sure to get there before it's ready and watch to avoid the parmegedon. Maybe ask for light cheese too. Also call ahead and order early. They really back up on busy nights. Good for them. If you have to wait for the pizza, that's probably a good thing. Wish I could give it 5 stars. But the cheese issue drops a star. It's an easy fix, I hope they make it. read more

Brooklyn Char - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Absolutely fantastic pizza thin crispy with a wonderful char in it. Probably the best pizza in the area. My wife and I will be back! read more

Brooklyn Char - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

We love Goodfellas in Brip but holy crap Brooklyn Char blew them out of the water. This is an awesome NY style pizza finished with hand grates Parm cheese. The place is a little hard to find as they don't have their signature up yet. Stop in grab a pie and taste test for yourself. read more

Best pizza I've had in the entire Indianapolis metro. I spent 20+ years in NYC and I've probably tried most of the major shops there, from midtown to Brooklyn and Queens to downtown and Jersey. This place is legit. Nice fold, proper cupping on the pepperoni, great tang from the sharp hand-shredded parm. Staff and owner are super chill and friendly. I placed my order around 5:30 and it was ready for pickup 15 minutes later. At the time of writing, they only take carry out orders and hours are late afternoon to 9:00 on weeknights (closed Monday & Tuesday) and noon-9 on Fri & Sat, via phone or a Toast link from their website. After 6 or so it can get pretty busy with longer waits, but it doesn't matter -- totally worth it. Run, don't walk to this place my friends. It's solid. read more

Brooklyn Char - Half pepperoni half cheese - Pizza Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

We had the pepperoni pizza. Pepperoni have a nice little bite to them. Sauce vs crust is spot on for NYC pizza. A little flop on the crust, but the under carriage is spot on. They do have a liquor license with a few beers on tap. Two or so tables inside and a few outside. The cashier was very pleasant and welcoming. A tad pricey .but heh so is everyplace else. Located next to Big Woods, in the old pizza hut spot Will definitely go back! read more

Stopped by here after seeing a ton of buzz on social media. We called ahead and were able to pick it up in store fairly quickly. The cost was a little higher than normal for two pies, but it did make more sense after seeing the size of the HUGE pizzas. Eating it, you could tell that the ingredients were fresh and the sauce was good. We have had a lot of east coast pizzas, so I went in with high expectations and it lived up to the hype. Overall, I usually like mine a little less crispy, but I know the east coast style is definitely a little crispy. It wouldn't not my favorite every week pizza in the area, but it will be a good option for special occasions or when craving that type going forward. read more