We were delighted to check out Pizza House in Cicero for the first time yesterday...and it definitely won't be our last. :-) We tried both their regular and their deluxe breadsticks and they were awesome. We also shared a small pizza. Thin crust was perfect (crispy, not soggy) and the finely ground sausage was just the way my wife likes it. In addition to great food, this faith-based business is focused on providing food and other assistance to those in need. Just one more great reason to support them with our patronage. :-) We will be back...soon! read more

1 st time visit, handicap accessible, clean dining room. The owner greeted us and explained the menu. We had the supreme Bread sticks they were wonderful. We had a pizza with all the toppings. It was very good and served 4 people with left overs. My son wanted to Calzone and only ate 1/2. He said it was best one he ever had. Excellent service read more

We just moved into the area and stumbled across Pizza House. It was a really fun and chill atmosphere inside and the staff were extremely friendly and accommodating. The pizza was great! I love a variety of different kinds of pizza and this one definitely fits a niche style. Great thin crust, slightly sweet sauce and great flavor from the crust up to the toppings. Our 10 month old son didn't make a peep as he was eating his share! I am excited to go back and try the hand tossed crust. We had the original and ultra thin crusts and I think I liked the original slightly better but both were great! read more

We get take out or delivery from here on occasion. The restaurant itself is small but cute and is clean. The staff has always been friend either in person or over the phone. The parking lot itself is small! The pizza it's self is good, I would not say the best I've ever had but it is good and it's always consistent. Prices are okay and I think on point for what you get. I hear their chicken is excellent and they have taco pizza on the menu which is rare for the area. read more

See all

We have hade pizza house several times. It is good thin crust pizza. I would say it is the second best pizza in Cicero behind bronkos but still very solid pizza read more

The manger on 6/13/25 was rude.I will never order from them again. His comment was"we have high school girls working". Really not my problem. read more

This is one of the most consistent Pizza place in Hamilton county. Ever since this pizza place has had one of the best pizza in Cicero,Indiana From the first day Pizza House opened it's doors it has constantly improved all of its food. The only pizza place I use to think was better was Pizza hut but over the years and decades pizza hut had changed it's recipes of it top sellers and has gone down in quality while Pizza House has done nothing but improve it's pizza and chicken as well as all of its food items. I will definitely be coming back again and again. I will be your customer for life read more

A nice little small town pizza joint. Clean and cozy. Food was good and reasonably priced. Staff is friendly and courteous. Service was quick, even on a Saturday night. Not best I've had, but far from the worst. read more

See all

My wife and I went on a Friday night during rush, but walked right now. Cleanly place with a helpful wait staff. Games are available for the kids. During our hour there they were slammed with take out and delivery order.We had a couple of Three Floyd's Gum Ball Heads and their deluxe breadsticks to start out with. (Highly recommend the deluxe sticks over the original.) Ae then ordered the original crust pepperoni pizza. Everything was fresh and very tasty. We will be back to try the fried chicken! They definitely sold more of that than pizzas while we were there. Overall great dining experience! read more

First visit and not impressed. Ordered the Taco deluxe and the Veggie pizza's original crust on both and I believe what they mean by original is antique or old because it tasted stale. Otherwise the taco deluxe was without deluxe. Taco Deluxe had big chunks of lettuce, tomatoes a few tortilla chips on a bed of sour cream, notice I didn't say cheese. Now for the veggie, ridiculously plain and tasteles. The service was very friendly even though the pizza was done 15 minutes after the stated done time. very disappointed read more

This place is a hidden gem! A friend who lives in Cicero introduced me to Pizza House. Most of their business is carry out, but they have several small tables so you can order at the counter and eat in if you want. The pizza is very good but the breadsticks and cinnamon sticks are awesome! Potato wedges are excellent too. Prices are very cheap, especially for the area. read more

1 or 2 weeks ago, we receive an order that was all wrong. They promised us credit for the screw up. I gladly accepted it. 1 or 2 weeks later, I called up for the credit and they said they can't find it in their system, then later on the conversation that they offered half of the credit, which meant that I would have to pay the other half. So I declined the offer since Pizza House decided not to honor the credit the had given me for screwing up my previous order with them. I will do longer business with them again even after I had done with them many times in the past, but it appears their business ethics has severely declined. read more

Ordered carry out from here last week while boating. The pizza was that of a cardboard texture and had no flavor. My kids didn't even like it. The breadsticks were so greasy we ended up feeding them to the fish! read more

Great pizza Great broasted chicken We received an over cook broasted chicken. The manager actually made us a whole new batch and had it delivered to the house. Kudos to him read more

The pizza is average, and the staff (seems like a high school run business) is good and friendly, but wait times and price drag it down a bit. read more

We stopped here after a day at the local historic park. The restaurant was clean and server was friendly. We ordered several items including a 16 inch extra large pizza. When the pizza came out, it was less than 12 inches. I assumed the waitress misheard us. We ate the pizza, but unfortunately did not have enough to eat our fill. I was going to order another. But when I asked the waitress about it, she said it was a 16 inch pizza but that they shrink in the oven. She clearly had gotten this complaint before. She then said that because we ordered hand tossed pizza, it is up to the cook to decide how big to make it. Unacceptable. To their credit, they discounted our bill, but we still had to go somewhere else to get more food. read more

This place is alright for takeout. Its only competition in Cicero is Domino's, and Pizza King...if I'm in the mood for pizza, and we're not makin' em at home, this is usually the place. The pizza is good. Not the greatest in the universe, but better than the chain options here. The crust isn't great. It used to be better than it is now...the ownership changed a while back, and since then we've stopped frequenting this place...sadly. The chicken is also good(ish)...a little dry though. read more

Foods alright. Business is all over the place. I hear they have new owners not too happy with pricing going up wonder why that is? i feel like every time i call i'm put on hold last time i tried calling i was hung up on 3x and whenever i go to pick up my food i have to wait an extra 10 minutes i even come later than they tell me to and i'm still having to say just to even pay. I know it's ran by high school students and that's awesome but they need more order! read more

Good pizza but service is a disaster. No visible organization. But food is fine. Best to just call in an order

Dont do it. 1:45 minutes later the extra sauce that i ordered is now dried up because the pizza sat under a heat lamp for an hour. The potatoes are again dried out. How it took almost 2 hours and i am 9 blocks away. read more

Best Stromboli's around, maybe anywhere. At least the best I've had. Wings are great!!! The staff is top notch, fast, and courteous. I always look forward to my trips to Indiana so I can eat here. read more

wow.. This is a great place for pizza, wings and the broasted chicken is to die for. The mac and cheese is one of the best we have had out in quite awhile, It is very creamy. the pizza was perfect, the crust was the not too thick , the sauce was the perfect amount. We will be back. Yumm read more

We have gone here for the past several months for carry out. They have always been busy, but still attentive when you walk in. Food is always hot and tasty. We love their Stromboli's and wings. Carolina bbq is our favorite. read more

I haven't had the pizza but the chicken is legit. Will definitely order it again. Great seasoning and not overly greasy. Good stuff.

Oh. My. God. I don't know how I have never tried this place! We didn't even get the pizza- butwe tried their wings, Stromboli and Italian sandwiches, and breadsticks! I'm in absolute love! They had great customer service as well. I am looking forward to trying their pizza! read more

The staff are very friendly and helpful. The pizza is bland. It was mostly dough, very little bland sauce and tasteless cheese. Unfortunately, and one and done for us. read more

Food is to die for. Never had a bad dish yet! And they deliver all the way to my house in Arcadia! Score! *BUT* I have waited up to two hours for my food to arrive and only because I called to ask where the heck it was! This has happened about six out of ten of the times that I've ordered from here. And about FIVE out of the six times my order was either wrong or cold...bummer. Best breadsticks I've had thus far. I only they can step it up with their deliveries!! Love you anyway, Pizza House. Next time, I'm driving to pick up my order! read more

Food is great, if you like coleslaw they have the best I've ever had..it's a little odd at first but you find yourself craving it later. Taco deluxe pizza is fantastic. The only down side to this place is the slow delivery times, but if you plan for it it's not that big of a deal. read more

Place has went downhill . I placed order for pickup and wait forever for my order. Listening to who appeared to be manager and was yelling out to kids working there who took this orders for others coming out of oven and still no pizza . Pizza was not even been made . Terrible compared to past owners ! Used to be my favorite. Now I'm scared to go back read more

Went for the 1st time tonight. Pizza was good, crust made to our specifications. Wings can come dry or coated. The wing sauce selection was wonderful! They were all good. It was very hard to pick one! Fried ravioli and breadsticks were also great! Taylor is extremely personal and running a good show! Cheers!! read more

Great food, great staff & management, and great location to stroll around the reservoir after dinner.

This place is heaven. Their wings are legit amazing - meat is raised locally, massive portions, completely smothered in sauce - and that house "suracha bourbon" sauce?! a refreshingly unique and addictive blend. For a place with the word Pizza in it, the pizza might actually be the only mediocre thing they offer on their menu - but let's be honest, even their pizza is orgasmic. Hats off to the guys throwing these ingredients around back in the kitchen, and Taylor (I think was his name) went above and beyond with making sure everyone felt welcomed and attended to. read more

Best broasted chicken ever!! Great owners and quality food! They deliver and that's always a plus! read more

This pizza is soo good!!! We ordered pickup and it was ready at the time they said it would be. The staff was so nice and attentive. We got a pepperoni, bacon, and banana pepper pizza and couldn't have been happier. We also got their deluxe breadsticks that I highly recommend. Just make sure you get an extra order of cheese to go with it! Stellar pizza shop! read more

First off I want to say is that I use to love this place. Best pizza place in Cicero. I've been eating here since 2017 and have loved their pizza. On the 5th of September was my fiancé's birthday. I thought it would be fitting to celebrate with some pizza. I paid 30 dollars for 3 small pizzas and breadsticks. I pick up my order and bring it home to find the pepperoni and sausage pizzas hardly have any toppings on them. I'm talking about like 5 sausages on top. I take a bite of the pepperoni to find it below the cheese not on top. Weird but okay. I've never felt like a pizza tasted like a saltine cracker with just sauce until now. The ratio of cheese to sauce was just off. I also purchased cokes. Those tasted like watered down soda. The only thing saving this review was the breadsticks. Man those were delicious ! I'm sad because I really liked this place but it's just one bad experience can ruin a customers ability to want to come back! read more

My favorite pizza in Cicero! The staff is mostly teenagers but they are nice. The pizza is good, and the breadsticks are amazing... And the prices are great if you make a trip to cicero stop in Pizza house! read more

We are new to town and trying all the restaurants. Pizza House served a delicious vegetarian pizza (even the leftovers were good) and the meatball sub was large and delicious. I also like the potato wedges! Delish!! Going to try some more! read more

Typically ... pizza and chicken is excellent. However... April 10 ordered pizza and 12 piece chicken dinner for delivery... 2 hours later ... still no delivery and no call... after phoning for update... was told delivery person was out... then story changed... delivery person was packing up to leave.. when finally arrived 20 minutes later .. pizza was cold, chicken was cold... Delivery guy told me to call management and complain. ... read more

Great service on a very busy night. It was our first visit and we ordered takeout. Pizza was good, the place was very well-staffed with friendly and helpful employees. We'll be back! read more

Ordered the chicken....tasted burnt..very disappointed. We have made it a point to stop on our way back home....The food was very mediocre...how sad...we will not stop again. The customer service was lovely..but I would rather have great tasting food to accompany the service. My son said the Calzone he ordered was meh also. So sad we really loved eating there in the past. read more