We had a Christmas get together among friends. There were 8 of us. Katie was our server. SHE WAS AMAZING!!! We had special orders. Diet restrictions and one of us wanted his cheese burger with sauté onions, mushrooms and jalapeño. She happily took our orders. Kept the drinks filled and help take pictures of our group. Katie made our night perfect. BTW the food was great too. read more

2 of us went on a Wednesday around 6pm and did not need a reservation. They seated us in the cellar which is like a speak easy. I highly recommend you request this area. I love the decor and the bar in the basement. It made me feel like I am in a different Country. Wednesday's special $22 Filet mignon dinner with side and salad. We both ordered the special and the spinach artichoke dip. Pros: speakeasy aka Cellar in the basement Cons: Parking is always an issue when I am visiting. I try to find something on the street. This time I found a little lot and walked to the restaurant read more

See all

Since Ten West changed owners, we have heard and seen various opinions, but most saying not the same anymore. They are one of our favorite carry-out places, so we decided to give them another shot tonight! Our meals were delicious and tasted very much the same quality we have always had. My husband enjoyed the walleye and I had the bacon-wrapped pork tenderloin. Both were great! We had to share my mashed sweet potatoes, since they forgot his, but they were terrific and so was the creamed corn! Missed the warm bread they used to include, but we didn't need it. Overall, we will continue to enjoy 10 West! Sometimes you just have to give places time to adjust. Thanks for a great supper tonight! read more

Share a family celebration here with our children & their families. Our group was 7 and service was excellent. It was quiet enough to enjoy conversations around the table. Dinners all came at the same time which was unusual for such a large party.Delicious and fresh salads. Folks ordered steaks, pasta and chicken. All excellent. read more

My wife and I were in Cicero on a Sunday close to noon, but we had already ate breakfast hours ago. The one local restaurant had a small line outside of people waiting on breakfast, so we chose 10 West hoping for a decent lunch. Upon being seated, our waiter showed us the brunch menu and we almost left, but decided to stay and try the more lunch type foods on the lunch limited menu. I had the salmon BLT, and was completely in love with every bite. It came with fries, but I substituted the Tomato horseradish soup which was awesome and not too spiced. The perfect compliment to this extravagant lunch was the bloody Mary bar where I put all the olives I wanted in my drink. Funny thing about this trip was my wife ordered the Indiana Sugar creme pie pancakes for lunch...they were great but we brought half of it home. read more

See all

This was my first time here for dinner. The drinks were great. Our server was always right there when we needed her and my lord the food. Absolutely fantastic. I had the prime rib special and my wife had the manhattan we both were incredibly pleased and my son loved his grilled cheese and fruit. It was a good mix of like date night vibes but also family friendly. I really can't believe it took me 2 years to finally come here but the Thursday night special will definitely bring me back! read more

See all

Had a great breakfast here the other day. The sugar cream pie pancakes were to die for! Coffee is self serve. Service was friendly. Feels more upscale than the breakfast joint a couple doors down. But honestly, I enjoyed it for a casual breakfast more! read more

10 West - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

See all

My wife and I were regulars here for nearly 10 years. We loved everything about it, from the food and service, to atmosphere and entertainment. It was a staple of Cicero, and it was the only place I would recommend in Hamilton County. I even included a screenshot of my first review for comparison. Unfortunately, the 10 West that we came to love and appreciate no longer exists. As of March 2024, the heart and soul behind what made this restaurant what it was - Bill and Lisa - parted ways with their business partner. Before the switchover, the social media presence and communication was top notch. After the FaceBook post announcing the departure and new staff, however, there was radio silence. No introduction of the new Chef or owners, and no recognition of the change. The new owners were merely trying to ride on the coattails of 10 years of incredible success by staying as quiet as they possibly could, hoping no one would notice. For us, however, the change in management was blatantly obvious in our first (and only visit) after the turnover. Upon arriving, there was an empty feeling in the restaurant. No personality, no charisma, and a heavy sense of defeat in the staff. It was reminiscent of a funeral home, which was appropriate, given the circumstances. At this point in time (04/2024) many of the same staff members were there, and we saw a few familiar faces. Those that we knew from the past decade were happy to see us, came over to say hey, and catch up on everything that had changed. We visited with 5 separate employees during our visit, which was the only highlight of the night. Here are some of the issues/concerns we observed during this visit: - We were given dirty appetizer plates and menus when seated They changed the coasters to very thin tagboard material, which curled when it got wet, and eventually shredded itself when picking up your drink glass - The spinach dip appetizer was no longer fresh spinach, but frozen. The drop in quality was very obvious. Additionally, they didn't even shred the frozen spinach similar to their predecessors did with the fresh spinach, which made it even more difficult to scoop with a chip - Cocktails were watered down compared to before, but the cost was the same - Dishes sat on our table for up to 20 minutes before being taken away, proving that they weren't touching the tables on a regular basis to keep everything clear for customers - My steak was overcooked - My wife's fish was burnt, not blackened - The floor manager was making rounds to tables, and because he saw us talking to multiple employees he must have known we were regulars. You would think that would be a perfect situation to introduce yourself to your loyal customer base, ask for feedback, and bridge the gap between ownership. Instead, he made eye contact with us multiple times, but avoided us the entire night. - The cake was one of the driest, most bland desserts I've ever had at a restaurant. The icing was very thin, and it tasted as if it was made no less than 5 days prior. To summarize: I will never be back to this location. It's obvious they cut corners every way they could to maximize profit. It's an insult to what 10 West used to be, but you know they won't change the name, or it would be obvious to everyone that it's no longer the same. However, the regulars knew right away, just like us. I have since been informed that after our visit that 10 West is under new ownership (again), only this time the owners of The Nesst in Noblesville. I wasn't impressed with them either, as their food was overpriced and underwhelming. If you want to experience the culinary perfection that was here during the first decade, go pay a visit to bar ellis in Noblesville. It is owned and operated by Lisa, her sister Chamron, and Bill is still working his magic in the kitchen. You will see a lot of familiar faces/dishes, a higher standard in every regard, a beautifully restored building, and the REAL after dark menu, not the one 10 West copied and began doing after bar ellis opened. 10 West removed this review from Google (and all negative Google reviews in the past year) which proves that I was right. I'll be screenshotting this after posting, because I'm sure they will try to do the same again. read more

10 West - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

See all

Visited as a party of 6 on a Wednesday evening. The ambiance in the side room is really cozy/warm/stay a while, and it's easier to visit when you can sit around a round table and see everyone. The food was good but not great. I had the filet special with asparagus for the side dish and it came with a salad appetizer. The side salad was excellent. I ordered the filet medium well and agreed to have them butterfly it for better grilling. I ordered mushrooms on the steak. The steak was tasty but arrived mostly rare, so I sent it back. It came back perfectly cooked and on a fresh plate with fresh mushrooms and asparagus. The steak and mushrooms were delicious. The asparagus was ok, but you get only 3 or 4 spears. Service was ok. Our server was new/in training, and he seemed sometimes excellent and sometimes surly. I chalked it up to nerves. In summary, we had a great evening. The ambiance and food added up to a nice evening out with friends. read more

This place is worth the time to make a reservation. So much better than Applebees or TGI Fridays. I had a salad and steak. The wife ate the fish tacos. She then ordered her vegetables to go....in the form of the carrot cake. She says it's the best around. Me, I don't do veggie cake. Now for the negative, they don't have coke products. It's all Pepsi and that is nasty. Pepsi tastes like coke pored in a glass that still has dove dish soap in it. Yuck. The best park of the evening was Lexie. She was there when you needed her, and not when you wanted to play footsie under the table. When you go, ask for her. read more

This place is really bad. -Food, awful -Waiter, stoned to the point of confusion -Vibe, strange and stuffy This place is rly bad, anything they make here, you can make better at home! Promise. Save your money and go elsewhere! Completely messed up our order and didn't even offer to take the dish off the bill. read more

A nice, quiet Friday night dinner. We had reservations and were seated immediately. We requested a regular table as opposed to a high top and that was accommodated. Staff is efficient and nice. We enjoyed crab stuffed mushrooms for an appetizer. Very generous portion w lots of crab meat! Very good My husband had the Meatballs and spaghetti. Good but nothing special. I had the Chicken Milanese. Very tender and flavorful. The broccoli was cooked perfectly. Nice dinner in a neat old building with very nice staff. We came back for brunch on Sunday and it was fantastic! The eggs in a blanket were delicious. Loved the sourdough bread and arugula. The 10 West breakfast burrito is also very good w a nice balance of egg and cheese. The champagne flight was a nice addition to the brunch. Our waiter was very attentive, helpful and nice! read more

Tried this place and I was blown away. This is a secret gem for sure. We had reservations which was good because on a Saturday at 7:30 it was packed. There was, however plenty of parking around the building so no worries there. The menu has something for everyone, steak, sandwiches, salads, pasta, just a wide variety of items to choose from. It took us all some time to pick what we wanted because everything sounded so good. I landed on steak and a baked potato. It was cooked to perfection. Because it was my birthday celebrations, I also was able to pick from a dessert. I picked the carrot cake. While typically I'm not the biggest fan of carrot cake, the server said how amazing it was and she was right. Lastly - They do have a speak easy type area in the basement called the cellar. We were able to have dinner down there (we put the request in ahead of time), but there were many people down there just have cocktails. Really nice vibe down there where you would want to go even if you aren't having dinner. read more

See all

Date night with my wife. We sat at the bar with wonderful service from the bartender Rachel! Felt like a regular and royalty. Drinks were on point and food delivered once again. Post dinner music in side bar by Dakota. Highly recommend! read more

10 West - Dakota - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

We are regular customers. We tried to make a reservation and open table wasn't working. Called for a reservation and told they couldn't take one but if we got there by 5 there would not be a problem. We arrived at 4:30. Asked for a booth and told no,they we were reserved. They were all empty at the time. We were seated in the family room by our self's . Our waiter didn't even know we were there . When we were served Mason did a great job. The room then filled with 4 other people and a family with a crying baby they started to seat right by us. The father of the child made in choice to move at least one table away ! The Walleye was very fishy which has never happened before. When we left the booths were still empty except one Very disappointed read more

We held our children's wedding rehearsal dinner there Friday evening for eleven people. We had made arrangements with Stacy a few weeks prior to create a custom menu with the bride and grooms names and wedding colors. The whole event was flawless! The food was top notch, and our waitress Melissa was on it! I would have a hard time finding a better experience. If I ever need to hold a similar event again in this area, it will be held at the 10 West. Thank you again for a wonderful evening. Andy read more

I had high hopes for 10 West, but unfortunately, the meal fell flat across the board. Every dish we tried lacked basic seasoning -- the potatoes, steak, broccoli, and fish were all incredibly bland and flavorless. To make matters worse, the pork was extremely dry and tough to get through. For a restaurant that seems to pride itself on quality, the execution was surprisingly poor. Definitely not worth the price, and I don't plan on returning. None of our food was hot either, just warm. The staff were all very friendly though and it is a neat restaurant. read more

Food is perfectly seasoned and cooked. Waitress was very knowledgeable about the menu. Very friendly. Food was served in a timely manner. Loved the atmosphere. Very different from other eateries. I strongly recommend this place to anyone who wants a good experience. read more

I made a reservation online for 7:30 in the basement, but didn't get seated until 8. They were busy, so I completely understand, and the basement is a smaller setting. You can't force people out the door, nor should you rush them. So I get the wait, and it really wasn't a problem for us. We had nowhere else to be. The ambiance is nice with a moderate amount of noise, and a lively scene. It's a family friendly restaurant set in a very quaint town. Local conversation, friends, family, out-of-town visitors. Brick walls, nice lighting, clean, and an old world feel. We did not get a pre-meal drink at the bar, but noticed their large selection and impressive display. It's definitely busy on a Friday night. I would suggest a reservation. Once we were seated (basement seating is highly recommended), our waitress was very receptive to our needs. The entire night. The basement feel captures the speakeasy vibe, and is adjacent to an even more relaxed lounge with ample relaxed seating. For starters, I ordered the crab stuffed mushrooms (amazing), and the horseradish tomato bisque soup. The soup was good, had a horseradish presence and a nice mouth feel, but lacked depth through the use of spices. The saving grace was a crusty, buttery, and warm sliced baguette for dipping. My wife enjoyed it very much. She got the spinach artichoke dip. Nice chunks of artichoke, and a good consistency for the tortilla chips. We ordered a bottle of Dablon Riesling. Good stuff. For my main, I tried the chicken and noodles. Nice handmade, rolled noodles like your grandma used to make. The chicken was a little dry, but the broth was good, and the whipped potatoes put me in my comfort zone. My wife got the filet with whipped potatoes and brussel sprouts. The filet cut like butter with a fork. A very nice steak. However, check the online menu for current prices. Pictures of the menus are outdated by quite a bit and should be removed to reflect the current prices. Our night ran late as we enjoyed our relaxed time and were encouraged by the waitress to take our time. We closed the place out, and took a to go cheesecake slice, which was the cherry on top. Literally. A must visit if you can. read more

See all

The food was very average. Not very flavorful. I had the Chicken Marsala and my wife had a Cavapatti pasta dish. Some of the tomatoes were not cooked. The sauce was bland. The service was very good though. Very attentive! The hostess lost us at one point The ambiance was bar like! At least downstairs was. Too loud! read more

I have dined here several times with friends, and the food is consistently delicious. Do yourself a favor, and try the Tomato Horseradish Soup-incredible! Everything from the steaks to seafood to pasta dishes is always fantastic, as is the service. I recommend asking to be seated in the lower level section; the atmosphere is different from the main dining room and adds a great ambiance to the dining experience. All in all, great fine dining tucked away in small town Indiana. read more

Love everything about 10 west. Wouldn't change a thing from my existing review. Food, service, and vibes are on point every time. Plus the drinks are great too! Reasonably priced! read more

See all

This was my and my husband's first visit here and we couldn't have been more pleased Melissa was attentive and informative. My cocktail was next level. We'll definitely be back read more

Amazing food, great atmosphere. The food is always outstanding, cannot recommend pork medallions enough. Bread and butter is so so good. Was surprised at portion size for kids meal. read more

See all

I had wanted to try for a while. We went today and will not return. This place, with their service and food leaves a lot to be desired. It was not even mid.... The waiter seemed confused most of the time of what we ordered, and what we didn't. It also took a long time to come out. It seems like there's teenagers working in the kitchen. That's fine, but maybe be hire an actual chef. The brunch burgers were not good. They were super thin with zero seasoning or flavor. It says it's a half pound burger. Absolutely not, it was at best, 4 to 5 ounces...... I wish I would've taken a photo to post with my review. I asked for fries with it and he was like "oh let Me ask " then came back and "we don't do fries with the brunch burger"... OK how hard would it be for the kitchen to make some fries? Someone else in our party ordered a burrito vegetarian style. It came out with meat in it. They then remade it and excluded what originally should have been in there. Not worth it for below mid food and service. They seem apathetic about the food and service there. read more

I love 10 West! The food is always great and the service is exceptional. Do yourself a favor and ask for Megan. She's the best!

We love going to 10 West. It's a fun atmosphere with delicious food and we had the best service. Megan was phenomenal. She was so friendly and knowledgeable. She made our dining experience even more enjoyable. I highly recommend going and asking for her. read more

We went for Sunday brunch and had a great time. Food was great, service was excellent and you cant beat having a coffee and bloody Mary bar! Unfortunately, I don't remember our servers name because I would love to mention her. read more

Thank you to our bartender, Joe M, for the awesome service!! We had a great time and our drinks were delicious!! We will definitely be coming back! read more

10 West - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Date night at 10 West. 10 Star service from Ashely and Rachel. Live music from Dakota King was fabulous! read more

We have eaten here before and the experience was nice. This time, again we had reservations and with children we had 6 total. Even calling in advance we requested a large table for our evening of dining. We were set at a 4 top (small table) while other larger tables were available. We were also sat next to the kitchen door. So a cramped space with servers walking past you and or bumping your chair was the tone. We asked to be moved and was told that "we will see". Not one to ruin the special occasion we were celebrating, I simply chose to deal with our situation and try and make the best of things. We ordered spinach dip which came out cold. The pretzel sticks were hot and for what they were, they were good. Getting our server to keep our drinks filled seemed to be an ongoing challenge as well as getting our salads. This was not a full restaurant at the time we were seated. We all ordered steaks and our steaks were cooked perfectly. The famous cream corn wasn't very good this time around. I was simply not happy with the lack of service we recieved for the $350 plus bill we recieved. One never likes to sit by the kitchen door and if you are going to have tables by the kitchen, make sure there is room so that your customers chairs aren't getting bumped into all night. For that kind of money, I have a higher expectation for the service and food I received on this evening. read more

Every time we go to 10 West in Cicero we wonder why we don't eat here more often! It's a bit of a drive, that's the only reason why! Service is outstanding; food is always VERY good and decently priced; drinks are generous. We enjoy sitting in the lower level which I believe they call The Cellar. It has a hip vive and also feels cozy. The whole restaurant is great and food is always very good! Try it- reservations highly recommended. read more

See all

Food is delicious and the service is good. Chicken and noodles is one of our favorite budget dinners. We also like their steak.

had Brunch for the Colts game and thanks to Darren for being a great waiter. The food was amazing Along with a coffee and Bloody Mary bar. What else could you ask for? read more

We arrived early for a 12:30pm reservation. Since we made the reservation on the OpenTable app, we had no idea that the menu shown on Open Table was not available. Only brunch menu. (Sadly we were looking forward to a steak and mushrooms for lunch on a Saturday afternoon.) Mallory our waitress was assigned to our large group but didn't seem to like being at work this day. It was for my daughter's 39th birthday and there was no mention of it by any of the staff. I ordered the bagels and lox-the lox was slimy like it was about to expire. My 6 & 7 year old grandsons ordered chicken tenders which were raw inside. Service was slow. Food was sub par. Ambience was nothing special. We drove to Cicero from Carmel because my daughter had been there once before and she Liked the place. I will not be back. Steven comped our meals (as he should) but I guess we had too high of expectations. read more

One of the best restaurants in Hamilton county. Great for both a date night and a family dinner. Food is great, service is always spectacular and the kids meals are a steal! read more

We went on a Wednesday night and made a reservation just in case. Lots of seating options, but we opted for the bar. Service was excellent, drinks were generous, and our salads were well made. Beef and blue and the blackened salmon salad. Green goddess house dressing was delicious. Beef was cooked to order and salmon was done nicely. We also had the stuffed mushroom appetizer...cheesey excellence...light on the crab flavor. The downstairs space looked nice and cozy. All the staff were friendly. You can tell locals frequent this place and it has a following. read more

10 West is a favorite. This time the food was so-so, and service a bit off. My wife's fish tacos were generic and not particularly flavorful. We were told there would be 5 jalapeño poppers and there were 4. Then when we got the bill, there were a bunch of drinks on the bill we didn't order or have. Fortunately we caught it and it was corrected. So overall so-so evening. We'll likely come back, but we'll likely find another place like Noblesville Grindstone. read more

Don't know if they have a new chef or manager but the food prep is no longer at the quality it once was. One fish order served raw in the middle the other overcooked. Never used to have these issues. read more

The Food was super good but our server was better, Pro tip ask for Rachel when you go!