I had not been here in years (since I moved away from Anderson). The pizza is still great, especially the sausage used. Stop by and try it, you will not be disappointed. read more

Scampy's Annex - 7" Combo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

I've heard good things about their pizza forever so I was excited to try, but was very disappointed. The crust was fine but the sauce was oddly sweet, and cheese (which I was excited because they put a lot) was so rubbery. It's rare that I dislike pizza. But at $25 for a large, I could barely take a few bites. And to top it off, not a single person greeted us, or was friendly in any way, our waiter seemed annoyed. Nothing redeeming. read more

I placed a carry out order for a chef salad and a medium pizza. Chef salad was delicious! It was loaded with cucumbers, tomatoes, eggs & cheese. I was super excited to try the pizza. My excitement quickly turned into disappointment. First, the pizza was not cut so I had to get my pizza cutter out and cut it before I could try it. I would have been very upset had I not had a pizza cutter handy. The crust was thin and hard. The cheese and toppings were all stuck together & came completely off the crust. The pizza was bland and lacked seasoning. For the $24 I spent, I definitely expected better. The place is in need of a major remodel. Didn't really pay much attention to the tables, but definitely noticed the OLD, dirty, carpeting. Will not be back. read more

Nice local bar with a home town feel in Anderson. I think what stood out to me about this place is everyone was very nice and it really seemed like everyone knew everyone. Even though it was my first time there it felt warm and welcoming. The server was the only one there and her attitude was 10/10. Dawn was her name and I tell you, she handled that place and had such an amazing attitude. I've seen servers with less tables have terrible attitudes! The pizza is very good. Came out super hot and the toppings tasted very fresh. Drinks are cheap, they also have a Touch Tunes and many TVs. Just a really solid place. read more

Scampy's Annex - a piece of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

See all

We tried multiple items off the app menu and a steak and cheese sandwich. Honestly the quality was so bad. It was a notch above a school lunch. Nothing is seasoned well, the bread and potato skins were undercooked. We took it back to get a refund, which I am glad they let us do. read more

Did a pickup order on 7/24/2025. Service was fine. The first thing that I noticed was how heavy my pizza box was, and I was really pleased when I opened it! They definitely covered the works pizza with toppings and did not hold back! The sausage on the pizza really made it for me, very very tasty. I think the next time, I will ask them to bake it a little bit longer since I would've liked the bottom crust to be a little bit more crunchy. The breadsticks were OK, they themselves and not have much flavor, but the dipping sauces were very good and paired well with them. The inside of The Restaurant looks like it hasn't been changed since the early 90s, so it is not much to look at on the inside, but the food more than makes up for it! read more

I have been to the pub side and it is fine. This review is for the annex/restaurant side. I visited at about 2pm on a Monday afternoon. There were two other people inside. The first thing that I noticed was the string smell of cooked pizza dough coming from the kitchen. One of the challenges of being a good pizza place is that the whole place smells like pizza. We were promptly seated and our orders were taken quickly. The ham and cheese and personal pizza were outstanding. The food has always been good here. That being said, the strip mall that it is in is old and almost off-putting. This place and the bar side have been here for a long time. Most of the customers are regulars and older. I would not let that stop you from enjoying it. The whole place does need a deep cleaning and makeover but this doesn't seem like the place that has $20K in cash reserves or is going to take out a huge bank loan to do the updates. I assume that it will keep going as it is until owners or those that inherit it retire. I have always had good service and good food. The place is just dated, which I am a-ok with! read more

Scampy's Annex - Strip mall with Scampy's Pub and Pizza Annex. - Pizza Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

For bar food, it's very good! The pizza is very good as our sandwiches! The service can be slow depending on how busy the bar is. Nice place to go to have drinks and some good food! The weekends are busy, but very lively! read more

Great Family place to get affordable Great tasting food! My favorite is the baked pasta! Portion is large enough to share or take home for a good lunch next day. There is a Family side and a full separate bar if you prefer an Adult setting. read more

This pizza place was recommended from a friend. It is small and family friendly. When I walked in, at 1st glance, the place could have been a little more tidy. I was confused as to whether to seat myself, but when I asked, they were very helpful. On to the good part. I felt like I had the friendliest waiter I could have ever had. He was very polite and made us feel very comfortable. I ordered garlic bread and pizza. Within 10 minutes, I was served both. They were both straight out of the oven and very good. The pizza toppings were piled on thick (just how I like it). For some odd reason, even the Diet Coke tasted very good! I would go back the next time I'm in the area. read more

Scampy's Annex - Combo pizza (sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers & mushrooms) - Pizza Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

See all

food was good. waiter seemed likes he had better things to do. room temp was 80°. refused to lower the temperature. thats nuts

The pizza is amazing. Definitely a local staple for pizza. Cozy dive bar atmosphere with great food!

Scampy's is an alright establishment. It has some good pizza, pretty good restrooms, and ok customer service. Although their breadsticks are dry but pretty good. They even stated it themselves that it was dry. Overall I recommend going there but they could be a little bit better. But I'd still would go there every once in a while. It's still a good pizza place. read more

Menu clearly states " $1.50 off all pasta dinners on Thursday"..this discount only applies to dine-in but that's NOT how they advertise it! They would not honor the discount on my carry out order. read more

I ordered carryout from here a couple of days ago and was pleased with the food, the price and the friendliness of the staff. The pizza and garlic cheese bread were excellent, can't wait to try some other options next time! read more

See all

Their pizza is the best and has been for many years. Thanks and keep up the great job for many more years to come.

I have been going to Scampys off and on for years. It doesn't look like much on the outside but the magic is on the inside. Great pizza, burgers and oh yeah the roast beef sandwich is to die for. I have had other roast beef in Anderson but Scampys is the best! read more

Food was great! Service was good, and the atmosphere is your typical local hole in the wall bar. Perfect night out for my husband and I that dig these local gems. read more

Two words - Stuffed Breadsticks! The pizza is fantastic, but I keep coming back for the Stuffed Bread Sticks! The carry-out service is great - very efficient & friendly! read more

Pastas, pizza, salads and sandwiches are good. Service is fast. Dining room is dark and dated, but usually clean.

If you like cheese they will make you smile, they have quite a verity of food but it's specialty is pizza. It's our go to place for pizza.

We have tried every pizza place in town, Scampys is the best. We get a pepperoni pizza every few weeks from here and it never fails. Their pretzel sticks, roast beef sandwiches, and alfredo sauce are top notch as well. The ambience is warm and friendly. The staff are fun and kind. The owner is beyond compare at doing the right thing, even when he doesn't have to. This is our favorite restaurant, hands down. read more

Man Oh man, I remember when I was 14 years old and Scampy's had a location in Alexandria Indiana with a Galaga & later a Double Dragon Arcade cabinet in the backroom.. That Pizza was so good man.. so good. The owner was a really cool guy. I like him alot. I GIVE "SCAMPY'S PIZZA" 10 STARZ MAN! YA THEY ROCK!.... I am old now.. I'm now 47, but.... KEEP ROCKING THOSE PIZZAS MAN!... That's some Damn good Pizza man... No joke... "Much love to everyone at Scampy's making those pizzas... Much love to the owner!...And I am a hardcore judgemental when it comes to things tasting right man.. SCAMPY'S? YOU STOLE MY HEART!...... 10 Starz People... No joke........Famous Forever -Randy French -Me read more

We have been eating this a lot since the quarantine started. I always get a pepperoni and my husband get the supreme. It's always hot and full of flavor. It's a favorite hang out spot for my husband and his friends! Super affordable and good customer service from the bar tenders! read more

5 stars for the pizza toppings, 0 stars for the crust. First time in a couple decades, my husband and I tried Scampy's pizza over the Thanksgiving Holiday. If not for the tasteless cardboard crust, the toppings would rank this pizza with the best you could get in this area. The price and the reputation deserve a second look at the who is selling them bread! Anderson residents read more

We went as non-regulars and, wow, we were treated awesome. Food was amazing! Servers and cook seemed genuinely happy to hear our food was good. The pizza was STUFFED. And delicious. Breadsticks were unique and equally amazing. We just went right in and sat down. Service was something special. read more

Huge mess up with my order and that it was to eat in and they made it for carry out. And the order was wrong and it took forever as everybody that ordered after me already had their food. Then the credit card machine didn't work so I literally had to leave to go get cash to come back. I will not return read more

Service was slow a little expensive but you get a lot for your money. Our family did not like the pizza.

Hot dogs were good, chili was also good. But the personal pizza was so bad that I'm hesitant to give 3 stars. It was on some kind of floppy pita, the cheese on the top was melted but underneath the surface it was still solid shreds. I am torn because I know they use real dough on the larger pizzas, and I wanted to try it. Give them a chance but stay away from the personal pizza. read more

Service is awesome! Great people running this amazing restaurant. Pizza is great! Loaded with toppings and tons of great flavor. Ham and cheese sandwiche was loaded with meat and cheese. We tried the jamaican chicken and it was so so and wouldn't recommend it. But it's a pizza restaurant and they have definitely knocked that part out of the water. read more

I wasn't impressed with the pasts or breadsticks. Sauce was bland and the breadsticks are coated in flour. I've heard the pizza is better however so I'll try that the next time! read more

Up-front, the pizza was great. I got the deluxe. Service was unassuming and polite, and kept us well-watered. Stayed out of the way otherwise until we left, and seemed keenly aware of our needs from a distance. Looking at the menu, it's inexpensive and I definitely felt like we got our money's worth with change to spare. I'd recommend it to anyone who doesn't mind (or prefers) a darker lighting in the dining area. read more

Just had scampys pizza for the 2nd time in my life , and oh boy it was amazing ! I'm a fan of other local pizza joints here in town but the friendly staff and fast service was great! read more

Really good pizza. They would get 5 stars but not really a fan of any of there other food they have on the menu. A little over priced also but that's with any pizza place now days. read more

What a great surprise. We left Anderson years ago and used to go to Scampy's. We are so glad we tried it on our visit here...it is as good as we remember and the folks at the restaurant were friendly and welcomed us back. We will be freezing and taking some pizzas back home with us. Thanks to Scampys for a great memory. read more

Delicious pizza with mountains if cheese! My husband loves the sausage pizza and I am partial to the pepperoni...if you like cheesy pizza this place is for you. read more

My favorite Italian place in central Indiana!!Scampys and arts pizza are both refined tastes. It's on the west side Anderson in the strip mall. The inside is no-frills no-trills. The pizza is Thick and if it's cooked right it's one of the best pizza in town!! There is a bar attached that is a simple neighborhood bar. The breadsticks are unique I enjoyed them. The Stromboli and baked pasta are very good also. read more

Well im not a regular by any means but thought i'd give this place a shot. I have to say that their pizza looks great and even tastes great im sure... that is if you like cockroaches. After ordering from this restaurant and receiving my pizza it looked delicious and smelled great. While preparing to dig in i noticed an olive moving around. Upon further inspection i found that it wasn't an olive at all. It was in fact free protein!!! It was a north american cockroach which i recognized because it is so common to this region. Nevertheless i try not to make it a habit to eat these little critters. I very politely informed the server who became very defensive and even accused me of contaminating my own pizza... why would i do this? Lmao well you would have to ask the rude staff of this establishment. I would give this establishment a 1 out of 10 for cleanliness not just because of this incident but from what i saw throughout the establishment. I would not recommend this establishment to any of my firends or family and although my experience was terrible i can laugh about how terrible it was because it was so unbelievable but i would say this establishment should be closed down for their cleanliness alone. read more