The pizza is unexpectedly incredible. I stopped for a late lunch with friends. The restaurant is trendy, upscale and clean. There is a lovely bar, indoor and (future) patio seating and a huge tiled pizza oven in the corner. Tables were set with cloth napkins. The servers are friendly and helpful. Water came to the table quickly as did the food. Our server checked on us frequently. The menu features pizza. We order two pizzas (which come in one size) to share. First, the crust tasted phenomenal - thin and chewy. It was one of the best crusts I've tasted in a long time. The Ortolano pizza had an earthy flavor with the mushrooms and eggplant. The Siciliano pizza had generous portion of fresh Italian sausage with eggplant and other vegetables. I absolutely loved the Siciliano pizza. Two pizzas were enough food for three people. There is a small dedicated parking lot and limited street parking. I'll definitely return. This is a perfect date night venue. read more

See all

Pizza is good. Pizza crust is fluffy, not too chewy. Ortolana pizza toppings were overcooked, not a standout. Pulcinella pizza with homemade meatballs and ricotta was good, well balanced. Friendly employees with great customer service. Weekday lunch time is not busy. Indoor setting is good for groups. read more

See all

So glad they expanded the menu. I didn't like the State St. entrance locked and having to walk all the way around as I am handicapped. Pizza was excellent and so was pasta. Service was also good. read more

In Italy Pizzeria & Bar - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Pendleton, Indiana

See all

We drove from the Fishers area to Pendleton to give this pizza place a try. Unfortunately, the food was just average and didn't live up to our expectations. The service also had a few issues that took away from the overall experience. The restaurant is new, so the ambiance was pleasant and had a fresh feel. However, the parking lot could use some attention. Part of it is a mix of gravel and pavement, the paved section has numerous potholes and crumbling pavement, making it difficult to navigate. Overall, we were hoping for a better food experience and most likely will not come back again. read more

Solid four and really 4.5 stars and easily could be 5. Tried going here a couple weeks back and it was packed! So we made a reservation this time. Still packed, but we got in. Had the Diavola pizza and my partner had the Margherita. The crusts were very good, though I wish we had a steak knife to cut the pizza. The style of plates they provide aren't very flat so cutting the pizza can be quite difficult. Eating it straight from the pizza tray could have been an option if the trays were a bit larger. Big plus on these pizzas is the sauce is actually visible, as it should be on Neapolitan style pizza! Too many places douse it in cheese and hide the sauce. And the sauce here is really good! Caesar salad was good and the dressing had a slight anchovy flavor to it. Once the weather warms up and they open up patio seating, I hope to come back to a slightly less packed and more open atmosphere. But the crust is rocking and the pizza is really good. Just could get a slightly better presentation. read more

See all

This is a weekly staple for work lunch. It's unique. I'd imagine if you are expecting a regular pizza experience you'll be disappointed. Very good flavor and atmosphere. Service was great. read more

In Italy Pizzeria & Bar - Pizza Near Me - Pendleton, Indiana

See all

Pizza very soggy and server was taking very long time before we could order when they wasn't busy

First thing you should know is that this is some the freshest food you will have. Every single thing made it's mark. Homemade pizza dough, tomato sauce, mozzarella and the meatballs were the best I have ever had. We haver never been to Italy, but I am sure we ate food lije we were.My pizza did not have tomato sauce so I ordered a side. So glad I did not miss out on that. Service started our slow but it was a festival day and they were overwhelmed. They made up for it. Super nice staff. Lastly, try the lemon martini, it's something special. We will definitely be back! read more

In Italy Pizzeria & Bar - Capriccoliosa pizza minus salami. - Pizza Near Me - Pendleton, Indiana

See all

Loved all of it! The food was amazing! Great service too! Plus no wait when we went. Highly recommend!

Would highly recommend! Reminded me of the pizza I had on my last trip to italy and absolutely felt like home. Fast and friendly service, excellent quality of food and lovely ambiance. Casual but with bistro elegance. Had the Buratta, the Capricciosa pizza and of course the Stragetti for dessert. Have loved Catello's for years and am happy to say I will be returning to In Italy as. regular now as well. read more

See all

The service was excellent during out visit. All the pizza come in 12 inches cut into 4 large sized pieces. The Friariella was a 7/10 because it just didn't have a lot of flavor. Now the Initaly was a 12/10, great taste, great crust, and the fresh mozzarella was amazing. I will definitely be coming back here! read more

See all

What a great place! Authentic Italian pizza in Pendleton Indiana! We were greeted immediately by two friendly servers. We chose to sit outside because the weather was beautiful! Hubby and I both had amazing pizzas! Everything was very clean! read more

We love this place! The menu is unique and the food is delicious I had the meatballs and a salad with an Italian margarita. My husband had the wings read more

Love this little gem of Pendleton. Good Italian wine. Wonderful pizza that we add to and great desserts.

Highly recommend INItaly Pizzeria & Bar Great service. Ask for Nicola. Great food. (Plus Flour is sourced from Italy. Less inflammation. If you know you know) You can make it a date. Pendleton Park, INItaly Deli, Gelato, Pastry Shop and /or in our case just a hop skip and Jump from The Anderson Menards. read more

See all

The food is delicious. It is on the pricey side but I promise you will love the food.

This is the most authentic Napolese pizza we've had in the greater Indy area. We've been searching for pizza that tastes most like the pizza we've eaten in Italy, and finally found it!! Absolutely delicious, fresh ingredients, true to what Napolese pizza should be. The service was phenomenal our server was so sweet and helpful, and the atmosphere was perfect. I only wish we could have tried everything on the menu! We will be back again and again for this delicious food and perfect service. What a gem of a restaurant- I feel so fortunate that we read an amazing article in Indianapolis Monthly about this place and decided to give it a try. Bravo, In Italy! You've got customers for life! read more

The service was good , the food was fresh. That said, the food was terribly lacking in seasoning. It was bland. I was expecting Italian flavors. some garlic, onion, and herbs. The tomato sauce was bland and tasteless. I tried the fried mashed potatoes and mozzarella and they were dry and quite flavorless. Some garlic and onion and black pepper would have spiced them up. They were served nicely but were not what I was thinking they would be. The eggplant on the pizza we ordered was hardly distinguishable. I live in Pendleton and I want this place and others to survive. I suggest they kick it up a notch. People go out to eat and want flavor. I want to really smell pizza and flavors walking in the door. read more

We came in late to add to a party with my daughters, who were already being served, they took a long time to come to the table when we joined them. The restaurant was not busy either. There was an upcharge for tomato sauce, and they don't have pepperoni. I would rather have had Papa John's pizza. Sorry for the price it was not worth it. The Ambiance was good but they need to work on the wait staff and service if they want to survive. read more

It was good to thin dough and too much olive oil over all 3 stars the crust was a bit sour and a little floppy

Excellent food and services. Worth it to visit. Cozy atmosphere. Fresh house made mozzarella is a great touch. Definitely going back soon. read more

Family member has celiac - menu says anything can be made using gluten free crust/ingredients. When we were ordering on a Saturday evening - we were told that the "chef won't make anything during busy times that needs to be gluten free bc it slows everything down". We tell the server its a life threatening allergy - she goes and asks the chef -- comes back "yah he won't do it, you can only get gluten free on weekdays". Its not 1980 - its 2025. I would not go back here if I had do. Food was bland, meatballs tasted like they were re-heated. Pizza was hard to cut. read more

Having been a longtime fan of Catello's and the InItaly deli, I have been eager to try out the new pizzeria. It did not disappoint!! I had the Siciliana pizza, which was both interesting (eggplant on pizza!) and DIVINE. I'm happy I made it in tonight as I fear the place will be jam-packed once word gets out about Pendleton's gem. read more

Absolutely love the pistachio pizza with mortadella. Love the staff and setting. This place is a gem!

Great pizza!! If you like stone oven crust. This is the place to go. We had the Indian pizza. It had ham, corn and homemade mozzarella. It was a different spin on a pizza. It was so great. Not your typical pizza. Nice clean place. Check it out soon!! The only complaint I would have is they ran out of ice for drinks. Good thing there is a gas station next door. read more

10/10 experience having my baby sprinkle at INItaly! Chiara was wonderful to work with and helped me pick the perfect menu items for my group of 12. They even opened early for us with no extra charge. After many trips to Italy, I can say that INItaly has the most authentic Italian pizza in the Indy area. Would recommend for anyone that loves Italian food, a friendly and stylish atmosphere and great service. read more

The food is delicious. Try the carbonara and caprese salad if you don't want pizza!!!

Visited Saturday 8/30/25 and I'm not sure how this place has 4.5 stars. Food was hot is the only reason I gave 2 stars! Flavor in bruschetta was lacking unless you enjoy just a tomato flavor, as far as the food itself it didn't have a lot of flavor but was hot! BIGGEST ISSUE was the service zero stars we asked for sweet and low got it when we had finished eating, table of 5 she carried a single drink out at a time to start us off! Everyone got their food fairly quick except me and I ordered a pizza the waitress never checked on us one time fifteen minutes go buy and a young man walks out from the kitchen and asked if we got our pizza, I said no and he says ok I have got it ready! Seriously finally still didn't see the waitress until it was time to pay her! I'd think as an owner I'd be very concerned! We said as a group it was the first and last time to visit this place! The place is clean, the restrooms aren't very well kept and I'll just leave it at that!I really hate to leave such a poor review but I just can't get past the poor service, I mean one drink at a time brought to the table? Have you ever heard of serving trays? Maybe also give a girl so many tables to take care of and not all the tables inside and outside! read more

The services is awesome the waitresses are very informative and well knowledge about the menu. Food is top notch pizza is all around solid appetizers are good as well. read more