Pizza King

Pizza is good. Pizza crust is fluffy, not too chewy. Ortolana pizza toppings were overcooked, not a…read morestandout. Pulcinella pizza with homemade meatballs and ricotta was good, well balanced. Friendly employees with great customer service. Weekday lunch time is not busy. Indoor setting is good for groups.

So glad they expanded the menu. I didn't like the State St. entrance locked and having to walk all…read morethe way around as I am handicapped. Pizza was excellent and so was pasta. Service was also good.

Burratta!

See all

Catello's Italian Art Cuisine

4.5(191 reviews)

As I was coming home from Ft Wayne I was detoured through Pendleton…read more I remembered I had an Italian place marked on my bucket list on Yelp- WOW- honestly this was the best Italian meal I have had in Indy! It is worth the drive!!! All pastas are made fresh. The staff was so friendly and accommodating! They have a piano player as well...what a treat! I sat in the back corner and took it all in! The food was outstanding, I ordered Linguine Frutti di Mare- homemade linguine ( delicious) served with clams, mussels, scallops? Shrimp, cherry tomatoes, evoo, garluc, parsley cooked in a white wine sauce!!! As you can see I absolutely hated it... lol! I has an expression and lava cake for dessert. The lava cake was a little overcooked- that is the only complaint.... Other than the lady sitting across the table from me that talked loud enough for the whole restaurant to hear her conversation. I wish people would be more observant and realize they don't have to talk so loud when they're sitting at their table it made it difficult to hear the piano player and it went from a relaxing stress free feeling to an annoyance. I was so happy when her food arrived. This place is very special. It's very small. I got in because it was very early in the evening. I believe their doors open at 5 o'clock. I would highly recommend reservations, but if you have a special occasion that you're celebrating, and it appeared that several people did this is worth the drive!

8.2/10 overall. My partner and I mainly went for the cheese wheel experience. The server or cook…read morelights the inside of a parmasean wheel on fire and scoops the melted cheese to have with the choice of pasta. The experience comes with either rigatoni or Alfredo noodles with Guanciale. The noodles and sauce were good but the pork cheek was not for us. 1/2 of the bites were pure fat. The rest of the meal was outstanding including the calamari/shrimp appetizer, Caesar salad, and the caprese salad. We already talked about going back to try other main courses. They had 3 options for nonalcoholic mocktails/drinks so that would be an improvement they could make especially for the non drinkers that would still like a NA wine pairing with a nice Italian dinner. You can bring your own with a $15 corking fee. The ambience was relaxing and romantic. They had orchestral music of popular songs so it was fun guessing what songs they were. There was a piano in the center of the restaurant and the mood lighting made the place seem even more cozy.

Rita's Ragu

See all

Denvers Garage Pizza & Brews

4.4(82 reviews)

7.3 mi

Great local place! Come for the pizzas, Margherita or Fortvillian personal favs, and stay for the…read morepeople, music, trivia, atmosphere, etc etc.

Good pizza, but not great. I ordered their meat lovers pizza called Charlie (bacon, ground beef,…read moreham, pepperoni, sausage). I liked the pizza, but the crust at the end of the pizza was too difficult to chew. They make their pizzas in a stone oven. The only options are a 14" pizza with 8 slices or a 7" flatbread. The restaurant is kind of different in that you only place and pick up orders at the bar. The bartender was REALLY nice. They have a huge patio that takes up about half of the restaurant. I wonder if they lose a lot of business when it's too cold to sit outside. They have a small bar with about 6 seats.

Da Bar

Philly Cheesesteak Flatbread Pizza

See all

Inside

Zion Brothers Subs & Pizza’s

4.3(14 reviews)

7.0 mi

The food is very good and is quite different from the regular fair here in Anderson. The problem is…read moreit's so very difficult to catch them open. The service is great and the ambience is very good as well and that it is totally decorated in Elvis Presley memorabilia. Which adds to the ambience overall.

We ordered a pizza since we were in the area working late. (We live in Mccordsville) We weren't…read moreexpecting much, just wanted food. Ordered a 14" combo (sausage, pepperoni, mushroom & green pepper pizza. We both were incredibly amazed at the appearance and taste. Fantastic pizza! Thanks to this biz for making a great pizza. We WILL be back!

Zion Brothers Subs & Pizza’s - Elvis is alive and doing fine. What a Delight to find this Place. Pizza was amazing, we did a half and half and they got it right down the m

Elvis is alive and doing fine. What a Delight to find this Place. Pizza was amazing, we did a half and half and they got it right down the m

See all

The Stable

4.3(48 reviews)

We went here last night for dinner and it was our first time but not the last. I am a sucker for a…read moregood martini list and they had some fun ones so we tried several. At $9-10 each why not! Blueberry Lemon Drop was good, but the Watermelon was my favorite. We also tried the caramel apple and it was good too. For dinner I got the pork tenderloin sandwich with onion rings. Both were delicious and the server said all were made in house. What I loved about the onion rings was the super thick and crunchy beer batter. We also got some sort or chicken bowl that was a lot of food. Came with chips. That's not my particular thing but the person who ordered it loved it. They make all their own dressings and believe me when I tell you the spicy ranch is spicy. I loaded my onion ring up with that ranch and I thought I was going to pass out it was so hot. I still ate it just not as much at one of time. They have plenty of seating at the bar or tables inside and a few outside tables by the street where we saw people take advantage of the nice weather and brought their dogs. They have a small stage where they have live performances, I think someone was coming last night we were just there too early. They have pull tabs for those who are gamblers. The place was really clean and staff were friendly yet busy. Parking can be tricky so be prepared to walk some during peak times.

I LOVE the renovations that The Stable has gone through! The place is great inside - places to…read morebelly up to the bar, grab a table with friends, and spaces for a date too! We were lucky to catch some live music too! They have a great been selection and incredible cocktails too. My favorite is the Spicy Jalapeño Mule!! I also highly recommend the Loaded Waffle Fries and the Asian Zing wings!! Delicious! Our server was really sweet and great too! Good times!

Bar

Grilled Tenderloin and fries.

See all

Storefront recently remodeled

HotBox Pizza

4.0(13 reviews)

5.7 mi

We order pretty consistently from this location (and again tonight) and have had only one to two…read morethings "wrong" that were not a big issue overall. The experience has always been consistent quality pizza that my wife and kids love it! Thank you Hot Box and keep doing what you're doing.

First time ordering a Hot Box Pizza. Also ordered the bread sticks. So glad to have more options in…read moreour area. They deliver!! Pizza was great! Stix and cheese were good too.

Heavy Veggie Pizza

8" Brownie

See all

Stix

King Dough Pizza

3.8(5 reviews)

7.7 mi

I'm excited to see King Dough is open in Lapel right next door to Pax Verum! Very convenient…read morelocation where you can sit and enjoy your pizza while enjoying your beer from Pax in their beer garden. This place has lots of potential and I hope they can expand their menu to align with their Indy location soon. We had a pepperoni pizza and it was delicious and sized right for 2 of us. The only bad piece is they are so new their customer service needs some improvement. I figure once they been open for awhile they will get into a better rhythm and improvements will come.

our food was great, the service was great, the staff was really nice & helpful! our food came out…read morequick & it was really nice to have the option to order by the slice!

Pizza Box

Pepperoni Pizza 14"

See all

Front of building

Art's Pizza

4.4(79 reviews)

10.2 mi

Excellent pizza! They make a tavern style pizza and are generous with the fresh toppings. We also…read morehad boneless wings which were great. Honestly, I don't get anyone going to a chain with local places like this. Prices are reasonable and our server, Keycee (sp ?) was super friendly.

The service was very good, and the restaurant was very nice inside. I grew up in Anderson, and…read moreArt's Pizza was the go to pizza for our family. Something is missing in the flavor, but I can't figure out what it is, maybe fennel seed? It just doesn't taste quite right. My husband and I got the Around the World and Hayes Special.

Dining Area

Mini Buffalo Chicken Pizza

See all

Bread Sticks with the ranch packet

Papa Johns Pizza

2.5(24 reviews)

I was very disappointed with my experience at the Pendleton Papa John's. I usually order from the…read moreAnderson location, and the food and service are always great, so I expected the same here. We ordered a Philly Cheesesteak sandwich, but it had very little meat on it. While that was disappointing, what upset me even more was that I specifically asked, "Are my sauces in the box?" I was told yes, so I trusted them and left. When I got home, both of the extra sauces I paid for were missing. The worst part of the experience happened as I was grabbing my 2-liter from the cooler. I hadn't left the store yet, and I overheard one of the employees call me a "white bitch." I was polite and respectful the entire time, so hearing an employee speak about a customer that way was completely unacceptable and unprofessional. Because of this experience, I will never return to this location. The food quality, poor service, and disrespectful behavior from the staff made this one of the worst experiences I've had at a Papa John's.

Such a long wait picking up time was 6:20 didn't get Pizza until 7:00. They blamed it on "new…read moreworkers" I highly recommend to just go to the one in Anderson.

Wings

See all

Store front

Pizza Hut

1.7(25 reviews)

0.4 mi

Had not been to a Pizza Hut buffet since before Covid ... no pepperoni, no sausage , no supreme,…read more... they kept bringing out multiple chicken pizzas a super sweet sauce ... how can you not have the basic styles .. was told corporate tells them what to put out ... they even had a cheese pizza with a salad on top of it ... not worth the $11

My family and I went to try the buffet at lunch and was very disappointed…read more The salad bar consisted of lettuce white onions and cheese and mushrooms, banana peppers, jalapeños, pickles Like who makes a salad like the The pizza was terrible no traditional pizza on the buffet like chicken and banana peppers and ham and pineapple with no sauce. It's like the one making the pizza had no idea how to make pizza I got charged for a 2 year old for the buffet who only ate nothing.. I will not be back and don't recommend. Waitress was very nice.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

M C.

7 years ago

Very slow, very slow did I say very slow.

Matt F.

14 years ago

Love it!

Pizza King - italian - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Restaurants near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Coffee near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Cocktail Bars near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Desserts near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Things to Do near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Dinner near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Pizza near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Wineries near Pizza King

BEST of Pendleton, Indiana Shopping near Pizza King

Best of Pendleton

Things to do in Pendleton

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pizza King also viewed

Hometown Classic Pizza

3.8

(80 reviews)

First ever visit on a Friday evening, and had a great time. Super friendly staff and great…read morefood/beer selection. Shareable desserts and very kid-friendly. Arcade games and board games, plus foosball. We enjoyed two IPAs, Toasted Ravioli, the Signature Salad, a personal Buffalo Chicken pizza and a Veggie pizza. Extremely reasonable prices. Fun decor of decades of movie posters. We'll be returning!

Hometown Classic is, hands down, the best pizza in Hancock County. They have a great selection and…read morewe've never had a bad experience. We especially love the Hometown Classic pizza with the bbq swirl. Perfect!

Scampy's Annex

3.6

(38 reviews)

I had not been here in years (since I moved away from Anderson). The pizza is still great,…read moreespecially the sausage used. Stop by and try it, you will not be disappointed.

I've heard good things about their pizza forever so I was excited to try, but was very…read moredisappointed. The crust was fine but the sauce was oddly sweet, and cheese (which I was excited because they put a lot) was so rubbery. It's rare that I dislike pizza. But at $25 for a large, I could barely take a few bites. And to top it off, not a single person greeted us, or was friendly in any way, our waiter seemed annoyed. Nothing redeeming.

Zion Brothers Subs & Pizza’s

4.3

(14 reviews)

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders of Anderson

3.8

(45 reviews)

The food was amazing! My aunt Beth is a vegetarian so we got here the 36 it is unbelievable! The…read moreservice was amazing! My cousin is Native American from Montana, Ktunaxa Kyle aka ksanka Kyle and the were very kind to him after his father passed yesterday. The ambiance is spot on. Tons of local charities wing supported through here. I'd be willing to drive three hours to visit again. Btw I got the meat lovers 16 grinder as well as the 16 veggie for aunt. Very fair priced and the server was very kind with my disability and professional. Being hard of hearing it can be intimidating or down right frustrating when the person across the desk isn't compassionate. This is your place to be bring the whole family!!! Call ahead if more than 25 id bet though it's so nice.

We were needing to go out of town on some family business so needed a safe place to find some…read moredinner on our road trip. The app directed us to this pizza place, which for me is never a high confidence situation. That said, reviews mentioned a pretty high safety rating and multiple positive customer experiences. We can only echo that the staff took great care with my gluten allergy, serving us a cauliflower crust pizza (pre-made and wrapped elsewhere) and a garlic cheese bread in an Udi's bun that were both very good. They were prepared in a separate area, too, and cooked on clean trays so as not to touch the cooking area. While not elite food, it proved a safe place to eat and allowed us to order a pizza while out, a rarity for us!

Marko's Brickoven Pizzeria

5.0

(3 reviews)

Moved to Indiana recently, we were looking for our go-to pizza spot! We don't need to look no…read morefurther! Marko's is awesome. We ordered a 12" cheese bread and a 16" pepperoni/mushroom pizza. OMG, soooo good. Fresh ingredients. The variety's of Olde Fashion Rootbeer were very tasty. I did regular with a touch of vanilla rootbeer. Tasted like a rootbeer float! He is now open full-time in Knightstown. I highly recommend Marko's! He also takes to-go orders. November 2025

Hands down the best pizza in Knightstown!…read more If you're looking for your typical pizza place, with basics ingredients and low quality pizza that requires cheese sauce just to taste "okay", then Marko's is NOT the place for you. If you're looking for a pizza place where each pizza is crafted to perfection and customer satisfaction is the top priority, then this IS the place for you. Go in and enjoy some refreshing, homemade root beer and get to know the owner while you wait for your pizza.

1000° Wood Fired Pizza

4.3

(180 reviews)

Food is amazing!I. I love the fired boiled crest pizza come out piping hot nice portions…read moreingredients all the way to the edge perfection. The vibe is great with your city inside or out lots of friendly people. The staff was professional, friendly, and helpful will definitely be

This place is way off the beating path for my wife and I but we are glad we made the trip up from…read moreIndy! To start the ambiance of this place is top notch. As you walk up the building there are flames and all sorts of awesome branding covering the building. Next when you walk in you're hit with incredible aromas from all the yummy food. We got in line and were helped by a very friendly hostess who took our order. We loved how many gluten free items they had and how serious they took our gluten free order. They change their gloves when handling our order and write it all in bold letters so no one can miss it! We waited nearly an hour for our food but when it came out it was all very good! To start our cauliflower cheese "bread" came out and it was super crunchy and yummy. Some might not like how crunchy it was but we loved it. Next our pizza came out and it was a really solid gluten free pizza! Next our ribs and wings came out. The wings were just okay and the ribs themselves were also just okay (they were dry) but let me tell you.. the baked beans were top notch! Might be some of the best baked beans I've ever had. Overall I think with the wait and some of the food coming out just okay.. a 4/5 is very fair for this place! We will be back and will be recommending it to people.

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

3.7

(53 reviews)

We had a group of 6 and came in on a Saturday evening…read more The pizza was good - the crust was a bit doughy but the cheese and sauce were good, and the toppings were plentiful. The bread appetizer was good, but a bit of a duplicate of the doughy crust. One of our party who wasn't in a pizza mood ordered a grinder and gave a "meh" review to it. There was a huge private party and we were seated near the door - it kept opening - then loud music and lots of noise - then the private party door closed. It happened ~50 times during our meal, and was a bit disruptive to conversation. In hindsight, I would have found seating away from that door.

The best grinders. The salads are good. The pizza is ok. But everything else is so amazing. The…read morepasta is also good.

Art's Varsity Pizza

3.0

(26 reviews)

I'm gonna be honest... this is a no for me. I tried not to be judgmental, but I just can't do this…read moreplace again. It looks small and dingy on the outside and I was hoping the inside would wow me. Unfortunately, you walk into what looks like it hasn't been cleaned in years. I instantly started looking for the most recent inspection, but it isn't required to be posted here, and so it wasn't. I'm not sure how they passed, but my fiancé wanted to try this place so there we were. The floors are dirty, benches are worn so badly your butt falls into the interior of the seat below the cushion, the stools are wobbly, EVERYTHING needs dusted, the ceiling tiles are stained with previous leaks, floor tiles are missing, etc. We ordered a drink, 14" inch pepperoni pizza, and 8 breadsticks. This came out to $36 something which is probably average, but I'm not paying that again for the average food. Breadsticks were plain as could be, pizza had a decently thick crust, but was overshadowed by the cheese (and where was the pepperoni?). The people were nice other than an assumed family member going in and out of the kitchen. Overall, it just didn't seem sanitary or like that was a priority at all. As we drove away, I noticed a broken window pane "covered" by a pizza box. Just not something I would recommend unfortunately.

My friend had wanted to show me this place for several years. We had an occasion to take a lap…read morelunch into a friend and bought the Italian roast beef sandwich here. It was worth the trip! I will visit again with my DH and introduce him to this tender hot juicy sandwich. They will cut it in half but anything smaller is better done at your plate, it is so juicy. The eating area is small but perfect got a quick quiet lunch. Service was quick and the staff friendly. Pricing was reasonable and once I tasted the sandwich it was an excellent value!

Pizza King

3.6

(24 reviews)

Service and food is great and definitely make ya feel like part of the family. Delivery drivers are…read morealways very nice and food is always hot.

I was extremely anxious to eat inside a restaurant, as restaurants began opening back up, mid…read morepandemic. With this location being in such a small town, my friend and I decided to stop by and see if we felt it was safe. We were surprised to find there was only one other person dining in. They also had taken out the front booth by the register, and then closed every other booth to allow for "social distancing." Every single employee was wearing a mask. So we felt as safe as possible to eat in. The food was excellent, as always. I don't know why some Pizza King locations just aren't very good anymore and have icky pizza sauce, specifically. I thought they got all their products from the same place. But this location is always that same, yummy, nostalgic pizza. I really enjoyed my personal Royal Feast. Our service was great. Wait staff took excellent care of us, kept us in fresh drink, no refills. Everything felt clean with obvious attention to keeping things as safe for everyone as possible.

Heard's Meadowbrook Pizza

3.5

(4 reviews)