Our favorite pizza restaurant. Reminds me of being back in Chicago. Excellent customer service and the pizza is delicious! This place never disappoints. The ambience is cozy. Clean establishment. read more

Roselli's Pizza - Best pizza ever. - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

2025 was my turn to host Christmas and New Year's for my family in Carmel, Indiana. We had visitors from Chicago, New York, Florida, Detroit, and Los Angeles. We did Newfields and visited the refurbished Speedway Museum--both great experiences. But nothing prepared me for this. One evening, my family insisted we go to Roselli's to experience "good, genuine" Chicago pizza because it has "good reviews." I warned them that Roselli's was excellent 25 years ago but has since slipped to mediocre at best. I was outvoted, and unfortunately, we went. We ordered deep-dish pizzas. What Roselli's calls "deep dish" is absolutely not deep dish. It barely qualifies as thick crust. It was a thick, bready pizza with almost no sauce, very little cheese, and hardly any of the toppings we ordered. By no stretch of the imagination was this Chicago-style deep dish. It was beyond disappointing. I ate one slice and refused to eat any more. As soon as we left the restaurant, everyone agreed on how bad the pizza was. Unfortunately, by then it was too late--we had wasted our evening and our money on food that was genuinely awful. Hate to say it, but if zero stars were possible, I would give Roselli's zero stars. read more

The server Mia was very rude and snobby. We will never order from there again. I hate to be judgemental, but glad my kids had higher aspirations than working at a pizza place. read more

I love PIZZA! New York style, and Chicago Deep Dish. Rosselli's gave me and the spouse a fantastic "Chicago Deep Dish" The sauce was 10/10 Cheese coverage was very generous without ordering extra. The crust's tasted like a midpoint between Lou Malnati's and Giordono's. read more

We ordered a thin crust classic combo pizza to pick up which includes sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and olives. We're from the Chicago area and this reminded us of a hole in the wall place we always ordered from. For anyone from the Franklin Park, IL area, this is super close to Jake's pizza. The crust is thin and crisp and the sausage is the correct type; it is actually Italian sausage which is the key...the balance of sausage, onions, peppers and mushrooms was perfect. The pepperoni and olives were "extra" in my mind but good! The aroma in the car was spot on a memory from childhood. If you didn't grow up on this pizza you might not like it as it is different from other thin crust pizza styles, but if you also grew up on Chicago thin crust you'll probably love this. Next time I will order it "well done". If they know what that means, they are definitely the real deal. The pizza was ready when promised via online ordering, and was hot and fresh. Pick up was quick and easy. I'll definitely order from them again. read more

Roselli's Pizza - 16 inch thin crust with "classic" toppings - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I was a little worried when I drove up to Roselli's and saw all the police cars, but later learned that police and firemen get a steep lunch discount. We stopped by to get a small pizza for lunch as I wanted to try their Chicago style pies. We saw pretty quickly that everyone gets the buffet. I didn't want a buffet, but after I saw the variety of pizza and an option for salad, we got the buffet. The dining room is pretty dark filled with large wood booths, reminiscent of a Chicago pizza joint. There is a covered patio if you want more light and fresh air. I got a couple pieces of pizza, salad and a piece of garlic bread that I really didn't need. The homemade sauce on the deep dish is really fresh and good. But I liked the crunchy thin crust pizza the best. The pizza toppings were pretty standard. The salad was basic bag salad with options to add tomato, cheese and peppers. There was pasta on the buffet, but I didn't need additional carbs. I tried the bolognese sauce which was delicious and the star in my opinion. The buffet comes with a soft drink, and I had pink lemonade. All in all, it was a decent lunch. The staff was friendly and worked hard to keep the buffet filled and tidy. read more

See all

I'm from Chicago and I'm so glad I found this place! The deep dish is legit, crust is perfection, not too thick on the bottom and the buttery end crust is crispy but soft in the middle. Sauce has a touch of sweetness which I love and ingredients are super fresh. I had the deep dish pepperoni, mushroom extra cheese and we got a thin crust pepperoni and Italian beef, all were outstanding!! Chefs kiss read more

See all

We decided to give Roselli's another try, as we know many love it. Unfortunately, it was another terrible experience. It took 2.5 hours to get our pizza. When we called, being polite and patient, the staff continuously mocked us and were rude. I can empathize with "busy", but I can't deal with employees turning the problem around onto the customer, as if it was my fault we ordered from Roselli's. When the pizza finally arrived, it was "fine". Service killed our loyalty 5 years ago... and it didn't change. read more

We purchased carry out - a deep dish, thin crust, and fried cheese ravioli. The ravioli was ok, but under seasoned - in particular the dipping sauce. The thin crust was a serviceable pizza, no better or worse than other local places. The star of this place is their deep dish. The crust is a great mix of chewy and crunchy with an almost pretzel texture to the crust. There was a perfect amount of cheese and sauce. I was disappointed at the distribution of topping though. While there were plenty of olives, they were in big clumps instead of scattered over the pizza. Since they melted into the cheese, it was difficult to move them around on each slice. There are worse things in life, but hopefully this was a one off and they are normally fantastic about spreading things around. We will definitely try them again. read more

I've heard of Rosellis but finally got a chance to experience. Our waitress was very friendly and outgoing..lots of personality. She made great suggestions. The Pizza is really good and we got the deep dish 10', which was more than enough for pizza for 2. Our appetizer was the fried Ravioli which can see are not in the pictures. It didn't really have a chance to survive to make a food selfie Perfect place to catch a game because it had few TVs indoor and outdoor. Definitely will go again and I recommend it. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Delicious pizza! Best I have had in a long time. Ordered a salad that was fresh and crispy. The Chicago deep dish with sausage and it was delicious. Our waitress was polite and friendly. read more

Ordered a 14" deep dish spinach and 16" pepperoni tavern style for carryout during the snow storm. The staff were wonderful, the pizza was perfect. Can't wait to dine in. read more

Cool little spot but we got ours to go. Pizza was good not great. Mozz sticks were solid but barely warm. Fried ravioli was pretty good. A little pricey for the amount of food. Friendly people inside. read more

See all

We love the deep dish sausage classic pizza! The chunky tomato pizza sauce accompaniments the toppings and crusty crust beautifully.

I was out of town and I remember someone posting this business and I had to GO. My comfort food. The picture speaks for ITSELF! Good service, great food! read more

Roselli's Pizza - Pizza, Sausage, Pepperoni, & Giardiniera Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Not the best, but also not the worst. It's pizza at the end of the day but I feel there are better options out there.

Our first and last visit. We saw pictures of this fabulous buffet on facebook and decided we needed to try it next time we are on the north side (Carmel) we live in Greenwood Wish we took pictures because it didn't even closely resemble what we saw. 5-6 different pizzas, garlic bread and a salad bar with lettuce and two different toppings and 3 dressings. It was a huge disappointment, especially at the price we paid. Chicago's pizza is a much better option read more

greatest pizza in the world love joey and Doug great guy big pizza great food joey is the guy wish I could marry him

Amazing food, service, atmosphere, and price was great!! Went for the buffet today with my client. Was something planned for him. He was looking forward to it and it did not disappoint. The pizza was top notch! Salad was very good, garlic bread was great to have...great to dip in cheese, marinara or even the meat sauce. My oh my, the meat sauce was good! The variety of pies was good to choose from and the staff was so kind and made you felt welcome. Roselli's, well done! Will be back, I will bring my family next time. read more

Service was good but pizza was pretty bad. I got a 10"cheese pizza that had very little cheese at all. Sauce didn't taste fresh. The bill for just my husband and I was $60+tip for 2 -10" pizzas and 2 sodas. Way overpriced for quality of pie. Very disappointed. read more

Not great pizza. Crust tasteless. Cheese and sauce good. Atmosphere was cold - had to go to car to get sweatshirt. Service slow even though there were only three tables occupied. Will not be coming back. read more

OMG! We have been looking for a good pizza place in the area and have finally found it!! We had the deep dish pepperoni special and it was deeeeelicious!!! Also got the chopped salad (regular) and it was huge and had so much flavor. Service was top notch. So happy with this find. Cannot wait to come back and try some of the other menu items. read more

As a Chicago-area native, I always goes to Roselli's to get my deep dish fix. Relatively very quick turnaround times for deep dish.

Roselli's is the true essence of Chicago. Many not from the Chicago area will probably order the deep dish Chicago is famous for, but the locals always order the thin crust. It was perfect made with fresh ingredients. The atmosphere quiet and quaint with wood accents. I haven't been there in years, but my wife and I will put into our rotation. They even have a great vegetarian options. read more

I like the cozy vibe.. they had christmas decorations up for the holiday- nicely done. We came in just after 5 and just a few tables.. but as we sat the place filled up! I like thin crust so thats what i went for-- I don't know what crust is their best- double pan deep- not sure... the thin was crackery - the topping and cheese were great - going 4 stars because the crust tasted pre-made (maybe?).... I will come back - and try a different crust read more

See all

We've been coming here for years. Being that I'm from Chicago, I'm always on the lookout for pizza that reminds me of home. While not exactly the same, I feel like the thin crust is as close as I can get here in Indy. It's always really good. The service is fine - they are usually busy so it can be a bit slow, but not bad at all. And the ambiance is the typical pizza pub. I do recommend giving this place a try! read more

This was my first time trying Roselli's pizza with my family and we didn't have to wait to place an carry out order. The guys there were very nice and welcoming. While we waited for the pizzas to cook we were catching up on the games next to the Christmas tree (the Christmas tree was probably my favorite thing because of the cute pizza ornaments). The pizza was really good and I am going to try the calzones next time. I really love the vibe of the restaurant and will be returning and bringing friends. read more

Roselli's Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom on thin crust. - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

First time here and came for the lunch buffet. The salad bar is small but the dressings are fresh and tasty! The pizza is delicious! They also offer spaghetti with meat sauce and garlic bread. We also got an order of breadsticks which were big and soft. I would definitely return and recommend them. read more

Received bad pizzas had to wait an hour for the 2pizzas. Manager degrees with what I said so he wouldn't give any compensation. Never had any problems in the past, so I didn't understand why. read more

When searching for deep dish Chicago Pan south of the Windy City pizza this place should get a "strong consideration." The deep dish pizza scene in Indy leaves much to be desired so when you come across a place like this it's worth mentioning. The factors to consider are: sauce, cheese, ingredients and crust. The sauce: the sauce was flavorful while having both and sweet and tangy flavor. The sauce is what prepares you for what is to follow. The cheese: the cheese was thick and chewy and did not disappoint. The ingredients: I ordered sausage, pepperoni, Canadian Bacon and meatball. these were very flavorful and I savored every bite. The crust: the crust was not soggy and the rich buttery crust, while not Chicago grade, still held its own for an Indy locale. Overall this was a good pizza. I will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Hot, thick, and gooey - Like any deep dish pizza should be. We were quick to be seated, service was decent, and prices reasonable. read more

Roselli's Pizza - a deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Went second time for lunch buffet last week on Thursday and had mild case of sickness.

It's been a while since we came here last time. Glad to come again. We really enjoyed it. We asked the waitress for extra thin crust pizza and they did not disappoint us. It was thin and crispy. Love the fact that they put lot of sausages. read more

Roselli's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

My husband and I like a variety of pizza and we really enjoy the deep dish pizza of Roselli's, which is just as good as any I've ever had in Chicago. Roselli's gives generous portions of sauce and cheese, and the crust is buttery and delicious and crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. They also take special orders like I'll take half of the pizza with pepperoni and I'll take half of it with something else less sauce more sauce they're very accommodating. read more

I was taken here by Chicago natives who raved about the food, and I totally understand why! We ordered a little bit of everything, and it was all very good. It was packed, but our server was incredibly attentive and made sure she kept coming by to check in. Excited to try the lunch buffet! read more

My friends and I ordered delivery through Rosetti's pizza for dinner one night and I was impressed with the pizza. We ordered a deep dish Chicago style supreme pizza and a thin crust pepperoni pizza to share with everyone. I had not had deep dish style pizza in a long time, and this particular deep dish style pizza was fantastic!! The thin crust pepperoni was just as excellent!! We did get an order of breadsticks as well, and they were very good. This was not your ordinary pizza. The spices and herbs in the pizza were absolutely fantastic and was very fresh when we received it and nice as hot. This was my first experience with Rosetti's pizza and it was a memorable experience. I will definitely order from them again when it is a special occasion. It is magnificent!! read more

Roselli's Pizza - Deep dish pizza monster - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Delicious!! Food is amazing and so are the owners! Love their pizzas, chop salad, and fettuccine Alfredo

Pizza lacked flavor. Crust was bland also. Sad...always want to support locals but will have to pass with this one.

Great pizza and salads. It's not the quickest service, but it's usually worth the wait.

The weekday lunch buffet is WORTH IT. It comes with all of the following: drink, pizza, pasta, salad, and garlic bread for $12. My favorite slice was the thin crust with sausage and hot giardiniera. I ended up having the garden salad too (choice of: Ranch, French, Italian). Today's pasta was spaghetti and marinara. Not very memorable but that's ok. They have a covered patio opened to the outside for fresh air, which is nice too. read more