You will find this gem of a pizza joint in a little strip mall. There is tons of parking available in the mall's lot. This is a very small joint, and it does not have a dining area per se, but it does have a couple of tables and chairs that patrons can sit at and wait or dine. They have tenderloin sandwiches, pulled pork sandwiches, salads, and of course pizza. They have many different-sized pies, from small all the way up to the gigantic one with about 50 slices. The staff there was friendly, but I will admit that my interaction with them was brief. I placed my order online, which I highly recommend, and it was ready when I arrived. I ordered some onion rings and a jalapeno popper pizza. I got a sausage pizza for the littles. The jalapeno popper pizza was amazing. It tasted so good, just like a popper. The onion rings were really good too. They were fresh and not your average frozen beer-battered ones. My kids liked their sausage pizza too. It never had a chance. They wiped it out in record time. I really enjoyed my food here and highly recommend checking this place out. It is best if you order ahead, though. I hope to make it back here really soon. read more

See all

Cugino's hit the spot for some Friday night pizza! We enjoyed a thin crust pepperoni and bbq chicken pizza, both extremely good. 2 sides of cheese, and 2 sides of garlic were great as well! read more

Cugino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Nothing worth the trip. Crappy customer service along with subpar pizza. Plenty of places elsewhere to frequent. Not a good experience.

I'd give them 3 stars but the value bumped them up to 4. I got an xlarge pepperoni and large Hawaiian. Both are good flavors. I got thin crust on the pepperoni but it wasn't crisp, a little disappointing. The selling point is the price for size of pizza. I haven't found prices as good as this for non chain shops. Plus they have a 30 inch pizza if you want! read more

See all

Great service and great food. We use this restaurant when feeding a team in town for training. Very reasonable and prompt delivery. Try the Pork Tenderloin sandwich. It's bigger than the roll. read more

We recently tried Cugino's for the first time and thought it was very good. The crust was a perfect combination of crispy and chewy. The sauce was on the sweet side. I'd tone down the sugar and add more savory seasonings. The toppings were fresh and delicious BUT they skimped on the meats on The Cowboy. They have a lot of specialty pizzas with catchy names. We had the Cowboy and The Works. The garlic dipping sauce was the best I've ever had. They were very nice looking pizzas (see pic)! Will definitely try again, especially since it seems all the chain options now taste like cardboard and artificial chemicals. read more

Cugino's Pizza - The Cowboy on the left, The Works on the right (11 inch pies) - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We stopped here to for a pizza one Saturday afternoon. I heard good things. Upon walking in, was a tad disappointed as there is basically no seating or tables. No big deal we got it to go. So options of pizzas and sizes. You can get individuals of any pizza. The cost is very reasonable too. Anyways we got home to try our pizza, a hearty pepperoni, and an "around the world, neither disappointed. A perfect crust loaded with toppings. This place is going to be in our regular pizza rotation. Delicious read more

Cugino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say this family-owned pizza place rivals any of the big pizza places in Indianapolis, and you will not find better prices. The food is absolutely wonderful!! Run, don't walk, it's important that we support this business and make sure they are able to serve the Indianapolis Community for many years to come! read more

The service here is fantastic! The owner really goes the extra mile to make sure your order is perfect, and the quality is top-notch. I love how fast they are, and the straightforward menu makes it easy to know what you're getting. And let me tell you, the food is just amazing! I'm absolutely obsessed with the mac & cheese--though I might recommend swapping out the nacho cheese for something like the three cheese but cavatappi is a great noodle for the mac. read more

Cugino's Pizza - Luau (Luan Pizza) - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

best tenderloin and onion rings ever this is a place you would drive right past... but we found it and if you love tenderloins you must try theirs. read more

Ordered from Cugino's for the first time on a Saturday night and we loved everything! We got a small thin crust, small traditional, and small deep dish to try them all. Plus a salad. They did mess up our order a little bit (chicken bacon ranch instead of buffalo chicken and then a meat lover's instead of just pepperoni) but I'm not complaining about that. The pizza sauce is great, crust was all great. The garlic sauce, ranch, and nacho cheese were all better than expected as well. Great local joint! read more

Located in LAWRENCE plenty of parking. Family owned. Pizza is always amazing. GF available.Delivery is available.however it's easier just to pick it up. They also have other items on the menu. Highly recommended read more

Yum. 16 years enjoying Cuginos. It takes 1hour +, most times, to have delivery. If you go pick it up, there is a bakery right next door that is open late. You can have dessert. read more

We have been loyal fans of Cuginos for years. Their new and improved park tenderloin is out of this world. You have GOT to try it! I think its up there with best tenderloin in Indiana!! Tell me Im wrong!! read more

We ordered delivery from Cugino's tonight for the 3rd time. We live fairly nearby and stumbled on the place soon after we moved here a few years ago. The pizza is always great and delivery so far has been within a good time with friendly drivers. Tonight we got a few calzones and a large salad and we're super happy. Love having a non-chain pizza place nearby that delivers and knows what they're doing. Thanks Cugino's for another awesome meal! read more

Consistent good food courtesy for all customers variety of foods available has been in business for over 25 years

Great pizza! Friendly service, quaint little local pizza joint! We will def be back.

Delicious, will definitely be returning!, very friendly staff!. Will be sharing with my friends!. read more

Cugino's Pizza - First time ordering from them!, pizza was hot and ready. I will definitely be ordering again the pie is amazing!. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We used to live near by and We always liked Cugino's a lot. We moved away several years ago. We live in rural Putnam county now. Just can't find a good pizza anywhere out here. We make our own because bought out is just not very good at all. We were in town on 10/19/23 to visit our son. We Ordered a 20" Sausage, Pepperoni, and banana pepper pizza. Delicious, best pizza we've had in years. Great crust, amazing sauce and let's face it, that's what makes or breaks a pizza. Quality sauce n crust are everything. These guys have the stuff down Pat. Give em a try. Best pizzas we have had in many years. Way to go, Joe n David. Awesome stuff fellas.. read more

Owner is very accommodating! Drivers are awesome! Great new location! Hopefully, this location will give them room to grow a great business! read more

Great pizza and wings! The flavor is delicious. I definitely recommend trying it for yourself.

so happy that they are in our neighborhood. They are always busy and we understand that, with, their fair prices and quality food, it is a popular place. Sixteen years, we have ordered from them and I can not remember a time that we did not like their food/delivery. read more

Wow. Came in from out of town and was just looking for a take out pizza place for dinner. I Yelped and this place popped up. I'm so glad it did!! If you're looking for ambiance and fine seat down, this isn't for you. If you're looking for nice people and really good pie, you found your spot. Fair warning, call early. I got lucky enough to get a one hour pick up time. Delivery was over two hours. This place is jumping busy, but that just attests to how good the joint is!!! read more

This place knows what they're doing when it comes to pizza at an affordable price. Dave and his team are great, and the pizza is always great. I have never had bad food from Cugino's. read more

The food was surprisingly good!! The service was terrible!! The young lady that answered the phone and took my money was rude and lacked all customer service skills possible! She would definitely hurt the business if she continues working there! read more

I've ordered from here before but I'm fast becoming a weekly customer. Everything taste so fresh. I get the medium , thin crust The Works with black olives. Love love love it. I call it my hole in the wall pizza palace. Beats you know who hands down. Oh man...forgot to take a . Next time! read more

Still going strong. It has apparently changed owners a couple times since my last review. But everything still holds from my previous review. Carry out or delivery, no dine-in. Generous toppings. Sauce is not acidic. The standard crust is thin style, with a nice crispyness on the bottom, and the top of the crust soft. The edge or border of the crust is about one inch wide, and is much thicker, making like a wall to hold in the toppings. There is a deepdish/thick option for an upcharge. Sizes are 10", 12", 14", 16", 18", 20", 30". Yes, thirty inch diameter. I stopped here on my way home around dinner time, and I ended up eating 3/4ths of the pizza by the time I got home. No lunch service. Note the hours, they don't open until 4 during the week, 2pm on Sat. Web site says they're open on Sunday, but the flyer says closed on Sunday. read more

Dive hole in the wall with EXCELLENT food. I have tried a few different items and everything was delicious. Pricing is also good.

I was in town visiting from Ohio and decided to try Cugino's. I was looking at their menu online and was excited to see that they had quite the variety of entrees, pizza, and sides. I ordered a small 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 cheese pizza, individual side of mashed potatoes, baked beans, and potato salad. The order was set for carry out. 20 minutes after I submitted and already paid for my order online a gentlemen from the pizza shop called me to tell me that they were out of baked beans, and potato salad, so I had to order something else since I already paid. He also stated that he just "received," my order and it was going to be an additional 20-35 minutes for take out. All in all, my pizza was delicious and I will definitely order it again when I'm in town. The sides were kind of bland and lacked Flavor... But I guess you can expect that from a pizza place? The service was slow, and unorganized, the staff was very unprofessional while talking to their friends using curse words. The price of the food was reasonable. If you don't care about professional service or non pizza entrees this place is for you. Otherwise, you might want to steer clear. read more

Cugino's Pizza - 1/2 cheese & 1/2 pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pizza is ok. It's fresh tasting and inexpensive. I've only eaten here once, so I don't want to beat them up too bad but the pizza is nothing like what's pictured on their menu. I attached a photo from them menu of their Deep Dish offering verses what I actually received. I'm sure the person taking the order understood as I mentioned being from out of town and specifically asked about the cooking times and was trying to be mindful of when they closed. I was told it would be no problem it would take 30-40min. This was not anywhere close to Deep dish or what was pictured in the menu. At best it may be considered a round Detroit style. read more

Cugino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Absolutely out of this world pizza and everything else. Prices are about the same as Pizza Hut but the quality exceeds that by a long shot. The location is off putting to be honest and customer service not the best. To be real it's like a prison inside but you won't care by the time you get home and taste that hot fresh za. read more

New to the area and this little hole in the wall pizza joint is AWESOME!!! We have ordered twice in two weeks and we usually only eat out once a month! They are pick-up/delivery only, but man they produce some awesome pizza. The sauce is great and they load the toppings on perfectly. From what I understand they have three crust options, but we have only gotten the hand-tossed. I would attach pictures but the family devours it before I get the phone out of my back pocket! read more

Fantastic pizza, great prices, CLEAN kitchen, and always friendly. I don't go anywhere else... and that's saying something.

I like thin crust they had it and gave me extra pepperoni and left it in there a little longer for a while then Piza just the way I like it read more

Cugino's Pizza - Got this meat pizza extra pepperoni thin crust bread sticks for a $20 bill it's what we do check 1-2 - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The place is an awful example of a non-chain pizza option. I ordered Cugino's once and my car died. Of course, I had to call back and cancel the order and they were extremely unhappy. The next time I ordered, they demanded that I Pay before I picked up my pizza because they couldn't afford to have me "trick them again" by not picking up the pizza. When I reminded them that the last time was out of my control, they said too bad and that they wouldn't make the pizza for me until I paid for it...they must not be doing too well, if my $15 order was really going to break their bank. After paying for the pizza, the product was actually worse than the awful customer service. A sweet sauce with little taste was only the icing on the cake for an overall terrible experience. I live somewhat close to the place and I would rather drive to Ohio then give that place another chance. read more

Oh Lord this place is so awesome. We have been ordering since 1998 and still love it!!! Great pizza but honestly we have advanced from pizza a couple of years ago and focus on calzones and tenderloins these days. You wont go wrong here! read more

Had the pleasure of eating this "OH MY! My taste buds did not expect that!" kind of pizza. I honestly did not expect their pizza sauce to taste so scrumptious! Then came the buffalo wings and honestly I've never had wings that taste so good! Definitely will try this place again read more

I adore this place. Close to my apt, always quick - food is without fail always fantastic. Everything always tastes fresh and hot - and everyone I speak to on the phone is always super nice. They have tons of coupons and deals available, I definitely recommend for everyone to try. Quick and easy place - meant for delivery/pick up. Definitely my favorite pizza place. read more

Came for the first time a couple days ago and ordered the all meats deep dish pizza. Was amazing!! I'll be coming back again soon :))

Figured I'd try this little place because it was close to my house and I needed a satisfying pie one evening. We were packing, moving, and needed food. Got onto their website and found a special for a 2-topping for $10. Done! Called and asked them about the online special and the kid said they weren't running that special, but they would give me another special for $13. I asked if I could have the advertised special for $10 and he said no, absolutely not. For real?? He said they can't change their website and they don't honor it. Wow. So, I called another pizza place instead and gave them my money. read more