The pizza and wings were so delicious! Definitely worth it to call in and drive there. The owner was working hard behind the counter and it was so hot in the restaurant. You can tell they put their all into their work. Definitely amazing food that I would recommend to others! read more

See all

Recommended by some locals I stopped in and overall pleased - so many different tastes with pizza but good balance of flavors and crust had a good chew read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Medium Sausage/Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Usually enjoy Pasquale's, but breadsticks were horrible tasted undone. Cheese and sauce also left out of order. Disappointing

I have not eaten here in 2 yrs and was afraid to go back, But I had a Stromboli craving and ordered one,....Too my surprise, it's under new ownership and the place is cleaned up and has excellent service. Last time I was there, There was a dirty older lady with a younger girl and little dirty bare footed kids running around the place...Thank goodness for change........Give this guy a chance, He's in it to do the right thing read more

Horrible! Pasquale is under new management & they have changed the menu. I ordered a Stromboli with light pizza sauce, pickles, onions & extra cheese, but I got brown gravy. I got a Stromboli with brown gravy & when I complained that was not what I ordered, the owner said that's how I was taught when I bought Pasquale I've been going to Pasquale on 16th street for 40 years & brown gravy was not mandatory. You had a choice of brown gravy or pizza sauce. One of the workers was very rude slamming pizza pans when I complained. I've attached a pic of my Stromboli...soggy & nasty! I will not be going back! read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This place has the some of the best Pizzas I've ever tried with excellent service as the staff is always very welcoming and friendly! read more

Pasquale's Pizza - BBQ Chicken Pineapple Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I was excited to try Pasquale's. Their menu reads pretty well, and the pricing on Grubhub looked excellent. I figured this would be a great day to try them out, as I was busy and did not feel like cooking. I placed an order for four people. Hungry and growling belly, I was excited when the order arrived, and I could calm this hungry beast inside my stomach. I won't tell you not to order from here because we all have our likes. I will say that my household and I will never order again! The best thing I had was their onion rings. I am unsure why they call their foagies(fake hoagie), hoagies, as the name does not fit what you get. If you enjoy a hot lunch meat sadwhoxh with a weird-looking pickle loaf, by all means, order this!! If you like your three-item casserole to be over-sauced spaghetti, with minimal of your requested topping, order them. Better yet, if you want to place a $60+ order and see four hungry people trash everything.. Call them! I, however, will NOT be back. read more

See all

Was staying at a hotel and needed to DoorDash some pizza. Checked the reviews for some local pies and found Pasquale's Pizza with some pretty consistent praise. I ordered the Meat Lovers pizza and it was fantastic! I'm picky about pizza and this did not disappoint. Everyone was fully satisfied! read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Meat Lovers - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love their mushroom Stromboli's. This is a old school spot that has been around forever. Conveniently located next to the Indy 500 race track. Service is what you would expect for a small family owned business in the hood. Don't expect a warm welcome, at minimal eye contact. They are typically on the phone taking orders upon your arrival. Although limited, they do have parking on their lot. read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Mushroom Stromboli Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Worst pizza next to pizza hut, dominos, and little ceasers. Stromboli is trash. Mozzerela sticks are average at least.

Pasquale's Pizza is located fairly close to the IMS off of 16th street just under the bridge and you're almost there on the right. They do a have a parking lot. This is a place that you can tell have many regulars and that's always a good sign. The pizza we ordered was so good! Not greasy and they added so many toppings it was great! The Stromboli's that I saw looked great also. They have a big menu of subs, garlic bread, breadsticks, stuffed mushrooms, pasta, salads, and pizza. Until next time! read more

Pasquale's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

New ownership has resulted in lower quality and higher prices. We discovered tonight that the quality that we've come to expect has suffered greatly and the prices have increased by roughly 40% - hardly a winning combination. We've been buying Pasquales for nearly 30 years but tonight was our last trip. Good luck with your new business model. read more

This is one of the best pizza places in Indy. If you love pizza and want a delicious hearty filling hot pizza then this is the place for you. Whenever I think about pizza this place comes to mind and it make my mouth water lol. We don't eat pork and Pasquale's has a nice selection of toppings. Awesome! read more

Pasquale's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The drive up is open for business! I don't come here for the beauty and splendor, I come for my childhood favorite the Strom with mushroom gravy, cheese, onions and pickles! If your a dainty lil debutante or proper Dudley do right you might want to skip this place if you value looks over deliciousness. read more

Pasquale's Pizza - First bite of my Stromboli with mushroom gravy on the toasted hoagie bun! Yum! I don't know if anyone who get the pizza sauce one. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Horrified to find out this is their very popular Stromboli sandwich. My mom ordered this. In the past she normally orders pizza and breadsticks which are fine. Just won't order Stromboli again. read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Stromboli Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This pizza is always hot and delicious. I eat here quite often You will not be disappointed

Not eaten their pizza yet but looks good!! Hope to order some very soon!! I do not care much fir pepperoni any more . Rita Hellmann read more

We ordered pizza special with a small salad, great place with great tasting and fresh and hot foods! Salad was freshly made, cold and awesome! Great work by staff! Delivery was very professional! We had them make a large chicken and mushroom pizza with garlic sauce! Yum da best! Very Authentic Italian foods here! We stayed at Country Inn and Pasquales is super close. This is a great restaurant for all Pizza etc lovers! God willing we will be back! read more

Pretty good pizza, but they now only do business through a drive up window. I arrived on time, sat in line on 16th street for a few minutes, made it to the window, and was told "come back in 10 minutes." So I drove out of the parking lot, got in line again, and 20 minutes later made it to the front of the line. PITA to the max. Pizza was pretty good, but that window ruins it. If you arrive exactly when they tell you to, you're still going to sit in line for 10 or 15 minutes. read more

I went to Pasquale's to get a large pizza. I always get sausage, pepperoni, and mushroom. They have good pizza, and they don't skimp on the cheese. The best part is they are about 3 minutes from my house. I think they have new owners, but I am happy with the pizza. read more

I always say that what makes a very good pizza, is the sauce and the crust, and the pizza I got today hit that out of the park.. The cheese was delicious too though. Customer service was good. I'll definitely be back. It's some of the better pizza in Indy. I'd say a notch above Jockamo's, tbh. read more

The customer service is great alone. The pizza is pretty fresh and warm. They do have call-ins so you can place your order ready before you arrive. There is a guy That will greet and take your order in your car unless they are super busy. Super nice people and easy to talk to. Will come back for more :) read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Pizza Bread Sandwich Stromboli Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This place must be under new ownership! The Pizza and Ravioli I ordered was not the same as it used to be by far. It was awful. The only reason I give to stars; they did have anchovies. read more

I don't want to give them any star. It's not the old Pasquale. I ordered an around the world nasty as hell. Ordered some fried mushrooms and they delivered French fries, when I called the chick hung up on me. I'm the wrong one for that. I called back and told them I want my mushrooms, they did deliver them but this place needs to change the name cause I just thought it was the same Pasquale and it's not at all. read more

Pizza and garlic cheesy bread are the best ! Seriously e is top notch and they are very friendly.

Bussin bussin You gotta smack a Stromboli with a peewee fire! I hate that they're closed on Monday's though read more

Pizza could have been cooked longer...kinda chewy...I love that it's a drive up window. read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

After reading all the reviews I decided to give this place a try. I decided to go in and order since I had never been before and there were a few items I wanted to ask questions about but didn't want to bother them over the phone. The lady behind the counter acted as if she was not really in the mood to answer any questions or offer up any time of customer service. With that a side we proceed to order a large pizza and breadsticks which came to about $20 and we were told it would be ready in 10 mins. The pizza was delicious even though it was slightly burned. I love trying new places and this place delivered! read more

See all

Best tasting pizza around town ! The dough is absolutely amazing. Would definitely say that this spot is a must try place :) read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Half jalapeño half cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I haven't been here in a long whole. Here recently I just had to have my favorite pizza and Stromboli.... Let me tell you both was the bomb. Their food is still good as ever. read more

Always Great! On time hot & fresh! Now all I need is a rewards program to get free pizza!

Worst pizza I've ever had. Dough was flat, pizza was cold. You can do better than this.

Driving by you probably might be inclined to NOT stop as the neighborhood doesn't seem too safe from an outsider's POV. That said, I am glad that we did as this seems to be one of the last real Pizza places that isn't a damn chain left ... Pizza was decent, and inexpensive (soda only .65!). Crust was a bit iffy but the rest was really decent. People were friendly. My kind of place. read more

My small pepperoni pizza was hot and fresh, right from the oven! Plenty of cheese and there was something quite tasty about the sauce! My only disappointment was that it didn't look like the picture of the pizza on the Yelp review. Mine had sliced pepperoni and it looks like crumbled/diced in the review. The price was right and the service was fast. I love supporting local businesses, so I'll be back!! read more

Pasquale's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The stromboli's with brown gravy, mushrooms, onion, and pickles are legendary here. Family owned, they are still cranking out the favorites on the Indianapolis west side (Speedway area). I absolutely love their pizzas as well. #The317Live read more

Their wings are absolutely delicious! Their pizza is good and I prefer it over Pizza Hut, dominos, and most big chain pizza places. The service is always great! It's family owned and ran, they have an array of cool pictures from back in the olden days. This place is really a hole in the wall place. Love it. read more

I am a first time customer and I have to say it's some of the best pizza I've had in awhile . Really good . Would highly recommend

Great neighborhood pizza place. A gem in the rough (neighborhood). Simple pies but sometimes that's all you want. Food: 5/5 Location: 3/5 - too small just take it to go! Service: 3/5 read more

I grew up on Pasqualle's Pizza, it was the only pizza I knew until I hit driving-age. Life took me away and I assumed this placed got absorbed by big-box businesses. Then about 8 years ago I renewed our relationship, and to this day I claim they have the best pizza I have ever had. I would like to try the stromboli due to reviews, but I can never get past ordering a pizza! It is not my experience that they have great service, as I have read in some reviews, but they're not really rude either. You don't have to hug everyone and flash a smile when your pizza makes up for it, and theirs does! Ask for a pizza "around the world " and you'll be hooked. read more

Love this place! Been going there since I was a child. Ill be going this weekend. My mom is craving it