I'm from New York, so when a place says "New York-style pizza," I'm already skeptical. We New Yorkers take our pizza seriously. Well... Manhattan Pizzeria can actually back it up. Thin crust? Crispy bottom? Foldable slice? Good sauce-to-cheese ratio? Tastes like somebody actually understands New York pizza? We were passing through Indianapolis on our way home and decided to give Manhattan Pizzeria a shot. I'm glad we did because this was the real deal. I don't leave many reviews. Usually, you have to be exceptionally good or exceptionally bad for me to bother. Manhattan earned this one for being exceptionally GOOD. If you're going to call it New York-style pizza, THIS is what I expect. Signed, A New Yorker who knows better. read more

There are very few New York style pizza places in Indianapolis, so when I saw this online, I decided to give it a try. It is definitely the New York style- pre-made pies are sitting in the window, you pick your slices and they throw them in the oven to heat up. The slices themselves were OK. They probably could've been heated a little bit longer to make the crust a little more crunchy, but they were decent. Two slices and a bottle of Coke for $12 wasn't a bad deal. (I hate getting bottled drinks in restaurants. I prefer a soda fountain.) I saw two employees and heard a third one in the back. Both employees who were out front were busy sweeping, mopping floors, and wiping off tables. Very clean. For the price, I would certainly go back again. (But I wish they had NY prices!) read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Pepperoni slice, cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Had never heard of Manhattan Pizzeria before but my coworker was stopping by and offered to bring me back a slice to try. Not wow'ing but not terrible - personally, I'm always going to be loyal to Chicago Style!! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We had just caught a TMNT movie at Alamo Drafthouse, so it was only right to get a slice of NY style pizza afterwards. This place had a nice selection and everything looked delicious. We went with a plain cheese, grandma style, and supreme slices plus a couple breadsticks. Throuroughly enjoyed it all, including the affordable prices! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Can't say enough how great everything about this place is. Top notch pizza with fast friendly service. Great prices on the specials.

Stopped by for lunch during the weekday to satisfy a pizza craving. This is a family owned pizza spot. Happy to report the restaurant is still clean and service is still fast and friendly. They do offer a lunch special, but I didn't get it this time around. I got the pepperoni breadsticks and a slice of the stuffed pizza. Once the order was placed it was heated in the oven. Wait time was minimal as usual. The breadsticks were filling and I ended up saving the slice for dinner. read more

See all

This is New York style pizza - giant thin crust slices with a dry crust that you fold in half to eat. You can buy pizza by the slice (roughly $3.50) or you can buy a whole pizza (roughly $20). The staff was really nice. I tried a meat lover's slice, buffalo chicken slice, and I forget what the side was called, but they were basically mini breadsticks stuffed with pepperoni and cheese. The mini breadsticks were great. The meat lover's was good, but it was undercooked. The toppings fell out of the bottom of the meat lover's pizza because it wasn't cooked long enough. The buffalo chicken was below average - not enough sauce or cheese. I had digestive issues immediately after eating this meal....perhaps because the meat lover's slice was undercooked, perhaps because this was way too much food for one person. :) read more

Pizza was Mid at best, the garden salad that was $7 was just a bowl of lettuce and a few cut up pieces of tomato (lazy) the cheese sauce tasted like plastic and the paper plate that they put my bread sticks on had 2 mouse droppings on it. Thankfully the bread was wrapped in foil. When I took them out of the bag and unfolded the plate and took the bread off there was the surprise. Never again. read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - 2 droppings on the same plate my bread sticks were sitting on.. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I loved finding this little casual pizza spot for lunch today. I ordered a large slice of margarita pizza, garlic knots, pepperoni stuffed breadstick, garlic and marinara sauce and a can of sprite for $14. Great value and everything was great. They also have cheap lunch deals, would definitely recommend for NY style pizza, several options. read more

See all

Stopped in for a late lunch and loved what we had. Just got two pepperoni slices and garlic knots, both of which were great. This is as authentic a New York slice as you'll find in Indy. The service was as fast as you'd expect of a by-the-slice lunch spot, and the prices were reasonable given the quality. If you're on the west side and are looking for a quick bite, stop by. read more

Best pizza in Indianapolis. The pizzas are huge and generous on toppings. The crust is perfectly cooked and the sauce is delicious. We love Manhattan Pizzeria. read more

this is a very good pizza. I only gave 3 stars because it just has to be cooked longer and get a crisp to it. do that next time and 4.5 stars. read more

Delicious pizza. Breadsticks are great! Nice selection. Highly recommend. Eating here during Colts tournament of champions. read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Nice selection. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Very good pizza. Was it the best pizza I've ever had? No but really good. Friendly service on the phone when I placed my order. I was told about 20 min. Took me about 20 min from my house and pizza was ready. They have signs up to "please wear a mask" as a private business they have the right to enforce it. So just wear the damn thing. They were offering eat in dining. I took mine home. Friendly service inside and the place looked very clean. They have one picnic table out front. Pizza had plenty of toppings and sauce and a good amount of cheese. I think I would have liked it baked just a tad longer to crisp the bottom crust. It was foldable like NY pizza should be. The edge crust was chewy and went great with the nacho cheese I already had at home. They have one size pizza. It's a good 20inches. Two pieces each were enough for us, so leftovers for midnight snack. read more

See all

Best New York style pizza I have found in Central Indiana. Get the whole pie, 1 slice is not enough.

The pizza is delicious! The service is super fast and friendly. I love the bench seating. I really just love this place. The crust is amazing read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza slices for lunch - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We love to stop in for a giant slice of pizza! The variety of flavors of pizza, as well as the variety of sides, means everyone finds something they like to eat. There is a row of booths where you can sit and eat. It isn't fancy, put prefect die a quick lunch, snack or simmer. read more

So naturally, every few weeks it seems I get a new craving for pizza and instead of going to the same places I try to switch it up every now and then so when I found Manhattan I decided to give it a shot! They don't seem to be doing any in person dining but i was able to do carry out. We got wings, garlic knots, and the grandma pie. Garlic knots: these were probs my favorite thing. This dipped in the cheese sauce was hella good. Really nice flavor to it without it being overwhelming. Def recommend! Wings: so I love my wings with ranch. Unfortunately I forgot to get some so having the wings just like that, they tasted solid, but they had a stronger vinegar flavor than I'd prefer. I think if I had ranch I would've enjoyed them a little bit more. Pie: so this is my own fault. I assumed the pie would be just a whole pizza, but to me it was more like a focaccia bread which was still good! It's just not what I was expecting so I definitely want to go back and try the actual pizza. I'm going 4 stars because part of the reason I wasn't the happiest with the meal was mainly my own faults and everything was still good. I enjoyed the meal overall it was just very different from what i was expecting. Overall it was a solid experience and I do want to try it again some point down the line! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My brother in law loves this place! I thought it was pretty good - we ordered a LOT of pizza and all of it was pretty simple, not too sophisticated, but fine for a group dinner. read more

Yum yum yum yum . This NYC girl has missed pizza . When really good pizza is available on almost every corner you don't realize how much it's become a part of your life . Late getting home ?grab a slice for dinner . Quick lunch ?grab a slice . Want to sit after a day of shopping ? grab a slice. Well this is the slice . It's as close to NYC pizza as you're going to find AND you can get a slice . A slice not a whole pie and not little squares. A slice . For most women and I assume some men a slice is all you want and that leaves most pizza here in Indiana off the "grab a bite " menu since you have to get a whole pie . If you find yourself anywhere near this place you should go in take a seat and grab a slice trust me it's great . They have wings and bread sticks etc but who cares they have real PIZZA! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria lives up to its name - you get a great slice of NY style pie. The prices are fair, the atmosphere is casual and comfortable. They always have a fresh selection of by-the-slice flavors ready to throw in the hot oven for that perfect crispy-but-chewy crust you can only get from re-heating in a proper pizza oven. Garlic knots are great. Desserts are good too. This place is a perfect workday lunch spot with 2 or 3 coworkers. read more

Reading some of the reviews of Manhattan Pizzeria I noticed some native New Yorkers said this pizza made them reminisce about the famous NY pizza they remember. If native New Yorkers give it a thumbs up than you know it's good. They had a lot of different options of pizzas to choose from. It's located right off of 56th close to Eagle Creek Park. It's in the same strip mall as The Boathouse Grill. I liked how the pizzas had a lot of toppings on them. No skimping! They have garlic knots, calzones, wings, and sausage and chicken rolls also. They have a pizza called grandma's pizza that's cut into squares and looks good! I will have to figure out what's on that and try it out! If you're looking for NY pizza go here! read more

See all

If you like New York style pizza and great prices, this is a place for you. They have some really good lunch deals and you can buy whole pizza or pizza by the slice. The service was quick and the food was delicious. The place was clean and comfortable. read more

I've been twice and both times were great! They have one size 'pie' which is super size large. We had it with sausage and mushroom... so good. Next time we decided to stop in because we knew they had pizza by the slice. Super affordable and lots of selection. I love the thin crust of this pizza l!!! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Fun wall art - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Love that they offer slices of pizza. This place is walking distance from me. I never knew they offered all these types of slices anytime. I only visited before during covid when they were only offering cheese or pepperoni for lunch and only ordered from outside. Love just a slice of NY style pizza. I got grandmother's special and it was so good!! Sucks that they are closed on Sundays so not available for game days. read more

Quick service. Homemade flavor. Cooked to order so it's always hot and fresh! If your whole family is made of pizza lovers get a whole pizza or two prepared with garlic knots and salad on the side. Or if you like to eat on the go, grab you a slice and don't forget to fold it like a REAL New Yorker. Wish I took pics cause my whole meal was tasty read more

One of my FAV Pizza spots! Whenever I am in the area I stop and grab it because it's on the other side of town. It's a small place but there's still a nice dinning room. They are always quick and actually satisfies my appetite! read more

Pizza was great and only took 10 minutes to make a large pepperoni. Staff was also great and helpful as far as different varieties read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Multiple people told me to try Manhattan since my husband and I are lovers of true NY-style pizza. A little annoying: I tried to order online, and the website directed me to an app. I downloaded the app, built my order and put in my billing details only to get an error that the restaurant doesn't use the app any longer. I called and placed my pickup order by phone easily - just wish I hadn't wasted 5 minutes on the app. We got two pizzas (there's only one size, and it's a huge 8 pieces) and garlic knots. The pizza is good. The crust was the perfect weight, the toppings fresh and the sauce tasty. Manhattan is worked itself into our pizza rotation. I've officially changed my rankings of favorite pizza in the Indy area. 1. Brozinni's (get the regular pizza but with the grandma's sauce), 2. Manhattan 3. Amore. read more

I've been wanting to go here for a year! I have high standards for New York style pizza but the group picked it so I had to try it! The pizza was my favorite! Definitely reminded me of being in New York City grabbing a slice. The garlic knots were 4/5 was good but felt like something was missing not sure what it was. The cheesecake was very good! Again reminded me of grabbing a slice around NYC. Two large pizzas, 10 garlic knots $50. The slices are very large. I'd deem this place authentic! Tried during covid where you have to wait outside for them to bring the food to you. No dine in options right now. read more

See all

Pizza is far above average. Not the best I've ever had, but better than chain pizza. Workers are friendly and they have a great lunch special, 2 slices and a drink for 8 bucks. Awesome little spot that doesn't get enough attention. read more

nice small business atmosphere. pizza made fresh daily. lots of different options and flavors. they have a nice lunch special, 2 slices and a bevies for like $6 or something. pleasant customer service. definitely worth trying! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Tasty pizza, friendly service, and with good prices. I could never tell you what's really NY style, never been, but I'll tell you the pizza is good! Crunchy crust, little oregano, and it's thin! They have a great lunch special during the week, you can buy by the slice or a whole pie, which are huge. The garlic knots were a little bland IMO, with just a ton of seasoning so I didn't care for them too much. But the standard ole cheese pizza never disappoints. Friendly staff, couple of younger kids running the show most of the time but it's very upbeat service and they're pretty attentive. Straightforward little unsuspecting pizza joint, if you don't get too caught up in the style! read more

Manhattan Pizzeria - Cheese pizza x 2 - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great pizza and the price is good too I would highly recommend this place for a good slice or pie read more

This place is the best for quick, delicious pizza! $26 for a large pie (I mean LARGE) and an order or garlic knots, you cannot go wrong with any of it. Right now, they're only offering take out, but it's a great local spot nearby that you truly get taste, value and LOTS of pizza. I cannot say enough about Manhattan Pizza, especially if you're craving a movie and pizza night in. read more

The pizza, garlic knots, penguins, and bread sticks were amazing! Our new favorite pizza spot! Well be back!

Just not my cup of tea, breadsticks were the best... I'd go back for them. The pizza ah not my favorite I'd rather have CiCi's pizza

""""Update: appears they are temporarily closing for 4 weeks due to local increase in Covid. Dang I will miss their tasty pizza! I love this pizza! You cannot find many pizza-by-the-slice locations in/around Indianapolis so that alone is a bonus. I'm not from New York but I've lived most of my life outside the Midwest and Indiana and I am a fan of pretty much every pizza variety and style. I generally order their pepperoni pizza on Mondays night for about $12.99. It is usually about $17.00. it's a big pizza and big slices and is hot and fresh. Any leftover slices reheat really well on a baking sheet in the oven. The giant pizza box barely fits in my fridge. At the current time with Covid restrictions they only do takeout. You can order at a table setup just inside their front door or call. I believe they close at 8pm most nights but they probably stay open later when we are not in a pandemic. As a non-Hoosier, I truly think the mom and pop restaurants in Indiana do not get the glory they deserve unless your grandma remembers eating there when she was 6. Their.pizza place looks like an average strip mall pizza joint...some of which are expensive and not good. But if you love pizza this place is definitely a hidden gem. You can order from a chain restaurant anytime. Picking up pizza here adds about 30 minutes to my commute home from work (as it's the opposite direction), but it's always worth it. read more

Everyday after kickboxing I come and get 2 slices of pepperoni and I am not kidding THE BEST pizza I've ever had and it's not a little slice either. read more

The only reason I'm giving it 2 stars because the owner gave me free garlic knots. I ordered breadsticks over the phone (had to call a couple times for them to answer) but when I got there I realized they had garlic knots. This is my first time ordering from them. The cashier acted like he couldn't understand what I was talking about when I asked what was the price difference from the breadsticks I ordered and the garlic knots I ordered. Seeing I was becoming frustrated the owner stepped in and just said it's on the house. On top of that it was not the pizza I ordered. I ordered a supreme meats pizza not a supreme pizza with all these veggies and peppers on there with one single pepperoni! read more