Gallagher&#x27;s Pizza

We usually get the Riverside Drive, and it's always amazing. Their garlic cheese bread is so good…read moreand pretty big! We got the 20" pizza, and it was huge for just the two of us We definitely had plenty to take home. We ordered it half-and-half so we could try different flavors, and everything was delicious! The restaurant is very laid-back and family-friendly, and our server was so sweet. I asked for a cup to take my leftover soda home, but instead, she brought me a fresh soda to go! Garlic cheese bread is SO delicious trust me, it's so good! Highly recommend if you love pizza!

Called in a carry out order to the restaurant. We got there & not only did they not have our order…read more& have no record of it but they were telling us we called a different location even when I showed them on my phone what number I called. No apologies, no we will make it right for you nothing. Not only will we never try them again we will be letting everyone we know how they treat people.

Brozinni Pizzeria on October 21, 2023

Riverside Drive Madison Ave

See all

Brozinni Pizzeria on October 21, 2023

Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

4.2(405 reviews)

5.3 mi

First time I came here I got pizza to go. We didn't care for that pizza too much, I don't know if I…read moreordered the wrong thing the last time but this time it was so much better. We did eat in this time. I also ordered 1/2 Cheese Louise and 1/2 Slaughterhouse Five. I ate the Cheese Louise and it was delicious. So cheesy with a crisp crust. Definitely would order this combo again. Look forward to the next time back.

Stopped by for my pizza fix and they did not disappoint. The Dillinger is my favorite pie on the…read moremenu along with their breadsticks creamy Parmesan dipping cause!! Several locations across Indy stop in for amazing pizza!

Inside

Tried to pick off some of the burned crust.

See all

Hoosier Brewing Company

4.5(38 reviews)

5.2 mi

I came here during a brewery crawl with all of the breweries in Greenwood and this was my favorite…read morestop of the night. They specialize in sours which is my favorite type of beer. I tried 6-7 of them as parts of a flight and I enjoyed every single one. I liked the vibe of the space. There was a comfy couch area near the axe throwing that we sat in. The only negative was that the bartender was not at all friendly and it almost felt like we were bothering him when we went up to order. But I really enjoyed the space and the variety of sours they offered.

nice outdoor seating area to enjoy the day. Inside they have Axe throwing and food to offer all…read morearound a good a Great set up parking is the only thing

Merchandise

Brewery room

See all

Tap room and dining

Coffee Junkiez Pizza Junkiez

4.3(149 reviews)

3.7 mi

Called ahead to order a small supreme pizza and it was ready when I arrived, really easy as could…read moreuse the drive through for pickup. Great friendly service, and the pizza was really good! Could order there, a small inside area to wait, but no dine in option. And with pizza needing time to prep and bake, ordering via the app or calling ahead is my pro tip.

We decided on pizza for dinner since I was not in the mood to cook. My husband wanted to try a new…read moreplace and decided on pizza junkies. I placed the order online and drove to pick it up. Two 12 inch pizzas - one was a supreme and the other was a build your own with mushrooms. We also added a 3 piece order of breadsticks which came out to $43.52!!!!!!! I got the pizzas home and they were both way overcooked! There were burnt pieces on the pizza! My pizza with just mushrooms was not good. I asked my husband his opinion and he said the same, that it was just ok. He said for what we paid, it should have been much better! We normally keep the remaining pizza in the fridge, for this one, we threw both boxes in the garbage can outside. I apologize for the negative review, but the pizza was overcooked, flavorless and loaded with oregano. We will not be ordering again from Pizza Junkies

Cheese loaf and sauces

See all

Jack's Pizza

3.4(20 reviews)

5.6 mi

Whoever was working/cooking tonight did an amazing job! We ordered pizza, breadsticks, wings, and…read morehoagies. Seriously the best I've had from Jack's! Everything was cooked to perfection and tasted delicious! Thank you!

We love getting pizza from this location in part because of the staff. Each time we call, we always…read moreget the "your usual Mr..." I understand their system pulls up our previous order, but it's a small but nice way to start the conversation. This is a carry out or delivery location only. As mentioned, the staff is always very helpful. The food is always hot and so good. It's the only place where 1 large pizza will feed our family of 5.

This is the meat lovers well done. I'm not sure where burnt was mentioned as being what is considered well done... ‍‍

Awesome pizza loving it

See all

The Original Chicago's Pizza

4.0(42 reviews)

6.5 mi

Family-owned & operated

Vegetarian friendly

The staff waited on us right away because we were the only ones in the place!! We got a deep dish…read moresupreme which it was not deep dish but that's the way it goes it was over cooked you can see in the picture! Overall the pizza didn't taste horrible but it's not as good as some of the other Chicago Pizzas we've been too!! It is trying to have a fun area to sit and play games!!

Enjoyed the buffet at lunchtime . Alot of different pizza combinations, bread sticks & drink for…read moreonly $10.00.

See all

The NY Slice

3.9(126 reviews)

4.4 mi

Wow! Don't let the outside fool you! I never stopped in because I judged and said how could the…read morepizza be appetizing considering the building looks so rundown?? After reading many positive reviews on fb and Google I decided to step in and give it a try. I know my NY pizzas and have yet to find an authentic one is Indy. Yes .... I've tried most places and trust me that here is where you'll find it! I wasn't disappointed in the least but. I mean not .... one .... bit! We were greeted immediately by the peppy owner. He was very nice and helpful. In true NY style he talked to us like we were family the whole time we waited for our fresh out of the ovens amazing 'pie' slices. We were able to watch him do his thing from the counter. You are able to customize a slice as well as your own pizza. There's no premade slices that are just sitting in a window waiting to be chosen and then thrown in to be reheated here! What you want is exactly what you'll get! The pepperoni bread sucks and garlic knots were amazing He even has a stone so if you want a crispier crust just ask for 'char'. I highly recommend it. This might give a perception your slice is burnt but it's far from it. Really makes it crispy and you'll love it! This is finally an authentic NY pizza not just a thin crust with NY slapped on it! My only complaint is I didn't try it sooner but I highly suggest you don't let the outside fool you .... Give him a whirl

Not only great pizza but great company. Owner was amazing and once inside, felt the authenticity of…read moreboth Dan and the NY pie!

Cannolis!!

See all

Bob's Tu Your Door Pizza

3.0(42 reviews)

5.2 mi

•$$$

Eight years later and the pizza is still as consistently good as it always has been. Bob's is a…read moreGreenwood institution! Is it the best pizza you've ever had in your life? No, but it is still damn good pizza. As I said previously, order it and decide for yourself.

Bob's Pizza is the best! The workers are always friendly!…read moreUnfortunately they close at 11:00 p.m. now which is just way too early for A pizza place on a Friday night especially in the summertime.

Tasted absolutely scrumptious but where is the pepperoni?

See all

Pizza King

3.7(6 reviews)

8.6 mi

I love ordering from this pizza spot when I come into town! They have a great selection of pizzas…read moreto order from! When ordering over the phone it was very easy and was able to pick up the pizza within 15-20 minutes. We ordered the bbq chicken pizza and loved it! They are carry out only!

Great pizza . A blast from the past. Takes me bast to high school. Crust is crisp, works is…read moreflavorful and delicious.

Last Chance Pizza

4.8(6 reviews)

7.1 mi

This is kind of a carry out only joint. It is co-located with its parent restaurant, the Barringer…read moreTavern. It is connected to the Tavern by a game room full of bar games like pool. I had to actually walk up to the bar in the Tavern to pay for my pie. You will find it on the side of the Tavern, near the back. It has a decent sized parking lot, but the spots were pretty much all taken up with Tavern patrons while I was there. They have outdoor patio seating available and you could probably also eat in the Tavern's indoor dining area if you wanted. They have a very compact menu consisting of a few signature pies or you can build your own with their toppings. You can get either a 10", 12" or 16" (they have a 6" option if you make your own. It is not available for signature pies.), you call it. I ordered the Death by Scorpion Sauce 10" pie. I got the scorpion sauce on the side because I did not know what to expect. The pie was ready in about 10 minutes. It was hot, fresh and delicious. It had a little kick to it, like I like. But it was not overly spicy to the point that you could not enjoy it. I really liked it. It was hard making it home without digging in, with it smelling all good and stuff on my passenger seat. In addition to my scorpion sauce on the side, the guy threw in some parmesan cheese and peppers packets. I will be the first to admit that this place looks like a hole in the wall when you are approaching it. However, they make a good pie. I highly recommend checking out this hidden gem. I am sure that you won't be disappointed.

On a whim we decided to try this somewhat new pizza on our way home today. After checking online to…read moresee the menu we ordered is phone for take out and was given a 15 minute wait time which was super quick! Once we arrived the pizza was being pulled out of the oven and was piping hot and smelled delicious. We ordered a 16 inch Katie Bug Pie which had veggies and a veggie patty. We asked for light cheese but might not have been heard as if this is light then regular cheese must be an abundance. Next time we would probably choose no cheese just to taste the veggies more fully. The dough was a nice flavor with lots of veggie toppings and plenty of sauce. It was a round pie which allowed for big slices and two were plenty for each my husband and I which means they were full of flavor and veggies. My only slight thought would be it is a tad salty fir me, perhaps the veggie Patty or sauce had more salt than I like but it was still delicious. I can't speak to their other options but from our first try it was a worthy spot for a take away pizza. Plus they have a cat that comes for petting and ha going out in the courtyard and who doesn't love a snuggle after pizza? Definitely worth trying out!

Katie Bug Pie

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Michael B.

0

2

0

6 months ago

Ordered 6 large pizzas over the internet right before they opened. Website is easy to navigate. Received confirmation of the order right when they opened. Pizzas were hot and ready at the time of pickup. The Kitchen Sink pizza was requested by the techs at our shop. All of the Pizzas were some of the best I've had anywhere. The gentleman at the shop helped me carry the pizzas out to my Jeep, as they are substantial. This is my new go to Pizza when I am in Indy! read more

Dan S.

0

55

0

2 years ago

Their pizzas are the Best lots of stuff on them when you order many items. They are quick to make them as we always pick unattractive.

Jamie R.

0

5

0

6 months ago

They do not skimp on the ingredients. Love the meat lovers pizza. Nice mix of all the ingredients.

Terry C.

0

1

0

3 years ago

wonderful food and very helpful service. Will definitely be back again! Best pizza around

Gallagher's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Restaurants near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Coffee near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Things to Do near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Desserts near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Breakfast near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Parking near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Dinner near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Burgers near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Shopping near Gallagher's Pizza

BEST of Greenwood, Indiana Movie Theatre near Gallagher's Pizza

Best of Greenwood

Things to do in Greenwood

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Gallagher's Pizza also viewed

Bob's Tu Your Door Pizza

3.8

(19 reviews)

Great food. Excellent service and friendly staff. What more could you ask for? We order from here…read moreall the time, and they always deliver with a smile. Now our friends who visit from out of town call before they arrive and ask us to order Bobs!

Bob's pizza is very good, BUT if the owners of a pizza place can't make enough money to be open 7…read moredays a week, then America's broken. I seriously doubt that's why they're closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, it's probably more like the owners choose to work the place and want some time off. That's not owning a business, it's owning a job. If the demand is sufficient to make a profit, then let teenagers run it in the days that you don't want to work. Growing up in Greenwood, I absolutely love their pizza, but I drive over 70 miles to visit my mother in Mooresville, and I usually try to go on a day that I can get Bobs. It definitely no longer a consideration for me any longer.

Bob's Tu Your Door Pizza

3.0

(42 reviews)

•$$$

Eight years later and the pizza is still as consistently good as it always has been. Bob's is a…read moreGreenwood institution! Is it the best pizza you've ever had in your life? No, but it is still damn good pizza. As I said previously, order it and decide for yourself.

Bob's Pizza is the best! The workers are always friendly!…read moreUnfortunately they close at 11:00 p.m. now which is just way too early for A pizza place on a Friday night especially in the summertime.

South Of Chicago Pizza & Italian Beef

3.6

(111 reviews)

So far, this is the best pizza I've had in the Indianapolis area. The Italian beef sandwiches are…read morefantastic. They are very accurate with their service times. And the seating barriers are very comfortable.

While at the Center Grove / Hamilton Southeastern Girls Basketball game I headed over to the…read moreconcession stand. The guy in front of me ordered a pizza and I asked where they get the pizza from they said South of Chicago. I had heard of this place just never been. They had pepperoni, cheese or sausage you could buy. I chose sausage and it was good. It wasn't a thick Chicago style pizza. It had a nice amount of crust to hold up to the good sauce they had on it. Some pizzas can be really dense and heavy. This was not. It was the perfect personal pizza size and I would definitely order that in the restaurant. I would want to try one of their Italian beef sandwiches with the peppers also. They have breaded raviolis, chicken Parmesan sandwiches, hot Italian sandwich and more at the restaurant in Greenwood. Yum! So, if you ever find yourself at a Center Grove Athletic game head over to the concession stand and get one of the yummy South of Chicago pizzas! Easy to carry to your seat and eat! I saw lots of people carrying the pizza boxes. So good!

Rockstar Pizza

4.1

(233 reviews)

Great pizza fast! Had the Hawaiian on hand tossed crust, it's delicious! I'm one person, but got…read morethe XxLarge for leftovers!

I stop in frequently for their lunch soup, salad, pizza buffet. It is always fresh and plentiful…read more Soups are homemade. Pizza is hot and fresh. The salad bar is truly second to none!

Randy's Tu Your Door Pizza

3.3

(26 reviews)

Why are these random pizza places in a warehouse across from CVS always so good?? How it works:…read moreorder, call when you get there and they'll let you know if it's ready. If not, just wait in your car and they'll flag you down when you're up. The... let's say non-traditional service model shouldn't deter you because this is tasty, crispy, browned cheese, well ratio-ed pizza. Try the cheese bread too!

The pizza is awesome and the cheese bread is good. I recommend this pizza over any other Pizza. The…read moreowner is really nice and it's the job done sometimes she's by herself that she knows how to cook.

Manhattan Pizzeria

4.5

(136 reviews)

I'm from New York, so when a place says "New York-style pizza," I'm already skeptical. We New…read moreYorkers take our pizza seriously. Well... Manhattan Pizzeria can actually back it up. Thin crust? Crispy bottom? Foldable slice? Good sauce-to-cheese ratio? Tastes like somebody actually understands New York pizza? We were passing through Indianapolis on our way home and decided to give Manhattan Pizzeria a shot. I'm glad we did because this was the real deal. I don't leave many reviews. Usually, you have to be exceptionally good or exceptionally bad for me to bother. Manhattan earned this one for being exceptionally GOOD. If you're going to call it New York-style pizza, THIS is what I expect. Signed, A New Yorker who knows better.

There are very few New York style pizza places in Indianapolis, so when I saw this online, I…read moredecided to give it a try. It is definitely the New York style- pre-made pies are sitting in the window, you pick your slices and they throw them in the oven to heat up. The slices themselves were OK. They probably could've been heated a little bit longer to make the crust a little more crunchy, but they were decent. Two slices and a bottle of Coke for $12 wasn't a bad deal. (I hate getting bottled drinks in restaurants. I prefer a soda fountain.) I saw two employees and heard a third one in the back. Both employees who were out front were busy sweeping, mopping floors, and wiping off tables. Very clean. For the price, I would certainly go back again. (But I wish they had NY prices!)

Chicago's Pizza

3.7

(19 reviews)

Pro - there's a lunch time salad bar! It's not huge by any means, but there's a variety of pizzas,…read morebreadsticks, dipping sauces and salad options to choose from which is rare at pizza places these days. I had pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was pretty standard. It's hard to go wrong with pizza- some are better than others and most fall in the average area, which is where I would rank Chicago's. They have the deep dish on the menu, which you can also order off, but I just did the buffet and tried the New York style slices. I would go back, but it won't be a regular spot for me.

They have my favorite Hawaiian pizza - lil chunks of ham and pineapple that's never runny or…read morewatery. AND they never hold back with the cheese dipping sauce - pouring it full to the brim. Now that's Hoosier hospitality!

Pizza King

4.0

(27 reviews)

Pizza King is more than a Central Indiana tradition, it's a religion among those that grew up with…read moreeating it. The Mooresville location is take-out only. However, they smartly have a dining room for customers to eat in. So there is no table service. This PK does not offer traditional breadsticks known to the chain, nor the same Royal Feast. Also no alcohol is served. However, you can purchase two liters of soda and get cups from them. We ordered a large pepperoni and sausage. The staff was super! The dining room was clean. They were busy too! They offer paper plates if eating in. The pie arrived hot and crispy out of the oven in its trade mark square slices. It smelled and looked amazing! The taste proved to be spot on correct, just like when I grew up. For me a solid 4+. But I am rounding down with a few of the Pizza King traditions missing. Also the wait was over 30 minutes.

I've always loved pizza king and this spot is one of the best. It's run by a great family and the…read morepizza and sandwiches are always perfect!

Lizton Pizza

4.2

(12 reviews)

Ordered a medium pepperoni and breadsticks. Everything was excellent. The breadsticks were the…read moreright combo of soft, airy, chewy, and crispy. The pizza was loaded with cheese and the crust was great. Again, the perfect combo of thin and crispy with the right amount of chew. Will definitely be back.

The pizza and breadsticks are great. A definite step up from chains like Papa John's and Pizza Hut…read more The staff. Is quick and friendly. I love it. Will be back again and again.

Enzo Pizza

4.6

(55 reviews)