Decided to try pizza from here tonight. Close to home and easy online ordering through the slice…read moreapp. Really appreciate the notifications and communication through the app to let me know when it was ready. Nice guy helped me get my order and I looked at it letting him know it was our first pizza from them. Looked really good! Got home tried it and it definitely was a great choice. Price was right in my opinion. I still tipped even though I picked it up. We ordered a sausage, banana pepper, and extra cheese large. Definitely will be back to order again.

You know Indy is a big city with plenty of ugly industrial areas and it just so happens, Pasquale's…read moreis the sole business in what seems to be an abandoned strip mall. I'm so grateful for this shop because once you step inside it's very much the romantic notion of a classic mom and pop shop that serves food far superior to all the surrounding area completion. Here on the east side we have all the big chain pizza places and a few others but once you have Pasquale's there's no reason to go anywhere else for pizza. I think maybe it's the daily in store made dough which is delicious and fresh and so fragrant and maybe the superior excellent ingredients. The last time I was ordering I asked the owner if their mushrooms were fresh or canned and he showed me a fresh mushroom! I appreciate someone who cares enough about their craft they don't mind discussing the details. Seriously best pizza I have had anywhere in Indy. Also, I really love the fact that all of the employees are gentlemen who are friendly, positive, patient and kind. They let you know how long it will be for take away and it isn't fast but it's so worth it! Somehow they magically impart a small town neighborly vibe that makes it fun to drop in and enriches the whole experience. Delicious food, top shelf service, connection and good vibes. I really hope everyone has the opportunity to experience this hidden gem.

Absolutely delicious sub sandwiches! We stopped in to get some subs for tailgating, and were not…read moredisappointed. The bread tasted homemade, and held up to date 2 leftovers. The sub toppings were plentiful, and veggies fresh and thinly sliced. It smelled amazing when we walked in, and we are very glad we chose this over chain sub shops. We will definitely be back next time we're in Indy, and would like to try the pizza. There were plenty of customers ordering pizza, so it must be delicious also. The owner was very pleasant, and the staff was very accommodating to our requests. The shop was very clean as well, thanks for such a great experience, can't wait to go back!

Great pizza! Hot and fresh and they use delicious ingredients. I will definitely return hereread more

My first review of 2018, WOOT WOOT!…read more Napoli's is on the far east side of Indy. I've only had their calzones and pizzas so I can't speak on their entire menu, but their pizzas and calzones are BOMB!!!!! Everything is put in the oven right in front of you. The staff is always super nice as well. We ordered an 18" pizza, breadsticks stuffed with pepperoni and a 2 liter for $20!! It also came with cheese sauce. As my grandma would say, "you can't beat that with a stick" HA! If you like pizza, you'll like Napoli's for sure.

Very good food! Quick service when ordering online. Spicy Italian was very good. So was the chef…read moresalad!

Wow! Don't let the outside fool you! I never stopped in because I judged and said how could the…read morepizza be appetizing considering the building looks so rundown?? After reading many positive reviews on fb and Google I decided to step in and give it a try. I know my NY pizzas and have yet to find an authentic one is Indy. Yes .... I've tried most places and trust me that here is where you'll find it! I wasn't disappointed in the least but. I mean not .... one .... bit! We were greeted immediately by the peppy owner. He was very nice and helpful. In true NY style he talked to us like we were family the whole time we waited for our fresh out of the ovens amazing 'pie' slices. We were able to watch him do his thing from the counter. You are able to customize a slice as well as your own pizza. There's no premade slices that are just sitting in a window waiting to be chosen and then thrown in to be reheated here! What you want is exactly what you'll get! The pepperoni bread sucks and garlic knots were amazing He even has a stone so if you want a crispier crust just ask for 'char'. I highly recommend it. This might give a perception your slice is burnt but it's far from it. Really makes it crispy and you'll love it! This is finally an authentic NY pizza not just a thin crust with NY slapped on it! My only complaint is I didn't try it sooner but I highly suggest you don't let the outside fool you .... Give him a whirl

The food was amazing. This is a real taste of New York style pizza. We took 2 slices and garlic…read moreknots to go. The pizza was fresh, thin, crispy and sturdy. The seasoning he added took it over the top, and had us wanting more. We joked about hitting Main St to get more. The owner was kind and helpful, and treated us like he knew us forever. We cant wait to come back. New Jersey Approved

NEW OWNERS. NEW LOOK…read more I wasn't even planning on getting pizza... but then I saw their sign outside and the branding was so cool it basically pulled me in like a magnet. Zero regrets. First of all--this is hands down the BEST thin slice pizza I've had in Indy. And I don't say that lightly. The crust? Perfectly crisp without being dry. The cheese? Just the right amount where it's not sliding off or drowning the slice. And the vibe?? Obsessed. They've got this super intimate bar area that feels like a hidden little gem, and the inside is decorated so well it actually makes you want to hang out and stay awhile. Honestly, I love a place that knows exactly what it is and nails it--and this one absolutely does. Came for the branding, stayed for the pizza, already planning my next visit.

We happened upon Byrne's at the Broad Ripple Farmers Market. They were selling a selection of…read morebreakfast pizzas (whole or by the slice). The pizzas are made on a cracker crust and grilled. Grilling takes a few minutes, so you have to wait a bit. The clerks are friendly. I had a slice of the California pizza, with eggs, cheese, spinach, sausage, bacon and a dollop of avocado. The slice is $7 and the slice is generous. I like the crunchy cracker crust that gets a smoky flavor from the grill. The spinach is fresh. The meats are small crumbles that have a salty flavor. I liked the pizza. It was hard to eat without a fork.

So far, this is the best pizza I've had in the Indianapolis area. The Italian beef sandwiches are…read morefantastic. They are very accurate with their service times. And the seating barriers are very comfortable.

While at the Center Grove / Hamilton Southeastern Girls Basketball game I headed over to the…read moreconcession stand. The guy in front of me ordered a pizza and I asked where they get the pizza from they said South of Chicago. I had heard of this place just never been. They had pepperoni, cheese or sausage you could buy. I chose sausage and it was good. It wasn't a thick Chicago style pizza. It had a nice amount of crust to hold up to the good sauce they had on it. Some pizzas can be really dense and heavy. This was not. It was the perfect personal pizza size and I would definitely order that in the restaurant. I would want to try one of their Italian beef sandwiches with the peppers also. They have breaded raviolis, chicken Parmesan sandwiches, hot Italian sandwich and more at the restaurant in Greenwood. Yum! So, if you ever find yourself at a Center Grove Athletic game head over to the concession stand and get one of the yummy South of Chicago pizzas! Easy to carry to your seat and eat! I saw lots of people carrying the pizza boxes. So good!

Very clean and very inviting. Staff was EXTREMELY friendly. This is our First time eating there and…read moreit was a great experience. Staff there were super helpful and answered my questions about what they offered and what was included on pizzas. Food was amazing and although it is a little expensive, money well spent. Quality and taste were nothing short of spectacular. My wife, whom is a picky eater , LOVED the food and we will definitely be returning. 10/10 recommend any day.

We were excited to try the new Magoo's on the southside and finally found the chance to visit…read morethere. We were in search of an Indian flavored pizza and we found it. We tried the Chicken Tikka with white sauce. It was very tasty. We also had mozzarella cheese sticks. They were good also. We had some yummy chocolate chip cookies for dessert. They also serve regular fare pizzas, fried chicken and sandwiches. We dined in but it appears there is a large portion of carry out. There were 5 nice sized booths for dine it. The owners were helpful with food advice and super friendly. We are trying a paneer pizza on our next trip.

Love their salad bar and breadsticks w nacho chz sauce. Usual order. Used to order in…read moreBargersville every Friday night to pick up on way home. Yummy pizza.

We received a coupon for a free pizza after recently moving into the neighborhood. I called to see…read morewhat the "catch" was, but there really was none so of course I ordered a pizza I got a pizza with ham, sausage, onion, mushroom, and green peppers. Being from Chicago, I guess you could call me a pizza expert. Don't be fooled. Chicagoans only eat deep dish pizza once a year, so anyone saying Chicago pizza must be deep dish is lying or misinformed! This pizza was exactly the type of Chicago pizza I am used to! It flooded my brain with memories of getting pizza with my family and friends. This is the closest restaurant to where I live, and it definitely did not disappoint! I can't wait to try their lunch buffet soon! The pizza was ready within 15 minutes, and it took no time to pick it up. My fiance said the vibe inside was really relaxed as well.