Great food and service! The bread is delicious and made in-house. Brian is a passionate chef and friendly. He's always giving me samples of new things he's coming up with. So far, I've enjoyed the bbq chicken, chicken salad, fettuccine alfredo, loaded mac n' cheese, and all of the desserts :) read more

OMG WOW! So good. My wife and i just finished our sando's from Greiners and we loved every bite. Those sandwiches are so good we practically moaned with the whole time. Definitely our favorite place for hot sandwiches and the gentlemen behind the counter was welcoming, quick, and friendly. You guys have it going on! read more

Excellent sandwitch. I tried the 1928 with everything. I got the 8" thinking ok it will be enough for lunch but might need some chips or something. OK I was wrong the 8" sub here withe meat, cheese, and topings along with the delicous hoggie bun was all I could eat for lunch. I can't wait to go back and try the chicken salad and other choices. OH and they have Icecream, and HUGE and I mean HUGE cookies. The staff was very nice and talked to me about the sandwiches since I had never been there before. read more

I don't know where to start so I'll just say from start to finish, if you're craving a sub or cheesesteak (like me), this is the place. The owners happened to be in while I dined in for the first time, and opted for the cheesesteak sub, loaded fries, and their famous salted brownie (still warm, omg). It hit the spot and more. Service too was excellent, and everyone was so warm and welcoming. If you have a hankering for a really good sub, this might be the best in the city. read more

Greiner's - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Food is amazing especially the forty toddy. Service is great even when they are busy!! And you can sit down and eat with your friends and family even though it's kinda small. Brain does hard work everyday and he's always blessing other people. Make sure you bless him !!! read more

Greiner's - Hotty The Hot Toddy - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Greiner's has Great sandwiches! Friendly staff! It was busy!! And the mac and cheese with sour cream was to die for!! read more

Second visit! The service was still impeccable and the food even better. A beautiful meant the garage doors were open with the screens letting fresh air in. 12/10 read more

See all

Had a three day weekend and decided to spend it in Indy. We had some restaurants set in stone for the weekend, but had not settled on Friday's meal. Was kinda craving Mexican. Kinda craving a good sub. Not a chain sub. A good ol' freshly baked, freshly made sub. So we did some research and found Greiner's. It's the oldest sub shop in Indy. Pulling into the parking lot, we were a little doubtful. It's clean looking but... nothing fancy. I've found out that's where you tend to find the best food. So... in we went. The line wasn't extremely long when we entered, but there are so many options on the menu that it does take some time to order and get your food. Don't get me wrong. They don't mess around. They know what they are doing and the food is well put together. The man behind the counter was larger than life. 6'7" and a personality that added flavor of its own. A mother in front of us asked what was on a certain salad. He told her. She asked the difference between that salad and another. He replied "no meat!" She pondered a moment and... ordered a sub. In a VERY good natured way, he roasted her! "You mean to tell me you asked all of those questions about salads only to order a sub?!?" Her husband was laughing, she was laughing. He ended their transaction saying he just couldn't pass up the opportunity. It was all in good fun. Being shy, I knew I wasn't going to ask questions! Ha! I opted for the 8" Hot Toddy while spouse ordered the 8" Philly Cheesesteak. Then we saw they had cheese fries. We stupidly ordered two orders. The Hot Toddy has capicola, turkey, ham, pepperoni, with chipotle sauce slathered on one side of the bun and mayo on the other, cheddar cheese, jalapeño cheese, lettuce, tomato (ordered mine without), banana peppers, with salt and a light drizzle of olive oil. I added fresh jalapeños. The Philly Cheesesteak had steak and cheese with your choice of toppings. Both are toasted. Let me tell you... we struck gold! Hands down the best sub I've ever had. So full of meat that it began to push through the underside. I couldn't get enough. The flavors are perfect! Everything stands out. It's hard to put into words how great the Hot Toddy is! Spouse loved the cheesesteak sandwich, but one bite of my sub and we both decided we will be back for the Hot Toddy. The question is 8" or 16"?? The loaded cheese fries were huge! Came with liquid cheddar cheese, shredded cheddar cheese, bacon and a dollop of sour cream. They were delicious. But... our stomachs were begging for mercy and we couldn't get them all down. This place is small, but it packs a huge punch! We left so impressed and excited to go back. ASAP! Would HIGHLY recommend!!! You won't regret it! read more

See all

Id heard about this place for a while now and finally made a point to swing by. Highlight: the staff was super friendly and the food was delicious. I didn't know what to expect but was happy I went. My Italian beef was flavorful and toasted wonderfully. The beer was cold. Chips delightful... The brownie... Uhhh . No other words needed. Staff was super friendly and pleasant to chit chat with while they worked. This isn't McDonald's.. so don't expect to blow in and out of here in 2 minutes with food in hand, they make the stuff/put it together as ordered.. I'll definitely be back! read more

Greiner's - Italian beef and more - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Greiner's is a sub shop established in 1969, and subs are certainly their speciality, but they also have AMAZING pizza and Mac n cheese! Family-friendly and quite possibly the nicest staff in the downtown district, Lisa makes every customer feel like part of the locals. 3 picnic tables outdoors and 3-4 tables indoors often with people working on their laptops, it's a lively place and just feels like Indy ! The sub sandwiches are massive - always on fresh French bread with fresh made meats. I honestly don't know how people eat them so I ate mine with a fork - you could suggest light lettuce if you actually want to be able to close it ;) HIGHLY recommend their Hot Toddy special, really good flavor mix and the banana peppers are the perfect topper. Honorable Mention: their brownies are worth getting every time. They go through over 3 sheets a day. read more

See all

Wife had the meatball sub, you could tell the meatballs are handmade, the bread is also made in house and it's great. I had the Hot Toddy, and while a little messy, it's totally worth it. The lady taking our order and making our food was helpful and gave us great suggestions. The brownies are really good too. Loaded fries were great. We will definitely be back. I want to try multiple sandwiches and the pizza. read more

Greiner's claims the distinction of being Indy's oldest sub shop deli. Located just south of fountain square, this place has a lot of items from subs, pizza to even Mac and cheese to choose from. Service was fast and the sandwich was amazing. I ordered the hot toddy: capicola, turkey, ham, pepperoni, cheddar cheese, jalapeño cheese, mayo + chipotle, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers, kosher salt and olive oil. There's no heat (spiciness) but everything seemed to mesh perfectly. The bread is homemade and perfect for the sloppiness of all the ingredients. I'm glad I ordered the 8 inch. If you're in the area you should give them a try. read more

Greiner's - The Hot Toddy - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My coworker and I stopped by for lunch the other day. I got the Hot Toddy and it was delicious. It did start to fall apart towards the end but it was so filling. The brownies are a must get item- so decadent. Service was great- spot is small to eat in but we made it work. read more

This place is amazing been going here for years. Never misses. The updated garage door is great for when the weather is nice.

If you like an Italian sub, trying this Hot Toddy is a MUST. If you're worried about spice levels, the sandwich does have several ingredients with heat, but they're all in moderation such that the sandwhich isn't spicier than pepperoni. The two staff members who helped me were kind and went above-and-beyond to give me advice on my first visit. I was initially surprised by the higher prices ($4 brownie and $13 sub), but the portions are MASSIVE. The brownie hardly fit in the to-go container because it's so thick. The 8-in sub is certainly 2 meals for me as a lighter eater, but even the man making my sandwich remarked that he will make a 16-in sub for four meals for himself. The homemade bread is excellent. Some aspects of Greiner's are a little rough around the edges, like part of their exterior sign had fallen off, and the back of the parking lot looked cluttered. However, everything that's essential to be clean was. The parking lot was well paved. The interior was clean. The truck display outside is cute. One thing that stood out about Greiner's is the humor in their signs. The place has character! I'm thrilled that Greiner's is a part of the community at the intersection of Garfield Park, Fountain Square, and Bates-Hendricks. read more

See all

What a find! Tucked near Shelby and Raymond, Greiner's has fresh, massive subs - served cold or toasted. They were busy this afternoon, but cranked out sandwiches quickly. They also offer pizza, mac n cheese, and loaded fries. I opted for the only sandwich that gets its own sign - the Hot Toddy. This sandwich is for meat lovers - turkey, pepperoni, ham, and cappicola accompanied by cheddar and jalepeño cheese and your choice of toppings. I'll be back for more sammies and their other menu items! read more

See all

Great food at their Shelby Street store. I have a Subway just down the street, but the drive to Greiner's is always worth it. There's a reason they have been in business for many years. Workers do a fantastic job. read more

Food was excellent. Best sandwich in town--and I search them out. To top that, the service was even better. Great people! Going back again.

Stopped in for the first time after driving by this place for years and had the most wonderful sandwich! Roast beef was tasty and they had lots of hot sandwich options, as well as lots of sides and non-sandwich options. The cheddar broccoli soup was a little off (it tasted fine but the cheese in the soup like...coagulated and split from the soup) but the cookie I had was fabulous. Guy making my sandwich was also very friendly. New fave sandwich shop in the neighborhood! read more

Friendly service. They have a nice parking lot. Easy to order. I just had a turkey sandwich with provolone and the usual sandwich toppings which they were pretty generous with. We also ordered the fries, chili, buffalo mac and cheese, and brownie. The turkey sandwich was pretty good, it was ginormous. I couldnt finish all 8 inches of it. I wanted the potatoe soup, but it was pretty late in the day so they ran out. The next option was the chili To be honest the chili had a bitter taste to it, kind of like the bottom of the pot taste, like where all of the seasoning I guess settles to the bottom. But the when you got past the bitter taste, you can taste how rich it was. The fries were pretty good. I would order the fries again. The mac and cheese was also delicious. I would probably try the mac and cheese with bacon next time. The Full order was huge, maybe do a half order. The brownie piece was huge as well, I do wish there was more sea salt on top though. Overall pretty good experience, I would cme back here. read more

Brian was so kind and made us excellent sandwiches. A fun, quaint and local vibe too! We'll definitely be back! There were also a ton of yummy sweet treats :) read more

Local, friendly, delicious. Always happy with the food and service. It's a Southside gem. Happy to support them. The 1969 is my go-to, extra mayo and extra wet! So good! read more

Greiner's - a table and chairs in a restaurant - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Sub was packed full and everything was fresh. Great customer service. Very friendly. Right around the corner from me so will definitely be back. read more

Came to grab food to avoid having to cook at home. With it being grey and gloomy out we didn't feel like cooking. We got a chef salad and a class Italian sub. Salad- was packed with vegetables. All tasted fresh. Plenty of meat. The ranch tasted home made. Everything was fresh and you could taste it. Mind you, we went right before they closed. Nothing wilted or soggy. Husbands sub was piled high. He could barely eat the half size portion. He agreed, meat was fresh. Vegetables were crisp and fresh. Oregano was unique but in a great way. Not sure I can ever get oregano again from the market. Interior was just fun. Industrial. Warm. Inviting. Not huge but if you want to sit back and eat it just has a warm vibe. Lots of glass garage doors to let natural light in. And it adds to the industrial vibe. Staff was just great. Smiles. Told us what they recommend, e courage'd us to add veggies I typically wouldn't have. Positive vibes. 10/10 read more

Greiner's - Classic Italian - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

08-93-2022 As an update...the Italian Beef here is excellent. Just add giardianara. Same with the Philly Cheesesteak. The Hot Toddy is still an excellent sandwich, though! read more

Greiner's - Italian beef sandwich - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is a rustic style deli that has been around over fifty years. They tout the best subs in Indy. They have a small dining area and limited patio seating. I sat out on the patio. The restaurant has a small private parking lot with a few spots. It seems to be ample given the traffic the place gets. They have some intriguing hot and cold sandwiches on their menu. They come in 8 or 16 inch bread. I knew I would be no match for the 16 in'er so I played it safe and went with the 8 inch. Based off of staff recommendations, I ordered the steak and cheese. I got a bag of chips to go with it. It took about 5 minutes for my sandwich to be ready. The sandwich was good. I liked the bread, and condiments on the sandwich. I was not a fan of the steak. First, there was not a lot of it. The steak was hidden by the condiments. Second, it was not your typical steak and cheeses. It reminded me of the old steak'ems that I ate as a kid. The bread and condiments brought all of the taste. The staff there was very friendly, helpful, and welcoming. They had a bunch of people working there while I was there, but they were all gainfully employed. In addition to this restaurant, they operate food trucks and offer catering. I like the mood and vibe of this restaurant. I will definitely be back, but I would try another sandwich though. I have heard good things about the Hot Toddy. read more

The service was amazing. It was our first time and he walked us through options and gave recommendations. Super friendly and knowledgeable. The food was excellent. Can't wait to return and try more menu items. read more

The Italian beef was QUALITY! Bread was very good as well and a huge portion for a $12 8 inch sandwich. I will be going back to try the Philly cheesesteak. Greiner's is a one of my go to for sandwich's in Indy! If you've never been it's worth driving or delivery. 5 stars! read more

Top notch sandwiches! Very unique and large portions. You won't find many gems like this place. The line was long due to it being very popular, yet they were getting people served in a timely manner. Don't miss this place, you will thank me. read more

Greiner's - RAY'S 1969 HOAGIE - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I drove past Greiner's on my way home from a Yelp event and thought it was the cutest little spot. I looked it up and saw it had outstanding reviews for their subs so I knew I had to try it out when they had gluten free bread on the menu. I walked in and was immediately greeted. The lady making my sub apologized for the size of the bread but assured me the meat would be the same. I opted for the old skool dressing way and it was perfect. Actually, there was so much meat, that I pulled some off and will be able to make a second meal out of it. The scent of my sandwich rolled heavily through my office and now everyone is dying to try it. I can't wait to try something else. read more

Greiner's - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Flies everywhere (and in the toppings as she made the sandwiches) and it was dirty in there, employees were nice but Would def not recommend. read more

I would like to say this place has very great customer service and a very nice staff. Everyone made me feel as if I was hanging with the family. The food is the best food I've had since living in Indianapolis. The food is ten out of ten . read more

Greiner's - Ham turkey and bacon sandwich - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The Mr Turkey sandwich (even for 8 inches, is huge and very generously filled. I had to add a little salt and pepper, since there wasn't a lot of flavor but once I did that it was a very good sandwich. The Fries were decent, not quite my style and unless I were sharing with someone, probably won't get them again because there were a ton! read more

Greiner's - Fries - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My father and i went to Greiner's this evening for dinner and it was delicious! He ordered the Hot Toddy with chips and i got the 3 Cheese Grilled Cheese with french fries. my sandwich was huge and had gooey melted cheese. The chef even let us try a piece of a toasted peanut butter and jelly sandwich that he was working on. it completely changed my view on a pb&j. the restaurant is small but it is very family friendly and the employees were so kind. i can't wait to go back! read more

Greiner's - 3 cheese grilled cheese and french fries - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

4.5 rounded up to 5! We've driven past this little gem on numerous occasions and decided to finally stop in. And so very glad we did! Prices are pretty similar to Penn Station for a bigger sandwich. No comparison there. The tuna sandwich was stellar. I'm a huge fan of the Jimmy John's tuna sandwich and this completely blows it out of the park. So much more flavor! My partner ordered the veggie and demolished it. The bread was so tasty too. Soft, airy, and hearty. The 8in is more than enough for a really hungry and huge appetite, as I couldn't even finish mine (not for lack of desire to!) The only reason I can't give a solid 5 is because of the Mac and cheese. We ordered the naked genie and it was just OK. I wouldn't say it's the best, nor would I say the worst. But it was a'ight. Probably wouldn't order it again, but would eat it if someone brought me some! Can't wait to return! read more

Greiner's - The Tina Tuna with all the fixings - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The bread for the sandwich was absolutely wonderful. These sandwiches are big - not jimmy John's big - Greiners big! The bread is thick, and they don't hold back on the meats and veggies! The mac was "ok", not my favorite, but acceptable. I absolutely loved the pickles, jalapeños, sprinkled with salt and pepper with oregano! Good service, patient and friendly staff! We'll be back again! read more

Greiner's - Claire's Veggie Head - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Accommodating and so kind. They make you feel like it's such a privilege to serve you. An Indy gem for sure!

I walked up hours past closing time and the owner just so happen to be there. She insisted that I come inside for her to make a sub for me! She was so friendly and kept telling me this was her favorite thing in the world to do. The subs were awesome as well! Will be back again (during normal hours!) read more

Greiner's - Mr. Turkey - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We had Greiner's delivered to us Oct.12th before the P!NK concert. I had the Mr.Turkey add let, onion, pickles & black olives 8". It was so big delicious & very filling. I also ordered a 8" BLT, 8" Philly cheesesteak added giordoni pepper's, & 8" Philly cheesesteak with the basics add mayo & 2 orders of crispy fries. All of us thourghly enjoyed our subs. We even enjoyed them after the concert. It only took 15 minutes for it to arrive directly to the hotel lobby. Excellent all the way around highly recommend. If Im in Indianapolis again I will definitelyinitely come back. read more

Amazing!! Four generations give it 5 stars!! You need to try it if you haven't had it already. read more

Greiner's - Food Trucks Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana