I had heard such good things about this pizza spot I had to try it. Boy I so glad I did. We were greeted as soon as we walked in. Since we were "newbies" the lady did go over the menu. I happy we got there right around opening time because as we were waiting customers were coming back to back. I know the next time I drive out there I will eat a couple of slices while I'm still there just to get the full experience. It was still delicious when I made it home to reheat it. read more

Xtraordinary has been a longtime favorite of mine! If you enjoy a tick topping, Sloppy, piled high pizza.... this is for you! I can't find another one like it that satisfies my pizza craving. read more

I'm not in the mood to write a long review. Xtrordinary Pizza doesn't need a long review. The Pizza tastes better than the pictures look. Good service and product. Space clean and neat. If it is eat-in, I wouldn't know. We pick it up and go. I visit this establishment monthly. Enough said. Go get you some. read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - You see it. Now go try it. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Our first trip to Xtrordinary Pizza is in the books! The pizzas and calzone were great! We ordered what was basically a supreme pizza and it was LOADED with toppings! I needed a fork to gather the toppings that fell off because it was so loaded. The price doesn't change based on the number of toppings either. The only downfall is that there isn't any seating to dine in or even any chairs to sit and wait for your pizza to be ready. read more

See all

The pizza place is the best in Indiana . The food is amazing and the service is excellent . The ambiance is laidback casual. I drive 50 miles round trip from my home in Franklin for there pizza !! read more

Waited a hour a 30 minutes today for a pizza name wasn't called or anything this was my first experience and i will never be back pizza cold lady at front desk did not do her job completely ruined my experience will not recommend any of my fellow co workers or friends to come here read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - box of their pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I've heard good things about this place, but I don't get down to this area often. My department decided to order here for lunch. I got the meat lovers personal pizza. The lunch special also includes 2 breadsticks and cheese dipping sauce for only $10. The star of the show was the pizza which was overflowing with toppings. They do not skimp on the toppings. Pizza was tasty and flavorful. They also offer sandwiches, crustless bowl, wings, and ribs. It is carry out only. The lunch special was very filling, I ended up saving half of the pizza for later. I'll definitely trying another pizza when I'm in the area. read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - Meat lovers lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My pizza wasn't good when I went there l see others and there pizza looked amazing my pizza was chewy and not much cheese l have only been once read more

Finally got to try it out. Pizza was loaded with toppings, and the calzone was really good.

amazing pizza for the $! can not go wrong with this pizza they are like extra EXTRA friendly with the AMOUNT of toppings no matter which you choose! Sauce is sooo tasty! read more

My absolute favorite pizza place hands down!!! This place is about 30mins from my house and I drive down to get carryout least twice a month. I always call my order in before I go. The staff is absolutely wonderful and treat you like family! Food is always extremely hot and fresh. I love the thin crust & how it's loaded with toppings. A single medium pizza will last my husband and I two days. They are hugeeee. You will not regret it. Pro Tip - Get your pizza cut party style. read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - Medium supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Order for pickup. Ready went they told me. Hottest pickup pizza I ever had. Got home feasted like a king. Or like in the USA feasted like the greatest President Trump the G.O.A.T!!! read more

One of the BEST pizza places in Indiana!!!! All the toppings you want at no extra charge....now tell me what other pizza place beats that!! SN: Now if you want extra extra toppings there is probably a charge. read more

Great food, great people, good price, horrible about answering the phone. Unfortunately bites that they don't deliver anymore as well

If this isn't the BEST pizza, and pizza deal, in Indy; then I'll eat my hat!! Xtrordinary Pizza just blew me away. The crust, the sauce, the edge-to-edge toppings (piled high!), the perfect amount of cheese, and THE BROWNED finish!!! We're talking pizza perfection here. I know I should have stopped at a couple of pieces, but I just couldn't. It was VERY hard to control myself. I had tried this place years ago, and wasn't impressed. Now I am!! Something has changed for the better, that's for sure. Very friendly people, as well. The only negative is finding it after pulling off the road. It's all the way in the back, hidden by other buildings. I will be putting this place in my regular rotation. Who needs Jack's anymore!!?? (They're too expensive anyway, IMHO). read more

When I'm craving pizza that will have me satisfied and sliding down my couch this is it! Topper mile high with toppings and generous portions there no comparison. Service is quick, simple and to the point. I've never had any issues with ordering and my order is always ready when I arrive for pick-up. This is an in and out type of spot, which is fine by me. Although it is clean, don't expect anything fancy. Orders can be made by. Asking and delivery is offered. I prefer pick-up so I can snag a slice in the car or before I leave the parking lot read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - Medium with everything, minus a few ingredients. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The pizza is amazing. The staff is very friendly and the place reminds you of like a mom and Pop restaurant very cozy intimate. This is also a Indiana staple. read more

I love a great pizza. This lived up to my expectations. The lady who waited on me was extremely pleasant. I placed my order inside and it was ready in less than 30 minutes. The toppings were amazing and plentiful with each bite. I live so far but I will definitely be back and often. I did call them later to tell them how much I enjoyed it. I definitely recommend this place. Great food and customer service. Also the price wasn't bad either. read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - Medium Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

best pizza i ever had lots of toppings an great price good service when you order here best be ready to eat we drive from indy to wanna maker just to get it read more

Oooh Weee Wowzers!!! This One Right here!!! The Around the World 16" All Toppings Pizza is definitely the truth!!! They also can you over the outdoors intercom when you order is ready to go!!! YEEESSSSSSS Ma'ams and Sirs!!! read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - a sign for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The pizza is always excellent, and the staff are always friendly. They do have some limited hours but they seem to be always open when I want a delicious pizza, my fav is with everything and some jalapeño too. read more

One of our favorite pizza places! We love the pizza! It is great & heavy with toppings. Price is pretty good, especially for how much you get for the money. read more

Better than "the ordinary" restaurant up the street that's been there longer! Pizza has tons of ingredients on it! Can get soggy depends on the ingredients! read more

So I found out there is an ordinary pizza and an xtrordinary pizza. I'm so glad I picked xtrordinary. The pizza was great. They don't charge per topping it's a 1 price deal. We got the personal pizza and breadstick combo..it's under $10. So when we walked in the employees greeted us like we were regulars. This was my 1st time there. They answered the couple of questions we had and didn't make us feel like a bother. There's no dining I strictly carry out. The place looked clean. They have a speaker that goes outside they call your name on when your food is ready since there are no seats inside. The pizza!!! My pizza was piled high with toppings. I was stuffed after 1piece and 1 breadstick. The only thing I didn't like waa the cheese for the breadstick isn't warm but I just threw it in the microwave. Go get some of this deliciousness read more

See all

The best pizza in town hands down. It's a family business. Everyone is always nice. Food is ready when they give you a time. read more

The best pizza in Indianapolis I found out about this place several years ago I've been driving there to pick up my pizza every time now I love their personal pizza which is only about eight dollars four good pieces and two breadsticks. I always call ahead for my order and in about 20 minutes later it's always ready. Forget about all the other pizza places you've ever been to and try this place you'll always go back. JOHN HOUSE. read more

Pizza was amazing albeit a little heavy on the ham. First time picking up Pizza here. When they handed me the box, it caught me by surprise how heavy it was, but I'm NOT complaining lol read more

First timers here! When we called, they said it would be a 3 hour delivery wait. We figured that must mean it was really good, we decided to go for it. (Delivery ended up arriving in around 1.5-2 hours which was awesome!) Delivery driver was nice and was able to find our house (new build that sometimes doesn't show up on google maps correctly yet!) I was soo excited when I opened the box because it looked JUST like a pizza place that I LOVE from back home. However, the pizza was just OK overall. I'm a sauce-person. This one had very little sauce and the crust was not good, in my opinion. The cheese, however was thick and they load on the toppings. Breadsticks were OK. A bit pricey considering everything. I think we paid about $45 for a large pepperoni pizza, breadsticks, and tip. read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I drove over 30 minutes to get a pizza from Xtrodinary Pizza. A friend introduced me to it by bringing a pizza to a gathering a little while back. I remember it being the best tasting pizza I've ever had. The building sits behind a set of buildings so you have to look for it. Once I arrived the staff greeted me and promptly gave me my piping hot 16" deluxe pizza minus the jalapeños. That box was so heavy which meant it was packed with deliciousness! And that it was!! When I got home and opened the box, Everything looked so good. The way my taste buds are setup these days (thanks to Covid last year) I couldn't taste the flavors but my family was in awe!!! They were like "where did you get this pizza from? This is delicious!!!" I guess we'll be making that drive more often! read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - Almost forgot but this is a 16" deluxe pizza minus the jalapeños. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The last 3 times I ve went to get pizza they have been closed before their posted hours. This use to be my favorite pizza in Indy but this is ridiculous Guess it's time to find a new spot read more

The pizza is so good and filling! I love it and recommend it! I wish they were open at noon I would so order pizza for lunch

My wife loves there pizza but I don't like their crust. But there is more on the menu that is to my liking.

Pizza is very greasy. My stomach can't handle it. It's Just not for me. The pizza itself is not bad. It's just extremely greasy. read more

The pizza was really good. There were lots of toppings and not too much sauce. I was greeted when I entered the restaurant and the customer service was good. read more

This is a pizza five that if you love pizza you must try this place. It's some really really great pizza. The only down side is that their crust could stand to be a little better crunchier. No offense but the crust might need a little work, but the pizza is the truth. I traveled 16 miles on the other side of town to grab this pizza and it was worth every Mike that I drove. Big ups, statistical extraordinary pizza. It's so filling, I could only eat 1-1/2 squares before I was totally full and satisfied. Um um good read more

Xtrordinary Pizza - The incredibly delicious pizza that I couldn't wait to delve into. So, so good - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Total hillbilly crap! Who put's breakfast sausage on a pizza anyway? Sauce?, bland ketchup. Crust? Cardboard, you have to cut it with a blow-torch. Cheese?, not from Wisconsin, they use that crap to make steering wheels. Sucks out loud! read more

OMGGGGGGGGGG BEST PIZZA EVER!! Absolutely unbelievable!!!!!! HOWEVER.....they take their phones off the hook an hour before they close (I'm guessing because they have enough orders and don't care to fulfill any new orders) FRUSTRATING!!!!! read more

Great pizza that is LOADED with toppings. Probably one of the heaviest pizzas I've every carried, but worth every lb! Pretty far to go, being that I live on the north side but I would make the drive if I wanted great, handmade pizza from a crew that cared. I've never had poor customer service, and even other waiting customers were super cool to talk to. DEFINITELY a great choice for pizza. read more

Went in at 9 PM, they don't close till 10. All I wanted was pepperoni cheese breadsticks and they told me they were closed. I have bought many pizzas from this place never again!!!! read more

The food is amazing. The service is awesome. I love everything about this restaurant... it's all good