My favorite pizza spot. Love their large slices. Make sure you get the buffalo ranch!

3 stars for pizza & breadstick 5 stars for customer service Ordered the Vinny...it lacked garlic flavor and definitely wasn't as cheesy as I thought it would be. It was terrible it just was not as garlic flavor as we would have liked it to be. The breadstick was hard and seemed old. It was not good so disappointing for that because they're usually pretty good. Customer service I will say is very good. Nice staff and great attitude and atmosphere. Clean dining area I noticed while I waited. I have had other pizza slices before so definitely going to get the OG pepperoni or the pepper, onion, jalapeño one. Now those are flavorful. My salad was good. Overall the Vinny was edible it just lacked the flavor but the breadstick was bleh, not fresh. I will have to try going earlier next time maybe they'll be much better. read more

See all

This place is great , NY mafia style pizza joint with a speakeasy craft cocktail part to it in the back which is interesting. The pizza is always fresh and huge slices which u can swing by just for a slice when strolling down Mass ave. They also have massive nearly 2foot long breadsticks they fold in half to fit in the plates. Nice convention quick and efficient place other than when they run out but all the food is really delicious Check em out! When u wanna quick bite and crave pizza read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Giant pep slice with cheese sauce - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I used to frequent this location a lot when I worked downtown. I recently stopped in towards the end of my evening on a Saturday, and it was so so busy. Good for them! Except, my food was not the greatest this time. As I mentioned, they were extremely busy, but the pizza seemed pretty sloppily prepared, and there was way too much sauce on my slice. I actually had to wipe most of it off, and the toppings kept sliding off because of it. Not sure if it was just an off day, but it didn't hit the spot for me that night! read more

$4 for a huge slice of pizza is just an incredible deal in this economy and in an area like mass ave. It was reliable late night spot for our large group and there was plenty of space for us to sit and super awesome staff!!! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My 5 Takeaways (in under 60 seconds) Location: Prime spot along Mass Ave. Easy to find, with plenty of street parking available. Vibe: Great atmosphere. Cozy, yet plenty of seating and room to move. Clean and well maintained. Service: Excellent customer service. Fast, professional, and welcoming. Food: Delicious. Fresh ingredients, well cooked, and good-sized portions. Quick Tip: You can't go wrong with the lunch special - $10 for a slice, a side, and a drink. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best pizza in town! Great atmosphere and the bonus is the speakeasy in the back. Bar service is outstanding.

This location sucks I ordered a pizza and came and they said "he's making it right now" came back 20 minutes later and he said "he's making it right now" this is kinda crazy ridiculous other people who ordered in store after me all got their pizzas and orders before I been to other locations much better ran. read more

Best place to get a quick slice on Mass Ave! The pizza is always ready and waits are low unless you catch the late crowd on the weekends. The service is great! Goodfellas has lots of seating options and a little hidden speakeasy that has all the vibes. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food and drinks and the all around vibe of the place and the service is top notch notch and a good time read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Food room - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great Pizza & Great Crew! I requested a Happy Birthday pizza and they hit out of the park! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Craving Pizza? You gotta try Goodfellas downtown Indy. Perfect if you're already in the area and need a bite. Best bet for your money is to take advantage of the lunch or daily specials. I know lunch includes the arm long breadsticks! The guys behind the counter are cool and fun to talk to. Lots of seating plus a nice surprise in the back. If it's not pizza you're wanting but want a tasty drink, inside there's a hidden bar, 'Wiseguy Lounge'. My drink was so good. A spin on the traditional amaretto sour. The bartenders are really nice and are helpful to find a drink depending on your taste. This wasn't my first time and it won't be my last. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

BEST CRUST AROUND The guy that took our order was very patient and helpful. He helped guide us through the menu to place our order. I'm a big crust guy, and this does not disappoint . The mix of flavors was amazing. We had the Goodfella which is a meat pizza. Simply amazing. We also had the cheese bread that everyone loved. Check out the cool bar in the back. I'll check it out when the kids are not with me. Great food, great service. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - The Goodfelka - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love a huge NY style slice! Goodfellas is perfect for a quick bite at anytime of the day or night. The Wise Guys Longue is also pretty underrated and a cool spot to have a drink and a slice. read more

This is a 2 for 1 if you can handle it! There is pizza on one side and cocktails on the other. You enter a really nice area, greeted with black and white tile floors. There are a bunch of tables and a table with stools that face the window you can look out of after you eat. You are immediately greeted at the door and you can see a few pizza options in the pizza window. Once you know what you want, they heat up the slice that's in the window. If it's not there, they will make it fresh. The breadsticks are so delish. I tend to get the pepperoni pizza. The smell of pizza dough is so intoxicating and the slices are bigger than your head! If you want to dine in, they offer you paper plates. I suggest grabbing some napkins because of the grease, but in a good way. Not too much. The bathrooms are always clean and fresh. I always enjoy coming here and love that I can grab a slice late night after going to a bar/lounge. read more

See all

It's usually busy in here so be prepared for that. We came in for some grub before going to the speakeasy. There was a line, but it moved quickly. We wanted pesto bread but it was going to take too long to make so we settled for a slice of pepperoni pizza and a breadstick with cheese sauce. We took it into the speakeasy to enjoy a cocktail with our food. I really like good fellas pizza, it hits everytime. The breadstick was very enjoyable, I love how you can take the food into the speakeasy too. I really enjoyed drink my cocktail and eating my food. The ambiance in goodfellas is chill most times but sometimes depending on when it it, it can get really live. For good pizza, goodfellas is a go to. read more

See all

If you're ever craving a quick bite, this is the place to go! They have such good and huge pizzas here for cheap! The food is made quick and there's always a variety of flavors to choose from. There's seating inside and outside! read more

Delicious pizza open super late with wonderful ambiance and a speakeasy in the back! Had fantastic service as well read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Giant pizza slice! - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great quick by the slice service. Spacious and relaxing bar. Typical wait for whole pizza

We stopped by on a rainy weekday and were surprised to see how busy it was! I might come back for the vibes, people there had great energy and it's in a fun location. The pizza was middle-tier, good for a quick bite after a concert a game but didn't satisfy my craving for NY style pizza. read more

Goodfellas is a great place to pop by for a quick bite, which is exactly what my dining companion and I did the other day after doing a little bit of shopping at local bookstores for Independent Bookstore day! Prices are reasonable, food is delicious, and service is fast and efficient. read more

Stopped in during lunch time - it's a decent pizza place with large slices of pizza by the slice and the breadsticks are huge! I liked the lounge-y section of the restaurant, it'd be great for larger groups looking to eat and lounge. I got the veggie pizza and shared a friends breadstick - the garlic cheese dipping sauce was delicious! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Fast, reliable, and delicious! Came here for a slice after a late night out and you can never go wrong!! The place looks small from the outside but is quite spacious from the inside. I appreciate that there is plenty of seating as well. The staff was quite patient as I made my decision on a slice. Pizza was crispy just the way I like it and hot! Will be back!! read more

See all

Give me a NY style slice of cheese and a coke and I'm a happy girl! Nothing fancy just simple and great. Not lacking in sturdiness either this was a thin but strong slice that folded into eating perfection. IYKYK Only downside was the breadstick. That was mid. But my slice and cherry coke hit the spot per usual. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Lunch special $10 slice, sauce, side, drink - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The pizza was tasty and fresh, and I really liked the dough. It was soft and well baked. The only small issue is that there could be a bit more toppings. read more

Food was great! Dave Portnoy needs to stop here! Great undercarriage and sauce. Got the pepperoni and it was perfect! Staff was friendly. I'll be back! read more

They made it right. I love Goodfella's pizza. Their slices are top notch and there are few things that hit the spot better after a few drinks than a slice and a breadstick from Goodfella's. On the evening of 3/22/2025 I came in to try one of the March Madness pizzas. The wait was reasonable and the atmosphere was lively. I did not check the box and drove home only to find that I was given a cheesy bread. I called and they immediately answered and asked how they could make it right. The manager even offered to make a larger pizza for me since I was willing to drive back. Even though I had to go back, I was impressed with how they handled the mistake. The pizza is fantastic and the people are even better. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Frankie Pickles Pizza - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Indianapolis is best! Quick, easy and delicious. I absolutely recommend this especially if you're in a hurry.

Yumm! Great toppings, just amazing pizza. Must try, you'll love it. They aren't just another pizza joint

Okay late night spot. Visited in for a slice late night after a concert. I wish detroit had these late night slice joints. Pizza is good. Of course the kids working there are crazy obnoxious, but it's a college crowd typically. It was enjoying to watch the pizza dough in the air. Line moved quick and they nice. Food was tasty. Price was kinda high. Priced per ingredient. read more

Pizza and breadsticks were great. Service was fast and nice. Got a piece of pizza and bread stick, very affordable. . read more

I've always had good service and love the pizza. Today the 2 employees that served me and rang me up sounded as if they were unfamiliar with the lunch special. I had to specify to the guy ringing me up that I had the salad (which I had put on the counter next to the boxed slice) so we did not need to wait on a bread stick. Then he didn't think there were any dressing choices except ranch when I could clearly see many dressing containers beyond just ranch...in the fridge. he didn't know what they were but did offer he'd give me a different one if I sons like the one that appeared to be a vinaigrette. I said I'm sure I will like it. The most disappointing part was the girl put my slice straight into the box. I never realized the slices were hot but that you always put them into the oven to crisp them up. I thought maybe there was a new process. I got in my car and started to head home. I grabbed my slice of pizza and it was floppy and not even remotely crisp like always. How could this employee be there during the lunch hour and not know you always hear the slice up in the oven. Maybe you will say she was very busy and trying to save time. When I walked in there was 1 guy ahead of me being rung up. A few people came in after me, but it's not like there was a line out the door. Anyhow, my piza was a floppy mess and not crispy like always. It was just disappointing. read more

Super yummy late night pizza spot. I love that they sell by the slice and have different pizzas with different toppings. Service was great, the guys behind the counter were funny and really welcoming. The restaurant is a perfect spot for late night pizza cravings. read more

Nice spot for a quick meal after an event at the Athenaeum. Within walking distance from the venue. A little high in cost, but well worth the taste. Short wait time, great customer service at the order counter. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - History - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I knew that this was going to be a good lunch when I walked inside the front door and someone said "Welcome to Goodfellas!" I had been there before and knew how it worked, but it was nice to be noticed! I got the lunch special, and they warmed my slice up for a short while in the oven. I got the delicious garlic butter for the bread sticks. She said they make it in-house. It's addictive! After I got my pizza and drink I sat down in the newly expanded dining room. If you haven't been there in a while, you wouldn't believe how nice it is now! And bigger!!! The food was great as always. Now the dining room is much more comfortable and nicer. It carries over into the bar, too. I was going to get a refill of my soda and the young man working in the dining room didn't for me. I could not be happier with the food and service! I cannot wait to go back. I may ask for some of that garlic butter to go next time! read more

Wanted to give a huge shoutout to April! She made 10. 22 inch pizzas for a meeting we had today and did it with only a 30 minute notice to our pick up, I'd like to add maybe set your system up to give them more of a heads up when ordering online in advance... but nonetheless April knocked it out of the park and had us out the door quick! Pizza was a huge success a lot of first timers and from the sounds of it a lot of people that will be visiting your location soon! Thanks again! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The pizza here might taste great when drunk on a late night out, but if I'm being honest, it's a cheap tasting pizza. I'd rather order from one of the pizza chains. Their box says "A Slice of New York City" and that's unfortunate because nothing about it reminds me of New York City pizza. The thing is... I literally just came from visiting NY this week and there's no way you can compare these pizzas. The ingredients on top tasted cheap. The dough is soft and floppy in an unappealing way. The pizza had a bunch of burnt dust on the bottom which is not appetizing. I work and make pizzas so I know how dirty a pizza oven gets when it's busy but clearly there's no care when it's late at night here. The breadstick is also a joke and gimmicky. No reason for it to be that long and it didn't even taste that good. The breadsticks from little Caesar's are legitimately better than this. read more

See all

10/10. My favorite place to order a TRUE NY slice of pizza whether I'm dinning in or taking it to go! The service and food are always top notch. The new Wiseguy Lounge expansion is just the icing on the cake read more

Great food and service! I got their lunch special a slice of pizza drink and side for around 10 bucks! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave - Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great staff! And the wise guy lounge is epic! Adriana gave great suggestions! Can't believe the fall menu is almost done! Can't wait to try the winter seasonals! Good vibes all around! read more