Ordered pizza while at work. Had some issues with door dashing delivering correctly. called the store, and the manager was more than helpful!! Offered to refund the pizza and even called back to ensure it was delivered! Will order again read more

10/10. My favorite place to order a TRUE NY slice of pizza whether I'm dinning in, picking it up to go, or ordering delivery! The service and food are always top notch. read more

Bumping up my review for this Goodfellas Pizzeria because the 22-inch pizza is impressive. I've ordered the 22" twice now, and each time, I'm completely taken aback by how large it is. I felt like a cartoon character carrying the pizza box to my car. I could barely fit the box into the passenger seat of my SUV. Each slice of the 22-inch pizza is unwieldy and perfectly greasy and foldable. For a pizza this big, you want minimal toppings, because otherwise, the slices will be difficult to pick up. Adding just pepperoni is perfect. I'm still a little miffed that there isn't seating in this joint, but I guess it makes sense. There is zero parking in front of the restaurant because it faces Broad Ripple Avenue, and minimal parking around the corner. I was in a parking pickle when I went to pick up my to-go order -- I couldn't find a space! Luckily, I found some parking in the back of the restaurant. The parking in this area looks like it's off limits because there's a fence around it and you need to enter through a gate, but (I think) you're allowed to park there if you're just popping out to get your to-go order. Allow some time for your order to be ready. It took about 30 minutes for my pizza to be ready, but it was great when I finally got to eat it. read more

Amazing pizza! I am usually skeptical whenever stepping out of my comfort zone of already established favorites when it comes to pizza but I wanted to give this place a try. Very impressed! Good sauce, pizza crust was crispy, and had a nice blend of garlic and oregano. I shall return very soon! read more

Forewarning this place only offers bar style seating so it wasn't ideal with children. The food was great and the staff is so dang nice it's enough to make me come back here!! Place was clean, they made my pizza fresh right there. My only complaint is our pizza was very soggy/greasy so you may need to ask for well done. The flavor was good though. They offer a great lunch deal and slices of pizza are available all day. I'd come back when I just want a slice or lunch. read more

See all

Very disappointed in the food. Tasted old as if it had been sitting since opening. Served cold. The dipping cheese for the breadsticks was also cold. So cold the seasoning was coming off when you tried dipping it. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Cold pizza for dine in. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Well I accidentally ordered a huge pizza. I was really really wanting NY Style Pizza and only two places in Indy came up. It was a toss up of driving further and having a parking lot. Or closer and searching for parking since B-Ripple chose to remove parking on Broad Ripple Ave. We tossed a coin and B-ripple won. The pizza I got was like 24 in across. It was just two of us eating it. It did fit the bill for NY Style and it hit the spot Friday night and again Sat night and last two pieces Sunday night. So splitting it up between 3 meals the cost wasn't really that much. Be careful. It will auto add a 20% tip on line if not paying attention and you will be charged a service fee on top of that. We'd probably do the pizza again but parking in B-ripple sucks. read more

Goodfellas is a great by-the-slice pizza joint. I've never seen the same person behind the counter twice. And the state of the drink machine and other amenities is always a crap shoot. But the pizza is good, cheap, fast, and tasty. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pizza is yummmm We went in for a late night dinner after getting drinks around town and decided to get some pizza at GoodFellas and I'm glad we did! They sold pizza by the slice and it was such a good deal considering their pizzas are huge. We also got a cup of cheese to dip the pizzas in and they were amazing. Not much space to sit at so we just stood and ate at the counter (keep that in mind). This place is great for when you're looking for something quick, cheap, and delicious after a late night out. read more

See all

I decided to take advantage of Goodfellas' 50% pizza Monday special and ordered online. As a vegetarian, I was so excited to see how many options Goodfellas had to offer. I ordered 2 pizzas: the "taste of Naples" pie and "the bootlegger." "Taste of Naples" is essentially a margherita pizza. "The bootlegger" was a pesto-based pie with sun dried tomatoes, spinach, and mushroom. Of the two, the bootlegger was my favorite! Both were delicious but the bootlegger is definitely my new go-to pie. My pickup order was ready right on time and was extremely hot (preferred)! Even though it was busy in the restaurant, the pickup process was extremely easy. read more

REAL New York pizza in Indiana!! Can't find this anywhere in Michigan, sadly. Mostly to go orders, though there is a counter to eat in. Lots of famous Italians and movie photos on the wall which is all right Hope they get a place like this up North, preferably East Lansing. read more

Kind of greasy floppy NY style pizza. I get NY pizza, you fold it to eat it, but this is just a bit too floppy and messy.

Take out order during game 7 of the NBA finals with the Pacers playing. Should have been a fiasco with how busy they were but instead the order was fast and flawless and the pizza was delicious. A+ visit. Will definitely visit again! read more

Ordered pizza and cannoli. pizza was cold, we never got the cannoli. I called the restaurant sev times. I spoke to Christian, who said he took my name and would give it to the manager, He said there was nothing else he could do. I called back and requested a refund or for it to be delivered. He said it was not possible, but his manager would be back at 8 pm to call then. When I called at 8:08 another person answered and after I asked to speak to the manager I was told he was gone for the day. read more

The staff was very sweet, the hours are nice because they are open very late if you are going out nearby, and the food is also great

Been here thrice in the last month. There are a lot of good pizza joints in Indy, and this is certainly one of them. Consistent, good crust (not too floppy), quality toppings and great cheese 1st time had the The Boss. I ordered it by accident as chicken and ranch isn't really my thing on pizza. It was ok. 2nd time had Paulie's Favorite. Fantastic! My favorite of theirs thus far. 3rd time The Goodfella. It was solid. Ordered takeout, ready when it is supposed to be. Staff is friendly enough. I'll be back. Especially for half priced Mondays! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - The Goodfella - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Quick, delicious, NY style pizza! We needed a quick meal after a long day and within 15-20 minutes we were able to order and pick up pizza and snuggle in for a movie night!! It is a pretty small...walk-in take out kinda place, I believe they also deliver but we live pretty close so pick up was easy! The signature pizzas were delicious we got 2, the taste of Naples(classic margarita) and the Vinny with sausage(white sauce, cheese combo and sausage) both were the smallest size and we had to try the pesto bread. We loved it all and with 3 adults I was worried we wouldn't have enough but had plenty and leftovers for cold pizza the next day....overall a total win for us!! Definitely recommend read more

This was fantastic. Never tried them before and grandma wanted pizza for family dinner. We ordered Tommy two times and Nonna's pie plus sun dried tomato bread. Then when we went to pick it up husband saw the breadstick and had to try those as well. Ordered for a specific time and we got there a couple minutes early. Order was hot and fresh. Tastes great. Sun dried tomato bread was awesome. Prices were reasonable. Pizza also reheated very well the next day in the toaster oven. Definitely will eat there again. read more

See all

I got one slice of cheese pizza. It had obviously been out way too long. It was dry, hard, and had very little cheese. It should have been tossed and a new one made. Also, the chef was not very friendly. read more

Fantastic pizza when it is hot, closest thing to crisp, foldable NYC style pizza in Indy. Staff is friendly and answers questions, made good recommendations. Speakeasy in the downtown location has a fantastic selection of whiskey, including allocateds and some good barrel picks, and is a nice quiet spot for a drink with friends, or to sample a bourbon before you buy the bottle. read more

Good pizza, bread sticks are disappointing. My bf likes the slices he can get here. They are huge slices, like bigger than your face. And they are yummy. I asked my bf for breadsticks last time and they were horrible. Rock hard, no flavor, and they are expensive. Go for the pizza, steer clear of the breadsticks! read more

See all

This is a solid choice for carry out pizza. We placed an order online which was really convenient. Our favorite is The Vinny. Goodfellas has huge pizzas, which is great for a large crowd. I also love that they sell pizza by the slice. A great price point too! This location is not setup for dinning like the downtown location is. Staff was friendly. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - The Vinny Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good food, big portions, friendly price points, great service, clean, quick, and timely. Never been disappointed at this location (or the Mass Ave location). Can be difficult to find street parking, which is metered, during peak times along the busy streets. Venue isn't set up for dining in. It's neat to watch them make the pizza, throwing the dough high in the air and catching it while waiting to checkout. Tried out the online ordering this last time and everything was perfect, on time, and easy. I don't think I've ordered the large pizza before so i tried putting it in the front seat but actually had to put it in the trunk because it's HUGE. The slices and breadsticks are large that they barely fit on a plate. If coming to pick up a prepaid order, you can walk up to the counter and bypass the line. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - 22" pizza with pepperoni, garlic sausage crumble, and banana yellow peppers - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Meh. Even for a late night pizza spot, just okay. We're out of most of their menu when we went. Had to wait 30 minutes for our pizza but the breadsticks were good. Again, okay for a late night pizza spot but there's better to choose from out there. Would try again is they would have the items missing from there menu though. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - The Don - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have ordered this pizza more times than I am proud to admit, but every time I get exactly what I expected and that is a big, delicious NY-style pie! I normally go with pepperoni and jalapeño but personally love Wiseguy & the Don. Taste of Naples and Nonna's Pie are both good choices as well. I picked up from this location once and while it's a super small spot, they have a counter you can sit at and the people working there are a delight! read more

Fast service, great tasting pizza! We get pizza every Sunday and this has been a staple! Pizza has a lot of sauce!

Hands down the best pizza in Indy! 8.1/10 on the One Bite app...always great service. Make sure to get it well done. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Medium Craft Your Own Pizza w: pepperoni, sausage, jalapeños and pineapple. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Goodfellas is always a fan favorite. It's quick and easy and very reasonably priced. Usually, we get a slice or two because of how big and filling they are. They always have multiple options of pizza ready to go. Location is awesome and is a great place to go after a night out in Broad Ripple. read more

Best pizza in town. Great lunch specials and 1/2 off smalls on Monday are the best. Great staff and friendly service

Nice pizza place strategically located in Broadripple! During the weekends this place is crowded, especially around 1 am when people are coming out of bars. What makes this place famous is their huge slices of pizza wich might be more expensive than a regular brand however eating a huge slice is what we all want right? What I didn't like of this place was that we were starving, just came out of a bar and wanted to order a complete pizza for our group of 4 and the cashier said that was not an option, I told him Ive asked for a complete one before and he said just slice by slice. I didn't want to pay for this because it would be more expensive but my was so hungry that he just said well if you are doing that I want 8 slices and we ended up having our whole pizza but at the cost of $44 dlls. I believe this was not fair and not to blame but looks like a trick to abuse of people that are a little drunk and instead of paying a normal price of $30 dlls for whichever pizza you would like you end up giving more money for the same thing. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Goodfellas Broadripple - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My favorite New York style pizza around Broad Ripple. It's a chain that has locations in a few states around, as well as multiple locations around Indy. At this locations it's deli style so they don't have indoor seating. They have large slices for takeout that are ready, or you can order a whole pie by phone or at the counter and wait a while. The breadsticks are about 2 foot long and necessary with any order. Pro tip- skip the marinara for the bread sticks and get nacho cheese instead. You will not be disappointed! They have pizzas that go up to 22 inches so you can feed a small army at home too. I wish they had an online ordering system as sometimes they get busy on the phone. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Cheese and pep - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love the huge slices and thin crust at Goodfellas. This slice is pretty close to what you'll find in NYC. Prices are great, especially when you get a lunch combo or their Monday night half price personal pies. As with most pizza, this stuff is best eaten fresh out of the oven (or reheated in their big pizza ovens). I've found that takeout pies lose some of their luster after the 15-20min of travel time when you finally get to eat. Just hunker down in the restaurant and enjoy the pizza off the flimsy paper plates like a real New Yorker. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Greatest NY Style pepperoni pizza. Delicious! I'm living in Chicagoland now and pizza sucks. Originally from Syracuse, NY around Syracuse Univ. Cosmos and Varsity pizza shops read more

Was looking forward to trying this highly suggested pizza, but there is absolutely no parking. And if by chance you do find a parking spot a block or more away, you have to pay. Very disappointing. read more

Goodfellas is classic football pizza. An oversized pie of good to mediocre pizza with lots of toppings. If you go into Goodfella's expecting a world class slice of pizza you would come out disappointed. However they offer ginormous slices and pies for reasonable prices. They also provide a great variety of different slices. You can walk in there on any given day and find your staples of cheese and pepperoni but they will also several other pies that very tempting. They also do good job of heating the slice up before giving it you. The breadsticks are also great and I would recommend them along with your slice. They have several different sauces that come with the breadstick. There is not a lot of seating inside the restaurant so this would be more a grab and go place. The seating against the wall can getting very crowded when they are busy and a line starts to form. Overall, an extra large slice of above average pizza at a good price. read more

See all

Decently priced and open late for the broad ripple bar crowd. Pretty authentic nyc style pizza (according to my New Yorker husband). It can be a little pricey if you get the speciality pizzas but it's not a bad price by the slice, and it's so filling that usually one or two is all ya need. Pro tip there is a some free parking in A lot off of Winthrop. read more

Good pizza, usually tend to buy it after a drink or two so it's great then. Not my top pizza choice but pretty good especially late at night when you need something cheesy and greasy read more

I think after visiting NYC a couple of times and trying Joe's Pizza, I measure all pizza against it. Especially when a place claims that they do NYC-style pizza. I tend to stick to classic cheese for my first go-around and walking into Goodfellas,' I remember thinking that the pizza case looked EXACTLY like the ones I'd seen in NYC. Cases are constantly refreshed with fresh pizza and slices of different varieties, each as tempting as the next. We went with the lunch deal to share after sharing some dishes at Brugge (RIP) and indulging in a cupcake smash at Smallcakes, just across the street. At $7, you'd think it's a bit pricey, but here's what they don't tell you: the breadstick is LITERALLY as long as your arm. If you're looking for a rich, hearty slice, this probably isn't it: this is your classic NY slice. Good cheese, crispy, thin crust, and a breadstick that's munch-able and also a good vehicle for dipping sauces, should you choose to get some (as I always do). I'll be going back soon enough and while I'm not sure I'd buy a whole pizza, I know where to go when I'm missing my favorite NYC slice. read more

See all

First time here. Very rude cashier, half of their employees wont even put their personal cell phone down while preparing customers food. I'll never come back. read more

Goodfellas Pizza is the best pizza I've had while sober. We ordered the Goodfella and added feta. This combination was delish! The medium pizza is HUGE, would be considered a large/xl at some pizza shops. The meat portions were great, no skimping here. And when your boyfriend is a power lifter, this is important. So now to the customer service...I literally wanna come back just to hang out with them (and eat pizza of course). Staff was super helpful with answering my questions because again protein is a must! Music was great, we (including staff) were jammin' out in the restaurant. I'm actually going back this weekend, see ya there! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana