Fantastic pizza and friendly fun service!! We love the big Arni beers too!... Cheers!!! read more

It was a Thursday afternoon and we had stopped at Arnie's for lunch. Merrit, came to serve and take our order for lunch. She was fun, friendly, and very good at her job. We quickly order with a few excellent recommendations from Merrit. The food arrived quickly and everything was delicious. As my friends and I enjoyed our conversation, Merrit was present but never intrusive. Our drinks were never empty and if we needed something Merrit was never far away with the help we needed. We finished our meal, thanked the team who served us for a great experience and promised to be back soon. If you are looking for great food, great service in well appointed and designed restaurant, it's hard to be Arnie's. If you want to add extra to the experience, ask for Merrit. You won't be sorry you did. read more

We tried to order online. The website offered Google Pay, which showed my credit card and personal information including my email address. I thought the order had confirmed and was paid for, but when we got here, they said they had not received the order. I would give zero stars if that was an available option. We will NOT be going back. Don't trust the website or order online. It doesn't work. Now, I'm wondering if they're going to try to take my money despite not providing the product. read more

Good pizza and I really liked the small pepperoni pieces. I would highly recommend getting a medium or large pizza - they do a much better job of putting an appropriate amount of cheese on the bigger ones, but the two small (personal) size ones we got had wayyyyy too much cheese and were inedible. read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We are visiting Indiana for a Show Choir Competition and heard great things about Arni's, so we decided to try it. We had a late lunch and it was absolutely delicious. Cheesefries were perfectly layered with cheese and bacon. And the Ranch... so so good. Chicken Quesadilla, my husband said was probably the best he has ever tasted. Cheese pizza, one of the top 5 pizzas I've ever had. And DO NOT SKIP out on the brown butter cake. The only thing wrong with that beautifully plated and phenomenal taste is that we ate it all and there was none left. HIGHLY recommend this restaurant. Great food. Great service. Clean. Family atmosphere. read more

See all

This is a great family restaurant that sells amazing pizza, wings, craft beer. My kids loved the kids menu as it has lots of options. I love the pizza with the tiny diced pepperoni and/or sausage. It's like an amazing pizza king. I'll be back for sure! read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pizza was delicious as always. However, I was rather surprised by the price for a small pizza. It is definitely one of my favorite pizzas, but I will not be back often just based on the price. read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Overall, I really like the atmosphere of Arni's. Place is clean and nice for a pizza joint. Pizza is overall good but not great. I've had several of the specialty pizzas which all were good but nothing stood out as fantastic. Service is usually very good with no issues getting food out quickly and fast. Only one time have I had slow service. Overall, great place to get a pie. read more

This is just a good casual restaurant with a laid back bar. Think Chili's/Applebee's/TGIFridays, but good. They are known for their pizzas which are pretty tasty. They do a lot of carryout business and there is a dedicated side entrance for just that. read more

See all

We typically order take-out and it's always delicious! We have ordered pizza's from here in the past and the hot Sicilian sandwich a couple of times. Today, we ordered the chicken broccoli fettuccine, added spinach, hot Sicilian sandwich, and the Junior salad with egg and tomato. We really wish the salad was spinach, or a spring mix, and not iceberg lettuce. Also, I would recommend different meat options on the chicken broccoli fettuccine, the chicken was chewy. The sauce on the pasta is tasty! The French fries with the sandwiches are crispy and seasoned great! Customer service is great here. You definitely get your moneys worth of food. Definitely one of our go-to places for dinner take-out. read more

Arni's - Chicken Broccoli Fettucine - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We dined in and the service was really slow. Arni was not busy so not sure why service was slow. My other half did not like the entree of salmon, Brussel sprouts. The brussel sprouts, fries were mushy and the salmon lacked flavor. I enjoyed my Caesar salad and the shrimp appetizer. Overall, our experience was not the best with slow service and not everyone enjoying their food. read more

Arni's - Salmon, Roasted Brussels Sprouts, Fries - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Both of us have fond memories of Arni's from our college days at Purdue. This visit did not disappoint. From the exceptional Pretzel Bites with cheese to the Build Your Own Pizza and Teriyaki Chicken Sandwich, well our appetites were well sated and our tastebuds delighted. Washed down with a pint from a good beer list we couldn't have been happier. read more

Mom & daughter dinner date! It went very well with great food and great service! We had breadsticks as appetizers and split a 10 inch. My daughter wanted Buffalo Chicken, I had pepperoni & mushrooms! Yummy! Server was excellent! read more

Arni's - 1/2 Buffalo Chicken, 1/2 Pepperoni & Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love it. There is the whole story of Indiana Pizza King. The brothers selling the recipe to Arni. Now Arni's has the pizza king recipe. I think it is true - and if you know otherwise, just don't tell me :). I grew up on Pizza King pizza. Arni's takes the great pizza I grew up on and adds a cool restaurant with other great food options and great staff to the mix. If you order carry out, there is a back entrance to get in and out along with parking for carry out. Use it! I love the pizza, I love the other food too, but I always get the pizza. They have outside seating if you like that. If not, the inside seating is a fun atmosphere too. Also - if you sign up for the birthday club - free personal pizza on your birthday! However, the 4 stars is because the large pizza seems like the size of what used to be a medium, and the price went up. read more

Arni's - Bacon Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Got the Italian sub. Food was bland, it did not stand out to me at all. The fries were soggy and wimpy. Service was ok. There was not a wait for a Sunday night. read more

Just about every time that I pick up an order there are things missing !! ive door dashed for this place a couple times now, they are rude , don't smile, dont seal the bags, dont write names on the orders , dont give receipts and they get pissed off when they mess an order up ! don't go there unless you want a dirty table a dirty bathroom bad food and terrible customer service ! Gotchu guys read more

How have I never eaten here? They have a lengthy menu and we decided on a pizza. They have best I can describe it is Pizza King on steroids. It's the same style but has great quality ingredients and lots of them. We went for the Aiden's Big show which was delicious. They also have a great beer menu and I think a full bar. I love this place. Prices are reasonable and we will be back soon. read more

Arni's has excellent food and salads. Unfortunately, they are plagued with the same problem a lot of other restaurants have: Poor customer service. Its too bad. A lot of these places are blaming the economy for their failure. While it may play a small part, its definitely customer service that is causing the doors to close. read more

Arni's never disappoints. Always hot with the perfect amount of sauce. The staff is always extremely nice and welcoming.

Today, I did a carry out order. I went in the front door, however, there is a side door for all carry out orders. :) I was promptly waited on. The lunch special seemed the way to go. Arni's junior and 7" pizza. It cost $16.88 for the lunch special. The salad is always the same here. Which is great! Taste great every time. I really like how the cheese is super micro pieces! Yummy! They have the best blue cheese this side of Texas! It's so delicious! Speaking of Texas, they throw a piece of their delicious Texas Toast in a bag, too! The pizza here is also the same. Again, this is a good thing. Knowing what your going to get no matter what Arni's you go to is important to me. The sauce and micro pepperoni is what really makes Arni's pizza unique and super tasty! read more

Arni's - Pizza & Salad - 7" Pizza / Jr Salad - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Still probably the best tasting pizza in town Seriously downhill went in hour and a half before end of seating and music was off and service felt rushed Atmosphere was seriously grim. Food is delicious as always but my lettuce was soaked like it had been washed but not drained. I blame management Food was pretty good as always Would reccommend still going but getting takeout cuz the vibe is dreadful Really wanted desert but felt rushed and pushed out. We left well before the 9pm final seating read more

I have enjoyed an Arni's junior salad with thousand dressing and a 10" or 12" bbq pizza in Indianapolis and in Lafayette IN since 1977. I and my wife eat there when we are in town for a Purdue game or to see family. We have poor students and had to share a salad and pizza but now I am rich and can afford our own. I don't let her touch mine. Sounds Selfish but it is that good. read more

Arnis is a classic and a go to for my family. There is a little bit of everything for everyone! They are known for their pizza which is great but I love trying out different things on the menu as well. This time around we got the cheesy garlic bread appetizer per usual. I wanted to try the Ava rose chopped salad. First off it was huge! I had it for lunch and the rest for dinner. Which it lasts in the refrigerator and doesn't get all soggy (huge plus). My mom and brother got a cheese pizza for the table. Again great portions and easy to split among a few people! We love the thin and crispy crust that Arnis pizza has and they don't skimp on the cheese! All around classic good family spot for lunch or dinner! read more

Arni's - The Ava Rose Chop - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Great place for large family to gather. Reliability great food and excellent service.

Just got my shipment to Dallas Texas. Can't wait to try. Came with an Arni's pizza cutter. Excellent touch can I suggest a few Arni's napkins for us old folk. lol. read more

Arni's - Pizza cutter - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I want to give this restaurant an incomplete rating rather than three stars because I had a pizza I really didn't like much but I think the problem was more in my taste buds than with the pizza itself. I'm trying to discover what the best thin-crust (aka Tavern Style, depending on your preference) pizza place is in this area after having tried Monicals (which was EXCELLENT, please see my review on that place!). Arni's is around the corner from where I live so I came by on a not busy weeknight. Decent crowd but not noisy. Nice, big, homey feeling restaurant with terrific servers (Taylor was mine) and a host and manager who seemed to take a keen interest in whether I was doing well and enjoying my pizza. I ordered an iced tea and only one other thing - a pizza called Aiden's Big Show. It has Italian meatballs, pepperoni, onions, extra cheese, and garlic Parmesan cheese. I asked for black olives (love 'em) rather than onions (hate 'em). And you should also know the pizza is topped with marinara sauce. So the pizza was fine. I finished it, very filling. However, I was initially displeased that rather than having small-medium-large pizza options that included a12", instead their medium is a 10", and the next size up is an 16 or 18", I don't remember which I was told and for some reason the menu doesn't say (nor does it even say it's thin crust pizza, it doesn't mention crust options at all). All of this is no bueno. I don't know how tiny their small is, but I'd consider a 10" a small and if you have smaller than that, it's like a personal pizza you get at the ballpark. A 12" should absolutely be standard. A 10" is too small and an 18" is way too big. Anyway. The pizza was filling because of the marinara sauce, which really served to only do two things: 1) Make the pizza taste like spaghetti; 2) Soak the crust and basically make it useless/tasteless. I didn't think any of this was good. So when I come back, I'll order something different. Most folks would probably enjoy that pizza. I can tell you traditionalists who love real thin crust would have a stroke if they were handed a pizza like that. I guess it all depends on your, well, tastes. read more

They have hosted our group of classmates from high school every month. Everyone has been very pleased with the food and service.

We did takeout for the Super Bowl and the pizza was ready quick and perfectly made! I called ahead and it was ready in a timely manner. They have their takeout down! Our pizza was delicious. We did a large make your own and the toppings we chose were pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, and banana peppers. read more

Arni's - Make your own large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I ordered carry-out with pizza, wings, and 2 Sr Salads. When we got home we saw that the pizza and wings were fine. The salads, however, were disgusting. The lettuce was so rotten it was slimy. We aren't picky eaters but this was too much. I called in and the manager said she could give me a credit (NO THANKS) or a "partial refund". We'll see. Either way - we won't be having our dinner tonight. This is very disappointing. We've never had issues at Arnies - but this is the second time at this location. Won't be going back. read more

We tried Arni's for the first time with three teens in tow. We all loved it! The kids had burgers big enough to fill up these starving 16-year old boys. The three adults enjoyed the meatball sandwich, tenderloin sandwich, and chicken tenders. Appetizer loaded nachos were delicious. Our server was helpful and attentive and the food all came out hot and fairly quickly. All in all, an enjoyable meal. We'll definitely return. read more

It just keeps getting more and more sad. Food quality is there. Portions are ever shrinking. Prices are always rising. I would rather pay more for the same portions. Every other Arnis in the state embarrasses this location. read more

See all

My husband is originally from Lafayette, Indiana. Every time we come back to visit, we eat at Arni's. Yesterday, November 21, was his birthday. We were in town to visit family. All he wanted was for his family to eat dinner with us at Arni's. I'm sorry I don't know our waitresses name but she was wonderful! There were 13 of us. We never waited for anything. They got tables ready when we arrived. Everything was amazing! A great birthday and a great meal! read more

Arni's - Our party of 13 - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Had my birthday party there. Made a reservation in the bar and service was awful. When I spoke with the manager she lied to my face and said she had been back in the bar helping so bar tender could focus on us. Funny thing I had never seen her before. Food was good but service was horrible and Mgr was dishonest. Birthday party disappointment.. read more

I have always loved Arnis but I agree with others that something has changed. I have always gotten the chicken parm, but it is now $15! I saw they just did a menu refresh and the prices are higher than ever. This combined with the decline in quality has deterred me away from here for the foreseeable future. read more

We had a party of two that visited for dinner the other night. Neither of us had ever ate here, but have heard nothing but rants and rave about it. I can certainly tell you that those rants and raves were everything we expected. We ended up ordering the Mozzarella Sticks for an appetizer, and the 26 inch "Aiden's Big Show" Pizza. The Mozzarella Sticks were nothing special, and they were cold too. I'll give them the benefit of the doubt on that one, because it was a very busy Friday Night. As for the Pizza, it was absolutely phenomenal. I absolutely loved everything about it. Plus, it was different than any other Pizza I've eaten. It had textures and flavors of its own. It was packed with fresh meats, cheeses, and the sauce was very well seasoned. It was cooked to perfection; chewy on the inside and crispy on the edges. It was like a upgraded and improved version of Pizza King. The staff was very friendly, the ambience was beautiful, the facility and bathrooms were very clean, and the overall experience was flawless. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

I love coming here for the Arni's salad and pizza. I have had other items on the menu which have been but those two are my "go to's". The Arni's salad Is simple enough: iceberg lettuce, cubed ham and turkey, mozzarella cheese, and just a few green onions but it so good. Their pizzas are thin crust with toppings end to edge. The Arni's Junior compliments a size of pizza. Full bar and coke products, with drink specials. read more

Arni's - Arni's Jr. Salad - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pizza are good. Carmel skillet cookie is really good Chicken nachos no flavor Wings and voodoo pasta are just ok read more

See all

Wanted pizza for dinner on the 4th. We weren't celebrating but staying home with a very high strung terrier that hates fireworks. Went to Arni's online ordering. Ordered a pizza and a stromboli at about 6:55pm. Said it was going to be ready for pick up at 7:25pm. Google Map says they are 7 miles from us, it takes about 20 min to get there and get back. Once my husband got there he called me and told me they were closed. I said it let me place an order and I got an email back confirming it. I told him to head back home and I would figure out second choice for pizza. After placing an order online for a different pizza place and sending my husband there, I went in search of how to contact Arni's. I called and it rang and rang. I thought they might have voice mail but no. Went to their facebook page and saw that they had a post that "all" their locations would be closed for July 4th. And then it listed some places that would be open? I sent a Facebook Message with a screen shot of my order. I then went to Arni's web page where it didn't mention that they were closed. They have a contact us area and I sent all my info thru that too. I got a message back from Facebook "Sorry they closed at 6pm for the holiday. Someone would contact me about this. Sorry for the inconvenience". I got a voice mail today since I wasn't able to answer my phone when they called. "Sorry for the inconvenience. They forgot to turn off the online order system when they closed early and people were able to place orders. The credit card will be reversed". Sounds like I wasn't the only one. No offer of a pizza in return for a 30 to 40 min drive to the East Side. I just think that's really poor customer retention. I will say the second pizza place made us probably one of the best pizzas we've had in a while. read more

I hope to Arni's for the Arni's Jr salad with honey mustard salad dressing, period! I crave it, it is delicious, and I am sure it is not on any healthy eating list, but who cares. It comes with garlic bread and make sure you get that too. I am not a fan of their pizza, although they are known for it. If you like to drink, try the Long Island Iced Tea, it comes in a mega mug. read more

I called and ordered carry out on my way home for dinner. When I arrived I was greeted and was told to go to the bar area to pick up. I gave them my name and then said I had a Yelp check in offer, I had previously checked in and not used the offer. The person working the check out counter, Nick, asked for a manager to come over to help put in the coupon offer, $12 off a Large pizza. A woman manager came over and looked at the coupon on my phone and said "We don't do Yelp!" and just starred at me and then walked away. She was very unhelpful and rude. Another male manager was watching in the kitchen and came to help and offered a different coupon to make it right. I'm not sure how you can offer something and then claim you "Don't do yelp" when the offer was valid, there wasn't an expiration date. I love Arni's and I am from Lafayette/West Lafayette, so I've had it my entire life. The pizza is always good and the Arni's jr. salad is my favorite! I would suggest getting ranch and french dressing. The only reason I gave 3 stars is because of the woman manager, she just wasn't helpful and was not kind. Maybe she doesn't care for Yelp? It was awkward, but I'm so thankful for Nick and the male manager that were both helpful. read more