I have already reviewed their incredible pizzas with flying colors. Yesterday I was extremely happy with my choice to try the Tuesday special which was wonderful!! The steak pappardella pasta is a real delight. Broad flat egg noodles in a rich creamy sauce with mushrooms and topped with sliced medium steak. Bonus.....Tuesday is half priced wine! Topped it off with espresso martinis was another bonus. You will love it. Sam the owner is a great guy. read more

I Tre Mori - Steak pappardella - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Came here for lunch on a random Saturday and it was in fact a later lunch than the usual rush-hour. There was only one other family at the time having lunch and we were quickly seated The menu seems really diverse with lots of choices. However, the pasta choices are only rigatoni or spaghetti. From the pictures yes they really do have a pizza oven, which is fantastic The calamari was great, especially because it contained tentacles. However, at this price point, the plate was pathetically filled with barely anything. So they're charging high prices, trying to present themselves as a great place to be, and yet are feeding you less than the competitors out there. Our server was very nice, however did not know what tentacles were. Our server was slightly attentive but slow. The two pasta dishes we ordered were very disappointing. The sauce tasted like they came out of a jar and they were definitely not homemade or made from scratch in any way shape or form. The cheese is as well tasted like they came out of a bag and were not shaved or cut fresh. Unfortunately, I can even do the simple pasta better at home. Further, the alla Norma I was playing a game of trying to find the eggplant. My partner got the Bolognese and you could not find any meat in it whatsoever. It was very disappointing. By the time we left the place was packed, so maybe they are doing something right but frankly from three dishes, this was a huge disappointment and frankly a waste of money There are lots of other Italian places in the fishers and Carmel areas please go there. read more

See all

The service was great. Server was very friendly and attentive. We had a pizza, a pasta, and focaccia was huge AND delicious - a bit tricky to eat with all the toppings. The pizza and pasta are very good- IF you like a sweeter sauce - the sauces were very sweet! Would've liked the bolognese to have more meet. read more

See all

Wood fire pizza at its finest! Loved the outdoor seating, and our server was so pleasant. Also, who can pass up a good tiramisu, this was the perfect finish to a great pizza. read more

I Tre Mori - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We've ordered from I Tre More for years now, so it's about time I give them the stellar review they've earned. We've never been disappointed with their salads, pastas, pizzas or cannoli's we've enjoyed, whether it be via DoorDash or via their super convenient drive-thru pick-up window. We feel fortunate to have this restaurant so local to us and would definitely recommend it! read more

See all

I grabbed lunch with a friend and we both really enjoyed our meal! We started with the bruschetta, shared a salad and the Angelita pizza. For dessert we shared the mille-feuille. Overall, every thing was really delicious. Service was quick and friendly. I look forward to coming back and trying more items! read more

See all

What a delightful little eatery on the North side! Tre Mori is hiding in plain sight in an area I've driven past many times. It has a good location, but I seem to only drive by this way when there is traffic and I want to get home. Yet, on a lovely weekend where I was experiencing a bit of wanderlust, a new venue seemed like the perfect way to quell my desires. And Tre Mori fit the bill! Tre Mori boasts wood-oven pizza, pasta and a wine bar. No wonder the siren song was calling to this Italian! I chose to sit outside as one does when you are at the throes of restlessness. It was a gorgeous summer evening. The sun was about to set and the breeze tempered the summer temperatures to provide the perfect Sunday evening. Tre Mori seems like the perfect spot for a lazy Sunday (if you find yourself out of Mr. Pibb and Red Vines, that is! And if you get that reference, my hat is off to you!) But, for real, Tre Mori is crazy delicious! ;) This Italian is slightly embarrassed to admit that I've only recently been introduced to burrata earlier this year. Oh man, but since I've discovered it, there is no turning back. Chances are, if it's on the menu, I'm choosing it. And Tre Mori has it on the menu! The burrata was fabulous, served with prosciutto and a balsamic glaze on wonderfully crusty bread. I'm also a sucker for a good Margherita pizza and Tre Mori did not disappoint. The pizza was great, the burrata was fabulous and the red wine was flowing. Why have I not gone back to this surprising little pasta pizzeria? I will need to remedy this soon! read more

See all

Went for two pizzas, and we added an calamari appetizer to start. Good beer, wine and cocktail selection. Their gourmet pizza is rock solid. Calamari was excellent; the entire order was tender. Too bad it came out after the pizza. Otherwise, everything including the service was great. read more

I Tre Mori - Calamari, well what's left of it! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Amazing food and service highly recommended . Pizza and pastas are fresh and flavorful

We've had this place bookmarked for eons after seeing it make one of Yelp's top data lists for pizza. Good news - it lived up to the hype and wait! They were quite busy during our Sunday evening visit (note that they do not have reservations). After a ten minute wait and watching the pizza magic happen in their open concept kitchen, we were seated. We ordered one of their arugala-based salad (pears, gorgonzola, walnuts, etc.) to kick off the meal followed by the popular lasagna and mortadella pistachio ricotta pizza. It was a great mixture of textures and flavors for our family-style meal. We ordered on the lighter side to save room for dessert. The tartufo (chocolate truffle) and layered pastry/cream creation (I'm failing to remember the name and its not listed on their website - it was so good that we ordered another!). Both of these desserts are hard to find in Indy, so we couldn't pass them up. Overall, it was a positive and tasty experience from start to finish. Did I mention that they offer a drive-thru window for carryout orders? If we lived closer, I would be rolling through that window all the time... read more

This is our go to place when we have an event at Conner Prairie. The food is really good and served quickly if you are on a schedule. The menu is primarily made to order pizzas and pasta dishes. Save room for dessert, since there are several to choose from. read more

I Tre Mori - Spumoni Bomba - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Linnea was such a great and attentive server . She was friendly and knowledgeable and PATIENT! . We got our food incredibly fast and it was a busy evening ! there's outside and inside seating . Not a lot high chairs , so expect to wait for one if you have kids . I'm assuming they have only have like 2. The pizza was AMAZING. It truly did remind me of pizza we had in Rome and it was very affordable considering we got two pizzas and focaccia . We had a Margherita and one with mortadella and prosciutto . Amazing place ! read more

I Tre Mori - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Spectacular, from the moment we opened this quaint little Italian restaurant! We were greeted immediately with a smile and shown to our table. As a party of 7 we didn't think it would be so quickly. We ordered calamari& CROSTINI DI RICOTTA the fig chutney on the crostini was outstanding! We had the PAZZESCA and we should have ordered 2! I'm still thinking about it! We also tried the TRE MORI is was yummy it had crushed pistachios on top this was a nice touch. We also had their lasagna IT is a must! I had the cheese ravioli with butter sauce this was by far the best I have had. And of course you have to have dessert before you go we had tiramisu, MILLE-FEUILLE & the TARTUFO am not sure they had anything that was anything less than phenomenal and have me full and wanting a nap and to go back for dinner! read more

See all

Don't miss stopping in this place! You may have a slight wait on the weekend, but the food is worth it. The ambiance of this restaurant is cozy, authentic, and can be a bit on the loud side. However, that's only due to how many conversations are happening! This is a place you can come and eat, drink, and enjoy your company. I got the alla Norma which is always delicious. For dessert I couldn't leave without a cannoli. My husband had the pepperoni pizza and there was zero left! read more

I Tre Mori - Alla Norma - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Ordered takeout from I Tre Mori and everything was excellent! The checkout process was quick and the staff was pleasant and efficient. We got the Caesar salad, meatballs, and a pizza and all of it was delicious. The salad was fresh and crisp, the meatballs were flavorful and tender, and the sauce was rich and savory. The pizza came out hot and tasted just as good as it looked. Great spot for a quality Italian meal, even on the go! Will definitely be back. read more

See all

The service was good, seated at the bar inside. I ordered their namesake pizza -- the tre mori -- with mortadella and burrata. The crust was on point, but they made a fatal flaw...mortadella would typically be added to a pizza AFTER the pizza comes out of the oven, not before. It is not meant to be cooked, as it loses its flavor. The pizza was overall not as flavorful as it looked or comparable to other pizzas with these ingredients that I've ordered in other parts of the country. Would also be better with pistachio cream sauce instead of tomato sauce base. Will not order this pizza again if I ever come back to this place. read more

I Tre Mori - Meat Loverss Pizza (Prosciutto di Parma) - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Pizza was good however i don't know if was because I was by myself or what but the host tried to seat me in a dark corner table in the back of the bar by the kitchen door.. I asked if I could not be right by the kitchen door as it's heavy traffic (she moves me over one table, still is heavy traffic ) ok fine.. it was not busy yet, as I got there almost right at opening and had almost all but 1-2 tables taken in their main dining area. Server was friendly although I voiced my unhappiness with him and he said "I'm welcome to move" but did not move me , have a host move me or have a manager come to check on me. I would understand if it was busy to seat me in the bar but I did not ask read more

I Tre Mori - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I love the pizza here. I now know to stick to that. My shrimp pasta was good, but needed salt. Calamari was 3/10. We didn't eat hardly any of it, and it was never addressed by staff. read more

Great food, service and atmosphere today for a birthday lunch. Really good pizza, pasta, desserts. No complaints read more

See all

Food decent. Service good. Atmosphere not great. No Iced tea and only water as the option for no sugar no artificial sweetener drink. Soda in cans is a big no. Didn't like the table configuration. Too many high tops and not any tables that sat less than 6 people. Just thought that was strange. I liked the mid century vibe with the paint on the wall. Zero noise dampening no soft surfaces or acoustic tiles. So it was incredibly noisy. 4 slices of bread should be a free app. It was nothing special. If it is homemade it didn't taste like it was made in-house. 4 Fromage sauce was good with the pasta. Lasagna didn't have much flavor. No small Caesar salad so husband and I split a large salad. I thought the best part was the Mille-feuille. Nothing to bring us back and we love Italian food. read more

See all

I really loved this experience! We came here after a basketball game so we were dressed casually and we were glad we fit into the casual ambience. The food portions were not too large and I feel were very reasonable for the cost. Everything had wonderful taste and from the owner/manager to the servers, everyone was kind and efficient read more

Wife and I decided to do an impromptu dinner night here and we were not disappointed at all. Infact this is one of the best Italian spots we've had in the city, especially for the cost. We got a few apps, a pizza and a few pasta dishes and everything was incredibly good. The lasagna was out of the world and for the most part the spaghetti and meatballs were too, the meatballs were just a little dry. Trust me though, you wanna try this authentic Italian spot. Service was on point and the ambience was alright! Our back bar room needs to be updated a bit! Over all.. we will DEFINITELY be back! read more

My husband and I just got back from Italy and were really hoping this would compare to the Napoli or Sicilian pizza we ate while we were there. I would rate the pizza a 6/10 and the cannolis a 5/10. Service was slow to start. We also noticed a server who was irritated and obvious about it with his coworkers and a party he was serving (we sat near the kitchen). Coming from a restaurant background, I'm surprised his attitude wasn't put in check by a manager. It was contagious and quite frankly, rude. The restaurant overall was clean. We took our three year old and they did not have kid cups - which is fine, just something I wish we would've known in advance. Glass with a toddler is a roll of the dice. We may go back, but weren't won over like we had hoped. My in-laws got lasagna and ragu and it looked delicious. Should we go back, pasta will be what we have instead! read more

We went here cuz we received a gift card. It was good. I got the fettuccine sauce pasta with fillet & hubby got the meat lovers pizza. It was all good. read more

I Tre Mori - The meat lover's. Only 3 meat. I thought meat lover's would be more than 3 toppings. Good flavor tho. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

What a gem! I Tre Mori is some of the best woodfired pizza I've had the pleasure of eating in central Indiana. The crust is chewy yet crispy with a slightly char-dusted bottom. They use San Marzano tomatoes for their sauce. They have a cozy, intimate bar area set off to the side just for adults. They have a magnificent wine menu. It's the perfect place for people who like good food and drink. Their thing here is woodfired pizza, so I didn't even think to order anything else. But they also offer pasta and salads. For the pizza, there are a number of toppings to choose from if you wanted to make your own pizza, but I suggest you order one of the specialty pizzas they offer. We ordered one Pizza Quattro Formaggi (mozzarella, mascarpone, asiago, gorgonzola, red sauce) and one Pizza Tre Mori (mozzarella, mortadella, ricotta cheese, granulated paw pistachio, red sauce). I fell in love with the Tre Mori -- and I was surprised because I ordered it on a whim and because I wasn't sure if I was going to like pizza with what's essentially boloney on it. But I loved it, and it's my favorite pizza now. We also loved the quattro formaggi -- it was cheesy but not overly so, and had a nice pull. One pizza was not have been enough for a family of four, so we ordered two, and we had leftovers to take home. Like any woodfired pizza reheated, it doesn't taste as good once you're back at home. For the same reason, I suggest you dine in, and don't order to go. For all you lookie-loos like me: The pizza oven is right in the middle of the restaurant, so you can see them slide the pizzas in and out while you wait. It's pretty neat. read more

Food was good and a little different from other Italian restaurants. Had pasta and not pizza which is their calling card. Will go back to try. Had an issue with spiciness of a dish and owner personally replaced. Was wonderful once replaced and greatly appreciated owner's concern read more

Ordered on DoorDash as my coworkers raved about this place. Now it's my turn to rave the crust is perfect- slightly charred with a great texture. They have unique pizza as well. Do yourself a favor and go here! It is life changing-may be dramatic but it's true! read more

Ordered delivery and had the Bresaola and Tiramisu, highly recommend both! Would love to stop in one of these days.

Excellent food and customer service as always! This is some of the best pizza that I've ever had! We got the Bianca cheesy bread with garlic added to it, the meat lovers pizza, the Pizza Piccantissima, and the meat ravioli. Everything was delicious! read more

See all

Loved the ambiance. It was busy. Loud. Lively. Love how the bar is separate. Service was great especially given the crowds. My daughter loved her lemon martini. The calamari was near perfection. Crispy fried but tender. Wish sauce had a little more kick but it's the pizza sauce. The Tre Mori pizza is different, I could pick up the pistachio. Sausage pizza was good if you didn't want much sausage. I love the thin, crispy, "charcoaly" crust. read more

I Tre Mori - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Saturday night visit. Sat outside, Quick service. Great pizza. Parking was a bit tough

I've been seeing so many great reviews on Yelp, and the photos of the pizza looked amazing! My husband and I finally were able to have a date night and try this place. When we walked in, we were a bit confused. There is no sign or host stand. We stood around for a while, then were finally greeted and taken to a table. Eventually someone brought us water and we again sat around for a while. A server finally approached us and asked if we were ready to order which was odd as we were never given menus. They had tons of employees just standing around talking, not helping customers or working. We ordered the Bianca Cheesy bread which was cheese stiffed pizza dough. They had so many unique pizza toppings and options. We ended up picking the Pizza Delicata which was delicious!! I think next time I'd like to try one of the more traditional pizza offerings. Overall, the service was terrible, the restaurant was very disorganized and employees seem to not care about customers. Hopefully it was just a bad night, as the pizza was excellent. read more

I Tre Mori - Bianca(cheese bread) - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We ordered to-go, so we can't say much on the ambience. The guy at the window was nice enough. Order was ready on time. We ordered a margarita pizza and 2 orders of bruschetta. Bruschetta was delicious, bread was great too. Everything tasted very homemade. The pizza was delish - we will definitely order again. read more

I Tre Mori - Someone couldn't wait for the phone to eat first - margarita pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We came in because we have been wanting to try this place since we drove by and saw it a few weeks ago. It's definitely off the beaten path, but not to be mistaken for a hole in the wall. We were greeted pretty quickly and asked to sit anywhere which was nice. The service got really slow after receiving water and menus. It took nearly 20 minutes for anyone to come back for us to place our order (it wasn't busy at all with it being between lunch and dinner time). I opted to try a new pizza and my love chose the pepperoni. Mine was pretty good, but nothing to write home about. My love's pepperoni was a bit disappointing because the quality of the pepperoni didn't quite seem to match the higher quality of the pizza dough and cheese. I hope they decide to try a better pepperoni in the future. Our Caesar salad on the other hand was actually quite delicious. We were both quite impressed with it and delighted to eat it. To note, I had eaten a Caesar salad a few days prior at a really bougie restaurant in Indy and this Caesar was much better. Well done there! The space is open and brightly lit with natural light coming in from their large windows. The interior is nice as well. Over all it was good. We'll be back to give their pasta a try soon. Thank you! read more

See all

Popped into I Tre Mori during our stay in the Indianapolis area. We were initially concerned about the lack of restaurants within walking distance of our hotel. Our concerns were quashed when we stumbled across I Tre Mori. The restaurant is a blend of fast casual and table service with great food. The Duchess had a prosecco while I quaffed a Stella and shared a delicious pizza. Bellissimo! read more

I Tre Mori - The Duchess approves! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is my favorite place to get pizza in Indy! I've eaten here several times over the past year, and I've enjoyed the food here every single time. The pizza never disappoints whether I eat in the restaurant or get carry out. I also love that they have a drive-thru. However, I highly recommend eating inside so you can enjoy the smells of freshly baked pizza and eat it while it's hot. If you're not craving pizza, they also have pasta, salads, and dessert. Their focaccia was alright since it tasted and looked like the crust of their pizza. The gelato was also okay since the texture of it was more like sorbet. Sometimes it's confusing on how to order since usually you have to go up to the tablet, but last time someone came to our table to get our order. The workers are nice, but usually no one checks on us once we have our food and we have to ask someone for more water. Otherwise, I love this place and so glad Indy has this delicious Italian restaurant! read more

See all

The food was excellent. I especially loved the cheesy garlic bread which was basically two thin layers of pizza crust and melted chees inside. But the taste was special and uniquely great. We ate outside. It is shaded in afternoon which made hot temps outside bearable. read more

Not bad but not great. I got the veggie pizza and it was slightly soggy and undercooked. My son got the spicy pasty, which was closer to Hot Ones level of spice than just a little red pepper. My friend got the eggplant pasta and it was fairly ok. The staff all seemed brand new and a little confused. They couldn't find a drink menu and rotated in and out from our table, making it hard to know which one was our waiter. I think with some work and polish, though, this place might become a real winner, read more

I Tre Mori - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My friends and I visited I Tre Mori on a Tuesday night. We opted to dine inside but patio seating is available. As soon as you walk in the restaurant, you smell the aroma of the Wood Oven! We were quickly greeted and instructed to pick a table of our choosing; a mix of high top and regular height tables. There is also a 21+ area. The menu is plentiful with options from pasta to salad to Italian Neapolitan Pizzas. I chose the Pizza Primavera. It was amazing! Very good flavors and the pizza was cooked beautifully. Not a huge fan of canned soda and would prefer a fountain drink. I also sampled a cannoli and got a tiramisu to go. Both were sweet with balanced flavors! The staff was pleasant and checked on us often. I will certainly be back! read more

See all

The restaurant is a really nice vibe. Smaller than I had expected but there is also a separate 21+ section which is nice. We ordered a pasta dish and a pizza to share. We were split on which dish was better. I, personally, enjoyed the pizza more. The crust was nice and crispy and the toppings were great. I appreciated that they had a whole section of vegetarian pizza on the menu. The pasta was spicier than I'd expected and cooked al dente. The service was interesting as you do have to go to the counter to place your order but they bring you the food, water, etc. to your table. The food came out very quickly. read more

I Tre Mori - Arrabbiata Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all