I was interested in trying this pizza, salad bar, and drink buffet but did not like the $13 cost as I could buy a whole 11" unlimited toppings pizza cheaper at Blaze Pizza. My co-workers were headed there so I joined them. This gave me another opportunity to write a review. I did not remember how to get there with the new road. I parked on the north side by the reservoir with a fountain. There was a giant landscaping truck who was hindering my ability to park and wanted to idle in the middle of the street. The restaurant is spacious and divided. There are 2 close pizza buffet stations. Salad bar is further away. Drink station at a third wall. I would have really liked the cheese sauce with breadstick, but they keep looking uncooked. I got a slice of cheese pizza and 2 slices of BBQ chicken pizza and of delicious dessert pizza. I ate a salad but could not recognize a salad dressing I would like. I should not kept drinking my Cherry Coke. I tried to get my $13 worth. Unfortunately, this location does not have a frequent eaters program like the Geist location, and they would not honor and association of a program. My co-workers who go there weekly would like such a program and could probably get more co-workers to join them regularly. I do not think I would go again. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Round 1 - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Went today for lunch and did the buffet which includes pizza,salad, breadsticks and a drink. I'm not a buffet person but this was really good. I loved the salad bar they kept the ingredients full and they were nice and cold and plenty of options. The breadsticks are skinny but they remind me of hotbox with a little salt and the cheese has a great flavor. My husband loves the deep dish so he really enjoyed it. Let me talk about the star of the show. The dessert pizza is amazing!!! I'm still thinking about it 8 hours later. Just FYI this place is busy at lunch! There's no one at the hostess stand it's just find a table. Worst part is they struggled cleaning up the tables because of the fast turnover and the many plates. We never once had anyone come to our table so if you want something off the menu you need to go to the cashier. read more

See all

I ordered two cauliflower crust pizzas and a salad to go. $48. The toppings on the pizza were extremely sparse. Very disappointing. You'd think for that kind of money, they load it up. read more

My family and I had dinner here Friday night. It was our first time here. Having lived in the Chicago area for almost 50 years, I am always intrigued by restaurants describing themselves as "Chicago's pizza." The pizza here is good (more on that below), but is it truly Chicago's pizza? The answer is yes and no. The thin and crispy pizza here IS a Chicago-style thin crust pizza. But, the "deep dish" pizza here is NOT Chicago style deep dish pizza. That being said, we thought the thin and crispy pizza was delicious! The "deep dish" pizza reminded us of Chuckie Cheese's pan pizza. It was a decent pan pizza but we didn't enjoy it as much as the other one. One other comment...true Chicago style Italian Sausage is irregular in size and appears hand rolled. The sausage here reminds me of Totinos pizza...tiny in size. The pepperoni bread sticks were good and my wife enjoyed the salad bar. Service was average. 3 1/2 stars. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - "Deep dish" sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

The pizza is delicious. My kid loves the garlic cheese pizza. We have never had a bad experience. Wish they were open on Sundays but other than that they are great! read more

Our go to pizza place! The deep dish is excellent, as well is the thin crust. We also love the breadsticks! We never eat in -- always get takeout but it's massive inside and would be perfect for an after sports game meal with teammates for kids. read more

Bad was the salad area was a mess and had not been cleaned good was the pizza and breadsticks were delicious

It's a nice Chicago pizza franchise in Noblesville. It's located near Walmart and in a small shopping comes with ample of parking spots in front and side of the pizza store. The restaurant has a pretty big seating area and clean space. Our server was sweet and very helpful we ordered a side of breadsticks, garlic bread. The garlic bread was a little salty for our taste and the breadstick were a little uncooked so we asked them to replace them and our server replaced those. We also ordered chicken and veggie pizza which were cooked to perfection. I recommend this place for nice dinner with family and friends. read more

See all

Great pizza and salad bar for lunch!! Amazing team member at the front who takes our order every week --- she is great!! Pizza is fresh and hot, they open the second window if the crowd is there and the salad bar is very good and fresh. Sometimes they have a hard time keeping up but all the team members are working hard to make sure the guest experience is good or great!! Excellent lunch spot!! read more

Always good, always fast! Love to order from here for carry out when we just need a pizza fix!

It's a awesome good place to eat in person or takeout staff is nice and polite...yes the workers are young but they have been trained well.. they know what they are doing read more

My family dined at Chicago's Pizza recently. This was our first time visiting. I don't know why it took so long to try this place, but we will definitely be back. Giselle went above and beyond to make sure we had a great experience. If you have not tried Chicago's Pizza, I highly recommend you stop by. read more

I've been wanting to try this place for a while, been looking for a good pizza place. Might have finally found a decent place. Got a thin crust Pepperoni and a traditional crust Skyline. The flavors are good, wish there were more toppings on the Skyline though. Second trip here got traditional crust Magnificent Mile and Pepperoni Sticks. The Magnificent Mile is great, good flavors and more toppings than the Skyline. The Pepperoni Sticks are yummy. They're smaller than I expected but pack a punch in flavor. I'll definitely be ordering from here more often. read more

See all

I absolutely love Chicago's. I don't go for deep dish; I go to Chicago for that - but the thin crust sausage is absolutely phenomenal. I don't have much to say other than the taste is awesome, there seems to be less sauce on the thin crust which I absolutely love, and it's always a pleasure to go inside and interact with staff. Few cons: it's a bit pricey and just a little far out of my way, but I think it's great for an occasional treat. It's better most of of the chains I'm always disappointed by. Solid 5. read more

We had lunch here today and everything was decent. We did the buffet that has a salad bar with it. I do wish they offered honey mustard and also tomatoes sliced up better than sandwich slices. It seemed to take a long time to get more pizza to the buffet line which was disappointing. It seemed to me like they were trying to govern what everyone ate by not having much on the buffet line. I requested a chicken bacon ranch be added which is my favorite but by the time they got it up there I had eaten a plate of salad, 2 pieces of pizza and a couple breadsticks which I love. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Bread my favorite and I love the cheese sauce - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

You can tell the ingredients are pretty healthy but the pizza was cold when we got it. Wasn't the greatest tasting pizza but wasn't bad. Breadsticks only came with 3 lol. That's a first. read more

There are a lot of places you can get pizza from, but when I tell you Chicago's is by far the BEST! It's by far the best. I absolutely love their pizza sauce and all the ingredients are fresh and they don't skimp on the toppings either. I personally like eating in because they have the best salad bar. Again everything is fresh and a good selection of veggies. They have a one trip option and it's perfect to go along with the piping hot pizza they bring out. If your craving a good pizza, this is the place. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Wanted pizza but didn't want to pay a bundle. I also just wanted a comforting slice of cheese on baked dough. With olives and mushrooms and spinach scattered atop. Well, I got what I was expecting! Their pizza crust is great. It's fresh tasting, has a good fluff, yet chew. Kinda reminded me of papa johns crust, but better. The cheese was not too salty and not too generous. The balance of toppings was perfect. Overall, a place I'd order from again. Oh, and the accuracy of the orders are spot on and so is the ease of picking up your order. read more

We've ordered take out on their pizza before but have never gone into eat. Well we did it and don't regret it. They are much more than just pizza (which I think is one of the better ones in Fishers). Beer menu is small, but the glasses are not. Cold cold mugs. It's a nice touch. My wife decided on the baked spaghetti and meatballs, while I went with the Buffalo chicken sandwich. We had our youngest with us, so he got the kids pizza and breadsticks. (FYI, all my kids rave about their breadsticks). All in all, it was awesome. The bread for the sandwich is unmatched in the immediate area. We did notice people getting the salad bar, and it looked worth every penny. Waitstaff was great and from time to order, to time to table was awesome. read more

See all

This place is AWESOME! I've never been to the location, but order through UberEats a lot. They read through "added notes" and actually care how I'd like my order. All who work here, your manager must be awesome. You guys really are great and the pizza is phenomenal. You never skimp and always make it an experience for the delivery folks too. The owners of this joint truly know how to run a customer-centered business. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - a plate of salad and a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Honestly really good! It was very slow and quiet when we went, service was surprisingly just okay for how slow they were. But the food was good and the prices were not bad! read more

We love Chicago's pizza. It has become a regular thing for us. MDH is from Chicago and is very picky about his pizza. He likes thin crust, cut in squares and with real Italian sausage. I like real mushrooms, not just out of a can. Yummy, consistent pizza. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Pizza cut the correct way. - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The lunch buffet is OK and it is convenient. Is it worth the $13? That's debatable. But it was food. I can usually eat half a pizza. Here I could only bring myself to do a couple slices and a small iceberg lettuce salad. Like I said, it was food. It has its place when you're hungry and in a hurry. read more

Old school! It brought back memories of hanging out with friends when I was younger. Smells, music and atmosphere. Spectacular. The pizza was just as I remembered and delicious. Salad bar on point. Really happy the wife and I stopped last minute. read more

This is one of my go to spots for pizza. Earlier this week when I didn't feel like cooking, I decided upon Chicago's Pizza once again. I LOVE their thin crust pizza, it's the BEST. This go around I opted for a small pizza with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and banana peppers. I must say that I have never been into their actual establishment, considering it is only a stones throw away from where I live, and I'm a big "just order online" and have it delivered type of gal. I will admit I was a little bummed (no fault of Chicago's Pizza) but when I got my pizza I realized it wasn't my usual thin crust that I get, it was traditional which actually wasn't too bad. I always get their pepperoni stuffed breadsticks as well with a side of cheese sauce and marinara. Their pepperoni breadsticks aren't the same as what I'm use to getting at another well known place that is known for their pepperoni breadsticks and shall remain nameless. They are starting to grow on me though. If you are a pepperoni fan, you'll love these. Instead of rolling the pepperoni slices inside the dough, they actually chop them up, which in all actuality you're getting more or at least it seems that way. I would have given 5 stars, but the breadsticks were just a tad bit too greasy. Overall my pizza and breadsticks where good, and they both heat up well the day after. I'm looking forward to trying other items on their menu along with visiting their establishment in person. Definitely if you're a fan of good thin crust pizza, I definitely and highly suggest Chicago's Pizza...!!! read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Pepperoni stuffed breadsticks w/ cheese sauce and marinara sauce - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I've visited here twice for the lunch buffet. The price is $11. It seems slightly high, but does include a drink. Their regular pizza is higher priced than other places so it makes sense. The salad bar has a lot of options. The pizza selection depends on how busy it is. If it's not busy there isn't a lot of selection and it sits for awhile. It also includes breadsticks and sauces. read more

Ordered carry out. Menu says hot ham and cheese sandwich with Italian dressing. Get home, no dressing on sandwich, just ham and cheese. Definitely not worth the $10. read more

This is our go-to for pizza. We love the thin and crispy crust skyline pizza with an order of breadsticks.

I ordered Chicago pizzas covid to try something new and wowzer ...did it exceed everything. Delicious pizza! Delicious ! And these like pepperoni stuffed breadsticks amazing ! Everything was so good--now that things have opened back up I'd really like to go get more pizza haha. read more

This is new restaurant in town. Watch games with beer and pizza. You get here some of the best Chicago style deep dish pizza. Chicago Fire is my favorite speciality pizza. Located in fast developing area of Fishers bordering Noblesville with lot of parking. Seating is comfortable and spacious. Service seems pretty good. read more

See all

My absolute favorite pizza! So delicious. I live out of town, and this is my #1 stop whenever I come back home to visit.

First off...don't get hung up on the name. There's not a whole lot about this place that makes you think of Chicago or Chicago style pizza. But once you get past that, this place is great! It's an awesome little pizza joint with a bit of an old school feel that reminds me of growing up and hanging out with friends at the local pizza hot spots. Outside of a Friday night, my preference is really to go to Chicago's during the weekday lunch hour. Their pizza buffet is everything you want it to be. The salad bar is a great way to start the meal (nothing spectacular but really solid). The breadsticks and pizzas are constantly coming out fresh with many different toppings combos. The pizza itself doesn't quite rival some of the best places around but it's much better than any of the cheap chain pizza buffets. Once you've finished the salad and main course, be sure to grab a slice (or four) of their dessert pizza! read more

Little tucked away off the 37 is this local eatery. The pizza was not spectacular but good to eat. We had the hand tossed magnificent mile. The crust was crunchy on the edge but easily chewed. They loaded it well with the ingredients. I would have preferred a little more sauce. The service was likable. Ensured we were taken care of. Will go back if I want some pizza. Oh a fairly priced. read more

This was my first time going here and it did not disappoint. The pizza was absolutely delicious! I got the Chicago Fire with a traditional crust. I also went to the salad bar. I will definitely be going back. Service was great. I love their outdoor area -- there is a nice breeze that comes through the windows and even though a thunderstorm started while we were there, we were able to easily close the garage door windows they have so we didn't get soaked! Happy customer! read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Chicago Fire, Traditional Crust, Small - Pizza Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I was in Indianapolis for the NCAA tournament games last weekend and came upon this pleasant surprise. I've been told that it's just normal pizza, but I was very impressed. Enjoyed the crust and the sauce. Only let down, was the pizza breadsticks. A little dry for my taste. Maybe a little garlic butter on the outside of them. I don't know, but it was the only thing that didn't shine. Our server was excellent. Unfortunately, my age will show here, I've forgotten her name but she was awesome! Good luck to her at the University of Cincinnati. Overall, an excellent experience, I will be back the next time that I am in Indianapolis. read more

We love Chicago's Pizza. They have a lunch buffet on the weekdays that we often attend for a quick lunch. Their pizza is excellent, and their salad bar is robust, especially for no place really having salad bars anymore. And the ranch is very good. read more

First time here. Not busy. Super nice people. Order was on time but incorrect. pricing wasn't bad. Frankly, not a great pizza; mall level at best. Minced toppings - not many though. Crust wasn't bad. Sauce was okay - not bad but not great. Certainly far below Chicago level pizza - but okay in a pinch. I likely won't return. I am so ready to give a glowing review to some pizza place in Fishers, but so far we're pretty much a pizza desert. This place wasn't a revelation, but more of just another average strip mall joint. Oh well, the search for pepperoni nirvana continues In Fishers. read more

Pizza was wonderful! We ordered half cheese and half pepperoni deep dish. Best pizza we've had in a long time! Breadsticks were fresh and hot and I love they don't have garlic on them. We had delivery and it was great! Thanks so much! read more

Went for the pizza buffet for lunch. The dining room was full but there was only one pizza on the bar for about 30 minutes. It looked like they had more to go pizzas being made than the buffet. Possibly poor timing or wasn't prepared for a Friday lunch crowd. Either way $10.99 for 2 slices and a Pepsi wasn't much of a deal. read more

The pizza was excellent. We had the skyline pizza that included plenty of cheese. The sauce is not overwhelming and the crust held up well. We also had the pepperoni breadsticks, they have a bit of a sweet flavor. Food was on time and the staff is very polite. We will be going back for sure. read more