Best sandwich I've had in a long time... The Italian. Made perfectly with every ingredient I requested. Thank you read more

Sandwich shop with a wide variety of options including wraps, hot and cold sandwiches, chips, salads, soups, soft drinks, cookies, and shakes. I decided to go with the Pick Your Pair and ordered a skinny Sweet Heat Pork BBQ sandwich along with the Farmhouse salad. The pulled pork had good flavor overall, but it didn't have any heat and the sandwich itself was a little on the dry side lacking barbecue sauce. The Farmhouse salad, however, was packed with flavor and loaded with grilled chicken, crumbled blue cheese, hard-boiled eggs, bacon, cucumber, and tomatoes on a bed of fresh greens. To wash it all down, I treated myself to a cold brew shake, which had great coffee flavor. read more

Potbelly - Farmhouse Salad with grilled chicken and a cold brew shake. - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Wanted to switch up my normal sandwich shop so I decided to stop at Potbelly this afternoon. They had a small line but still had me in and out quickly. My sandwich was hot and delicious. I'll be back . read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Get double meat ! Trust me. Expensive but delicious. The wreck is the go to for us

First timer at a Potbelly. First, parking is atrocious. There are not enough spaces to support the businesses in the strip mall. We had to wait for a space to open. Ordering sandwich and soup was fairly straightforward. Sandwich was up fairly quickly, but it seemed to take forever to get through the register to pay. When we sat down, we realized that we were overcharged, so had to wait through the line again to fix the bill. The tables were all dirty. I had to wipe one off to use. We never saw tables cleaned while we were there. What a hot mess. For the food, my husband ordered the Wreck, which had a single slice each of salami, turkey, roast beef and ham that were so thin, you could see through them. The toppings were generous and the bread was good. The sandwich was good despite the thinly sliced meat. I had a bowl of the broccoli cheese soup. The soup was thick and creamy. Kid's eat free on weekends, which is a good deal. They cater and push use of their app for ordering and special deals. I probably won't add this to my regular sandwich lineup as there are lots of sub shops in the area with clean tables that can get the bills right the first time. read more

See all

If you have 45min this is your 'quick' sandwich spot. All the employees were super stoned like time had stood still. Go somewhere else

I ordered a variety of vinegars and condiments on my sandwich but somehow it still came out dry. Plus the pricing is way too high for what you get, you can easily find better quality sub meals elsewhere for less, even when factoring in a side drink and chips. To top it off, they gave me the wrong cookie order. The pickle was the only decent part of the meal. read more

Very slow and late pick up orders. Waited for 20 mins for a pick up order. She told me it would be done and then continued to help everyone else purposely making me wait. She refused to turn around and bag up one sandwich and one soup. This went on for close to a half hour. When I asked her what was going on she laughed. I watched about 20-30 people be helped and she refused to make the carry out orders. read more

I've seen this place for years but really had no idea what it was. There is one downtown and the one I stopped in is in Carmel. Someone recommended it saying they have really good sandwiches, and indicated it's like Penn Station. Well I LOVE Penn Station and I was close by so decided to stop in. First off, it's NOT like Penn Station. Sure they serve sandwiches but that's really the inky comparison there is. They have several sandwiches to choose from (not a Philly steak) they don't do fries and they have soups and salads to choose from. I ordered a Chicken Pot Pie Soup and it was very good. Very filling, comforting and the perfect amount on a cold day. I ordered the bowl and it was plenty. This location is very clean no dirty tables, no overflowing trash cans very clean and well taken care of. Everyone was nice, not overly but pleasant. It was pretty quiet in there but I did go maybe an hour before closing. Good experience and if you like chicken pot pies I really recommend you stop in and try it! read more

See all

Sandwiches were awesome, friendly staff, very clean. Wish there was one closer. Will be back when we get back up that way.

I cannot speak to any other food at Potbelly. But today I split the ice cream cookie sandwich with a friend because it was so huge. No, we did not share the same handheld delicacy. Rather, large top and bottom cookies were chosen, then the ice cream was split into two small bowls. It was the perfect amount, my sweet tooth was more than satisfied, the team member granted every request, and two people were made very happy for under $4! #Getlostindiana read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

We were greeted as we entered this sandwich shop. I was craving soup and a salad and was happy to see that I could have both options. I opted for the apple walnut salad and cup of veggie soup and my husband got The Wreck skinny wrap and a strawberry shake. Everyone was very friendly and it wasn't very loud so we were able to have conversations without yelling, which is nice. Our food was ready right away and they brought the milkshake to our table. They even offered to pour it into two cups if we planned to share it, however, I was opting to stay healthy. My husband looked like he started to be healthy with his skinny wrap and then last second asked for a milkshake which cancelled out his healthy choice... clean. The salad was great and the veggie soup hit the spot! My husband devoured his wrap and milkshake so I'm guessing they were good as well! We will be back. read more

See all

I LOVEEE potbelly's. Every time it is made quick and fresh. Their cookies are melt in your mouth

I love the chicken pot pie soup! The crumbled pie topping that comes with it makes the soup better - i can eat this everyday too! I like it just how it is with no addl toppings. My husband loves the hot sandwich (any). My son loves the broccoli cheddar soup, the mac and cheese and the chocolate chip cookie. Definitely a family friendly place! read more

The food is always good and on time for Mobile apps I have placed. The orders that have been wrongly made (rare) were immediately refunded and I was given an apology, which doesn't happen often anymore. I don't expect perfection but I respect an apology when order is done wrong and they deliver on that so I return if that happens. Restaurant is always clean. read more

Did a mobile order. Got there at the time we indicated. It was not there. Waited 15 minutes and asked the cashier. He pulled it out from the counter behind the cash register. He said the stand that says Mobile Order is for door dash. Mobile orders are behind the counter. My husband said he had been waiting by the mobile orders for 15 minutes. He said, "yeah, maybe we should change the sign". They guy did not apologize. This isn't a staff shortage, this is a staff that couldn't even care less. Kindness & empathy in a service industry . That's all that was needed. Fast forward: We got home and realize they forgot a cookie and then we saw the receipt saying "sorry we are out!" Of that cookie. They Could have told us when we were there (hindsight: this is probably why the order was behind the cash register - because we saw a friend walk in and pick up his order which on the mobile Order shelf...) (see picture of receipt) Then my salad had wilted soggy greens () (see picture) And then, 2 out of 3 sandwiches had meatballs in it - we ordered no meatballs (see picture). We called, the manager and they offered a refund and mailing gift cards. We declined the gift cards and asked for a full refund. And for the refund, I give them one star. Now time to order dinner from some other place. This location has let us down almost every time. My favorite place to eat at growing up in Chicago is dead in Carmel. read more

See all

Potbelly is a top two local sandwich shop for me. They get a 5 for my sandwich and a 1-2 for service. Not sure why, but you can never order via app at this location anymore. I've tried many a times and it always says it isn't available. The majority of the staff always seems annoyed that you come in. Yesterday I actually got a lecture by a young employee on "how to make their life easier". So if you want to get a good sandwich-you'll probably get one. You just may get it with a side of attitude (hence why I wish I could order via app). read more

Potbelly - App-can't order in Carmel - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Great food great service. People were friendly and the restaurant was clean and organized

Order a few sandwiches from here to go. The app made ordering a breeze, we were impressed by the quality of the sandwiches, overall they were pretty good. This was on the expensive side for a fast food restaurant. read more

Great food and service. In and out quick with everything tasting right. Watched 20 people roll through efficiently while I sat and enjoyed my sandwich. read more

Potbelly - A Wreck - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Ordered delivery via DoorDash - working late so I didn't feel like cooking. I order my food around 8:50pm, I get my food almost around 10:30pm. Now I know that's not potbelly's issue, even though my food was cold. I found this piece of plastic in my chili and my sandwich was dry and burnt. Don't think I'll return. read more

See all

I work at the hospital across the street and didn't have time to take a long lunch break so decided to order mac and cheese for pick up. I appreciated it being wrapped in tin foil to keep warm while sitting on the shelf. However once I got back to eat I was disappointed to see half my bowl was empty. The other times I've gone here they've either forgotten my chips or napkins/utensils in my bag. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Incredibly rude staff. Received the incorrect order. Did not ask for a replacement as we were turned off by the rude waitress.

We were wondering around monument circle in Indianapolis the other day and we stumbled upon this deli / sandwich shop downtown. We enjoyed a wonderful lunch of soup and sandwiches. The sandwiches were phenominal very hardy with lots of meat and fresh vegetables the soup was hearty and seemed homemade, I had some Voodoo kettle chips for the first time (very delicious). We enjoyed visiting with the staff, wonderful girls dedicated, friendly, and professional for young adult girls totally impressed with this couple of teenagers, my teenage boy was quute smitten with them as well. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

I've ordered from here twice, and both times the sandwich was great! Can't remember the name of the items, but they both were great! Ordered one with turkey and beef... read more

For me, Potbelly's is all about nostalgia. As a Hoosier, I only was introduced to Potbelly's when visiting my cousins in Milwaukee: I had never been to a place that, by default, toasted sandwiches: Subway was our go-to, and, well, it was reserved for road trips only. When I went to Potbelly's the first time, I discovered mushroom-forward sandwiches. First, it was the vegetarian sandwich: the standard. Always accompanied by an Oreo shake or smoothie (this was younger me, the version could afford the calories and the sugar). Then, I came across the mushroom melt: less bread that actually helped you TASTE the cheese better, as well as better overall veggie-to-bread ratios. A much more reasonable calorie count as well. Potbelly's also carries some great, kettled-cooked potato chips that come in a variety of flavors like jalapeno. If you want a change from your usual sandwich joint, give Potbelly's a try. You won't regret it. read more

See all

What a pleasant surprise! Much better than the typical simple sandwich and over-salted pre-packaged soups. Needed a late night spot and this one is open late! Staff very friendly. Clean restaurant. Yummy tuna sandwich with variety of toppings (must get their hot pepper mix - yummy and quite mild) and broccoli cheddar soup. Large selection of bottled and fountain drinks. Quick, well-priced, clean! Convenient. Will make it a regular option...might even try one of their tasty-looking shakes next time read more

The food is good enough. However their online ordering service seems to be offline 90% of the time, for no reason given. other Potbelly locations in the region do have online available. Additionally parking is a major issue here many days around lunchtime. There are many other businesses/restaurants in this shopping area that share parking. Between the online issue and parking it is easier to go to Jimmy Johns next door they do have online ordering. read more

I like Potbelly. I seem to always get the meatball, but tonight I ventured out to get the Gyro FLATS. I think I have a new favorite sandwich! We also got the milkshake, Mac & Cheese and a cookie. The cookie was free because I used the new app to order / pay. And, I also earned another cookie by using the app for my next visit. The staff tonight were friendly and helpful. We ate outside and had a great experience. I always have been and still am a fan of Potbelly! read more

Great food, great mobile app, but the "USS" fan blade thing is annoying sound. Trying to eat here and this thing is just making horrible noise... read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

My husband and I are huge fans of potbelly and this location does not disappoint! The service and food are always incredible. My go-to order is a mushroom melt with broccoli cheddar soup on the side. I dip the sandwich into the soup and it is magical!! (Don't knock it till you try it). read more

Last time I was there ordered via app. They had door locked and we're very slow in food prep.

I really like a lot of their sandwiches but lately I've been getting the Mediterranean sandwich with chicken. It's definitely the only place I can get a sandwich like this. Instead of mayonnaise on the bread they use hummus for this sandwich. I've never really thought about using hummus that way but it works. Gives the sandwich moisture but not a lot of fat. The only thing I don't like on this sandwich that comes with it and are the artichoke hearts. They always seem kind of chewy and so I just leave them off. For extras I always get lettuce and tomato and of course the hot peppers! To me the hot peppers aren't very spicy and they add the right amount of kick to the sandwich. If I'm really hungry I get it big! read more

My Mediterranean sandwich was delicious!! Their vegetable soup is the best I've had anywhere!

Beware this Potbelly location. It is woefully inconsistent in quality. I've avoided writing a review here because my love for Potbelly is long standing. I think my family discovered them in West Lafayette about 16 or 17 years ago, and I was hooked immediately. I've since eaten at many locations in multiple states, and I don't remember a single bad experience until frequenting this store. I order the tuna salad sandwich 95% of the time I eat at Potbelly. I just love the way their hot peppers complement the tuna salad. On multiple occasions, the tuna salad has been SO dry here. For some reason, it doesn't seem their employees can follow the tuna salad recipe. One time, I had to ask for mayo packets to put on my sandwich because it seemed like they just gave me flaked tuna straight out of a can. So bad. Now since 2020, I've started ordering on their app and picking up carry out in the store a lot. It is a very handy way to be able to grab a meal ... if you could trust that they make your sandwich well. Unfortunately that only happens at this location about half of the time. They don't seem to be able to follow notes requests well. I like extra hot peppers. I only get this on my sandwich every couple times. This I deal with, but what I can't deal with is getting home with a sandwich that has about half the normal amount of meat on it and completely torched, dry bread. If they're cutting corners and not putting the adequate amount of meat and cheese on, their toaster completely burns and dries the bread. Inedible. Things like this happen at this store too often. I've contacted Potbelly HQ about it when the store wasn't very old (after the no mayo tuna salad incident) ... that they need better training for a consistent experience, but this store just doesn't seem to be able to get a handle on it. I wish this weren't the store that was local to my work commute. I want to stop eating here. But I love Potbelly. It's frustrating. read more

I haven't eaten at a Potbelly in a while so I thought I would try it again. I got here at 30 minutes before closing so I got the RBF look. I ordered a 9 inch turkey add bacon. Loved the bread and the bacon stole the show. Loved it. The turkey on the other ham seemed cheap and didn't wow me. Sandwich drink and chips $13+ so I'd expect more. I'd come back but next time I'd get a BLT for sure. The guy who I will assume was the manager went back to cleaning while my sandwich came through the toaster he did wash his hands for about 2 seconds which was alarming but at least he put gloves back on. read more

Meh. So you order and give all the specifics about what you want. They make the sandwiches in front of you. Then you go to the cashier and they ask "what did you order?" I just went through this, now I have to repeat the entire order again? Seems kind of silly. Here's an idea, whoever takes your order should write it down (I know, genius) and hand the ticket down with the order. Vanilla milkshake was good but nothing special. No whipped cream or cherry. Sandwiches were ok. Although both the wife and myself were missing avocado that was supposed to come with both. We brought this to the attention of the staff and they gave us some avocado and apologized. We've been here a couple times and probably won't be back. Too many other places to support. read more

Great sandwiches and soup! We first went to a Potbelly in Chicago so we were excited when they opened In Carmel

I've tried Potbelly years ago in Texas. I don't know why, but I've never been back. Well I'm glad I decided to try their salad tonight! I didn't get any names, sorry! The young man who took my order was nice, swift, and built my salad with TLC! I think it was the manager who rang me up, very nice, out going and helpful. Try Apple Walnut Salad, get the balsamic vinaigrette too, it's yummy! read more

Customer service at this location needs tons of improvement. The person who answered the phone (afternoon) on 3/27/23 was not very helpful. Will not return. read more