Absolutely amazing! I ordered the garlic cheesy bread, honestly the best I've ever had. I would eat 20 slices if possible. I can specifically for the chicken parmigiana, which had a great review here, and it did not disappoint. The crust was crispy all over and the sauce was so good. 10/10, will make an effort to come back! Our server was very attentive and met all expectations. The restaurant itself wasn't very big but the tables and lighting were nice. There is also a bar. The only negative is the bathroom. read more

See all

The chicken Parmesan is God-tier! You won't be disappointed with any dish here! Also, the GM, Jordan, creates such an inviting atmosphere! My friend is vegan and Jordan spent a solid 5 minutes explaining every vegan food item for my friend in-depth on a Saturday during peak busy hours. She is so knowledgeable of the menu and is amazing at making each patron feel seen and welcomed. This is the best Italian restaurant in Indy! read more

Everything was delicious! My girlfriends and I met here and loved everything we ordered. I think I will dream about the honey ricotta bruschetta for the rest of my life! Definitely recommend. read more

Maialina - Bruschette Pomodoro - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Food: 10/10 I get the garlic cheesy bread and customize my pastas by noodle to sauce. I love how flexible they can be! Service: I've sat at the bar and tables, everyone is quick and attentive. Ambiance: it's a chill vibe, dim lighting and a good place to catch up with people or meet for drinks. read more

See all

Recently tried the Apple Cider mule and it was delicious! Loved the fresh apples on top. As always, the Spicy Chicken vodka was also perfect. read more

Maialina - Vodka - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Came here with a big group for dinner. I tried some of the apps which were all tasty. The bruschettas were well prepared, and the calamari were perfect. I ordered the mussels for my main, and I would definitely pass on these. The tomato sauce didn't go well with the dish and overall it was a complete flop IMO. I also had the sausage rigatoni dish and it was amazing. The sausage was soooo tasty and there was so much of it. Would definitely recommend getting the pasta here. Service was good, drinks were average, and prices were a bit on the steep side for Indy, but good for a nicer occasion. read more

See all

My friends and I went here later in the evening one day. We ordered pretty quickly, as we knew we didn't have too long before they closed and we don't ever want to be in anyone's way...though the food was good and the restaurant itself was pretty quiet, the service just wasn't there. I'm not sure if it was cause the server was ready to go, but he seemed dismissive and we felt rushed. I don't ever want to leave not so great reviews, but being in the service industry for some time now, it's never okay to make a table feel like they shouldn't have come in. I'll be back to try it again, because I truly did enjoy the food..I just hope to have a better server. read more

Maialina - Menu - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Still my favorite Italian place in Indy! The food is beyond delicious - I crave it weekly. The staff is very kind and always welcoming. The drinks are top notch - it's the best place in Indy to grab a drink, meet up with friends and savor delicious bites. read more

I was craving Italian food one day, and I am glad this place popped up on Google maps. Be sure to snag a reservation if you can. The place is dimly lit and the ambiance is perfect for a date or a night out with family. I highly recommend the Garlic Parmesan Bread and the Vodka Rigatoni. The service the first time I went was great, but the second time I went, it could've been a bit better, but I overall recommend going to try this food! read more

Maialina - Garlic Parmesan Bread - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Very cozy ambiance ( we went kind of late though). Our server was amazing vigilant, and helpful. the bartender was solid and made what I requested to a T. and the food was great. I'll be back to try more. read more

Maialina - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Always a great place for date night or girls night. I've love the gluten free pasta and my go to is Cacio Pepe with chicken. Amazing service and good for groups. Great wine list and location too! read more

See all

I may not have enjoyed the cacio e pepe but I keep coming back for the ricotta bruschetta and the rigatoni Rustica. The Rustica is so good my husband and I both get it. The current seasonal sangria is the best! Always great friendly service and a great ambiance. read more

See all

I really need to do my reviews faster these days. I always check in on yelp so I remember to go back and review but I can forget and then it can be months later. I can't remember our exact experience here but it was our first night on vacation and I remember the food being good. Service I'm sure was good otherwise I'd remember if it was bad. It was also a cute place and the perfect start to our vacation. I think my son was also acting up a bit which is probably why I can't remember our experience exactly lol. They were super nice about it. read more

Excellent Italian restaurant. Great service, great menu, great value, excellent interior. read more

Maialina - Rigatoni Rustica - Excellent, well-balanced and generous portion. - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We had a wonderful visit here. We happened to visit during Devour week, so we got a fantastic deal that enabled us to try a lot of different dishes. We were very happy with the food, the service, and the atmosphere. read more

Maialina - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We were able to snag a last minute reservation at this home-y Italian restaurant in Fountain Square. Dimly lit, with a romantic feel, this place was perfect for a date night. Jordan was our waitress and she was very friendly and attentive. My date ordered the apple cider mule and raved about it! I tried their Caesar salad, which was prob in my top 5 Caesar's I've ever had. Very delicious. We ordered the chicken vodka rigatoni and the chicken parm and we savored both dishes. Note- the rigatoni was a bit Al dente, so if you're like me and prefer a softer bite, it may be worth mentioning. For a very affordable, authentic Italian dinner, add Maialina's to your list! read more

Maialina - Vodka rigatoni - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Maialina, Maialina! This is probably the best Italian restaurant in Indy at the moment. It is a small, quiet storm in Fountain Square that is quaint, cute and the food is full of flavor. For staters, we ordered the cheese bread, marinara and the seafood fondue. The seafood fondue is to die for. You must get the fondue with the cheesy bread. It is rich in flavor with a bit of spice. You will certainly keep going back for more. We had the calamari which was lightly breaded and cooked just right, nice and tender. We also ordered the vegetarian and beef versions of the bolognese rigatoni. Both done beautifully. We ended the night with caps..the white russian was made to perfection, if you like a dessert cocktail. Parking is always available in the area and there wasn't a wait to get seated mid week, after work. I am sure this is a different story on the weekend regarding a wait. I experienced my first visit with co-workers but this would be a great place for date night, special occasion, family meetup or a casual visit with others or alone. read more

See all

I've been waiting to try Maialina and it was fantastic! Our table tried: nonna's meatballs, Parmesan garlic bread, calamari, Caesar salad, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, rigatoni rustica, cacio e pepe, sausage pasta and salmon. All outstanding and delicious!!!! Entrees came out steaming hot! For dessert we had pistachio cheesecake and lemon torte with berries. We will be back again! If you want a quieter experience be sure to ask for the third room. First bar area is rather noisy, and the second area to me felt like a flurry of activity. read more

See all

I can't believe I have not reviewed Maialina yet!Maialina is in my frequent rotations for restaurants. They have a gluten free pasta that is incredible! I love to bring my kindle, sit at the bar, and order a drink and some food. Jordan the manager and bartender is fantastic. Their drink specials rotate seasonally, but Jordan's lemon drop martinis are absolutely delightful. The food is always served steaming hot and is portioned so that most people will have leftovers. I have never had a bad meal or drink here. My go to meals are the shrimp primavera with gluten free pasta or the rigatoni rustica with gluten free pasta. Located in Fountain Square with free street parking. There is a step up to get into the restaurant from outside. read more

Maialina - Cucumber Martini - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Came here for a friends birthday dinner and it was my first time here. It was so cute and quaint and our server was absolutely fantastic! I had the Cacio E Pepe with blackened chicken and since this birthday dinner I've gone back twice to order the same thing, it's THAT good and the portion size is great for what you're spending. I ordered bruschetta which I could've done without it was just difficult to eat with the bread being too big and the toppings falling off. My sangria was great and so was my Sauvignon Blanc! Overall this is a new staple for me! Parking is limited but street parking and FREE...gotta love Fountain Square! read more

See all

We wanted to try something different so we stopped in here. Couldn't have worked out better for us. It was a Sunday and I think one of the managers was tending bar and she was perfect. She made great recommendations and was entertaining without being over the top. Food was very solid And The Wine list was reasonably priced. We will definitely come back here and probably on a Sunday and hopefully have same bartender. read more

Maialina - Awesome app - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

A dish so simple but so flavorful. The Cacio e pepe. I loved it so much I recreated it at home. The calamari was amazing I tried not to eat it all before the main course and my old fashioned packed a punch. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars because we did arrive a little later in the evening and sat at the bar but we felt a little rushed during our experience. Now that I'm writing this review I'm suddenly craving some Italian :). read more

See all

Outstanding. I would need a taste test between Maialina and Mama Carolla's for best Italian food in town. I had lasagna and parmesan garlic toast. They're both excellent. The parmesan garlic toast is a huge appetizer so be careful on that one. The service was borderline St. Elmo level. A+ all around. I can't overemphasize how great their staff was. The menu was a little too expensive, but everything else was so terrific that I still give them five stars. read more

We stopped in for devour and you definitely get your moneys worth that's for sure! So much food! The atmosphere is nice and the service was great. There's really nothing bad to say about this place, but there's also nothing really that stood out. I started with a dirty martini (w blue cheese stuffed olives) and while it wasn't a big issue I did find it odd that only one of my olives was stuffed with blue cheese. The food was all good, but the pasta dishes aren't anything you can't make at home - with maybe more flavor. It's a fun spot to come for drinks and apps or dinner with friends. We all split the devour appetizers among everyone (meatballs and bruschetta) and then got a side order of the shrimp fondue (SO GOOD!). I then got a Caesar salad and vodka pasta as my main. I wont order the vodka pasta again, not much flavor. We each got the different desserts - cannoli cake was so good. read more

See all

I don't do food reviews often, but we had the best Italian the other night and I can't gatekeep. First things first- I've been to Italy and had "real" pasta AND pasta is not usually my first choice. In fact I probably have it twice a year. BUT THIS... Was. So. Good. Highly recommend the pesto ravioli, sausage pasta, Parmesan garlic toast, and shrimp fondue. Service was great and restaurant was a cute vibe, which feels as important as the food itself. read more

See all

As someone from the Boston area in Massachusetts, this Italian spot holds up. Amazing red sauce, slightly sweet but no heart burn, tastes fresh. Service kind and friendly able to provide suggestions, and the hostess was kind to our table of 6 as an uber was holding up a couple of the guys. Clean on the inside, and thriving. Felt at home. The food was amazing, you MUST get the tiramisu please save room for that it was the best I've ever had in my life and I will forever think about it. read more

See all

We live in Fountain Square and often try to come up with excuses to get Maialina for dinner. It is on the pricier end, but it is SO good. So we often come here to celebrate the good things in life. My husband is a big aperol spritz guy and says they have the best. I love the Parmesan garlic toast, Caesar salad, and bolognese. My husband is obsessed with the lasagna with white sauce. Everything we've tried though is amazing. The service is friendly and the vibes are wonderful. If it's a nice day outside, we enjoy going up to the rooftop bar for a cocktail after dinner! read more

We had a wonderful dinner for four with a fantastic mushroom truffle oil flatbread for starter that was truly much better than I have had before. Four great entrees and loved the special with the white Negroni. Jennifer the waitress was first rate - she knew the details of the special drinks and steered me away from a special I wouldn't have liked because of a single ingredient. Saved the day with great energy backed but listened to us and recommended accordingly. read more

How have I not been here before. It was so good that honestly I'm already wanting to go back. The Caesar salad was great-- the right amount of salad to dressing to croutons. I then had the Gamberi pasta which I think I will have a hard time moving from. It was nice that you could specify mild/medium/hot in terms of spiciness-- I hadn't commonly been asked that before, at least not at an Italian restaurant! Splitting the salad + a friend's meatballs + the Gamberi came out to ~$50 with tip, which was not cheap, but worth it. Finally a good Italian place in Indy! Thanks, Maialina! read more

Upon arrival immediately greeted and seated at my table. Very knowledgeable server who took the time to explain the menu and the popular dishes. I ordered the 1/2 ceasar and the appetizer meatballs.ceasar the right size for A 1/2 portion. It was good. Meatballs were good as well. The sauce was thick and tasty. The appetizer could easily be shared. Great find and wonderful service. Definitely with a visit when in Indy read more

See all

Really good. Would have been a lot better if at least one piece of bread came with the dish. It is Italian food after all, and charging $30 for pasta and sauce I think a piece of bread can be offered, kinda cheap IMO. Great meatball appetizer, to share, but one piece of bread? Overall, really good though. read more

If you're looking for good Italian food with big portions, this is the place to go! I loved how Al dente the noodles were and each pasta dish we got was so flavorful and unique. We also got the calamari appetizer which was pretty good. Wish it was a little more crispy. The garlic Parmesan bread had the right amount of cheese and garlic. Loved the softness of the bread mixed with all creamy and melty cheese. Our server was very knowledgeable about the menu and helpful as we were ordering. He also made sure to check in frequently with us. The vibes at the restaurant were perfect for a small group dinner. read more

See all

I'm leaving feeling good about Maialina. I scrolled yelp for the tea. I agree with the yelper who said the ravioli was rich, the flavor intense, but I love pesto, so I was good! I agree with the yelper who said the ingredients taste fresh, I actually tasted the spinach, which was nice. I disagree with the yelper who said there wasn't enough cheese inside the ravioli. Twas fine. Vibe is chill, casual, busy on a Saturday night. Felt like the regulars were in tonight, lending to the laidback feel. I will say the ricotta bruschetta is bigger than one may assume- slices of bread vs toasts, so bring a friend to share it with. Two word review: the expect leftovers. read more

See all

AUTHENTIC! AFFORDABLE! Old family recipes and hospitality! One of Indy's best kept secrets! Our best Italian flavor by far! SUPPORT FAMILY BUSINESSES! read more

I had an amazing experience at Maialina! The food was top-notch--I highly recommend the Bruschetta and Chicken Parmesan. The service was just as incredible. I wish I remembered our waitress's name (she had lots of tattoos!) because she was so friendly and attentive. Even though the restaurant was very busy, the staff kept everything running smoothly, and the food came out quickly--not just for us, but for other tables as well. We don't make it to Fountain Square often, but Maialina has definitely earned a spot on our "favorites list"! read more

Maialina - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Such a cute spot in Fountain Square. We came in with a big group and our server was working overtime. Seriously, she handled everything so gracefully and made sure we were all taken care of. The vibe inside is low lit and cozy, perfect for a dinner that feels a little elevated but still chill. Now onto the food. The cheesy garlic bread? To die for. Like I'm not kidding, I'll probably just get two orders of that next time and call it a day. I also had the shrimp scampi, which was solid. The shrimp were big, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. Tried the ricotta bruschetta for the table and it was the perfect sweet and savory bite. I kept going back for another. Definitely a spot I'd come back to, especially if I'm craving that garlic bread again. read more

Maialina - Shrimp Scampi - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Absolutely love Maialina. It's a fav spot for us and we took my family here for my birthday. Drinks were excellent and so was the food. The bruschetta and cheese bread are delicious. I ordered an espresso martini, with pesto ravioli and it's heavenly. The atmosphere is dark and moody inside which is great for a date night. read more

See all

I can't get enough of the vodka pasta. It's soooo good. I've tried other pastas and flatbreads and they are all wonderful too, but I always want to go back for that vodka pasta! Almost all of their dishes can be made with gluten free pasta or gluten free flatbread. I love the atmosphere here too. It's a cozy neighborhood Italian restaurant where you can just as easily meet up with friends and family, or enjoy date night. The servers are friendly and the bartenders are comfortable chatting with anyone. read more

Took my Mother In-law here tonight for dinner. Made reservations well in advance. We started off with the Cheese Bread. It was delicious. We each got Caesar Salad and all said the dressing was a bit bite-y. Usually means lots of anchovy paste. Still good though. My dish Rigatoni Pasta with Sausage and Broccolini. It was just on the edge of too spicy for me even leaving off red pepper flakes. Husband got Chicken Parm and Potatoes. Potatoes were great. Didn't try the chicken but he said it was good. Mother In-law got Shrimp Primavera. It was a huge plate full. Her only complaint was the broccoli wasn't cooked enough. Dessert was Chocolate Layer Cake and Tiramisu. Husband loved the Chocolate Cake. I thought it was dry. Their Tiramisu I just need to stop trying. While tonight it wasn't gritty it had an off taste like cheese going bad. Not sure what kind of Mascarpone they use. Couldn't taste the coffee in the lady fingers at all. Also not as sweet as most Tiramisu I've typically had. Service was ok. Seemed slow at first. They do have other staff clearing dishes and filling drinks which does help the flow. They need a host stand. The table at the front door isn't tall enough and a stand would hide the menus and other stuff they had on top. It would also put the reservation tablet at a more comfortable position for the host to see. read more

See all

We were craving Italian and Maialina did not disappoint! We did their Devour Indy menu which was 4 courses of deliciousness. We had the bruschetta ricotta, garlic cheese bread, Caesar salad, vodka pasta, chicken parmesan, Torta della Nonna, and pistachio cheesecake. It was the perfect way to try a ton of dishes! Service was great - our server was very attentive and always made sure to give us enough time to enjoy each course without feeling rushed. Definitely will put this high on the list for Italian restaurants in Indy! read more

See all