Really 4.5 Stars.
BLUF: ie... Bottom Line Up Front. The best pizza, or wine, whatever, is the one YOU like the best, not someone else. If you will take that into consideration;....
I have thought long and hard about this review. I lived in Naples for several years and worked in Italy among a zillion other countries. When a restaurant is several hundred years old, they are doing right. Neapolitans argue over the "best" pizza amongst themselves. There is no correct answer.
Traditionally, a pizza is not made at home due to the space and the ovens that are required. Also, the ingredients are minimal as the crust is so important. Pizza's are not cut into squares or triangles as eating them with your hands is the same type of sin as cutting your spaghetti. You are considered an uncouth slob. HOWEVER, the younger generation is more and more eating a part that is larger and cut to hold in their hands (when their mother or grandmother is not around of course).
A traditional Neapolitan pizza (you can google the requirements) is simply placed on a large plate, uncut in front of you. It is not covered with ingredients as it is only 1 of several possible courses in the meal. You first attack the very center with a knife and fork and ideally should be soft enough to twirl around the fork. Eating outward, the dough becomes more and more solid, but should always be where you can cut a small piece and fold over a flap onto the fork. Lastly comes the crust, which is eaten in bites while carrying on conversations about soccer or what will be the next course or wine. This softness in the very center can be off-putting to those who have been told a thin crust is an Italian pizza. These can be obtained from places that sell to American tourists, but they are not recommended. Also, when arriving in Naples, if you have a friend that lives there, they may warn you NOT to have a pizza for at least 2 weeks so your body can adjust to the massive amounts but wonderful olive oil. If you don't, you may be sick that evening.
What is available in NYC and the area is Italian pizza, but it is not like what you find in Italy. One of the basic reasons is that the ingredients are not the same as the FDA does not allow the import of many of the items, right down to the flour, without additives. That is why you can get something called Italian bread in the USA, but it does not compare to the bread in Naples. Hey, but it is still good! Now the famous NYC slice, which I like, is starting to make inroads into Italy. However, it is eaten, not folded over with the ingredients on the inside, but the outside. Impossible? No. As pizza is eaten normally with a knife and fork, it is more like an inside-out calzone. If you just want the amount of a slice, particularly one you are going to eat in you hand (with paper around it), the pizza is quite small. Italians routinely dress much more formally and they do not want to get it one their suits or dresses.
Now, in my opinion, and the opinion of the Lady of the house, Pieous did an excellent job. The dough was soft-soft in the center and spot on. We had two types of pizza as we can't agree on which is better, Margarita or one with four ingredients. We also got the Tiramisu. It was very good, I would get it again, but it needed a touch more of booze and/or coffee to hit a home run.
The staff was wonderful and the place was spotless. Will we be back? Yes, absolutely! We loved it! Was it the best I we have ever had? No. But in the USA, I would rank it in the top 5 we have eaten. I place this in a totally different category than the NYC slice, which I love to eat and people watch. If you have not been to NYC, and dove into the food, that is a sad thing.
If you take it home, I recommend having the oven hot with a pizza stone already in there waiting, and warm it up for a couple of minutes. Any longer and you may end up with a very tough outer crust and the underneath trending toward an American thin crust.
I hope this helps. This is just our opinion. What is correct is what you like. Don't worry about trying to agree with or please others.
Enjoy! read more