Stopped here for something sweet after spending the afternoon on St. Augustine Beach with my family. This was my first visit to Cone Heads, and I had a very enjoyable experience! Cone Heads is located right on A1A Beach Blvd, just a block off of the beach. It is in a standalone building that is inviting with both colorful signage and plenty of outdoor seating. They also have a drive-thru and a private parking lot. When we visited on a Tuesday in July around 5:30 PM, we had no issue getting a parking spot. There were some other customers enjoying some ice cream, but there was relatively no line when we entered the store. The ordering happens inside, and you walk right into the ice cream cabinets and counter. All of the flavors are displayed and can be seen from the order line. Additionally inside, there are some tables to sit and eat at, along with a restroom. They sell a variety of merchandise along with their food and dessert selection. I liked seeing the community cork-board, where there were a variety of different posters and advertisements for events and services around the area. The menu consisted of traditional ice cream items one would expect - cups, cones, sundaes, banana splits, milkshakes, and more. They also had a Seasonal Special section on the menu, which I assume changes somewhat frequently. This trip, that item was a Donut Ice Cream Sandwich. There are some sundae combinations on the menu, but you can customize your own if you choose. There is hard ice cream, soft serve, and also some hot food options - hot dogs, sausages, and tamales, primarily. For drinks, they had canned soda, bottled, water, and some coffee options. As far as to-go, they had pints and quarts available for the ice cream, along with a freezer full of pre-packaged pints, quarts, and ice cream sandwiches for a grab and go situation. Having never been here before, our group needed some time to look at the menu and flavors before ordering. There were around 30 different flavors of hard ice cream, which included No Sugar Added and Dairy Free varieties, in addition to traditional full dairy varieties. I thought that the flavor selection was a healthy mix of traditional favorites and unique offerings. The staff working were friendly and helpful with answering all of our questions about the flavors. I even got to try a couple samples before making my decision. After much debate, I landed on trying the Donut Ice Cream Sandwich. This was made to order, and I got to choose the ice cream for the filling. I opted for the Kahula Chip for a coffee and donut flavor combination. I did enjoy this treat! The donut was fresh (and from a local spot), and the ice cream complimented it nicely. I thought the price was also fair for the size and specialty of the dessert, at $5.50 before any tax. My dog was waiting patiently in the car, so we ordered him a Doggie Ice Cream. It was a small boat of vanilla soft serve with peanut butter sauce and a Milk Bone. For my magnet collection, I also purchased one of their logo to take home with me. I personally did not pay the bill, but I thought the pricing here was fair and in line with any other similar type of shop. They took both cash and card. This shop is exactly what you would want out of an ice cream shop on the beach - fun, colorful, and local. They incorporate various other local businesses into their products. The theme of the establishment is appropriate for being a block away from the ocean, and there is a lot of color and fun decor to look at around the building. The staff were all pleasant, the product is tasty, and the price is right. Really enjoyed discovering Cone Heads on this trip, and will make sure to stop by again during my future trips to St. Augustine! read more

See all

Glazed donut Mudslide ice cream sandwich. Coffee & donut in one! Need I say more? My wife had the scoop of Creamsicle in a plain waffle bowl. A yummy time was had! Definitely would come back! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

As you would expect during the Summer in Florida, be prepared to wait in line if you are trying to find a place to cool off! The wait is extremely worth it! The ice cream is quite creamy and delicious! The staff works very hard to make sure you are served well! Inside the small parlor, there are items for sale like T-shirts and such. The local, fan, favorite flavor is chocolate peanut butter! It has loads of liquid peanut butter pieces that have solidified and chopped peanut butter cups! For those non-dairy, ice cream lovers, there are nondairy options! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Everything you want in an ice cream shop. I ordered a banana split to share with my husband. They were out of vanilla, but they let us pick any flavor to substitute, which was great. They took care to put everything together and didn't skimp on any toppings. 5/5, would recommend! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Banana split and turtle sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Ona hot day and needed a little pick me up and a drive thru with kids, this was a score! Made a couple of trips here during our visit in st Augustine. A variety of ice creams and milkshake options. There is outdoor seating too or some spots to eat in the car. Quick service and friendly staff! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Hot fudge sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Love this little shop. Is always crowded but they move things along quickly. Even have a drive thru! Great selections.

Large portions dependent on who serves you. Small sizes were $5.25 decent ice cream was a bit flavorless. I got the creamsicle, raimbow sherbet, peach, brownie caramel in a waffle bowl. The waffle bowl tasted cinnamony. I love cinnamon but not on a waffle bowl. Finally tried it. read more

See all

Absolutely no complaints from our group of six - I had the banana crunch (real banana ice cream mixed with walnuts and chocolate flakes) I love it. The staff here was extremely friendly and accommodating - the prices are expensive as is everything else in 2024 but the quality is good and the portions were more than fair. Plenty of customers with smiles on their faces during my our visit. Plenty of parking with easy access and a drive-through window. read more

See all

Seriously the most yummy ice cream shakes I have ever had! Best flavor- malted chocolate! Staff is wonderful and you cant beat the location next to the beach. read more

Oh my, love this place. On a recent trip to Saint Augustine Beach, we went there both nights. I love the espresso chip and peanut butter chocolate... Friend loves the vanilla and the butter pecan, but wished they had pistachio!! FYI, they have those obnoxious machines which strongly suggests that you give a tip. read more

Not the greatest picture as this was at night and Cone Heads was so crowded that I couldn't snap a pic without it including random people in the background. Great ice cream! There are a variety of flavors being offered which is always nice, and there was also tons of different cones and waffle bowls as well. What I really appreciated about the ice cream was how it's homemade, creamy, and stayed hard and intact as I took my time to eat it. Cheaper and lower fat ice creams will melt immediately, but their ice cream was awesome, and I really enjoyed! The prices were also reasonable which was nice, certainly recommend! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Ice cream was delish! I got the waffle bowl with 2 scoops. It was more like 4. Key lime & salted caramel. Great service. Cute place.

Stopped the evening of 3/27. A bunch of young adults working. They were awesome! They hussled and kept a long line moving quickly! Bonus - they had chocolate peanut butter ice cream. They are learning a good work ethic and will make good entrepreneurs or employees someday!! read more

Yum!! Waffle cone has interesting cinnamon flavor. Enjoyed Snickers flavor. Good service

A good place to satisfy your ice cream Fix. Choices are many and the portions are good. I had the black cherry, which was very good and the chocolate fudge, which was also very good. Friendly staff made for a nice experience. read more

We came to Cone Heads specifically for the Chicago-style hot dogs, and they didn't disappoint. Great all-beef dog with a spicy pepper, crisp pickle, vibrant green relish, and a nice touch of seasoning, definitely the highlight. The ice cream was decent, with pretty basic flavors, but nothing that stood out. Overall, a fun little spot, but more for the hot dogs than the ice cream. read more

Great variety, reasonably priced but the staff is kids who act like it's a bother for you to order.

So yummy. We tried the peach ice cream on a cone. So delicious very creamy and generous size scoop.

Wow. This place blew me away! I came here with my family on Saturday and it did not disappoint. The icecream was fantastic, I got mom's banana which tastes just like banana pudding! Staff is excellent and very attentive. Don't be scared off by the long lines they go by quickly! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Let me tell you about this amazing lil ice cream shop right on the beach. My mom and I were craving some ice cream at the oddest hour (almost 10pm on a Thursday). We did a quick Yelp search and we see a shop 6 minutes away. Of course we took forever to actually get out of the door and we realized we were cutting it close to closing time (15 mins). I called and we begged them to hold off on closing for two lil old ladies craving some ice cream. Not only did the whole Cone Heads crew have the best attitudes, they were also very helpful working with us and our indecisiveness. Mom and I couldn't settle on 1 scoop each, so we settled on 3 pints and 2 scoops of goodness. Watermelon sorbet, lemon sorbet and a dairy free toasted coconut (TDF!), plus.....blueberry cheesecake and orange dream. Needless to say....We love cone heads!! We appreciate the great customer service!! Thanks for making our night!! See you again soon read more

See all

Probably the best tasing and one of the largest freshest waffle cones I've ever had! Delicious ice cream too! One scoop was plenty for me and priced below $6.00. There were nice picnic tables with umbrellas to sit under outdoors. Counter service with friendly staff. read more

Great little ice cream joint... Stopped in for dessert after we finished dinner just down the street, so glad we had dessert here. When we first walked in, the line was almost out the door, but the folks working there were so efficient and super friendly, they knocked that line down quick. It was amazing to experience and then watch as we ate our ice cream seeing the rush that hit them afterwards and how quick they were to take care of everyone. The ice cream they offered was very varied and eclectic. I enjoyed the Razzle Dazzle with a banana ice cream, my wife had the Razzle Dazzle as well with their Black Cherry, we shared and it was all fantastic. I can see why the locals frequent this place, definitely worth a stop if your staying at the beach or nearby... read more

The biggest cone ive ever had in my life. I didn't realize when I was ordering 3 scoops they were going to be humongous. That's my mistake. Got the strawberry and cream, banana crunch and khalua coffee and all 4 were so good!!! I def gained a whole pound while eating this though, could've gotten something way smaller or shared my fiancé's icecream with him LOL read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Strawberries and cream, banana crunch, Kahlua coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

So this review is completely based upon the ice cream itself. I didn't actually go and pick it up. It was outstanding fudge Sunday that was recommended. I could've done without the whipped cream, but it was outstanding. read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Sorry. I had already eaten most of it and put the leftovers in the Vrbo refrigerator. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Little ice cream spot that packs a very flavorful punch! Good prices, good service, great ice cream. I had the Run raisin, and I think it's the best Rum Raisin ice cream I've ever had!! It tasted like good wholesome ingredients, none of that artificial aftertaste you find in many places. My husband had the 3 scoop container, and we found that compared to another ice cream spot just down the street, these ice creams seems to be more flavorful and richer. Creamy and none were overly sweet, exactly how each should have been. Outdoor seating was available, and nice as its pet friendly. Not sure if this is part of a chain or not, but my answer to the magic question (yes, I'll go back!!) will have me searching to see if there are other Coneheads in my travels :) read more

See all

Great service! The folks slinging the ice cream and shakes were on a mission: fast and friendly. And the ice cream was delicious! We'll be back read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

So I am local. Been driving this section of A1A for 30 years. Also I don't like the summer or the beach. So I was surprised when we took the grandkids to Coneheads. Aside from the reference to an SNL kit and movie, the cones themselves were good (a bit cinnamon-y for me). Ice cream good. BUT MORE! A Friendly staff. A table inside away from the sweat box outside. Polywood tables outside. Shade outside. Parking outside. Smoking outside! Vienna Chicago Dogs! Drive through too! Clean and nice. Wow! read more

See all

Excellent ice cream, decent selection of flavors. Really good quality ice cream. Nicely priced compared to tons of other places. My only suggestion is a little warmer greeting. I lived this place and would definitely drive out of my way to come here read more

See all

I cannot eat real ice-cream because I am seriously lactose intolerant. My creamy cold treat is sorbet or sherbet. I had the watermelon sorbet. It had a very full watermelon flavor. It was really tasty. My wife had the caramel-brownie ice cream in a waffle cone and her one-word description, "Amazing". The service was fast and friendly. read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Came to St Augustine for my wife's baby moon and she was craving this place. Have to say we felt scammed. Paid for two scoops and barely got a scoop and a half if that. My wife asked if they could put a full second scoop and the girl said they could not. They get two stars for somewhat good tasting ice cream but nothing out of this world. Mayday's down the street is better in my opinion. read more

Delicious ice cream. Great selection and fast service. Drive through is very fast. Priced reasonably.

Cone heads is super tasty and it would get 5 stars from me IF they took card payments. Not sure what the reason would be for not taking cards but I would definitely choose Rita's over Cone heads for that reason alone. The flavor selection has a lot of variety which I was a huge fan of. I chose the Cookie Monster and the dark fudge brownie flavors. The ice cream was delicious and my boyfriend loved the flavors that he purchased as well. The staff was all very friendly and offered to let us sample any flavors that we wanted to try. Overall would recommend if you happen to have cash or don't mind using the ATM in store. read more

See all

What a "cool" place! Sweet, little spot to hit close to the beach. They have sooo many options. The staff was very friendly and helpful to us. I was surprised when my daughter ordered coffee ice cream but she loved it. My other daughter ordered the one with all kinds of stuff in it, and I wish I could remember the name but it was my favorite. But I also enjoyed my scoop of birthday cake and chocolate with hot fudge oozed on top. I am so impressed with their bags of broken waffle cone pieces. I'm such a slow eater that I never get cones because they're just a goopy mess when I finally get down to them. With the broken bits, I actually get to enjoy some cone with my ice cream. The place was clean inside and out with plenty of seating outside, but also a couple seating areas inside. We got lucky and were able to sit inside. We'll be back! read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - One cone (dipped in chocolate and sprinkles), one cone bowl, and a couple scoops with a side of waffle cone bits - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

A fun place we visited on a weekend trip to St Augustine. The place was packed but the staff behind the counter worked quickly and efficiently to get all our orders out. Lots of flavor choices. Perfect spot to end the day after spending hours on the beach. read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - a woman eating ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great ice cream! Patient and helpful staff. Adequate although tight parking. A great treat after beach and dinner

Lot's of delicious flavors to choose from. Generous servings!! Helpful and cheery staff. read more

Always been a favorite stop for ice cream. Cone Heads used to sell Working Cow ice cream, which was a premium ice cream from St. Petr, but Working Cow stopped manufacturing ice cream last fall due to several health violations (listeria) and now Working Cow only distributed ice cream from other manufacturers. In spite of this, Cone Heads found a great solution in the Chocolate Shoppe ice cream (Madison, WI). This also is really good, premium ice cream. Tonight I had the Munchie Madness and Heaps of Love, both of which are "everything but the kitchen sink" type ice creams. I think I found a new favorite in Munchie Madness! Cone Heads offers a lot of flavors to choose from, friendly service, and resort area prices. read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

How else can I rate this place, but saying thank you for having delicious ice cream and loading up my cup with rainbow sprinkles. After a long day of a venturing out in downtown Saint Augustine, this was our last stop before relaxing back at the beach house. There was two guys behind the counter, who were super sweet. This place is a only cash business, so make sure not bring the credit card. I ordered a soft serve chocolate and vanilla swirl with extra rainbow sprinkles. I am now happy as a clam. My night was now complete. read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Update May 2021 - what happened? We loved this place, but this time it was awful. The ice cream was full of large ice chunks. I got the cookie dough and my boyfriend got the captain rum raisin. Both had frostbite. :'( I couldn't even finish mine read more

Cone Heads Ice Cream - Cookie dough - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great ice-cream. Lots of options and friendly staff. I forgot to take a pic, because all I could think about was eating my ice-cream!