Simple delicious! Great service, ambience amazing. Definitely recommend this place. 10 out of 10. Amazing ice cream! So good!! read more

The was the place to be on a hot May evening. We stopped by to grab a couple ice cream cones and there was quite the line. They offer a great selection of ice cream flavors. We were told the ingredients were locally sourced if possible. We ordered the banana pudding and straight strawberry along with a dip of parent trap in waffle cones. The flavors were tasty and the ice cream a good creamy consistency. The prices are on the high-moderate side. The staff were very friendly. read more

See all

Great customer service! And the ice cream , cone, and whipped cream are amazing. Excellent fresh ice cream flavors! Good seating inside and benches outside to eat too. read more

A little pricey but really great and creative flavors. I got a single scoop of the aviator and it was absolutely delicious. Don't forget to ask for a bite of waffle cone if you get a scoop in a cup! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - The aviator - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Pros: Nice, cute shop. Cons: Ice cream was super sweet. Price for two double waffle cones seemed ridiculous....$27. We usually get cake cones but that wasn't an option. They have the obnoxious tip screen when you check out. read more

Caden was awesome! He gave me a sample, dipped my scoops and was super friendly! We love this place! It's always fast and amazing! We come here a week a year and always visit atleast 4-5 times during that week! Be back tomorrow! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Key Lime pie and ice box lemon in a waffle cone and in my beard! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Just after opening on a Thursday. The store was all mine. Plenty of parking in front and in the back. Benches to enjoy ice cream in the sun. Parent trap in a sugar cone was so rich. read more

See all

The food was amazing delicious flavor combinations. The service was quick and friendly. The ambience was welcoming and extremely clean. It was absolutely amazing to walk in and smell sweet delicious ice cream immediately! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice cream sandwich! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Top notch Ice cream shop! Inventive and delicious flavors, homemade waffle cones, with homemade sprinkles! We enjoyed session chocolate, the Aviator, and brown butter chocolate chip cookie! All excellent! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We walked in and everyone was so welcoming. It was so bright and fun inside! It was also very clean! You were allowed to try as many flavors as you wanted! The ice cream was soooo delicious! There were so many different flavor options, I had a hard time choosing because it all looked so good! Gisele was awesome! She was so sweet and happy and welcoming. read more

It is so so so good. I like darker chocolate ice cream usually and this place has a really good one. And their biscoff flavor REALLY taste like bis off and I think the cookies are mixed in. Most places biscoff barely has the flavor. Even tho I prefer chocolate, their other flavors were also REALLY good. Wish I lived nearby, they are way better than Kelly's ice cream . Also bonus since their spoons and bowls are recyclable (no pic, ate it too fast) read more

My daughter was familiar with Mayday a locally owned ice cream parlor from a previous trip to St. Augustine and insisted that I go. I'm glad she did. The ice cream here is rich and delicious. There was a large variety with some unusual choices like "Rajah Honey" and olive oil. Faced with so many awesome choices we went with "the flight" which was six golf ball sized scoops to share. Each new bite was declared "the BEST" and in the end Caramel Queen was the winner. The server was so nice and they encourage you to sample any flavor you fancy. There is no outdoor seating but plenty inside the cute shop. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I went to Mayday during spring break time. It was so busy. Sometimes line out the door. But it moves so quickly. The workers behind the glass are so efficient. I literally went back every night. I had Caitlin help and he was fantastic. Thanks Caitlin and the Mayday team! read more

Every flavor of ice cream we tried was so delicious. Service was great with attentive employees!

First time visit but I would definitely come back and most definitely would recommend! So many tempting choices. The Sunday Best banana pudding is outstanding! Bright, clean environment with a friendly and courteous staff. If you are in the area it is worth the trip! read more

I have been to many ice cream joints and this one is awesome. Staff was extremely friendly and went over board trying to get me to sample their most popular flavors. Definitely that homemade and they were absolutely no leftovers when I was done. Two scoops is enough for two adults. read more

Not the first time to Mayday Ice Cream in St. Augustine Beach. This awesome shop is right on A1A with the feel of a 1950s vibe to it. They make their own ice cream, which is really creamy and flavorful. The Blueberry Crunch has real blueberries in a vanilla base with bits of a cone to give it the crunch. Their bourbon pecan is also incredible. The people there are really friendly and helpful if want a recommendation. If in St. Augustine, I highly recommend you stop by and grab some of the best ice cream in the area! read more

Great location near the beach! Super indulgent flavors with complimentary sprinkles on top. Staff is always lovely and willing to give you samples to try before you buy. Highly recommended! read more

Nestled just one street back from the main strip at st Augustine is MayDay ice cream. We wanted a sweet treat when we went to st Augustine and saw there were a lot of ice cream locations on the main strip, however we decided to shop around and see what flavors we could find and see which place tickled our fancy the most. This was a fantastic choice because we stumbled across May Day which we've never seen before. Going inside we could already tell the filming was a lot more exciting and interesting than the other options available in st Augustine. We had a quick look at the menu and decided this was our favorite choice for the day. The staff were incredibly friendly and let us try a couple of the different flavors and told us about them too. After trying a couple I noticed there was a flavor called Big Top, a take on a frosted animal cookie, of which it was impossible to turn down. I also tried the banana pudding and cloud 9, both of which were fantastic. A second choice was The parent Trap, another flavor bursting with nostalgia. The seeming of this location was really fun and really stood out from the other options available in the area. The theme certainly drew us in but the flavors sold us. We will definitely be back to try the 'flight' option, which is six mini scoops where you can try the different flavors, this is a fun double meaning due to the aeronautical theme of mayday ice cream! read more

See all

The ice cream was amazing! So creamy! The gentleman working there was friendly and helpful. Free samples were available if you wanted to taste first. I thought it was a little pricey, but worth it! read more

Amazing vibes, ice cream, and costumer service. Both of the workers were friendly, enthusiastic, and helpful, especially Rachel! Will definitely be coming here throughout our trip. read more

Wonderful little ice cream shop right on the beach! The staff was so helpful, patient, and kind as we figured out our orders! The prices are a bit steep for the amount of ice cream you get but it's definitely worth a try if you're looking for good and fun ice cream flavors! read more

We had a great experience at Mayday Ice Cream! Giselle was awesome super friendly, chatty, and incredibly patient while my very excited mom tried most of the flavors. She made it fun and welcoming, and every flavor we tried was delicious. We got the mint, Yule nog, salted caramel and keylime pie. Amazing ice cream and even better service. We'll definitely be back! read more

Gotta LOVE Mayday Ice Cream. Hands down, some of the best ice cream I've ever had (and I have some experience with ice cream!!) We've already visited a couple locations, picking it over other places just because of the quality. On top of that, the kids behind the counters are top notch with lots of personality. Well Done and Keep it Up!!! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Fabulous Ice Cream Cone!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Nahlia helped us with our ice cream order today. Great service and awesome ice cream flavors.

Love this spot! Easy to get in and get your ice-cream! We had a terrible dinner experience elsewhere so having a great desert place was a highlight! Simple atmosphere. Great service. Little sitting spaces inside which worked for us. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Parent Trap in a waffle cone. YUMM - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Yummy ice cream! Gisele was hard working and very sweet. She took pride in her job which is nice to see

Creative flavors and delicious smells - mayday - we are stopping the car!! The scoops were a little pricey, but you do get free sprinkles or cookies with your ice cream. They also let you sample flavors before making your decision. I went with the biscoff one, and I would get that 1000 times! It was rich, but light and the cookie pieces were still crunchy. My husband got coffee and donuts (I think that was it), and he said it tasted like the most delightfully sweet breakfast. We like this spot so much, we walked here a few times during our vacation. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - The littlest enjoying his vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

What a gem of an ice cream shop! I am an ice cream snob because I actually make my own ice cream at home with my ice cream machine. When I eat ice cream outside of my own, some can taste waxy, oily, and unclean but not Mayday. As advertised their handcrafted and artisan ice cream is spot on. The variety of flavors, the quality of their ice cream, and the friendly staff will keep me coming back next time I am in the area. We stopped in after a day at the beach because of a recommendation from a local. I had their flight which is a dish of 6 golf ball size scoops of ice cream for indecisive people like me. Their normal size ice cream scoop is generous. Highly recommend Mayday if you are in St Augustine visiting or if you are a lucky resident. Spacious and clean inside with comfortable seating. read more

See all

Great well made ice cream from this spot. This wound up being my go to spot for ice cream during the week I was there. I tried three flavors and the Sunday Best Banana Pudding was the top one for me. I also enjoyed the coffee and donuts and the simply strawberry. The coffee ice cream was milky and creamy with a not too strong coffee flavor. I appreciated the strawberry ice cream wasn't artificially red - more like a strawberries and cream. I order a waffle cone for one of my orders and through it was almost too thick as you got towards the bottom where most bites were waffle and not much ice cream. Very friendly staff always welcoming - I think I got new people each time I went each asking if I experienced Mayday before or if this was my first time. haha read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Sunday Best Banana Pudding in a Waffle Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Doesn't matter which Mayday you make it to. Everyone always has a smile, everyone is always so kind and friendly, never annoyed by the endless sample requests. This is really my favorite place to come. Inside is colorful and vibrant, always plenty of seating. Love the many gluten free, dye free options. Stop in ! read more

So many flavors to choose from! 10/10 service and cute facility. Parking is available out back. No fraps but they do have floats and handmade ice pops. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Cookie Crush Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Amazing creamery ice cream. Queen Salted Caramel is out of this world! Very nice customer service. They take their time and explain things to you despite the business of being down in SAB. read more

Great place for ice cream around the beach. Service was great and helpful which explained the different flavours for ice cream. Got to sample some of the flavour before committing to the bigger size. Ended up getting the Gillespie's bourbon pecan flavour. This one has a great kick of bourbon, so I was glad I got a small one. Overall, great place to grab some ice cream and have a walk around the beach. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Excellent ice cream scoop shop with many unique flavors. Excellent service too!! You can sample before you decide! Limited indoor and outdoor seating. Limited parking in a private parking lot. Close to the beach - you can hear the waves breaking. This is a destination I will definitely return to! read more

See all

First time at a mayday icecream place cool place ,people were friendly,I had a double in a cup the size of scoops are big both were monster mint excellent mint I believe made with Andes chocolate I looked at the vanilla for vanilla bean specks like the old bryers no luck so I passed but overall it was good I would definitely go back. read more

On a hot summer day, this place hit the spot! So good! Cookie Crush: [5] Triple Vanilla: [5] read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This review is of the Nocatee location that has just opened. Datil Dark which is a dark chocolate ice cream with beads of Datil peppers in it is my all time favorite ice cream & I've eaten a lot of ice cream in my day. This is a seasonal flavor only available in the winter months. And this month the pints are BOGO! What joy! Mayday has plenty of other wonderful flavors as well. All ice cream come with a homemade cookie & homemade sprinkles if you so choose. All I can say is I'm so glad we have a Mayday a golf cart ride away ! read more

I got a cookie crush scoop in a cone with the sprinkles. Everything was exquisite. The service was top-tier. They greeted me with a cute little Cheer the KALEO! kids are so precious. Sophie Madison, Anna Marie, Alex, and Dylan were angels. Highly recommend. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Amazing ice cream with lots of fun and interesting flavors! Caleb was very friendly and helpful, he let us try a few flavors before we decided. My new favorite ice cream on SAB! read more