Another day roaming around Saint Augustine - another excuse for a tasty treat! Cafe del Hidalgo advertised artisinal homemade gelato on their outside sign - they had us at gelato! Lots of choices - over 20 different gelato flavors - it was hard to make up our minds! I eventually settled on the Toasted Almond gelato and my wife the Chocolate Hazelnut. This place knows their gelato - it was fantastic. My toasted almond reminded me of my Chicago childhood and favorite toasted almond bars from the Good Humor truck. My wife's chocolate hazelnut was perfect for a chocolate lover. Great spot for a gelato break. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Having just come back from my beloved Italy, to find "authentic" Gelato in St. Augustine was a dream come true. You know its authentic as the color represented exactly what the ingredients were. Pistachio (pronounced Pis-tac-kio) was a creamy tan which it should be. Then a sample before ordering sent me back to Italy as the flavor was perfection. Best surprise was the taste of their Ricotta, Lemon and Basil. OMG!!! I would stand in line to get another cup. read more

This is a cute little restaurant on Hypolita Street right in the heart of Saint Augustine. They feature gelato, coffee drinks, salads and sandwiches. We had checked into our nearby bed and breakfast and needed a light meal to tide us over until supper. Upon our walk we stumbled across this cute little restaurant. We were especially looking for indoor seating as it was a warm Friday and I really don't like eating outside. We were greeted and found a clean corner booth in comfortable air conditioning. We ordered the Mona Lisa pressed panini sandwich which features roasted turkey, lightly melted brie, green apple and raspberry preserves. We split the panini and also split the Hidalgo Salad. The chef brought the food and indicated the salad dressings are all homemade. For beverages we had a nice iced tea and a water. I recommend this nice little independent restaurant if you need a light lunch or gelato while visiting our nations Oldest City! read more

See all

Amazing gelato super nice staff and good atmosphere in restaurant, the lemoncello flavor was also very nice read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - hazelnut chicks ye gelato - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Can't stop going back for the gelato definitely try it good service eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Mango is best flavor in my opinion - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Food was quite good. Our service was horrible, we sat in the restaurant for nearly an hour. The restaurant had switched customers completely twice, not to mention, this place with filthy, there was dust everywhere, and upon arrival there was crumbs all over the floor, all over the booth as well. When we arrived, we were kindly greeted, and ordered almost instantly. Multiple tables around us were being serviced and getting their food within 10 minutes, including much bigger parties than us, we waited for our food for around 45 minutes and had to ask for our order to be made, once we got our check we asked politely if we could remove an item for the awful wait, the server agreed and said she would remove it, and when we asked for the receipt she infact removed nothing. We went to the manager there and talked about how poor our service was and they gave us $10. Not to mention the 6 violations of health codes, and the fact that there's no free refills, seems to be a standard for 2026 but I guess not. We will never be returning. read more

Although their sign and information on yelp says that they are open until 10:00 PM, they closed at about 8:09PM and would not allow us to come in and place an order for some gelato, with people still inside. Will definitely not go back and spend money with them. read more

I enjoyed a small cup of gelato. Server was friendly. This was a nice treat on a super hot and humid day. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Café del Hidalgo has amazing gelato! I was thrilled to find so many vegan/plant-based flavors, and they were delicious. Service was friendly and plenty of seating. A perfect treat spot with plenty of options for everyone! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Must be new owners, group of 5, tried to jip me on two scoops, when I said something they got all defensive, I left, this place was never this cheap or bad. Stay away. They want to argue. read more

Presidents' Day so a lot of people are down here with the day off, walking around, but we literally sat at a table for 15 minutes when finally we made eye contact to the kid who said he would get back to us. Well, we sat there and sat there. Nobody came to us. We finally got up and left. Didn't even so much as take our order. It was a kid and the old man and obviously they were overwhelmed, but at least you can do is get back to people just sitting there. When we first walked in the old man was making sandwiches in the back by the time we left nobody was making any sandwiches and nobody was taking our order. Bye, never again. read more

Nice spot for a little relaxation and some gelato. The place seemed to have changed from last year. Prices are higher than most. I'm not as impressed as previous visits. read more

I got a chocolate frappe and it was delish! Service was great, I think it only took a minute because they were having trouble with one of the mixers. I'd love to go back and try some of their food! read more

I had their Reuben panini sandwich. Big fan of Reubens + not a big fan of panini's = a mixed experience. The filling of the sandwich was pretty good, plenty of meat, more cheese than I usually see, but the bread was disappointing: white, surface crisped just like you expect of a panini, but no trace of butter. Chips and pickle slices on the side. Service was ok. It was nice to be in air conditioning on a hot afternoon. read more

On St George St in downtown St Augustine is the best quaint cafe that serves a variety of coffee, smoothies, milkshakes, gelato, crepes, sandwiches and salads. Today we stopped in for gelato and it was sooo delicious! I recommend getting the medium size and they will accommodate 2 flavors! I ordered the wild berry and grapefruit! My son had key lime pie and mango. My daughter got hazelnut and toasted marshmallow! They had a huge selection of gelato! Everything is beautifully displayed! All blends were A+! I will try the pistachio next time. I observed they didn't add food dyes which is nice. They also had a cannoli creme crepe that looks amazing! There's a nice chill vibe here. It feels relaxing to step off the busy St George and enjoy a desert. I highly recommend as they make everything homemade. read more

See all

Creamy, fantasy-inducing, rich, tasty, dreamy, delightful, mouthwatering..... the gelato here is OUT OF THIS WORLD! It's a tiny place: good for a quick stop (especially for cooling down from the hot FL weather). The owners are very attentive! Try the pistachio flavor in a waffle cone! You'll savor every bite! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - the interior of a restaurant - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

What a magical place with unbelievable magical flavors..... I don't know where to start. Gelato better than in Italy. The owner is making by himself from the Old family recipe of his grandfather and father just unbelievable. You have to try to understand what I'm talking about...... and the coffee straight from Italy Wood roasted no acidy flavor...just pure flavor of unbelievable coffee....a place you must experience when you are visiting St Augustine!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato...omg.... house made from the owner's family recipe.....just unbelievable..... - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

we've been coming to st a for years and they are always friendly and helpful, very good gelato !!

I told my friend I was going to be in St. Augustine for the day and asked her for dessert recommendations. She raved about this place so my boyfriend and I went. It is a mixture between a restaurant and gelateria, and the atmosphere is kind of like a pub! Anyway the gelato WOWWWWWWWW it was so good!! The lady behind the counter was so nice and let us have as many samples as we wanted! I eventually settled on hazelnut because it's typically my favorite and it was everything I wanted it to be!! My boyfriend got the chocolate hazelnut and that was also super yummy!! Another honorable mentions is the pistachio! Next time we're in St. Augustine again, we will definitely be getting more gelato from here!! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Hazelnut gelato - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Stopped in for a hot chocolate and cappuccino. There was a bit of a line. There is a gelato counter inside as well as food. Prices were steep. read more

See all

The Gelato and coffee is like a trip back to Italy!!!! The panini's are delicious. It is a very relaxing atmosphere where you want to savor your food and relax. read more

Stopped in on a hot day for gelato. Many delicious options. They'll let you sample. Chose amaretto. Incredibly tasty and smooth. Prices are reasonable. read more

"An absolute gem! The location is fantastic, making it a perfect spot to stop by. Their homemade ice cream is simply amazing, full of rich flavors and creamy goodness. The Italian wood-roasted coffee is exceptional--bold, aromatic, and a true delight for coffee lovers. On top of that, the staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Overall, a fantastic place that I highly recommend read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Coffee and gelato - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Best gelato I've had in Florida. Taste like I'm in Italy. Love it my niece got the bacio and their Reese's peanut butter cup. I got the bacio, is like baci chocolate and then Nicolla which is like a hazelnut. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato. - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Delicious gelato perfect for hot days in the summer. The service was excellent and the place nice and cool!

So many dairy free options!!! My daughter was delighted to have choices. I had the DF ones too and they were so good. Highly recommend.

Amazing fresh cannoli and gelatos. Friendly staff. Quick service. Great St Augustine shop atmosphere. Highly recommended. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Cannoli - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Not impressed. I get it, that area of St. Augustine is definitely touristy, and I'm a tourist. I didn't feel as if the staff even cared I was there about to spend money in their establishment. The space was dirty and not well-organized. I would have normally just walked out, but I had worked myself into a time crunch and just needed a quick bite. I ordered the Cuban sandwich. It was OK. Nothing to write home about, for sure. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - tables and chairs in a restaurant - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Gotta dust the ceilings, my dudes. Haven't eaten any food yet. Unsweetened ice tea tastes like nothing. read more

Un lugar super lindo, unos sándwiches delicioso, y el mejor helado de mango del mundo

Absolutely love their chocolate gelato. Their vanilla is also anther favorite. Their gelato is homemade and delicious.

Reuben was worse ever! Pastrami on plain white toasted bun. Maybe tablespoon sauerkraut and teaspoon of Russian sauce. Maybe 2 slices pastrami? We thought we'd be served a great Reuben since it was a German restaurant...nah! read more

Pretty solid place to grab a bite. Tried the Cuban and New Yorker both great options. The bread was toasted nicely and each sandwich had good flavor. With such a big party and an influx of customers, the service was a little slow. It took awhile to get our orders in and receive our food. I wouldn't mind coming back to try their other food items when/if we go to Saint Augustine again. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - The New Yorker - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Stopped here for a quick bite before heading. To the airport. Cory was very helpful We ordered the Rock Panini (turkey, sun dried tomatoes Swiss cheese and mustard ) and a Mona Lisa (turkey Brie cheese sliced apple and raspberry preserves) It came with a bag of chips and a few pickle slices. It was a tasty quick lunch. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - The Rock - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Meh.. it was a tad disappointing unfortunately. It's not hard to please me with gelato but there was something missing in flavor here .. I can't quite put my finger on it. I feel like maybe it lacks flavor? Smoothness? It seems a little gritty too which is weird for gelato because you're expecting the smoothness of gelato. I got the hazelnut - which is my go to. It was okay. I did feel like it was a waste of calories though unfortunately. :( My waffle cone was also stale. Which is a big no no. Unfortunately, will probably not return nor do I recommend. It's in a cute area though in romantic St Augustine! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Went on a Monday afternoon, and have to say a bit disappointed with the Cuban panini. The bread was delicious and well toasted, but there wasn't much substance to the sandwich at all. There were maybe two pieces of ham inside and a single slice of melted cheese! Maybe I picked the wrong sandwich, but I really expected a little bit better from a cafe in the heart of St. Augustine. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Cuban - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Wonderful Sandwiches, great Gelato and coffee. Service was good and pricing normal for the current timing. Very casual environment read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - a cut in half sandwich on a plate - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Five stars. Food, service, taste, authenticity. If you walk too fast, you might just miss this spot. It's absolutely worth a stop. Ran into some legit Italians who said this is the best gelato spot in all of St. Augustine, took their word for it, and they proved it right. Bartender is 10/10 as well. Highly recommend the Pistachio and the Stracciatella. Enjoy! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We came here for the gelato and weren't disappointed. The variety of flavors reminded us of the many gelatarias we've visited throughout Italy. I had the ricotta and Nutella combo in a small cup and that's more than enough. Because the gelato was so good we returned for lunch the next day. We shared the New Yorker panini with pesto sauce and it was delicious. I was a bit afraid of the pesto since I've had many bad experiences. But their pesto had the right combo of basil and pine nuts. Amazing. I had the opportunity to thank the chef as he was making the paninis. Go there and don't miss the gelato. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - New Yorker panini - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Fabulous gelato! Large variety of flavors, with many unique. Also serves salads and paninis.