went on saturday as a surprise treat, but afterwards couldn't stop thinking about it. had the coffee ice cream in a waffle cone and all i can say is it's some amazing ice cream! the flavor was rich and im not sure if the cones are made in house but they were perfect! no soggy cone or drippy cone action, everything stayed together really well! 10/10 recommend and will be back read more

This little stop has some good ice-cream and flavors. We discovered this place a couple visits ago and try to stop when we come. Today was the day since we parked in the lot across the street. I typically get strawberry cheesecake and did again but with a scoop of cherry also and a sugar cone to top it off. They have some sherbet, waffle and came cones too. Worth the stop when you are in St Augustine. read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I stopped in here after seeing good reviews on Yelp. I wanted a hot chocolate to walk around with so I could admire the Christmas lights. The hot chocolate was rich and delicious and topped with whipped cream. 10/10. The wait was a little on the longer side. I would love to return to try their ice cream or milkshakes. They had so many flavors! read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Hot chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Great service, convenient location, excellent selection of ice cream, iced drinks and teas/coffees Quaint beach town feel! read more

Castillo Ice Cream - 10 minutes ago, the place was full and the guy working knocked the line out fabulously! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Probably the pick of ice cream options in historical district of st augustime. We tried 4 different flavors. Each of them was very nice. Liked the brownie batter. read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Chocolate and brownie batter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

BEST ICED COCONUT LATTE IVE EVER HAD! We unknowingly walked up to Castillo as they were opening up for the day, during the busiest time of the year. Instead of saying that they weren't open yet, they not only welcomed us in- but were incredibly kind and patient with my kids. Amazing ice cream, incredible service, and kind of ruined any other coconut latte that I'll have in this lifetime until i get back to st. Augustine! Highly recommend!!! read more

After lunch, I wanted to treat my sister in law to ice cream because it was her birthday. I got on Yelp and thought I would try this new spot. We waited roughly 10 minutes to be served. There was one person working on a Thursday afternoon of Easter weekend. But it was worth the wait. They offered 40 flavors as well as coffee. I tried salted caramel truffle and road runner rasberry. It was hard because they were both good! But I went with the rasberry. I ordered my ice cream in a cup. It was creamy and refreshing as it was a hot day. My sister in law ordered black cherry in a cone, and she liked her flavor as well. We sat inside as there are a few tables and a small couch. I believe there was also some outdoor seating. It was nestled back off the street a little. But there was a sign on the sidewalk, so it was easy to find. Stop in and give them a try! read more

See all

Love the options of ice cream, Service was perfect and the lady was nice the ice cream was really good and we got the superman ice cream they even have soda drinks, powerade, Energy drinks and more. read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Superman Ice Cream, Blue Moon ice cream etc... - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Conveniently located, awesome service. Good prices, and yummy ice cream. Inside is cute and welcoming, gives a happy Los Angeles feel. There was no line when I came in, but after ordering the place sure filled up pretty quickly. Good place to give a try. read more

See all

Ice cream was calling and we decided to stop in to take a break from touring before we hit the San Marcos fort monument. The ice cream shop is right across the street and you won't feel guilty about the extra calories walking it all off afterwards. Beware of the names since all of them were really intriguing to get ;) My kids got the cotton candy and the lil' blue panda ice cream while my husband got the banana milkshake. I didn't get anything since I finished off the three of theirs :D I don't got a favorite since they were delicious and the perfect afternoon treat. The friendly service was easy and quick. There are a couple small tables inside that you can sit and eat at. Whether it's rainy, hot, or maybe even cold, the ice cream never disappoints. read more

See all

After eating dinner at the seafood restaurant, my friend and I wanted dessert. There were many places to go, but he pulled up this location in his phone and we decided to check it out. They have so many flavors of ice cream here and it all looks locally owned as well. I am a sherbert kind of guy, so I was happy to find this flavor there. I also found what I called an Orange Creamsicle, which is a mix or orange sherbert and vanilla ice cream. I got a scoop of each in a waffle cone. Rainbow Sherbert: Can never go wrong with this flavor. My go to and I love the taste they had. It was not too sweet nor too tart. It was also smooth and creamy for a sherbert as well. I really enjoyed this flavor. Orange Creamsicle: I forgot the proper name they gave it, but this is how I remember it. The orange sherbert tartness paired well with the subtle and creamy flavor of the vanilla. This was a nice combo. Overall, one of the better ice cream parlors I have e ever been to. I would come back 100% here to try more flavors. read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Rainbow Sherbert, Orange Creamsicle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

What a little gem we stumbled upon! And the ice cream!!!! It was absolutely delicious. Best I've had in a long time. I had the banana pudding and my husband had the cappuccino crunch. I can't say enough about kind owner and her patience for my 3 little ones under 4years old. They can be a lot but she made them feel right at home. Love the array of coffee drinks as well. What a great amount of choices for all beverages she has. We can't wait to go back! read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Small little shack in the hustle and bustle of St Auggie and TOTALLY WORTH IT! A little expensive, but their service is great, the prices aren't the worst, and the flavors and options are top notch! I got an espresso milkshake and it was around $6. So creamy and lots of espresso and you could drink it all thru a straw (versus other places where you start getting that "dry" ice effect at the end of your cup lol). Go here!!! read more

The service is great and so is everything in store! I ordered a divine scoop of cappuccino ice cream, and I'm excited to go back and try some more. The vibes are also very welcoming... It's the perfect place to take a break from walking down the streets of historic St. Augustine. read more

The location is right in front of the Fort. I went with my kids and my grandkids and we all loved their ice cream. The ice cream was absolutely delicious. Waffle cones were very fresh & crunchy. I ordered the coconut flavor on a waffle cone it was like eating sweet coconut cream with real coconut pieces. My daughter got coconut chocolate almond & mint chocolate chip flavored ice cream on a waffle cone . Also the cake batter ice cream was yummy. Grandson got chocolate & chocolate sprinkles in a cup. Everything tasted delicious. The place was small but plenty of covered seating outdoors. Must go back when I am in St. Augustine. read more

Great location, great ice cream! Was very busy there! Love St Augustine to visit and ice cream!

They have the best espresso in Saint Augustine! And del ice cream too! If you love amazing refreshments served in a family business setting this is the place for you! read more

Great place for ice cream and milkshakes. Very nice staff! We will be back to try the coffee!

This is such a lovely place to just stop for some ice cream and a good cup of coffee. Very cozy, I almost forgot I was at an ice cream shop with how comfortable I was. Stopping here every time I find myself in St. Augustine! read more

Castillo Ice Cream - I - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We met some friends here tonight. The kids got ice cream and we were all able to go next door to White Lion and sot where the adults could get beers. Castillo ice cream had a lot of flavors to choose from, with a variety of toppings, and other ice cream treats. It was a cute little ice cream store to stop at on a hot St. Augustine Day. read more

Cutest little ice cream shop! We got the espresso milkshake and it was a perfect afternoon treat! read more

See all

Amazing ice cream!! Very friendly service, and a very cute shop!! I would recommend trying it out!!

Cute family owned business directly across from the fort. I was craving a good espresso and wow did I get one! Highly recommend this awesome ice cream coffee shop. Ice cream was delicious as well. Hold out and go here. Very nice owner. She runs it with her sons. Support small family businesses! read more

Charming little shop with great flavor variety and great service. It's conveniently located on the main road across from the fort.

A great place for a treat!!! Either a cool scoop of ice cream or a pick-me-up of coffee, it's worth the stop!!

The best coffee in town and also they have more then 40 different flavors of ice cream . The real old fashion ice cream place . I strongly recommend Castillo Ice Cream . The place is very clean and the staff is really nice and friendly read more

See all

So friendly! Stopped in after Mother's Day brunch. Be prepared that their serving sizes are huuuuuge. Conveniently located directly across from the fort. read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Their cotton candy ice cream was delish!!!! Cute little spot to stop for a little cool off in between hanging around the town. The trolly has a stop right in front too! They offer different color cones, the kids liked that. read more

Great ice cream selection and very yummy flavors! Very close to the Fort which was convenient after we melted all day in the sun. read more

Castillo Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

My husband & I stopped in Castillo's while we were waiting for our trolley. Everything was excellent, from the super nice girl serving us to the delicious peanut butter milkshake! We'll definitely be back for more! read more

Dude, this place is fantastic. We got three milkshakes here...vanilla, caramel chocolate cheese cake, and brown butter bourbon truffle. All three were superb and use real whipped cream, but man oh man was that brown butter bourbon shake good. It was one of the top five shakes I think I've ever had and I love me some shakes. Both of the other shakes were quite tasty as well. The difference maker here is the ice cream which is most definitely top of the line. There is plenty of competition in this neighborhood for sweet treats, but they are making some quality ass milk shakes at this spot. Will be back for more hopefully soon... read more

Cute little ice cream shop, great coffee as well. Clean, plenty of options and convenient location

We were looking for some treats after a night of food and drinks. The waitress from White Lion recommended this place. They had many flavors of Hershey's ice cream, but played it safe with a waffle cone of Vanilla Bean. My wife indulged with a caffeine free mocha frap. WOW. The coffee flavor. YUM read more

Go to Mayday ice cream instead! I am a local and kind of disappointed. I came in here with my two friends and we wanted to share a banana split. But then we saw the "strawberry dream" option on the menu and the picture showed that it was very similar to a banana split but with different ingredients, so we ordered that instead. Our ice cream came very melted in a cup like a milkshake, NOT like a banana split. We asked to add a banana to make it more like a banana split and she charged us $1.50 for three little banana wheels. Then, we asked for extra cups to share our melted ice cream concoction and we were denied. read more

Its was the best hot chocolate ever in st.augustine they are very friendly and prices was very very reasonable ill give it 10 stars if i could... read more

My favorite ice-cream shop in St. Augustine! So many flavors to choose from there's definitely something for everyone. When it's cold I enjoy getting a hot latte, soo yummy. The employees are always so kind and helpful. read more

The ice cream was excellent. The owner was very friendly, and was helpful by giving samples. The music was welcoming sound of classic 50s music read more

Such a sweet little ice cream shop! Owner was incredibly nice. We plan to enjoy much more ice cream at this location.

Very friendly at the time of serving, excellent ice cream very good with great variety to choose prices impeccable bathroom.

Amazing hot fudge sundae & the staff there is fun & friendly. And can we talk about the amazing view of the fort while you enjoy your ice cream on a hot Florida afternoon? I'm a local & it's a favorite for my family! Thanks Castillo staff! read more