Had the strawberry matcha ice cream and it was AMAZING! So sad we don't live close by, I'd be there all the time. Staff was so nice and the shop is adorable. read more

After a Cuban sandwich lunch we were in the mood for something sweet - and just a few doors down was Mayday ice cream. There was a line, but it moved and our wait wasn't very long. The one complication of the line is that it made it hard to see all the flavor choices with your view blocked. We ended up choosing Triple Vanilla(My wife) and Espresso Chip for me. The few tables inside were taken so we enjoyed our choices outside in the sun. This ice cream was excellent, not your run-of-the-mill typical ice cream. It's advertised as small batch ice cream made with premium ingredients and that's exactly how it tastes. As a sweet tooth satisfier it definitely hit the spot! read more

See all

I went here back in February for the first time. what a cute ice cream shop. clean, organized, sweet girls working here. I am grateful for the vegan options. I had a small kiddie size portion of the dragon fruit and strawberry ice cream. fruity, refreshing and hit the spot. One unique thing is that they have pretzel cones. I would love to come back here. thank you read more

Holy cow is this place good! Tried the ice cream cookie sandwich and you can make it the way you want. You choose 2 cookies (can be the same or 2 different kinds) and your choice of ice cream (3 scoops). This sandwich is a massive piece of creamy heaven! The staff here is super friendly and explain what's in the ice cream as you sample it. For the price, the ice cream sandwich is a great deal! There is usually a line but it goes pretty quick. It's kinda small so you can't sit inside if it gets full but there is seating outside. Probably some of the best hand crafted ice cream I've had in a while! Please come and enjoy a scoop or two and see for yourself! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice cream cookie sandwich (top cookie/First Class Chip, ice cream/ Sundays Best Banana Pudding, bottom cookie/Orion's Triple Chocolate) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

So delicious! I had the honey flavor, and how wonderful. Light, not overly sweet, and great creamy texture. What a treat! read more

See all

Love this place! I found out about this shop through TikTok and decided to try it upon vacationing in the area. Our trolley dropped us off in the historic downtown of St. Augustine, and after lunch we needed something to cool us down from the heat! Mayday to the rescue! The options were plenty, and the service was excellent. They offered us samples to make sure we were happy with our selections! We ended up ordering a flight which Included 6 scoops of different flavors! It was the perfect option for our family to try a little of everything we were craving! From cookies and cream, to strawberry dragon fruit everything was homemade and delicious! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice cream flight ! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

If you know me, you know, I'm a dessert after a meal type of girl. Mayday Ice Cream is a great go to after chowing down on DJ's clam shack. Because I'm so familiar with this ice cream spot I decided to go with my familiar flavor, which was the brown butter chocolate chip. Tim, I believe his name was, he was so helpful and friendly, and letting me know that they were getting ready to launch their spring flavors soon. We had a great conversation while I picked out my ice cream flavor. I forgot my loyalty card, but he was so sweet and gave me a new one and stamped it for my visit. I cannot rave enough of how much I enjoy coming to this ice cream shop, especially when it's less than two minutes from where I just had an amazing lunch. Mayday created the perfect vibes to end an amazing day and it was awesome because it was sunny and 75 so it felt right just walking around and enjoying my scoop! read more

See all

This gem of a place is the go-to spot for ice cream if you're paroozing around town. Super friendly service, clean, and they have a great selection of flavors. So glad we stumbled upon them, as there are a lot of ice cream competitors. Their cones are also delicious! Never knew a pretzel cone existed but now I can say I've had one. We'll be back for another scoop before we leave. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This is an excellent location for dairy free ice cream. We stopped by on the evening of one of our days in Saint Augustine and ordered a two scooper. I was anticipating the scoops would not be generous, but they were so one would've been enough for us. Friendly associates, clean and well-stocked, and great for patrons who have dietary sensitivities. read more

See all

Very Unique flavors of ice cream and great customer service. We tried pretty much every flavor in there. Loved the banana pudding ice cream. Jared they were sold out of the brown butter chocolate chip cookie. Will have to come back for that one. read more

So glad I got to try mayday ice cream, the flavors are just out of this world and high quality. And the toppings omg, they have fresh cacao nibs and homemade whipped cream that I got on my brown butter cookie ice cream and it was such a masterpiece read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Brown butter cookie ice cream with whipped cream and cacao nibs - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We got the Lavender High Tea and Earl Grey flavors and they were so delicious. This place has so many interesting flavors options and cute atmosphere. HIGHLY recommend if you want something new, sweet, and fun! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Came in for my FREE pilot cup for my birthday!! Datil dark is the most delicious and unique flavor only available in the winter months. A lush chocolate with hot datil peppers. So good read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Datil dark - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We found the coolest ice cream shop in the area. The day was so hot and all we could think of was to cool our afternoon off and we were able to do it! Very friendly and patient staff. This ice cream shop had a great variety of flavors, and a great atmosphere. We had great ice creams a lovely experience! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

So many flavors to choose from! My friends and I stopped here when we were walking around the little town. It did not disappoint. Staff made greats recs and let us try a few flavors to decide. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We found Cookie Crush while walking around downtown and this place was awesome! The decor was so cute it felt like you were at grandmas and the cookies were even better! Service wasn't anything to brag about she didn't speak much, nonetheless the dessert was tasty! read more

See all

Mayday is always a stop when we are I town. Every flavor is wonderful and we ended getting an ice cream flight. Palmer was helping up and was very helpful and sweet. We got a mix of our favorites and some new flavors! I would definitely recommend stopping here on your next trip to St Augustine. read more

See all

Yes, the ice cream was excellent, but in what world can you justify the pricetag? I know what goes into making ice cream, and I've had plenty of great-tasting ice cream at ice cream shops for half the price. There were only three of us, but as I was leaving the store, I thought about a bigger family, maybe a less fortunate family, who could never afford to treat their whole family to ice cream here. One scoop of the cone came out to over nine dollars with tax. read more

Ice cream was great the people working there were very welcoming.The experience was so good.The Ambiance was literally like a ice cream shop! read more

Bailey was amazing at scooping my cream I would definitely go back for Bailey and the cream read more

What more can I say about Mayday Ice Cream that hasn't been said before - this place is amazing. From the service to the ambiance, the St. George's location somehow manages to pull you away from the craziness that is downtown STA. I've been loving the espresso chip ice cream as of late, but will keep coming back for their new innovative flavors. Honestly, my favorite ice cream shop that I've tried in a long time, and will keep coming back to this place. read more

Best ice cream on St Geoege Street! Skip the chains and head to this locally made spot. We LOVED all our flavors: Blueberry Toast Crunch Caramel Apple Pie Aviator (Nutella, hazelnuts, biscoff) The Parent Trap (peanut butter Oreo) Blueberry and apple pie were delightful and perfect, aviator and parent trap were very rich read more

See all

I was in St. Augustine for a short work trip and ended up coming here twice! Loved the aviation themed concept, and most importantly...loved the ice cream! They have some unique flavors, but most are plays on your "traditional" flavors. You must get a waffle cone, the perfect complement! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Cookie Crush Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

My favorite ice cream place around the 904 by far and consistently so. The flavors deliver whether it's a classic or new innovative seasonal. It's just so good and once you have it, other places just don't compare. Trust me & try it! read more

Absolutely delightful home made ice cream. So good it didn't matter that it was 44 degrees feels like 38. The salted caramel combined with the banana pudding was amazing!! And you can sample so you know what you want. Bella was patient and helpful while we decided what to order and debated our faves. Can't share a pic. Was too greedy and ate it too fast. read more

This is very very good ice cream. Cute business with lots of good energy. There must be 10 ice cream places within five minutes of the place, but this is the best one. read more

My Ripple Berry Sorbet was beyond words! Very tasteful! The service was 5 stars. They were all smiling, super kind and friendly. They offered us if we like to taste feel free to ask them! They helped us to get what we were looking for...The ambiance was chill and also i saw sitting area outside. Im not sure if its part of their ice cream shop or its for the plaza that they were there! Overall, yummy ice cream and great experience! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Bella and crew were great. Helpful, kind, knowledgeable. Service was fantastic. Food was too.

My family and I loved visiting Mayday today. The staff was great especially Campbell. He was very kind and patient as well as playful with my son. If we lived here we'd come back regularly! The ice cream was so delicious! read more

Kate hooked us up this year and did a great job! Very friendly and helpful. We ate a lot of ice cream this time through. Irresponsible amounts, I'm saying. In the end, Cloud 9 took the cake as foundational in any combination you could choose. We say outside under an umbrella and enjoyed the evening before moving on the enjoy old town. read more

The ice cream flavors here were unique and tasty. I think it might be a local chain since I saw a couple of them around but the ice cream so excellent. We tried the one ice cream with corn I. It and while it sounds strange it was actually good and was the favorite of my husbands. The avatar was my favorite since I love Nutella and biscoff cookies. This was perfect in my opinion ion and not overall sweet. If I was local I would be going to here more often to try all the flavors since the ones we had were so good. read more

My favorite place in St. Augustine! I love the Ice cream and atmosphere here! It's a cute little shop with a ton of flavors, definitely recommend! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Mango Cardamom on waffle cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Delicious ice cream and great customer service. The environment was fun a family friendly. Cam made the visit a delight.

Service was so amazing. Izzy Pinlac is the most amazing employee and the ice cream is sooo good !

Very delicious ice cream! The line was out of the door due to it only being one employee! We thought it was pretty surprising because it was on Easter! Anyhow, she rocked it and we gave her a tip for it. The ice cream was yummy and creamy. I wish there were flavored cones but overall it is a very nice ice cream place with a ridiculous amount of flavors! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

That was our first time in St. Augustine, me and my family got the best icecream so far. Thank You Micah Everything was awesome Greetings from Palm Beach Gardens read more

I came here and had a blueberry crumble ice cream, and it was really good. The only reason why this is not a five star simply because it was crazy expensive for a scoop of ice cream in my opinion as I have gone around to other ice cream shops in the area and they were more affordable. The taste of it was fantastic and sold all the places around here. They have really good ice cream as well but this was just a little too pricey however I would 100% go back if someone else is paying for me to go lol read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Nahlia was incredibly friendly and helpful! Will definitely be coming back. Incredible ice cream too.

Lucy and the staff were beyond Amazing & the Ice Cream was delicious! Highly recommend!!!!

Gisele was great, and the ice cream was even better. Nice rest stop as you explore Old Town St. Augustine. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Pilot with Triple Vanilla and Parent Trap! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida