Cute little ice cream shop with the sweetest woman working. She made our day - we were planning to just stop in and grab ice cream quick, ended up chatting with her while eating our ice cream. My daughter asked to go back just so we can say hi again before we leave read more

I had a great experience at Island Ice Cream Cafe thanks to Kayli! She was so friendly, welcoming, and had such a positive attitude. She helped me with my order, made sure everything was perfect, and made the whole visit even better. You can tell she genuinely cares about customers and works hard to create a great experience. Outstanding customer service like hers is hard to find these days. Kayli definitely deserves a raise for all the hard work and kindness she shows every day! read more

Kaylee is amazing and so kind!! The ice cream is sooo good and it's right next to my favourite beach spot! I will definitely come by every time I'm at the beach now!! read more

great ice cream and great service. Much better deal than going downtown. I wish we found this place earlier in our trip.

Great ice cream. Great service and the environment was really nice and beachy. Ice cream had deep and rich flavor. read more

Island Ice Cream Cafe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Love it. Tasty and friendly people. Went back daily. How can you say no to I e cream during summer!!

Near our beach house. Clean and bright inside. Tons of flavors. Kids got kid size scoops ($5) in cups, filled. Adults got "regular" scoops($6) in cones. Quite a difference between the two sizes. Oddly the kids scoops got significantly more than the more expensive regular size. My "one scoop" of Superman in a cake cone looked like it had been hit by kryptonite. Wasn't close to being round, basically a few shavings piled shakily on top of the cone. It was gone in instants. Meanwhile my kids couldn't finish their cups. Not trying to be picky but $6 for one scoop of ice cream is a bit steep so I expected at least a round shape on top of the cone. Taste wise everything was good, hard to mess up ice cream. read more

Great place for ice cream with the family!!! Nothing flashy just good people serving treats

Patrick served a regular coffee w/milk within minutes of ordering. VERY strong coffee; I recommend asking for 1/3 coffee + 1/3 water + 1/3 milk & LOTS of honey (or sugar), unless you want a straight-up, RockStar brew w/lots of gusto packed into one cup... think 'Truck Stop' coffee... & under $3, too!! Me? I will be ordering their 'Affogato' (espresso w/1scoop ice cream) next time. The freezers are well stocked with LOTS of #IceCream choices with #WaffleCones to cool off in the afternoons. Patrick manages the store for his Pops, John; super nice, friendly guy, made the coffee taste better. (Note to self: When offered a sweetener, TAKE IT!! ) Easily accessed off the A1A, across from #BeverlyBeach, with 2 designated parking spots available, bc summer hasn't quite hit; it's still early in the season. read more

See all

I heard this shop had great coconut ice cream so I had to go try it. I ordered a small and it was a good size. It was bigger than my posted picture as I had already eaten some. They had a lot of flavors but I didn't look carefully because I was all in for the coconut. My husband enjoyed the spumoni. Both employees there were super friendly and they were eager to help and make suggestions. The shop had seating inside and outside and we were able to watch the customers get greeted and served quickly. Most interesting thing was the female employee checked in to see how we liked it. That has never happened to me in an ice cream shop. read more

Island Ice Cream Cafe - Medium spumoni - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Awesome service and a great product! Great value for the price per scoop! Love this place!

This place is amazing!!! Little and tucked in but worth it to go! Owner is so kind and caring. Our 3 kids loved it! Highly recommend!!!!

Great ice cream shop. 36 flavors to choose from. Excellent customer service. It has cool barrels for tables in sitting area.

After enjoying Crescent Beach we decided to stop over for some ice cream, and weren't disappointed! They have a nice selection of ordinary and some not so ordinary flavors to choose from. Service was top notch and we were encouraged to sample anything we wanted. Portions are large -- I had to tell her to stop adding ice cream to my cup to avoid over indulging! I had my first affogata and let me tell you, it was fantastic! The espresso was nice and strong but contrasted nicely with the sweetness and richness of the ice cream. I suspect it will be hard to beat this one, but after eating it I am hooked and am looking forward to my next! We will definitely come back here the next time we're at this beach. read more

Island Ice Cream Cafe - What a nice selection of flavors to choose from! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

I was told that place was a great spot and it definitely lived up to it's potential, Luke helped us out by giving us information about the different flavors and was overall very nice, I definitely will be coming back read more

Great selection of ice cream flavors!! Ice cream was really good and the portions are generous. Friendly and polite staff! Make sure you stop in here!! read more

Went in and place is FILTHY Ice cream glass cases are disgusting as well as all the candy displays in plastic Floors filthy Window and door too I won't order here read more

Because what's better than ice cream and coffee? Island Ice Cream Cafe is a small business in Crescent Beach. When I spent the weekend in the area last month, we not only came here for ice cream on Saturday, but again on Sunday for coffee! The versatility is palpable. The place has character as soon as you walk in. Brightly painted walls and around 20 seats. Thinking back, I honestly can't remember the flavor I dove into, but it was astounding in said moment! Maybe Salted Caramel? Geez Matt, you're getting old... You know how much I support locally roasted coffee, so seeing none other than Bold Bean on the menu won me over completely. The owner told us how the upper management team from BB trained them thoroughly. Totally recommend when in the neighborhood, especially after a classic Florida beach day! read more

See all

Nice little shop that gives great service. Took my 3-year old Granddaughter and she loved their chocolate...but who doesn't!

Such a cute little ice cream shop. The employee was so great and very helpful. She recommended excellent flavors followed by a generous sample! There were tons of great flavors and a few non dairy options. I chose cookie dough and pecan praline and my boyfriend got the gator tracks and fishhawh. The portion size was much larger than I was expecting, no complaints here! Make sure you double check on their open hours before you go. There was a sign in the window that noted March hours being different than the hours posted online. Next time I'm in the area I'll definitely have to stop by again. And hopefully get a good picture before digging in! read more

Service is great. Ice cream is very good. In a nice location to the beach. Will return when in town.

Quaint ice cream shop & cafe. Just opened last week. The owner & staff are very sweet (that's good for an ice cream shop)! Their shop is right on A1A & there's nothing like it in Crescent Beach. Btw - if you haven't been to Crescent Beach - it's worth the drive! Walking into the shop is like taking a step into the Caribbean. There is a beautiful mural that covers the length of the wall. It was done by a local artist & really fits the location. They are currently offering 36 flavors & coffees from Bold Bean! read more

Yummy delicious Stop in for dessert you will be glad you did I was visiting St Augustine and decided to try. read more

The best Ice cream! Cherry Vanilla and black walnut yum!! Good service and reasonable prices! Will be our go to for ice cream.

Delicious ice cream. Small local shop, lots of flavors and toppings. Excellent afternoon stop. read more

Island Ice Cream Cafe - Cotton candy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

This is the best ice cream I have had near Crescent beach. Huge scoops!!! I love the Chocolate shake and Rockyroad ice cream. The staff are very friendly always very helpful. You can also be part of a rewards program and get free ice cream. I highly recommend this place. read more

Stopped in with my Family. Had ice cream, and my wife and I enjoyed an espresso. Place was clean, I cream and coffee we good, girl behind the counter was friendly. She was cleaning and wiping things down behind the counter and it seemed as though she was really taking pride in her work. We will visit this place again. Thank you! read more

My family of 4 (2 adults, a 10 yo, and a 6 yo) got some ice cream here on 4/5 during our Spring Break vacation in the Saint Augustine area. There was a large selection of traditional and unique flavors (I'd compare some of the selections to those offered by Mayfield). The service was great. We took advantage of the small, but nice, seating area they had inside (since there was some rain in the area). We also noticed that they also offered coffee, milkshakes, and other goodies! read more

All 4 of us enjoyed our ice cream. The portions are very generous. Plenty of flavors to choose from. The staff was friendly. Clean inside & right across from the beach. read more

Great ice cream spot in Crescent Beach. Friendly owner, great selection. We'll definitely be back.

One of the best places to get ice cream in the area. A solid selection of flavors and the prices are fair. Limited seating as is the usually case when you have a place like this in a small strip mall area. It is always a stop for my family when we are visiting this part of the state. read more

Good solid ice cream, nice selection of flavors and a generous scoop given the quality cream. Nice little cupcake espresso to boot!

This place says they are open, WRONG!!! They do not open till 8 am and without updating their website makes me wonder what else they miss. Avoid!!! read more

Great mom and pop place with super friendly service! Wonderful way to cool your insides when you step off the beach!

We went here on a very hot day after taking our young son to Marineland. The service was exceptionally good and the ice cream was, too. Their prices are fair. The place was clean which is always a plus. We will be back! read more

Great little spot for ice cream! Had all the normal flavors plus lots of unusual yummy flavors as well as a large assortment of coffee options. Cute and bright inside with plenty of seating plus very clean. The man behind the counter was very friendly. read more

Drive by all the time- looks like an ice cream shop (which it is) but excellent coffee. Uses high end espresso beans with a high end imported machine. If you're up and down A1A, pull into this place. Just south of 206. People working there are friendly and well trained as baristas. read more

We wanted ice cream for our last night of vacation. This charming ice cream shop was just down the road. The staff was welcoming, patient, and went out of their way to make our experience pleasant. The owner even sat down with us and explained how he started this new business and their unique coffee brewing process. The ice cream was amazing, with several options of flavors. You're welcome to, and they encourage you to, taste as many as you would like. This will definitely be on our list of places to stop next time we visit Crescent Beach. read more

Island Ice Cream Cafe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

We stayed at Beacher's Lodge, and this spot was right across the street. It had delicious, homemade ice cream. The service was good. It is open late til 10 pm. We really enjoyed this late night snack! It will be a regular stop when we revisit Beacher's Lodge. read more

See all

The Dutch chocolate was an excellent ice cream, but I've had much better peach than theirs.