Nahlia was incredibly friendly and helpful! Will definitely be coming back. Incredible ice cream too.

There are a few parking spots out front. We went after dinner and there wasn't a long line. So many flavor options available. They have regular flavors as well as seasonal rotations. The Blackberry Earl Grey was great. It had a giant blackberry chunk . $5.75 for one scoop, $8ish for 2 scoops,$10ish for a small flight of 6 flavors. read more

See all

Gisele was great, and the ice cream was even better. Nice rest stop as you explore Old Town St. Augustine. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Pilot with Triple Vanilla and Parent Trap! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

My family and I loved visiting Mayday today. The staff was great especially Campbell. He was very kind and patient as well as playful with my son. If we lived here we'd come back regularly! The ice cream was so delicious! read more

We had a wonderful stop at Mayday Ice Cream. The staff was extremely friendly and happily entertained my son's requests for samples. He absolutely loved the Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie ice cream. Extra points to the young lady who went out of her way to grab me a room-temperature bottled water from the back--a small gesture that made a big difference. Excellent service and a great family-friendly experience. read more

Un ambiente limpio el servicio excelente la muchacha que nos atendio habla español el sabor de los helados bien cremosos read more

See all

Open Christmas Eve afternoon. Lovely staff. DELICIOUS and unusual - as well as the usual - flavors. Hubbie enjoyed his 2-scoop chocolate & salted caramel in a waffle cone I was happy with one scoop in a cup (was able to select 2 flavours for one scoop, so nice for a taster option - real homemade gingerbread eggnog and bourbon pecan ice-cream - delightful, tasty flavours). read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Delicious ice cream and great customer service. The environment was fun a family friendly. Cam made the visit a delight.

Service was so amazing. Izzy Pinlac is the most amazing employee and the ice cream is sooo good !

When it comes to indulging your sweet tooth, "Mayday Ice Cream" is an absolute haven for ice cream lovers. This delightful ice cream parlor offers a variety of mouthwatering ice cream selections, and you're sure to find flavors that tantalize your taste buds like never before. What sets Mayday Ice Cream apart are their creative creations. Whether you prefer your ice cream in a cup or a crisp waffle cone, they've got you covered. Each scoop is a work of art, with an array of innovative and unique flavors to choose from. From classic favorites to inventive combinations, they've mastered the art of crafting unforgettable ice cream experiences. One thing is for sure - you'll never be disappointed with the options at Mayday Ice Cream. Each visit is an opportunity to embark on a delicious journey through a world of flavors, and you'll find yourself returning time and again to explore their tantalizing creations. It's a must-visit spot for anyone seeking the perfect scoop of happiness. Plenty of parking available, the ambiance is friendly. I visited both locations in Saint Augustine and Jacksonville Town Center. read more

See all

I ordered the Brown butter chocolate chip cookie composed of brown butter ice cream filled with crisp chocolate chip cookies and topped it with homemade whipped cream. I couldn't get over both the flavor of the ice cream and melt in your mouth, fresh whipped cream. The sweet girl behind the counter recommended this dynamic flavor. My boyfriend ordered the peanut butter Oreo which he also raved about. A cute little place in the heart of Saint Augustine and a fun escape from the rain. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Lucy and the staff were beyond Amazing & the Ice Cream was delicious! Highly recommend!!!!

Bella and Bee were amazing and helped us navigate the many unique flavors with patience and humor. We took their suggestion of using the Queen Salted Caramel flavor in an affogato and it was delectable. The shop is super cute, clean and air conditioned and makes a perfect stop on a warm day. read more

Hello! I visited this location on Friday May 8th at night and everything was fine up until then. I asked to try a sample of a cookie and pointed at it and the worker was very rude. She stated, "They have names you know". Very rude and disrespectful. Tables were dirty and staff was not welcoming. Would not recommend!! read more

I don't understand the hype on this ice cream shop was very disappointed. Got the flight which included 6 flavors and to say the least an ice cream from Publix taste way better. It's hard to believe these are homemade. Wouldn't return. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Flight - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Our tour guide recommended the ice cream flight. We tried six different scoops; the strawberry was our most favorite followed by the coffee flavored. Our server was very helpful while making our selections. read more

Anna was great! Plenty of samples and yummy ice cream for all! Waffle cone was exactly what I wanted

I was so excited to see my favorite flavor, Andalusia, come back. Stopped in and Jordan happily scooped us a fresh pint. Fantastic customer service! read more

This place is SO YUMMY!! So many original flavors and the vibes are immaculate. Selena served us and she is a bilingual queen who was able to speak to and help out a Spanish-speaker in our group. Will be going back to this cute and delicious place in downtown St. Aug. read more

Adyn was "abrasively kind" and disarmingly accommodating, I have a friend who struggles with sensory issues and he was especially careful with regard to the donut ratio in the "Coffee and Donuts" ice cream! read more

Kate was so so lovely!!! First time at Mayday, traveled all the way from Seattle hehe

The Midnight Chocolate was cRaZy good. Best ever! Get two scoops. You won't regret it.

Shoutout to our ice cream fairy godmothers, Nahlia, Rachel, Darrien at the downtown Mayday for bringing an even better vibe to an already beloved shop. They were so fun, sweet, and had great customer service. I would snag a cone off these ladies any day :) I could probably pay off my student loans with the amount of scoops I have purchased from Mayday, but it's just that good. My boyfriend and I have probably gone through 4 or 5 punchcards in the last year. Choose this place over Kilwin's or Ben & Jerry's if you're not from around here! (My only qualm: Downtown is supreme to beachside, sometimes A1A Mayday gives abnormally tiny portions depending on who is working.) read more

Food: raspberry sorbet 5/5 very refreshing and tastes like a frozen raspberry. Queen salted caramel 5/5 salty and creamy so good. 5/5 Blackberry crisp was super great and not too sweet. Service: 5/5 let our children try all the samples and gave a cookie and sprinkles for free. Ambiance 5/5 it smells so good. The murals are super cute. Clean. read more

Great ice cream! The mint monster is my favorite! Such a sweet treat while walking around St. Augustine. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Nahlia was great and the ice cream was just as good. Would 100% recommend if you are in town.

Kate served my boyfriend and I this evening, she is such a kind girl, and so sweet! Everyone should come here!

This is the absolute best ice cream in the world! The service here could not get any better. Very unique flavors the waffle cones are amazing! Still warm and soft! .. you can tell they are using the best ingredients in the ice cream. The guy's and girl's working here deserve a raise. Absolutely top notch! So if you're looking for an old time experience go to this place. It reminds me of days long past considering the current lack of quality service you have come to expect. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - The absolute best staff ever! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Excellent ice cream, excellent experience! We chose to come to Mayday for ice cream because of the positive reviews about them being Celiac safe and it did not disappoint! Everything was well labeled and Bella was very knowledgeable about proper precautions including scooping from a new container, a glove change, and using a new scooper. She even got sprinkles for my 3yo out from an untouched container. Thank you for a great experience! read more

Well, it was good, lots of options and flavors were good! Had some very unique flavors! We tried the salted pretzel cone, which I think could be good and a great idea, but it is lacking in substance... customer service was great, and they definitely don't skimp on their scoops! Overall, it's good, but I would do a waffle cone instead. read more

See all

Service was great and icecream was tasty. Bella was super helpful and friendly. I would recommend anyone in the St. Augustine area swing by for a tasty treat. read more

A wonderful place to visit when you are in St. Augustine. Palmer and Ray helped me choose the best ice cream to get. I highly recommend stopping here and seeing them. The best customer service! read more

Mallory and the ice cream are the best!!!!! Ice cream was great, and the service was even better!!!!!

Go get midnight chocolate right now!!!! It was so good. Cute little outside area. They were quick!

bailey was super patient and kind! visiting from out of town and would definitely come back.

Yum! Many many options to choose from Including multiple dairy free and even 2 that were 21+! This isn't the cheapest place but prob not the most expensive either. The many options help and you can get dish, waffle cone, pretzel cone or sugar cone. They also offer a few other toppings like sprinkles made in-house! They also offer floats and for $2.50 a shot of espresso over your ice cream! read more

See all

We've traveled all over the USA and tried many ice cream shops Mayday is great, with the best salted carmel ever! And excellent service by Lily!!! read more

Great ice cream! Jordan was great and very helpful! The peppermint ice cream was great.

Went there on a busy Friday night, service was fast and efficient and super friendly. Caitlin assisted me in making two beautiful Sundays for us. Because they were so busy, I thought that there would be pushback because I wanted to order Sundays, but on the contrary, she was super excited and she said that's one of her favorite things to do and it showed because it was made with a lot of care... they were not made in a rush or sloppy. read more

Fourth of July, very hot outside, we ran across this place and decided to stop in. It smells great, instantly makes you want some ice cream. We went over all of the flavors, probably missing a couple, there are a lot. I had the key lime pie, it was great. It's a very busy, friendly, clean little place to stop in for a treat. I definitely recommend it. read more