I have come here over the years for over a decade and have loved it. Except for now....if I could give it zero stars I would. The gelato had no flavor was like mild flavored ice and the cone would not even stay in tact to hold it. Paid $16 for two cones we threw in the trash! May as well saved the money and gotten McDonalds soft serve. So disappointed in this place! read more

So much regret. Walking down St. George, my family needed a break and a snack. After I cleaned the table, I went to order. We ordered some paninis and after viewing the melted ice cream/gelato we decided to pass. The paninis were hot. They tasted odd. .. just so odd. The meat was odd. The sauce. Just overall NO and gross. While waiting on our paninis, we watched other patrons come and get ice cream. They each got some melted ice cream in a little bowl. The bowl was not filled. Each patron was then provided a small "sample size" spoon to eat with. Keep moving. There are so many other options read more

This place has an authentic st. Augustine ambience whilst providing refreshing drinks and delicious gelato. We stopped in for a quick lunch. I had the Mona Lisa panini, and hubby had the meatball panini. The bread was light, crispy and the combination of turkey, Brie and raspberry marmalade was complementary. The gelato is smooth and delicious. Great place for a snack and refreshing drink. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Mona Lisa panini - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We stopped in to kill some time while waiting for a table at Prohibition Kitchen. Rather than gelato which this place is more known for, we grabbed a cafe con leche to try what they had to offer. Flavor was good but waaayyy too much foam. Too frothy for a cafe con leche. Based on review by Jo El, will definitely have to come back to tackle the pint of gelato with a friend or two. read more

See all

First stop of our morning to get our coffee fix and I'm so glad we decided on this gem. Great customer service and delicious drinks. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Affogato - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

One word; GELATO! This has probably been the best gelato that I have ever had to date! I took my little sister here while we were vacationing in St. Augustine, and we both fell in love. This was my little sister's first time ever having gelato, and now she's addicted! Café Del Hidalgo makes their gelato fresh daily, and you can see and taste the difference. The fluffy and creamy consistency will drive you nuts! They have lots of different flavors to choose from, but my favorite was the dulce de leche! Absolutely flipping amaze balls is all that I can say! The customer service is so-so being that this place is constantly packed because it's located in a touristy area of St. Augustine. The lines will be long, but be patient because it's totally worth the wait! And the portion sizes, you ask? Fully LOADED! The employees here will hook you up with a heaping mass of creamy goodness! There are several paid parking lots around the area, but it tends to get crowded in the evenings and on the weekends. Ever since I left, I've been trying to find a gelato place that's comparable in the bay area. Unfortunately, I haven't found a place that tastes even remotely close. I guess I'll just have to wait until I make another trip out to St. Augustine! read more

See all

Amazing coffee and ice cream! They are friendly and there are so many different choices of coffee and ice cream. Café de Italiano. read more

See all

Awesome stop in for cappuccino, mocha latte and a must is the gelato! If you're in the mood for fresh, tasty and creative blend- try the ricotta lemon basil gelato! Delicious! read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Mocha latte - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Went there in the morning to get some refreshments and snacks 5 mins before they opened, and we planned on waiting till shops opened in that section to shop all day there .Sat down outside at one of their tables and a lady came out and put out menus condiments and a laminated paper on our table and went back in. My wife said good morning to which she said nothing. 1 minute later a guy came out and said very nasty like Can I help you two ?? I nicely said yes when are you open 10? He angrily replied not now! Took us both by surprise so my wife said excuse me? He said you both need to leave you can't sit here. The girl that came out told you that but you ignored her ! She never said anything to us. At all. My wife said sorry we sat at your tables! The guy just angrily kept stating he has us on camera and he's going to report us to the city , and we should not have sat there . Another couple we met overheard our conversation after about what happened and said thank you we will know not to ever go there either ! We've been going to St Augustine for over 22 years. Never ever had a bad thing to say about any restaurants, shops , tours etc. Always great service and friendly people. Until now. read more

Café del Hidalgo has a prime location and offers what people want: sandwiches, simple salads, and let's not forget gelato, which is probably its biggest draw. The space is festive, ample enough, and busy but not cluttered or tight. It's clear this is a restaurant used to tourists coming in and out, having quick meals, and fussing over samples of the famed gelato. From a business standpoint, this makes plenty of sense, but it doesn't lend over to the highest of quality control. Indeed, you cannot concentrate on a superb, hand-crafted approach with great attention-to-detail in a place like this. And that's fine, there is a place for restaurants like this one and certainly a town's tourist epicenter is that place, but don't expect the level of consummate service and food found at, say, The Floridian. The gelato is very good most of the time. It tastes very fresh and many flavors are offered. The sandwiches are not as impressive, and seem an afterthought of sorts, even. The service is mostly young, college-aged, kids and they are super-friendly and try to be helpful. Alas, they are not always able to keep up with the crowds: it can get slow here, downright pokey at times. They do try their best, but its seems there is some issue with organization plus the sheer volume of business they contend with here. So, in all, I would recommend Café del Hidalgo for gelato but not lunch or dinner. And not if you're in a rush. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Exterior sign. - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The crepes are amazing. We had the Canoli crepe and another crepe that was filled with taramisu Gelato. They were both so good. I wish we had one back home. They take great pride in the food. I would recommend it for anyone. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Canoli crepe - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Server was sweet, food was hot and delicious and made exactly the way my daughter and I (picky picky eaters) ordered it! The cook brought it out with a smile! Stop by and grab a bite read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - The Pollo Royale - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The affogato is fantastic. The gelato was a bit icy for my taste, but when it is put in a crepe, It is pretty hard to complain. read more

This is a quaint little café located in Saint Augustine Florida. It is on St. George Street, one of the pedestrian streets in the Old City. It was very cool day when my wife and I were there. At least cold for Florida standards. We originally came in to get a café latte. But we saw the gelato. We both had an amaretto latte, and we shared a gelato. It was one scoop of New York Cheesecake gelato, and another scoop of creme brûlée gelato. Everything was simply delicious. This is one of those places where you place your order, pay, and they will bring your coffee and ice cream out to you. Keeping up with seeing Augustine, the Decour inside was, ancient Spanish style. Good coffee, dessert, give it a try. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - New York Cheesecake & Tiramisu gelato. 1/14/18 - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Apparently this place is under new ownership. 3 females, two didn't speak any English behind the counter and one who looked to be possibly a child who partially understood English. They cannot understand you to order. They removed the best selling gelato flavor and the other flavors (4) we tried are gritty unlike before. This is a recipe for disaster. I've been patronizing this business since I can remember, I'm local, and has always been our gelato, coffee and sometimes food spot. I was very disappointed today, I don't think I will be back. Signed a concerned patron. read more

30 minutes since ordering 2 crepes and the order is still not ready. That's on top of having waited 10 minutes after sitting down, to be told that you have to order at the cashier first. I guess you are "supposed to know that" because a tiny sign at the ceiling says "Please Pay Cashier". Not sure how that is supposed to mean I have to order there before I sit down, and sure enough another couple just found out the same after waiting at their table for a while. The server doesn't speak perfect English and that can come across rude. The food itself would get 4-5 stars but the above seriously takes away from the experience. read more

We wanted some coffee at 9pm on a Christmas Saturday. My sis in law found the place in Yelp so we followed. Good place, nice environment. Met our expectations. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Sister in law and mother in law on board! - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Amazing place for gelatos and cafe. Right inside St George St in downtown St Augustine, FL. Great place to take a break after a long walk. Very relaxing place and decorative. Ordered a Stracciatella gelato in a small cup and mint gelato in a small cup. Decent price for a small cup but amazing gelato. I would definitely go for a bigger cup next time I come back (tomorrow since I will be here for a week). read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Mint and Stracciatella small cup gelatos - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Best Nutella gelato in the World. We've been all over the world including Italy. This cafe in St. Augustine has the best gelato we have ever tried. We tried the Nutella and the Pistachio and they were both over the top. read more

Great Cuban. It was fresh and delicious. Friendly and professional service. Thank you!

Absolutely delicious! Ordered the chicken salad except ordered it as a wrap. The Chef put it inside of a crepe wrap....WOW is all I can say. Croutons are homemade and full of flavor, I highly recommend. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Chicken salad wrap. - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Coffee had chocolate in it. Didnt even taste like coffee. Also horrible service , very rude

Food took forever to get to the table we waisted over an hour waiting for food, they charged different prices than in the menu and argued we had to paid for the food we never got because we ordered and they would put it to go. So bad customer service and disrespectful people read more

We spent over an hour waiting for our food and after some food never came we told them we didn't want them and they didn't let us leave without paying what we didn't eat or came to the table, they asked us to call the police if we were not going to pay the whole food(including the one we didn't have) read more

The owner is this place is the rudest person I've ever encounter in a restaurant/cafe. The lady that was bringing my two cappuccinos said it was gonna take few minutes and then I asked how long is few minutes and he said "few minutes is few minutes. It is like I can predict it is gonna rain tomorrow" then he waved with his hand meaning I needed to leave. DO NOT GO. read more

I know people will continue to stop at this place because of its location, but it's not good. The gelato was grainy and just not tasty at all. I've have gelato all over the world and this junk is made in someone's bathtub or something. Grainy, bland and expensive. The guy behind the counter needs a break or something. He needs to step away from the counter, he doesn't care about customers. I asked for a medium then he gives me a small. I ask if it was a medium, he says 'no it's a small just like you asked for.' I take it as a hint from the universe that maybe I only need a small, so I make a joke saying 'I probably don't need it anyways.' His response was like he was exhausted with himself making these mistakes all day. He sarcastically says ' look I can make it any size you want, you just have to tell me.' Well I already had told you guy, you weren't listening and it's honestly ok. Nothing but attitude from the cooler to the register. He could have done something for his mistake, even a simple apology goes a million miles, but nope he said nothing. Overall: junk product and horrible attitude from guy that's exhausted from making mistakes all day. Good luck, I won't be returning and neither will my friends/family. read more

Authorities should close this place. Extremely overpriced, bad service and bad taste galore. It's a shame places like this are allowed to function in the heart of St Augustine. We were a big group and ordered 10 "signature" coffees of different flavors, they took forever and very disorganized, only brought half of the coffees ordered with very poor presentation and didn't even have the size (20oz) that we had paid for. The cups were broken and dirty (see pics). We are never coming back to this place. read more

See all

The gelato selection was great! For the Christmas season, I tried the eggnog. And for something different, I also ordered the black sesame. Both were amazing, creamy, and full of the expected flavor! read more

We stopped here for lunch while visiting St Augustine. Panini's were good. My kids had salad and loved it. Service was good but it got busy and it was hard to get help after that. I think they were short staffed. read more

The manager is rude and condescending, which will make you feel uncomfortable. Also, there was one table occupied at the time so that speaks volumes in itself. read more

My fiancé and I were very satisfied with this lunch stop. The panini's were delicious and it was a nice break from the Florida heat!

What great good! It's a little bistro hidden on the corner of St. George Street and Hypolita Street in St. Augustine. I got the frozen white sangria which was amazing! Our food consisted of the Mona Lisa panini (yum!), a balsamic and pork crepe (yum!) and I had their famous meatball Parmesan panini which was absolutely amazing! I asked for more of the marinara - and recommend getting extra - as a dipping sauce and it was perfect. Such delicious food in this hidden gem! Will definitely be back! read more

Stopped in for gelato on a hot afternoon. The gelato was very good and authentic. The staff was very friendly and the restaurant was clean. read more

I am going to tell you the best kept SECRET of St. George Street: you can get this GIANT PILE OF GELATO for $10! This heavenly platter is usually best enjoyed by a party of 4 or more. They will let you choose TEN flavors of Gelato and then embellish this creamy masterpiece by adding whipped cream, nuts, and fruit at no extra charge. The prices of Gelato as of August 2016 were $4.95 for a small, a large for $5.95 (3 flavors) and a Pint for $9.99. My favorite flavor is their Tiramisu, but I have YET to have had one that wasn't delicious! You can read about it more here http://www.simplystaugustine.com/dining/cafe-del-hidalgo-2/ read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - The "Pint" of Gelato for $10! - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We came here for the gelato which is amazing. The paying system is a little annoying. You come in- taste the flavors then go to a register around the corner to pay if you liked the flavors then go back to the flavors to pick out and order. Super friendly service- let us try there different flavors and the gelato is delicious! read more

Yesterday we had to get our fix of the best gelato I have ever tasted ANYWHERE. This place is a regular for us and I always call ahead to make sure they have my favorite flavor Mango ! They make many many flavors and they will gladly let you taste because, they know wants you taste they have got you hooked( WHICH THEY DO). This is so good I even had some shipped to NC for Christmas I mean its that good! Yes shipping 2 gallons in a cooler with ( What I call Hot ice) was not cheap but, I could not take it any longer! I needed my mango Gelato fix! Its a must stop if in the Old City.. read more

Went here with Family on Christmas Eve. Five of us came in for dinner. After stating we were uncomfortably warm ..The doors were propped open and we were told the AC was broken. Our sandwiches were fine however the salads looked like they used bag lettuce with most of the lettuce having brown spots. The cashier ( young woman ) who claimed to be the person in charge gave me a ticket for 3 small gelato and when I stated there are 5 of us, was told that is 25.00 of free gelato and she could only give me 3 .... How is it free when we just spent over 60.00 on food that was disappointing while tolerating the heat. My family is from north St Johns County and has been coming here for years....The owner should definitely make some changes... read more

See all

Stopped in for gelato last weekend. The best way of describing it is to say it was okay while shrugging. The cafe was clean and the employees were nice. They also make a good cup of coffee. Probably won't go back because there are better gelato/ice cream options in the area. read more

I walked in because of the beautiful ice cream display. It was calling my name from the door. Inside was a nice and relaxed atmosphere with big tables made of heavy antique wood. We decided to have a few scoops. The guys behind the. Iunter were friendly enough and helped us with sampling different flavors. When we were ready to order they sent us around the corner to get in a line and choose sizes and pay. It was s very weird ordering system. We ordered way too much ice cream one cup with two scoops is enough for two to 3 in my family. Instead we ended up wasting a lot of ice cream and money as s small is $6 . In future we will order the large four scoops one for $8 and split it versus $25 . The ice cream was delicious. It was soft. Fresh and flavorful. I ordered the tiramisu and it tasted just like the dessert. Rum cake flavor was awesome. Cherry Garcia was good, lots of cherries blended in . I would pas on the cheesecake flavor. Cookies and cream was very good and soft and fabulous. They definitely know I've cream , not so much how to make the customer experience go smoothly but we will return with our new knowledge and try again. read more

See all

Sample the gelato until you had your winning selections in mind, then go around the corner (slight right as you enter the store) and pay for your selection there, get a voucher/receipt, then return to the gelato counter to get your delicious gelato. My favorite is the limoncello that was tart and sweet and just plain refreshing. read more

Cafe del Hidalgo - Gelato Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida