I absolutely love this place. The food here is so good. I ordered the Eggs Benedict and I was not disappointed, it was delicious! My experience at Pegasus was great, really good food and awesome service. They definitely deserve 10 stars! read more

"Pegasus opened its doors in 1993 at 8610 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY, in Bay Ridge. We wanted a small diner where neighbors could feel at home and take a break from the rush of the city. From the beginning, we focused on simple American breakfast and lunch made with care. Over the years, Pegasus has grown with the community, becoming a steady place for everyday meals and familiar faces." Pegasus is a longstanding landmark in Bay Ridge. I wouldn't call it a diner per se because it is cozy with a few booths and a counter. I would call it a classy coffee shop. The menu has something for everyone: burgers, eggs, pancakes, salads and all the comfort food from home made for you. I had some errands to take care of on 86th street so I decided to stop in; I haven't dined here in a while. Pegasus is not just for Brooklynites, many patrons come from Staten Island and other far away places. As I stood on line I heard " I made a reservation is my table ready?" "45 minutes wait?" and I said "I'll take any seat even the counter" as I was told 30 minutes for a seat. Then, 10 minutes later, three seats opened up at the counter. I found my seat and reviewed the menu; I was in the mood for a turkey burger but they do not offer it anymore. So, I ordered an Impossible Burger deluxe and a cup of coffee. The coffee was served piping hot and it was delicious! Then, my burger came out.TBH I didn't know what to expect. I spread some mayo and ketchup on it and took one bite... delicious! It really tastes like the real thing. The fries were plentiful and also scrumptious. The service was on point: iced water served, coffee cup refilled and love the fact there are extra napkins in the bar to take which I needed. The burger was a little messy but worth it! It is not hard to understand why Pegasus has endured; simple food cooked like a home meal, cozy environment and great service. Pegasus Brooklyn 8610 3rd Avenue 8:15-4:30pm read more

See all

Besides the amazing high-quality comfort foods that are executed flawlessly, I made a new discovery. Yes the food is superb but what keeps us coming back again and again are the staff. We've never encountered a place where all the staff put out such a unique and beautiful energy. It is absolutely magical and you guys are all fabulous. We love you! read more

See all

Cute diner with quick service. You should defintely check them out. Food is filling and yummy. read more

See all

I would take my daughter to a prep course in this neighborhood for the past month every Sunday and I didn't know where to go for the 1.5 hours that I needed to wait for the class to end. So I walked around and came across this diner. The waitress sat me down as soon as I walked in and took my order immediately. I asked for freshly squeezed grapefruit juice. It went wonderfully well my order of eggs with kale. I have to say that the best dish that I absolutely there was the Greek Beeny which was Benedict eggs on muffins and a homemade hash brown. I loved the fresh ingredients and that it came out steamy. I no longer go all the way out there on Sundays but would like to go back at be day for brunch with my family. read more

See all

- extremely fast delivery - great orange juice! - extra hot coffee even with delivery - bacon did not taste freshly made - large wraps - my chicken caesar wrap was just ok - inexpensive prices read more

4 stars plus! Great place, good service our server was nice, food is excellent, prices are fair, it's clean and bean in the Bay Ridge neighborhood for years. They have an extensive menu and specials. You can have brunch as well and the menu should satisfy everyone. We had the Peaches and Cream French toast and also the blueberry pancakes with eggs. The French toast was made with challah bread. It's a light meal and the French toast is a little on the small side. I would have like to if the portion was a little larger.It was made well and was tasty. The blueberry pancakes were the star of the show. I am not a huge pancake person although I felt these were among the best I've had. If you come here on the weekend plan to have a wait of usually around 30 minutes. I would recommend them for breakfast or lunch and will be back. read more

See all

Best breakfast and brunch & fresh, tasty, and cozy! My husband and I have dined in and ordered delivery a few times from Pegasus. It's a small spot with seriously quality food. When the place fills up, they have booth seating which is nice and cozy. If you want to avoid the crowd, try coming after 3 or 4 pm when it's quieter. Their eggs Benedict is my go-to. I love it with a side salad and unlimited coffee refills (yes, please!). My husband swears by their burgers, and we're both big fans of the waffle fries. We've even made it a fun competition to compare burgers and fries with other local spots like Bayridge Diner and The Monk but Pegasus wins for quality every time. Heads up: If you order delivery too close to closing time, the packing can get a little messy. Sometimes fries come without ketchup or utensils, and the bread on the eggs Benedict can be a bit burnt. But I get it they're hustling to close up shop, so no stress. Plus, delivery usually comes straight from them, not a third party, which is a big plus. Tried the mimosa once & it's smaller than I expected, so probably a pass next time. No cash, just Venmo for payment. Delivery: 7/10 Dine-in: 10/10 Staff: 10/10 Food: 15/10 read more

See all

Yummmmmy. Food had flavor and was warm when it came to us. Cozy spot. The coffee was hot. Blueberry pancakes love.

This morning was the third or fourth time we've been to Pegasus. I made sure to take plenty of photos. When we arrived, there was a 25 minute wait for a table. The 25 minute wait turned into about 10-15 minutes. That was lovely! We sat down, were handed menus and about 60 seconds later a very tall, professional lady with a definitive 'get-'er-done'-notion approached our table and asked if we needed a few minutes. Luckily, we did our homework, studied the menu prior to arrival and knew what to order: I ordered Avocado Toast, swap the salad out for House Homefries and a cup of Tea with cream g Sucralose (yesIknowitcancausecancerbutIdon'tuseitmuch) and my man ordered the Kickass Benedict with Coffee. We had about 20 minutes to sit and chitchat before the order was up. Very reasonable amount of time. I coated my House Homefries & Basted Eggs with some Salt & Black Pepper before digging in. Everything was very good, particularly the homefries. They use a bit of green bell pepper in their Homefries, which adds a great differential in flavor. The Avocado Toast - I wish I could be as exuberant with my opinion, but I just can't. The Avocado was super "skimpy". The slice of ciabatta bread that held the Avocado Toast as a 'foundation' was pretty long, and on this bread, there were, at the most, four 1/4" slices of Avocado. ... Umm...? Regardless, the eggs were eggs, and that was that. The Kickass Benedict - from the first visit to today's visit, this has been the ONLY dish my man has ordered and he's loved it every time. Today, I tasted the hollandaise sauce (that gets spooned over the poached eggs). I can tell you that it was definitely yummy BUT! If you can't handle some heat, this is NOT the dish for you. Wooooah baby!! I *think* the entire floor of the restaurant (excluding the guests seated at the bar) is handled by only 1 waitress (the uber-professional one), with another waitress handling only top-off's of beverages, but I could be wrong. Due to the understaffing, we waited about 15 minutes for someone to notice that we were finished, and that we were ready to have our plates removed. We waited another 15-20 minutes before we could grab the attention of someone to ask for our cheque. The total for everything was definitely reasonable. Luckily, we weren't in a rush. It was just a lot of time spent on "waiting". Overall, I'd NEVER rate this restaurant as anything negative. However, I can't say this establishment is "Stellar", either. It's a beautiful restaurant that will supply an exquisite ambience during a 'better-than-average' meal, for a fair price. These are all GREAT attributes. Frankly, I look for a little more than this, in a restaurant. Although I was not disappointed, I unfortunately was not impressed. read more

See all

Such a great brunch spot! Came here with a group of friends over the long weekend. We came early in the morning and we were seated right away, but shortly after the restaurant got packed. They have bar seating and booth seating. Booth seating is kind of small, but we were a group of 5 and we were able to sit comfortably. Staff was nice and attentive. Food was delicious and we all enjoyed every bit of it. I ordered the corned beef hash with eggs which was soo good. My friends ordered huevos rancheros and the breakfast burrito, which they thoroughly enjoyed. The pancakes were amazing, which we ordered to share amongst us. The pancakes were thick, and so fluffy. The food portions were a good size and we left feeling so full. We loved our meals, and want to come back again to try more stuff. read more

See all

Tried the Corned Beef Hash & Eggs, Bananas Foster French Toast, and an Iced Cappuccino -- and everything was absolutely on point! We had to wait about 40 minutes to be seated, and the food took a little while to arrive. This place is always full, so I definitely recommend calling ahead to check availability or ask if they can hold a table. That said, the wait was 100% worth it. The food was delicious, perfectly cooked, and packed with flavor. The ambiance is nice and cozy, with indoor seating only. It's a great spot to relax and enjoy a good meal. I'd absolutely recommend this place for brunch or breakfast -- just be prepared for a bit of a wait! read more

See all

We are here at least once a week! Service is excellent. The owners are helping out. Our entrees never disappoint. Highly recommend - a true five-star gem! read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Kick A** Benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I went here for brunch at 11:30am. When I arrived, I had to give my name and phone number to the hostess. Hence, she called me when a table was available. She estimated it was going to be an hour wait. At noon, we were seated. This restaurant was quite busy. Moreover, there were three people I encountered. The waitress who took our orders. The busboy who delivered our drinks and he set up the table for us. Also, the hostess was the one who refilled my coffee cup. I ordered the Kick A** Benedict. It was different. Typically, it is served with English muffins. This dish had it with ciabatta bread instead. I wish the hollandaise sauce was spicer. The Benedict had a sprinkle of red pepper flakes. I expected "kick a**" to have a kick to it. It was quite mild. The hash brown was ok. I had to add salt and pepper to it. I would come back here to try other dishes. I want to see why this restaurant has such high ratings. read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Outside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The food is good, but the Pegasus is unfriendly to single diners who are forced to sit near the bathroom and watch people go in and out.

Excellent breakfast and brunch spot! We had the brunch Benedict with the spicy hollandaise.. it's to die for. We will be coming back for sure. read more

Pegasus is a place that gets everything right. The kitchen is efficient, the atmosphere is welcoming, and you can feel the attention to detail this establishment puts into everything, down to the silverware (sturdy and feels good in your hand). This family business understands proper hospitality. The menu is not overloaded with options but still provides a solid variety of choices. They stick to what they're good at and they succeed. I ordered the Kick A** Benedict and I was skeptical, but it delivered. The texture of the bread provided a light crunch and perfect mouth feel. The hollandaise sauce was unique and differentiated itself from other Benedicts, so the dish was far from boring. The pancakes were exactly what I look for in a pancake. Perfectly golden crispy outside, soft inside. Not much more to say than they got a simple classic just right. Wait was not too long as the staff here is efficient in serving and providing service. I look forward to my next visit at this authentic, local classic. read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Kick A** Benedict and Silver Dollar Pancakes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I usually go to Mike's Diner but wanted to change it up. The wait at Pegasus on a weekend morning wasn't too bad. We called in advance to put our name to the wait list. Those that asked for a table when they got there had to wait about 10-15 minutes is what I observed. I got the peaches and cream french toast. The flavors were nice but I was left pretty hungry after. I guess I wished there were combos or sides that came with my dish like Mike's Hungry Man Meal. My partner got the Kick Ass Benedict. It was a bit spicy but like its name, it was just a kick. My partner was also hungry after. I wouldn't come here again but the Christmas decorations and spirit/vibes were top tier. Everyone was coming in greeting each other, the bar seats was almost full as well. It was just bustling in there. read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - two plates of food on a table - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'm writing this review purely to beg Pegasus to bring back the breakfast burger with the peanut butter. Everything is delicious, from the fresh squeezed orange juice to the huevos rancheros, to the burgers, but the breakfast burger, which sounds crazy, is my husband's favorite. It was just listed as a special, but it needs to be on the menu permanently. If you ever see it on the menu or as a special, order it! We bring all of out out-of-town friends here for breakfast. Sometimes on the weekends there can be a wait, but there's a great coffee shop, and book store across the street and north a block or two where you can wait until they text you that your table is ready. Becky is also such a nice waitress there. We love chatting with her when we go. read more

This place is hidden in Bay Ridge but offers an old school diner vibe that is super cute and cozy. The staff is super friendly and the food is well priced. 1. BANANAS FOSTER FRENCH TOAST (8/10): This was delicious. If you are feeling something sweet, I would definitely recommend this. It had really great toppings that paired well with the French toast. 2. TEX MEX BREAKFAST BURRITO (8/10): This was a solid choice. It was big and came with waffle fries. It was filling and they did not skip out on what is inside the burrito. 3.OMELETE (7/10); This tasted like a classic omelete. It was good but did not stand out that much. On the weekend there is usually a small wait but most of the time we are seated almost right away. read more

See all

Good food, great service, small place I wouldn't recommend for a party of more than 4 ppl but it's very cute

This place was the best! From the minute we walked in, our hostess was friendly & made all the recommendations. She was spot on! The eggs Benedict was the best I ever had! It had the perfect spice.... And then the bananas foster French toast was the perfect way to end the amazing brunch! read more

Excellent diner! They had a brunch menu separate and every dish sounded good!! I decided on the mesculin salad and added chicken and avocado for protein and good fat. LOL My daughter daughter wasn't feeling well so she had a bowl of the chicken noodle soup and some toast. Service was great. The menu said they only took cash or Venmo, but when the waitress saw me struggling to reset my Venmo password (since I never use it!) she told me she could accept a debit or credit card. Good tip for her! When we're in Brooklyn again we would definitely return. read more

See all

Great food and fast service! Our waitress was very friendly. We got the fresh orange juice, Cheese omelet, and Chicken & pancakes. Every thing was a 10/10! read more

See all

Such an amazing place, especially for brunch. I believe it had a face lift within the past year or so, and it's adorable and cozy. Staff is amazing and attentive - I ordered the Kick A** Benedict and neglected to ask for it without the ham. Either the owner or another waitress took notice and asked if anything was wrong with it. When I explained to hear my mishap, she gave us the bill and had reduced the price! Very sweet and not needed. The good is delicious and it came out quick. The Kick A** Benedict has perfectly cooked eggs and a spicy hollandaise sauce that was to die for. My fiance had the Banana Fosters French Toast and it was absolutely delicious. The bananas were browned perfectly and it was served with vanilla ice cream. Bellini's were too good but very dangerous with how quickly you drink them. Will be back! read more

Good ole spot for brunch. Very lively in there. I waited around 15mins for seats. Staffs are very friendly. Would definitely come back. Corn beef hash and eggs was my go to. read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Quirky, but fun. Expensive, yet somewhat affordable. Eclectic, but not far out. Intimate, yet family focused. Fast, but with some elegance. Tasty, yet needs a bit more off the top. Cute staff, but only one server. Right near the subway, yet it never runs when you need it. Safe area, but near some run down spots. Near the bridge, yet so far away. Cash only, but there are signs that warn you. You will leave happy, yet somewhat forlorn to leave. read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Huevos Rancheros - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great place ! Food was excellent! Service was super! I will continue to go there! I enjoyed the time at this place!

Holy moly. This is my kinda brunch place! Not "trendy", but also well-maintained and clean. Friendly servers. Food is ridiculous. Had their strawberry shortcake pancakes and peaches and cream French toast. Both so ridiculously good - rich, filling, great portions. This place is definitely for people that think of brunch not as a "drink all you can on a weekend afternoon" but as a place to get a big ole plate of breakfast food. No credit cards accepted here; only cash or Venmo. read more

Loved everything about it, it was a real treat. II was new to Bay Ridge and would go back to Pegasus in a heartbeat..

Came by on a Friday morning around 1115am and place was quite busy. Didnt have to wait long to be seated at the bar but there was a wait for the tables. They had dividers between tables and between seats on the bar so it felt pretty social distancy. Sitting at the bar isn't the most comfortable for my height but it's not bad. Peaches and cream French toast- delicious! Love how everything complements well with each other. The whole thing wasn't too sweet either. Kick a$$ benedict- also delicious. The ham that they use is quite thick so that was nice. The ciabatta bread was also a good substitute as it did not get soggy easily. Mint lemonade- its decent for a lemonade but I kinda felt like not minty enough Overall, I had a good delicious brunch read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Kick a$s benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food is delicious, I love to go for brunch with my daughters. Service is friendly and ambiance is great.

Game here for a late brunch today and we were sat within 5 minutes(since they don't take reservations). There was no parking around here, it took about 15 min to find a spot that ended up being only 2 blocks away. We got a short stack of pancakes to share for the table: HIGHLY recommend, they were so so yummy. Also got the breakfast burrito which was delicious and filling, it's served with home fries but I would substitute these out, they weren't very appealing and tasted bland. Other people got the eggs Benedict, and a bacon cheese omelette. Our waiter was so nice and all our food came so quickly. It also was well priced we all paid less then $20! Would return:) read more

Overpriced,overrated,tasteless food.Dishonest waitstaff,asked if their quesadilla or cheesesteak was made with real steak and was lied to,

I love eating here! Food is always so good, from Bfast to a nice yummy salad and many more delicious dishes. Everything is always fresh and the staff is always nice and attentive. read more

Top notch breakfast & lunch spot . Always a line but moves quickly. Great food and excellent service. Can not really accommodate large parties as the booths are either for 4 or 2 people. Fresh squeezed orange juice or lemonade a must ! So may wonderful choices , reasonable prices . Worth the trip and the wait read more

This was my first time at this cozy, family friendly little diner. The food was great and service was awesome, I met my kids and grandkids and they were so accommodating. Great place. read more

The huevos rancheros are good but my Orange juice taste is not good.. more water (ice) than orange read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Orange Juice came with a lot of ice, I don't taste the orange.. more water than orange - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I usually hate Diner food so i never go. My boyfriend wants Diner food so I checked reviews for places near me. We came here and immediately I loved the interior design. It's so cute. This place has become the exception for me and will literally now be one of my favorite places to eat. The service is wonderful and the food was fresh and delicious. I can't stop thinking about it. read more

Pegasus Brooklyn - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I got the kick ass Benedict. It was so good. I wish it was a little bit spicier, but it was still good.