3.9 stars, rounded up. Remains a good restaurant. Service and FoH can vary widely in consistency affecting your experience. Friends, and lots of chefs I know in the area, avoid bc of this specific reason. Diner had my original review taken down when I mentioned this? I usually repost and substract a star when this happens, but Diner does remain close to my heart. It does need to work on the consistency end of things, as with entrees in the $48 range (for real) everyone should know what they're doing. For the most part, they do. Remains a neighborhood fav. read more

A New York institution. I first came here about 15 years ago, and I'm happy to see that not much has changed. I remember dinner being exceptional back then, but this visit was for brunch. The food was very good, and the service was excellent. That said, I remember being even more impressed by the dinner menu years ago, so perhaps a return visit in the evening will earn that fifth star. Either way, it's great to see this New York classic still delivering after all these years. read more

I'd rather listen to Bowling for Soup than Pink Floyd. The experts are often wrong. That's my explanation of why I hesitated to review Diner for months. The Caesar salad was a knockout as was the burger. With the passage of time I can't recall the particulars of the Fitzcarraldo but I liked it. It was priced like one might expect in an ironically named Brooklyn venue but they were generous with the good stuff. Even the bread was impressive. So this isn't my usual spot but I'm glad that more highbrow out-of-town friends chose it. The absence of a formal menu in favor of the server writing down the day's option may be a gimmick, but after a few bites I was swayed. Better to be king for a day than dollar pizza for a lifetime. read more

See all

We came here based on a recommendation from a friend who said the servers are super kind and knowledgeable. They were right, the service was incredible. There is a lot left to be desired about the food. We ordered a burger and it came out almost raw. The fries were burnt, and way too salty. The train car ambiance is fun for a quick drink at the bar but not quite the place you'd like to go for dinner or a date. It is also rather load given the design of the space so it will be difficult to talk to your party while dining. read more

Diner - Grassfed Burger - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food was flavorful and well done. Fresh ingredients, good consistencies, and balanced flavors and original. Limited vegetarian options. Cozy interior, but the concept seemed like...trying too hard to be different and hip...? Why do you make your waiters write down the menu on the table for each group of guests? Doesnt even save paper since those menus are not reused. And honestly, our waiter's handwriting was sometimes hard to read. Also, quite pricey. The crab pasta was $35, the celery root was also $35 (like what?!), the squash was $23, and the Caesar salad (not pictured) was $22. Service was friendly and knowledgeable on the food but slow. read more

See all

Food is really good and the menu experience is quite interesting- I love that they're constantly changing it and I love the farm to table concept.. service is quite lovely here as well. Ambiance, GREAT! I do think the food is a little rich for me though, as a personal opinion. Maybe I just have a lighter palette. read more

See all

This is a cute spot that's cozy and has a good brunch. The menu is really small, so I would look at it before you go just to ensure there's something you like. The burger and the egg sandwich are both good and they have good cocktails read more

Diner - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

solid brunch spot with an interesting menu. was gonna go for the burger but saw the beef tongue hash and was glad i tried it. it was very flavorful and the eggs were beautiful but a bit heavy for me. on the other hand the gravlax was lighter and refreshing compared to lox. service is great and cute interior but seats were a bit sticky. read more

Diner - beef tongue hash - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

One of the most memorable dinners I have had in Williamsburg, thanks to both the food and the incredible service. Our waiter Benjamin set the tone right away. He came to the table, unrolled white paper, and literally wrote out the menu for us, walking us through every dish with so much detail and enthusiasm. It felt personal, special, and set the stage for the meal to come. We started with the crudo, which was absolutely out of this world. Fresh, bright, and paired with the most insane garlicky dip in a little ramekin that we shamelessly saved to dunk bread into after. Next up, the Caesar salad. They called it "robust" and they were not lying. As a Caesar purist, I can confidently say the anchovy dressing was perfection. The sweet corn risotto was probably my least favorite. I expected it to be a little "cornier" (ha) and thicker in texture, but everything else more than made up for it. The brick chicken was a showstopper. However they flatten and crisp that bird, they brick the hell out of it and lock in every bit of flavor into the skin. Absolutely unreal. And dessert. I did not know ice cream could be this sinful. The Wendy's Ice Cream Sundae was unreal. Chocolate, cherries, bordeaux. It was decadent, nostalgic, and had me literally drooling at the table. If you want a dining experience that is both elevated and full of character, Diner is it. Benjamin made the night, the food blew us away, and I am already planning my return. read more

Diner - Wendy's Sundae - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Went for dinner on a Sunday evening and we were able to get a reservation very easily. The restaurant was steadily busy, but not jammed during our visit. The atmosphere is cozy and casual, the music is fun, and the staff seem to enjoy working at Diner. All of which makes this an enjoyable spot. Then there's the food! We shared a Caesar Salad, had a cheeseburger and a pork shoulder over beans and rice for entrees, and finished with sorbet and a cobbler. Everything we ordered was excellent. With the feel and flavors of having been home-cooked just for us. The menu is a little limited, and its best to be in a mindset to trust and take advantage of the kitchen's creativity and expertise. Recommend Diner for a great meal amidst a welcoming setting. read more

Great place. And long counter as well Small menu but everything was delicious and the menu changes daily . Our waitress was awesome Would definitely go back and recommend read more

Very cozy diner near ferry station. Has good brunch but also dinner vibes. Service is great and ambiance is even better. Stopped their for just a hot drink and some dessert-Liked my chocolate cake slice. Will defo return for dinner! A lil towards pricey side though. read more

Diner - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very high quality and fun culinary experience with different menu options nightly. Starwe: Bread butter (great) Meal: Black Bass(unreal) read more

Diner - Black Grilled Bass - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Poor service. Poor food. Good vibes and martinis. Dont get the latke (singular). Was very disappointing

This is one of those restaurants that literally caught my eye as I was walking past. The exterior was interesting and peaking inside, I thought it was super cool. So I just had to try it for myself one day. I had the burger with coke and it hit the spot. read more

Diner - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I literally wish i knew what some of the negative reviewers are talking about. This place was incredible! Our server, Charlie, was so attentive, knowledgeable and welcoming. The food was absolutely delicious. Their menu changes frequently so you can always expect to experience something new and delicious. Can't wait to return. Ambiance was beautiful. Music playlist was on point! Thank you for the wonderful dinner experience. Didn't photograph it but the cucumber and melon salad! Omggggg. A must try! Thanks for the recommendations, Charlie read more

See all

Service is trash. We have been sitting for forty five minutes after ordering and still have not received any food. After telling us that half of the menu is unavailable, the server clearly forgot to put our order in because everyone that was seated after us has been served. The server tried to charge us $20 for a side of bacon and has not offered to reimburse us for the extra time waiting for our food to arrive. Overall, very disappointed with my experience here. The hostess was very nice though. read more

Love it, a neighborhood staple with the most friendly staff and a wonderful vibe all around ...and the burger crushes! read more

What an amazing culinary experience! Every dish that we had was absolutely stunning. For appetizers, we had the beet salad and the country pâté with sourdough, as well as the lamb sausage. For entrées, we had the pork, cheeseburger, and half chicken. For the side dish, we had a polenta with wild mushrooms. Everything was absolutely sublime and cooked to perfection. Warm and friendly service. Tight seating, anything over 4 people will be a squeeze. They are constantly updating their farm to table menu so the next time I go I know there will be something new. read more

I stopped at this place while I was in Brooklyn, my lunch was amazing! The hamburger was delicious and full of fries!!! I would say, a perfect American lunch experience since I was sitting at the counter. I really recommend this place! read more

Diner - Grassfed Burger - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

v cute place. amazing service. called diner to be williamburg cool. not old school diner food/menu. it's new american menu. food was good. drinks were also good. it's a vibe. def recommend trying. read more

Diner - bloody mary - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great service & ambience. Sourdough bread was fantastic, as was everything else. Don't sleep on the butter beans!! read more

Diner - Door - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Diner never disappoints! I love going & camping out in their outdoor seating with my pup whenever the weather is nice. The menu is constantly evolving depending on what's in season - while I sometimes miss ordering something I've liked in the past, I always find something new to enjoy. The burger is delicious, but don't sleep on their salads - their revolving rotation of greens is always amazing & so flavorful. The staff & drinks are great as well! read more

Diner - Grassfed Burger - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Yum yum yummmmmmmm it was so yummy and everyone was so nice! 10/10 def would go back here

Came here for dinner with my friends and I go the catalan fish dish. It had black sea bass in it and monkfish along with potatoes. It was super delicious and great for a cold night. The broth is a white broth but very unique. All the fish was cooked perfectly. We sat outside in the heated dining. Only minus is the table on the otherwise kept the door open making it a bit cold for half the dinner. Plus was they gave you warming blankets which was definitely a nice touch on top of the heaters. The waitstaff was attentive and very nice. This is definitely a neighborhood staple I will be happy to go back to! read more

Diner - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Man that converted whatever it is, is sooo dirty. "Diner" is right... Anywho, the burger was great- I mean truly very, very good. It was a tad messy, but not distractingly so, which I appreciate. If you can get over the W'burg vibe (which I can take or leave to be honest) it's definitely worth a try. Maybe you might even be into their specific brand of ambiance. Too many fries, but great burger, tho'. read more

Diner - a plate of food with a burger and fries - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This was on my list of places to try and finally gave it a go. Overall it was okay but probably missed the mark on my expectations based on other reviews and from what I'd heard of the place. The place is really cute essentially set up like an old school diner with an elevated feel. The service was good throughout the night. Might just be me but I wasn't a huge fan of writing the menu down on the table. Its totally playful and not a big nit but just didn't see the point. Also, the menu is written as the server faces you so essentially it's sideways as you read it. Plus, in a small & loud place it's hard to hear the server anyway as they talk through the items. Food Ordered the burger. One w salad and the other w fries. Burgers were really good. Cooked to order and the sides were both clean. The fries were awesome. Ordered the Caesar salad and I really enjoyed it. Loaded with flavors and liked the larger romaine lettuce style. Two small nits- slightly over dressed and it was a bit too forward on anchovy. Ordered the shisito peppers and I liked this dish as well. Lightly battered and fried and the white sauce was a nice cool contrast. Ordered the lamb steak and this was a big miss. A bit too dry and the dish overall was just underwhelming. The eggplant purée essentially looked like a grayish paste. Felt bad for the person that ordered it at our table. I tried it so I could weigh in on it. Drinks Ordered the chilled Pinot noir on the recommendation of the server and it was horrible. Basically a homemade grape juice. I accept fault for ordering a chilled red. I always make that mistake but the overall wine itself, which apparently is made exclusively for the restaurant, just fell flat. I would recommend the burger/ fries and the Caesar is also a good option. Overall I probably would not go back for dinner at the diner unless I wanted a burger. You see what I did there... read more

See all

I came here for brunch and was very quickly seated thanks to the attentive hostess. The menu itself was very simple with a few dishes that contained common brunch fare such as an egg sandwich or your classic burger with fries. The food was average, not justifying its price point. Their dinner options seem more worth while. Definitely seems like a brunch with an alcoholic bevvie of your choice kind of environment. read more

Intimate and nice ambiance. Sat down within 10 minutes with no reservation on a Friday night around 9pm. Love the booths and the bar seemed comfortable as well. Definitely an upscale diner. The waitresses sit at the table with you and write the menu on the table. Didn't love this as it a bit weird to just sit there while the waitress describes every item on the menu. Although I could see other people thinking this very unique and sweet. She was attentive though which was nice. Otherwise drinks were great, we had a gin drink that was amazing. Food was delicious. The mussels were unreal. read more

Diner - Burger and swordfish. Size comparison but also both were great - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

So very into Diner these days. This is one of the older restaurants in Williamsburg but it is so fresh and cutting edge. They have a new weekly, seasonal menu which the server goes through with you by writing it out on the paper table cloth. The food is exceptional with both classic options and some creative ones for foodies. For someone who gets sick of the same thing on the menu time after time, this is the spot! read more

Unfortunately, not too impressed by Diner. Will be open to go again. The caesar salad has a very strong fish taste, that cannot be removed since it's part of the sauce. Also, the inside of the venue seems a bit beat up; renovations could go a long way. I don't think I got the best first impression, as the cocktails may be the key to the restaurant also. Will visit again. read more

See all

Second time I have been to Diner and treated poorly by the bartender with short black hair. Seems like he doesn't want to be there. Used to be one of the best restaurants in NYC. Guess the employees decide how it's run now. Heard their other place just closed down the street just closed...ouch! Wonder what happened there... read more

For a place that is nautical theme (i.e. the inside of the restaurant is a boat), I thought the menu would be heavily seafood but thankfully it was not. FOOD - We tried to many things here, but my fave was the pork chop ($42) followed by the chicken ($36). The plates are ideal for sharing so bring a group. DRINKS - Cocktails and wines, all about $15. SPACE - The outdoor dining is the way to go. The inside felt too dark. Glad I finally got to try this place after walking by it so many times! read more

Sick spot. Can't believe I've never been. Awesome, awesome vibe inside. Feels like you're in another world. Definitely want to throw a party here one day. Food-wise, eh. Didn't have much to demo but followed waiters instructions on what to eat. Burger was solid nothing amazing even though it's the "house special." The fries were epic though but carbs. Chickpea soup was actually awful. Tasted like straight butter. It was a special that night. And the chocolate cake was fine. Kind of salty that I wasted my high carb meal on it but overall had a nice experience. The staff was anything too special either. Not mean but just not very lively or happy to be working - can't blame them though with those ceilings. Primary takeaway - tons of potential but food and service lacking. Would 100% go back for drinks and to hang though. read more

Diner - Flourless Chocolate Cake - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Yummy little spot! The staff was super nice and the food was great. The restaurant itself is small and cramped, but still lots of seating outside and to the side. It was a little pricey but nothing crazy for NY. read more

Diner - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

What a find in South Williamsberg. A converted antique railcar diner. I can not say enough about the staff from the front of the house to servers and waiters. We had the Caesar salad, stracciatella, swordfish, and the classic cheeseburger. Everything was delicious and well prepared. I asked for a rare, and it was perfectly cooked. Loved the detail of the waiter writing out the menu on the table for us and giving us great recommendations. Because they source different local ingredients based on what is available, causing the menu to shift frequently while also having some core staples like the burger. It was explained that beef and bread are sourced under the supervision of management. It's easy to access from NYC. I took the East-River NYC ferry to South Williamsberg. Also easily accessible by subway, via Brooklyn L or M. I love this place. It's on my list of stops while in NYC. read more

Amazing service as soon as we walked in. Cool place. We basically ordered everything from the brunch menu. Everything was amazing. We got: -egg sandwich -omelette -French toast -beets -Caesar salad -ribollita -burger -yogurt parfait (don't skip this) -she wolf bread and butter -non alc mocktail sunset deck (rly refreshing) So full, but don't regret a thing. read more

Not quite the ambience and decor I would choose if I owned a restaurant, but I suppose some Williamsburg hipsters really like it. I was a bit sad to see that many of the items people have referred to here on yelp weren't on their brunch menu anymore. I wish they had more gluten-free options. The shakshuka I ordered tasted just like canned tomato paste I have at home, but with an 800% price markup. The aioli potatoes were good, but not enough to save the meal. Definitely not worth the price. read more

Diner - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stopped here for a quick bite, saw a customer having the cesar salad and had to try it. It was hugeeee. The sauce backed a punch but it was delicious..I was only able to eat half. I jad it with two servings of crusty bread. I devoured the rest later in the night. The set us is cute. Alot of outdoor seating. Perfect for covid dining and the warmer weather. Inside is pretty small but outside was were it was at. read more

Diner - Crusty bread and awesome salad, so filling - Diners Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Good food. Menu changes daily but we had a buttermilk fried chicken sandwich that was wonderful. Sausage with mustard cream fraiche was fabulous. Everything was great except the toast. Airy, hokey bread had too many air holes but taste was great. Service was great. The waitress with the blonde dreadlocks was funny, attentive and got it right. Decor was authentic complete with old tiles and curved ceilings. Try it, really good read more

See all