Looking for good Peruvian food in South Brooklyn? Feeling a hole in your heart after realizing Pio Pio's Gravesend location had closed? Well, La Chacra will make you fall in love with Peruvian food ALL OVER AGAIN.
My wife and I have been seriously running out of food options in Brooklyn having explored the entire southern part of borough over the past few years together - American, Chinese, Japanese, Italian, Malaysian, Mexican, Russian, Vietnamese - you name the cuisine and we've explored the most popular of restaurants serving them. And with those adventures, there's a whole lot of consequence to those trips, as in an undesired expansion of the belt line.
So, what else was there to explore? Peruvian of course! But with Pio Pio's closing in Gravesend, solid choices were slim, until we found La Chacra's respectable reviews on Yelp. We swung by at around 6:15pm on a Friday evening and, if you're familiar with the area, then you will know that parking is slim pickings all of the time with the plethora of double parked cars on the block. Chances of finding a parking space usually increase on the side streets. The small restaurant was pretty quiet when we walked in with just 2 other parties inside, but while we dined, foot traffic was pretty constant and by the time we left, the restaurant had a decent amount of tables filled.
If you've been to a Pio Pio, the menu here will look just like your classic Peruvian restaurant menu, with the spotlight shone on the rotisserie chicken combos and sides. And, honestly, it's the extent to which most customers will look at the menu, which is perfectly fine because you're really here for the chicken. One thing that customers will notice though and, quite frankly, loveeeeeee, are the reasonable prices. From the rotisserie chicken combo section, ¼ chicken and 1/2 chicken combos were ONLY $9.50 and $12.50, respectively, with a side of either fries and salad or rice and beans. The sides part kind of sucked as customers are stuck with those limited additions and cannot swap them out with something like maduros, which would count as its own separate side. If you came with a party of 3 or 4 OR can just down right eat a horse, there's only one choice you should go with - The Combo La Chacra - a whole chicken, salad, salchipapa, maduros, rice and beans all for just $32! Without reference, $32 might seem steep, but compared to the consensus favorite of Peruvian cuisine lovers, Pio Pio, it's a damn straight steal as it typically runs at $42+.
OK OK, so it's inexpensive, but how does it fare versus Pio Pio's famed Matador Combo? Hmmmm, a few thumps up ... and a few (small) thumbs down. Everything was about on point, but we couldn't help and nitpick here and there. First, the chicken was cut up into 4 pieces (as typical) and flavorful as heck, even the typically dry, flavorless white meat. The white meat was a bit dry, as expected, but if eaten with the skin, it made a huge difference. It was also accompanied by the addictive Peruvian green sauce/Aji Verde, which was (dare I say) unlimited. The salad was probably the most underwhelming item as there wasn't a lot of avocado slices and a few of the pieces that were there had tiny black spots, which was a sign of not being fresh anymore. The salchipapa was excellent. You can't really go wrong with crispy fries with hot dog slices mixed in, however we could have used a little bit more hot dog. The maduros were also great and they gave a nice portion for that, so in a way, it made up for some of the shortcomings. The rice and beans, well, were what they were, but like the salchipapa we could have used MORE.
Overall, everything was solid. Was it Pio Pio? Not exactly, but for $10 less on the Combo La Chacra, I'll easily take it. The Combo La Chacra was great and our only legitimate gripe was the avocado's freshness. The chicken, salchipapa, maduros and rice and beans were everything we could have hoped for here. In addition, the waiter was quick and friendly and we asked for extra green sauce and he gladly obliged. If Peruvian food is what you're craving, put La Chacra close to the top of your list. read more