I ordered this meal for my mother's birthday. We had never tried it. NO WAY Never again. The containers were filthy, they looked used. Greasy finger prints all over the salad containers. And the food was awful! My fish and chips were cold and soggy. The salad was good, hard to mess that up. The service was awful. They forgot my mother's steak, veggies and potatoes. When I called and spoke with Diane, twice, after realizing the steak wasn't there and then a call back to say the potato and veggies weren't there either. Diane was completely rude to me as if it were my fault. She basically hung up on me. We spent 189.00 dollars on the awful meal with totally rude service. I am not much of a complainer I rarely do this, but it ruined my mom's b day meal and I don't appreciate rude customer service. If you don't want to deliver then don't offer it. Please be better. Such a huge let down for my first time trying this restaurant. Hopefully others have a way better experience. And for their mistake I was treated very rudely instead of suggesting to make it better by adding a free dessert or adjust the meal price. Instead I was treated badly, I wouldn't recommend this restaurant at all. Awful...,eat and pay at own risk. read more

See all

Excellent spot! I fully enjoyed my meal of halibut, veggies, and polenta. The service was great and we secured a reservation without issue. So glad we chose this restaurant tonight. I will definitely be back! read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Halibut, veggies, and polenta - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

The food very tasty, They have several unique dishes. Wait staff was over and beyond in helpful. The atmosphere is Traditional.

Came as a group of eight. We had the oysters, crab cakes, and calamari as appetizers. The crab cakes were great and had a nice texture, not dry there were two in an order. The calamari was good as well, the batter was nice and crisp. The oysters were okay, quite small tho, I believe there were five or six per plate. For an entree, I got one of the daily specials, the halibut fish and chips. It came with soup, fries, mixed vegetables, and three pieces of battered halibut. The chowder was good, not salty at all and had good seafood flavor. The fries were nice and crisp and the veggies were veggies. The fish was good. The battered crust was very crunchy and the fish was tender and flaky. I believe the special was around $26. The prices were a bit high, especially for fish and chips, but the food was pretty good. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Halibut fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

Before I explain, I understand everyone's experience is different, here is mine. Sat at table for 5 minutes and were given a half glass each of water. Every other table had a full bottle. Our glasses sat empty until I finally asked for water. Oysters were not served on a bed of ice and were warm.. my kids buttered noodles looked like a ramen soup of melted butter.. we had to drain before she could eat. My girls halibut was served with the same buttery mess. Our soup, which was supposed to come with/before the meal came after the meal by 10 minutes. $$$ ridiculous! read more

If it's you birthday, anniversary, or any reason to have the best food and best restaurant in Eureka Ca. The seafood chowder is the best on the west coast. Skip the salad. A very good variety of fish is always on the menu. Every night they also have great specials, both seafood as well as beef. Great service and the feeling of being in a classy hotel dining room, along we a nice long bar for any cocktails you may desire. They also have a private room in the rear for large parties in private. I have had great dinners with my lodge in the past so I attest to the Sea Grill is the place to go.Baked OystersDungeness Crab Alfredo read more

Fantastic food and service, every time. A great selection of fresh seafood, super steaks, and a salad bar worth considering. We try to have a meal here every time we visit Eureka. Sadly, on our recent visit (a Saturday night, celebrating a graduation), they weren't offering the Fisherman's Combination... which was very disappointing. read more

The Sea Grill is a tried and true fine dining establishment in Eureka. We're in the middle of a pandemic, and still they do not disappoint! Delicious foods, impeccable service! This evening we tried the ahi poke (lunch)... the jalepeño slivers gave it just the right kick. We tried the fish and chips... the fish melted in our mouths, and the house cut French fries were crisp. Scallops, which I never eat, were incredible in a butter wine sauce. Beer battered onion rings and prawns, yum! And the chocolate mousse was divine! Our server was Samuel... one of Eureka's finest! Being in hospitality myself (events), I appreciate exceptional service. What sets Samuel apart from other servers is that he's made waiting his profession... a refined craft... his artistry. Throughout our dining experience I observed him with other guests. He is quick with his tasks, and offers the utmost unrushed presence with his guests with the deepest spirit of service. We feel royal when seated at his tables. The outdoor ambiance is one I hope carries on beyond the pandemic. Sea Grill has set the standard for outdoor fine dining in Old Town! Thank you Holly, the Sea Grill has pivoted in these times beautifully and gracefully... well done!!! read more

What a awesome place!! They have a bar on the side that the second I walked I felt at home! The two girls (this morning I forgot their names) are so warm and friendly. That means a lot to a traveling sales person! They recommended the macadamia Inuit halibut in lobster sauce and it was so good!!! Everyone was so friendly and I will be planning a dinner meeting here because they have the perfect separate meeting room!! Thanks again for being so sweet ladies. See you next trip for the upcoming Coippino read more

On a long drive from WA to SoCal, we decided to stop in Eureka for a night. Looked online at a few dinner options and drove by one and decided to explore more in the area. Came across Sea Grill and it was fantastic! Great service, drinks and the appetizers and mains were delicious. Finished the night with a slice of Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Torte which was really delicious. Glad we found Sea Grill and hopefully we'll find our way there again read more

Amazing food, service, and atmosphere. The seafood is always fresh and they have a great salad bar. The drinks from the bar are always good. This place is an all time favorite. read more

Tonight was my first time here and it was AMAZING. I got a macadamia nut encrusted halibut with lobster sauce special and it was out of this world, tasty and perfectly cooked! It was a bit of a wait but I didn't mind at all, the staff kept me updated on the food's status (the was a sudden rush for this tasty special) and made sure to check in on me - being seated by myself near the bar I didn't feel neglected at all! Great tip on saving a little bread to dip in the fabulous lobster sauce :) I will be back! Edited to add an important detail: best clam chowder!!! read more

Pricy, out of clams which is why we came. CB lam chowder was tasteless and thick like gravy. Waitress tried very hard and was actually running to get our orders. read more

We paid $60 for hardly any food and it was the wrong order to go. I received half an order of chowder, fries when I ordered a baked potato, and not even crab to feed one person even though it's supposed to be a pound. We didn't get any utensils either and when I called to tell them the mistake they just stayed silent and told me they'd be closed for the next few days for a reimbursement. Won't be coming back again. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Crab - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Great atmosphere! 3 of 4 dinners were good. My Ahi Steak was fatty and stringy. I made our waiter aware of it. He comped us a dessert; I felt the meal needed to be replaced by a better quality of Ahi or offered a different meal. For $35 I would have expected a different gesture! Hope to hear from the owner. read more

The food is good but the facility itself is mediocre. It badly needs an interior update. For the price it should be nicer. It also used to have a salad bar that was the best in town but covid took it out and they never bothered to put it back in. read more

3 stars average? Really, Yelp? We wandered into here after a long drive from the bay area. Needed some good food, and since Eureka is a seaside town, why not seafood? Place is extremely busy. We waited for around 30 minutes and the bartender was super friendly. When we finally got our table though, it took a while for the waitress to take our order. We got the grilled artichoke appetizer special, clam chowders, dungeness crab fettucine and grilled salmon with baked potato on the side. The artichoke was lathered in their special sauce while grilling, and wow, what an appetizer! It's gotta be one of the most flavourful grilled artichokes I've had. The red pepper aioli they serve on the side is almost redundant. The clam chowders are pretty decent. Thick and creamy. The mister really really liked his baked potato that came with the salmon, and my crab fettucine is piled high with crab meat, not to mention that it's super delicious. It feels like a very old school American place -- loads of food, rich and creamy sauces. If you like that, you'll like this place. One caveat though, I know they're busy, but the waitresses kept telling you about it. Sure, I understand, but however busy you are, I don't care, I just want a good experience. If you are looking for superb service, Eureka isn't the place to be =p read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Clam chowder - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

My third time eating here over the years and it's always amazing. Will always return when I'm in the area. Waiter was friendly and attentive, food was mouth watering. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Excellent service, fresh seafood and wonderful old world atmosphere. If you are in Eureka a for only one meal, this is the place to go !

I have been here a handful of times over the last few months, seated outdoors. The staff is attentive and kind, and service is quick for being outdoors during Covid. On one of the trips I brought my mom, and she LOVED it. The seafood chowder is excellent (always arriving HOT), and each time I've had the broiled oyster appetizer - super yummy. I've tried a number of items from the menu and have like all of them, with my favorite being the petrale sole. I only have a couple more weeks here, but am definitely going to stop by again before I leave! Added plus - outdoor seating is dog-friendly; my girl Sadie is going to miss coming here when we leave! read more

See all

Came here with my family and the food was amazing! Service was excellence and it was a very cute place. Definitely going back!

Highly recommend the batterless sole and/or scallops. The polenta cakes were amazing too. Everything was priced very fairly - almost too fairly - and the servers, bar, host and bussers worked together like a well-oiled machine. Place was bumpin' so I'd suggest making reservations. read more

Had an amazing dinner for our anniversary this weekend. They were busy but managed to get us in last minute.

Visiting a friend that lives in the area, she highly recommended I try this place and it did not disappoint! Starting with the clam chowder that had the perfect consistency, definitely made from scratch. My husband and I really enjoyed the halibut and surf n' turf. Service was great, I will definitely be returning. read more

Don't hesitate. The food is wonderful and great service. Best meal we've had in years. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Halibut Special and Red Snapper Almandine. - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

The food was terrible place smelled like urine and the drinks were gross the wait staff was cordial

Outstanding food and outstanding service. My only complaint is that they didn't have any rib eyes. So I got the prime rib, not my favorite, but it was still very tasty and serving sizes were generous. read more

Oldest restaurant in Eureka for a reason! Always delicious, every time. Consistent. I know I can go to the sea grill and get a good meal. Attentive staff, and quaint ambiance. read more

This is a very nice restaurant. The decor is old fashioned but the service is amazing! The staffs were so attentive to me, always making sure that my water is filled at all times. Now, let's talk about the foods. Okay, I admit. I went rogue today. Sea Grill means seafood, not steak. But I justify that the word grill could mean grilling a steak so I ordered the ribeye instead of halibut or salmon. The ribeye was about 14 ounces and it was huge. I could not finish it. They cooked it medium rare. That was exactly what I wanted. The outside fat was charred and burnt, and yet the temperature was still medium rare. My only gripe was the fact that the burnt fat tasted like it was lightly soaked in gasoline. You can smell the gasoline fume. Maybe their gasoline powered grill left an odor. It would have been more tolerated if it was charcoaled. The salad was okay. The dressing were nothing special. The key lime pie was excellent. Granted, I am a sucker for key lime pie. Every key lime pie tastes good to me. Overall, I'd I'm back here, I'd definitely come back and stick to the seafood menu. For #Thinsulun fans, there are many green light options. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Not bad of spot for fresh seafood. We both ordered special of the day(halibut), which came with excellent clam chowder, decent baked potatoes and not so good frozen vegetable medley. The halibut fillet were fresh and delicious for $44. read more

The customer service here was epic for humboldt standards. All staff was attentive and catered extensively to the customer. Our waiter, James was cordial, friendly and clear in his menu interpretations. The appetizers were excellent, from the Oysters Rockefeller, the clams and the calamari. Shortly after appetizers and salads, the dinners came out. A great cadence of service. Fish was non-greasy and all fish lightly flaked with just a touch of the fork. The dinner ambiance was warm and open. Though other parties were seated near you, the layout allowed for easy conversations and discussions. This was a refreshing change for our large party from other Humboldt restaurants. read more

Excellent seafood & Stake house. Came here our anniversary. Was not disappointed. Had the crab, shrimp, and stake. , Thank you staff for making my night wonderful. Key lime pie was so good. read more

Just amazing food service and ambiance:) eating here is a must, best fish hand chips :) chowder, soup, clams and scallops

This place is wonderful! The clam chowder was one of the best I've had. The waitress recommended the oysters Rockefeller dinner. I was not disappointed. The food is very good here, and the service was excellent as well! read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Oysters Rockefeller with polenta and vegetables - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

I absolutely love this place! The people who work here are amazing and I really appreciate each and every one of them! The food and drinks are outstanding along with amazing ambience. If you come to Eureka or live here you can't miss this wonderful establishment. Thank you Sea Grill for all that you do! read more

Excellent seafood! Always consistent in their dishes. I love the Salmon, Halibut, Lobster, Ribeyes, and more. I've never had a bad dish at this restaurant. We love to sit in the window, in the bar. read more

Love this spot! Best prime rib I've ever had and the fish is always on point! It's our go to spot.

Excellent entrees and waiter was extremely helpful and gracious with wine choices after first one was disappointing. Clam chowder was too much heavy cream for my taste. read more

Absolutely love the Sea Grill. My husband and I go here most anniversaries. Before Covid my favorite was the salad bar but unforgivably and understandably it went away for the time being. The crab cakes and calamari are our favorites. And if you have room split the Creme brûlée! read more

My girlfriend and I wanted to go somewhere for a nice Saturday dinner. We made a reservation before they opened and are glad we did. They were turning people away at the door. Tonight was one of the first nights they had indoor and outdoor dining to to Covid (we dined outside). I think they were a little understaffed, as the service was a little slow (totally expected). I told my girlfriend the service could be a little slow as long as the quality of the food was not compromised. Our waiter was Samuel and he was running around all night trying to take care of all the tables. He did a great job of taking care of us and of all the other tables. Because he was so busy, I went into the bar to get a drink and met Daisy the bartender. She was doing it all, taking orders, pouring cocktails, clearing tables and working were butt off. Despite being slammed, the service was as good as could be expected and the food was on point. I had the scallops and they were very good. My girlfriend had the snapper and it was good, albeit a bit under seasoned. We both look forward to returning and trying other items on the menu. Daisy and Samuel, you made our evening out one to remember, you both rocked. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California