Went with a group visiting from out of town and wanted somewhere nice and cozy inside. The restaurant looked a little busy, most tables were full but the parties were small. Staff overall were great, and our waiter was very professional. The menu looks really good and as the name implies, there's a lot of seafood options for dinner. Someone got the fish and chips which was pricier than other places BUT it came with FOUR pieces instead of the usual three. I did the Snapper Almandine which was so good so amazingly delicious, I would absolutely eat that again. the polenta side tho was probably my favorite of the night, so crispy on the outside and soft and tender inside, flavor was amazing . If they piled high on a dinner plate and served that for 30 I would take it!!! I'll be very curious to try one of the steaks next time and see how it compares with other restaurants in town that I hear recommended often. The only minor issue was trying to get a replacement water glass after we first sat down because of lipstick print on the glass. I hate talking too loud in restaurants so thankfully the hostess noticed us before long. I feel for the kitchen staff, those oils do not wipe off cleanly and I often wonder how it is removed from cloth napkins. read more

See all

We were passing through Eureka and the hotel that we stayed at recommended this restaurant. We called and made a reservation, which was very easy and walked from our hotel to the restaurant...a few blocks. We were quickly seated and water was brought over and that our server came to take our drink order. They had specialty cocktails, beer, and wine and a full bar. I just wanted a glass of wine, and i did get a glass of wine. However, I would say the choices for by the glass wine was not great. The food however, was excellent! We started with the Dungeness crab cocktail, which was a very nice portion for two. Then we followed with a cup of clam chowder that we shared. We each had a house salad that I thought was delicious. I had vinaigrette on mine and my husband have thousand island on his. He has been on this eternal search for the best thousand island dressing and he swears by this one! We also split tonight, special of Halibut with a white wine, garlic butter sauce, and Shitake mushrooms. It was not only the perfect portion size, but extremely good! We skipped dessert, but moved to the bar for a nightcap where we met a local guy and a few other visitors...it was very fun...everyone was very friendly! If you're passing through and you would like a good dinner, I would suggest this location. read more

See all

This place is pretty nice inside and has friendly service. The food took a bit to arrive. The fresh bread and my drink was good! The coam chowder needed more clams and less cream in my opinion. The dungeness crab fettuccine was disappointing tbh....$45+ for just the most cheap-tasting sauce with bits of crab. I was expecting more richness by using the crab guts....just a missed opportunity to make a great dish! The sole was yummy, nothing too special. Oysters were good and tasted pretty fresh (but I also don't eat raw oysters often haha). Overall, it's a bit pricy and the food is mediocre... read more

See all

Our waiter Samuel was amazing he had been there for 14 years, had wonderful recommendations and was very attentive. Nice ambiance and had that old school feel. The meal was absolutely delicious and we can't wait to go back and try something different. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Grilled Sea Bass with cilantro butter and a grill lemon for a little Smokey flavor - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Longtime seafood restaurant in Old downtown Eureka. One of the best seafood dishes we had. Super friendly staff and excellent food all around. read more

The food was absolutely incredible. I had a crab fettuccine dish and my partner had a special for the night, a macadamia crusted halibut. The quality of the food was seriously up there for the best meal I have ever had. Our server was named Luís (probably spelling wrong) and he was as big an impact on the experience as the food. Checked in multiple times throughout the night, was thorough and communicated well about the menu. The building itself was beautiful inside and all in all a calm environment. Absolutely would come again. Food was not cheap, but in my opinion worth every penny. read more

We had dinner here on our one night in Eureka, on our Pacific Northwest Road trip. The food was good. But you are packed in like a can of sardines and that makes it very loud. Not a date location or a place to go if you need to have an intimate conversation. Because it was so busy, our service was a little slow, but that is understandable when the crowds are so overwhelming. Portions are generous. We were traveling, so could not take our leftovers. But if you plan it right, you can definitely have lunch the next day. read more

See all

As soon as we walked in we were greeted by the owner. She asked if we could wait at the bar as she walked us over to a seat and said she will grab us as soon as our table is ready. The man next to me told me that she was the owner it must be busy. He said she was a nice lady. He was a local. We asked him what he would recommend on the menu and he suggested the beer battered shrimp. I'm not a fan of things being deep fried though. When the owner grabbed us and took us to our seat, I noticed on the menu how much food you get when you order an entree. Soup or salad, I got the clam chowder of course, they were out of prime rib so I got the rib eye instead. I was really sad about that choice since I haven't had prime rib in a while. The meal also came with either scampi, beer battered shrimp or calamari. It was so much food which is nice, but the steak was so chewy. I usually love it when I have to fight a bit for my meat like on a rib or something but not my steak. But it was a great restaurant and the seating on both sides of the restaurant were packed. It was set up for like nice dining on one side and then bar style dining on the other. read more

See all

The food was absolutely delicious. The steak was on spot we had appetizers that were so good. The calamari was not tough. It was wonderful. The service was nice. The clam chowder was delicious and Jeffrey Smoller at the guitar filled in all the empty spots. It was awesome. read more

Food was great. Staff were great. Wonderful old bar with several tables for less formal dining. Highly recommend.

I was visiting Eureka. I decided to try this restaurant. Restaurant gets pretty busy for weekdays. Service was great. We decided to try fried oysters, clam chowder as a starter. It was delicious. Then we had snapper puttanesca and sea grill fettuccine. It was very well, sauces were on point. They give a very good portion for every meal. We had to get a to go box. Definitely give it a try. It is an indoor dinner. It also has a bar area for seating. Plenty of parking available and you can also find street parking. read more

See all

The good, service and ambience were equally exceptional. They have nice beverage and dessert options including after dinner drinks. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Seared Tuna special. - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

Amazing food, solid historical charm and salt of the earth staff. Truly a great experience. Highly recommend

My colleagues and I are in Eureka for work. We've now been to this restaurants twice. The first time we went there we ordered appetizers and drinks and then we each ordered fish. After the apps arrived, we were told that they were out of some of the fish we ordered. We decided to leave after appetizers and go somewhere else. First, the apps were very good. The fried calamari was delicious. This is what brought us back for a second try. The second time, we called ahead to see about availability. They were very nice and told us to come over, they greeted us and had a table ready. We got assurances that all the fish was available - although there were no crab legs. No biggie! We ordered the delicious calamari. So good! We ordered the sauteed mushrooms, very tasty. Two had fish and chips and were satisfied. We both had clam chowder which was thick, had lots of clam, was hot, and very good. Ahi tuna steak was very well prepared, tender, and delicious. Oysters were fresh and very good. We didn't order drinks as it was a work night. But if memory serves the drinks were good the first time we were there. In short, we forgave them for running out of fish. I'm glad we did because we were very happy with our return visit. Go check it out if you're a local or visiting the area. read more

I'm sorry I never take pictures of me food. But we got the calamari appetizer. It was thick juice slices and soooo tender. Lightly battered not too much. And for the mane courses, we got halibut and salmon with a twice baked potato. Let me tell you as a potato lover this was one of the best I have never had. But the Best part of out experience was out server James. He was the single best server we have ever had, and we have eaten all over the country and Europe. Give this man a raise! read more

We arrived on the night before Valentine's with no reservations, but were treated to excellent service. We were seated quickly and they had a musician playing in the waiting area. When we were seated the waiter (Samuel) arrived quickly. He gave us the specials and we ordered drinks. He then proceeded to let us know the specials and give us recommendations. From start to finish the service was impeccable. Each course came promptly, and was delicious. We ordered the steak and lobster combo to share with the $8 upgrade. The service surprised us because it was much better than typical Humboldt service. The only negative I have is the chef likes mushrooms much more than I do, because they were in everything. Beware if you are allergic! Otherwise, I thought the food was delicious. We would return to experience more items on the menu. When in Humboldt county, give it try! read more

Absolutely need a reservation to get into this restaurant. But the food is so incredible! And the vibe is really cozy. It's a very small restaurant, but the service is amazing and everything was very worth the money. read more

Great food! Many choices, Good service, my husband favorite raw oysters. I enjoy fried calamari. read more

The Sea Grill reminds me of the classic Seafood restaurants on Fisherman's Wharf in San Francisco. To me it feels classy and upscale. Had a wonderful dinner with friends. Last night. Even with reservations it took a little time to be seated. Granted they were very full and slammed with guests. Food took a while to get to us but was very good. I had the cioppino with was a little light on fish but had a great spicy flavor. My wife had the swordfish special with polenta. The swordfish was excellent the polenta was not what I'm used to so wasn't to my liking. You want a nice place with good food and good atmosphere visit the Sea Grill. read more

This is a great gem in eureka for a bit of a more upscale meal. The service was great our table never had dirty dishes and drinks stayed filled as well as timing of courses. The main dining room is small but the conversations don't carry and they have a cute bar in the next room also. The only things that weren't 10/10 was the potato, kind of dry but flavor was good and the "sundae" was just chocolate syrup not hot fudge. read more

The Sea Grill is a welcome throwback; a time capsule where the contents are still intact, not crumbled into dust. I guess it's within or close enough to the Old Town district of Eureka. We visited over the fourth of July, when downtown had three nights of back to back festivals. So, a little bit of the block party vibe leaked into this sanctum, but that's fine. I dig oysters, the local Humboldt bay bivalves were top notch- briny, tender. The chowder, as others have noted, as a bit "out there" in that it includes button mushrooms, but I thought they blended into the overall flavor profile nicely. Three of us went with the fish and chips- rock cod, that apparently isn't actually cod, but whatever- again, I appreciated malt vinegar being placed on the table without a request. The fish was tender and flavorful, the battering most excellent. I should also not there was live entertainment: a classical guitar player, who at one point exclaimed "it's time for a SONG"! and then stood up and belted out some acapella opera aria -and then he slammed his drink in salute to the appreciative audience ;-) Just a great time, wonderful atmosphere, professional service, great food. read more

We are traveling through Eureka & stopped at the Sea Grill for some good coastal fare. It did not disappoint! We were seated promptly, and enjoyed the quaint dining room- not too noisy & there was a nice partition between us the the table next to us. The menu had seafood, steak & chicken options as well as some vegetarian dishes. We ordered the fried calamari as an appetizer- it was the best calamari I've ever eaten! For dinner we both had the special for this evening - beer battered halibut fish tacos served with a mango salsa & a chipotle & cilantro type sauce on it. We also had a cup of chowder with dinner that was more "bowl sized" than cup, and equally delicious. Our server, Samuel, took good care of us, made great recommendations for drinks & even told us of some local live entertainment to go check out after we were done with dinner. We will definitely keep this place on our list of "must-eats" for the next time we are in Eureka! read more

See all

Excellent quality seafood and service. Pricey, but worth it. Had Dungeoness crab cocktail. Then salmon entree.

This place has pretty decent food and the service by Louis was exceptional. Had crab cakes to start and they were very tasty. Ordered the halibut which came with house salad or clam chowder. Had the clam chowder which was very hearty, rich and full of clams. Shown is the halibut plate with rice. This plating reminded me of the way food was plated at a restaurant called Anthony's in the 1970s, especially with the side veggies. The ambiance was nice and glad we got in early as this restaurant filled up. read more

See all

Never disappoints! Fabulous food and service. My husband had the clams and I had fish tacos, delicious. James, our waiter, was super attentive and made sure we had everything we needed. Highly recommend this wonderful venue read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Fish tacos, so delicious! - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California

Sat at the bar ,beautiful restaurant and we received excellent service. The food was amazing, the Oysters are the best in town. The Cod tacos super flavorful. read more

One of the best restaurants I ever been to. The original design was preserved and it felt like you were back the time. We asked the server to recommend us some of their dishes and that was perfect recommendation read more

Let's start off by saying we've been coming to this establishment for many years and have had the best memories like birthdays and I was proposed to there. We went this last Friday for my birthday. The service was AWFUL! My daughters made a reservation for 6:30 and they were there at 6:30 and the guy was asking what appetizers they wanted as there were putting decorations up, and he kept asking over and over. Even after they said, we'll order once we are done with the setup and the others get here (we were there just outside door, so they could set up). As we were sitting, the waitress started asking for drink orders. I said, could we have a second? She was already irritated! We ordered drinks and asked for a minute to look at the menu. She takes our order and says people will stay seated in their spots correct? It was my birthday and there were three little kids and they were excited to see me! Yes, they moved chairs, but we know when food comes to have them in their seats. She was so annoyed with being there in general! She handed my food to my daughter and she said, for mom. My daughter is mom also, so she said, thank you, the waitress rudely said, it's not for you, it's for her! We asked for bread, we had a group of 9 and they brought enough for a piece each. The waitress said, we'll have to charge you. We said, that's ok. She NEVER came back with it. She didn't have to do any extra for us we all ordered water, besides the little kids and one bar drink. But we didn't ask refills or anything extra. They did cut my cake for me, but of course they grab it and don't tell you there's a charge. The charge is ok, just let people know. She was just so rude and the guy helping her was so pushy! We had two bills one for $167 and one for $250! She proceeds to say oh the tip is added. I was so irritated, because at that point we knew why she was so rude, because she knew she had her tips already. Paying a $38 tip for 4 people, the service should be amazing! It was the WORST experience! Oh and we had 9 people and had 9 chairs, she literally came and took my grandsons because he wasn't sitting in it, so we had to ask for the chair back! We will never return! The waitress was Paula and we didn't get the guys name unfortunately. I would give 0 starts if possible! read more

The food and drinks are always amazing, the staff is friendly. The atmosphere is perfect for date nights. I love their halibut or cod when they have it on special. read more

We chose to come here cause my grandson wanted his king crab legs for his birthday, unfortunately they were out of them so he ended up with a lobster dinnr, which was not a disappointment to him or us . I called ahead and asked about dress code, as we were visiting and lady said anything goes...to my dismay i felt under dressed when i arrived... The ambiance was very pleasant and peaceful...The service was great... They were attentive and patient... The food was phenomenal as were our cocktails. Definitely will be back! Also i must add that our server Katie went beyond making my grandson birthday dinner, memorable read more

See all

The halibut at The Sea Grill never disappoints! The staff is always friendly and tentative. The ambiance is prefect for date nights.

All the food was consistently delicious and cooked to perfection! Cocktails were great, bread and butter was amazing! Service was perfect and friendly. The Ambiance was comfortable and welcoming. We definitely made the right choice. read more

I haven't been since Covid and I was worried about going back but they are still amazing. The atmosphere and service are warm and comforting and complement the wonderful food. I would highly recommend the Sea Grill for every occasion from date night to casual outing. I was a walk in and they were very accommodating. The Seared Ahi a favorite. The clam chowder is delightful and bread was a perfect compliment. Juan was a wonderful waiter and I can't wait to go back read more

See all

Prime rib was so tuff we could not eat it. Owner removed it and charged me for the over cooked zucchini and luke warm rice. I am from San Diego and really looked for a nice restaurant to have Christmas eve dinner for my sister and I as we have not had Christmas together in 30 years. What a disappointment. I would have not written this review if she had not been so petty to charged me for my sides. I left hungry as I did not get a meal because someone does not know how to cook a prime rib. I could have gone to several other restaurants but came to yours.... read more

What a beautiful find! The food was amazing, the service was over the top! The ambiance was incredible....guitar player turning beautiful music! It was the best restaurant we found in Eureka. Definitely worth a try!! read more

This weekend we visited Sea Grill for the first time. I was very impressed by the aroma in/outside the restaurant. The smell was very aromatic and we were very excite to try out their menu. The welcoming staff she was very friendly. The restaurant has different seating options for dining in. The bar, fine and standard dining, but we were not asked where we wanted to be seated. They also have a party/event area for reservation. The female restroom was clean and comfortable. There is no dress code. I would say formal casual to formal dressing, depending on your event. We were out on a date so we were formally dressed. The mocktail menu is limited, but you could ask them to make something for you. The complimentary bread and butter were very fresh and taste. We were planning on having two appetizers, two main course and one dessert. We ended up getting half of what we originally planed because our server was not attentive as much to us and had difficult time answering my questions about the menu. We order beer battered prawns and it came with salad and baked potato. The salad is crisp and the vegetables were so fresh and we got it with ranch salad dressing. The baked potato was average. The main course was very delicious and cooked properly. The prawns was fresh, large and seasoned well. The side sauté vegetables were salted and nicely cooked. We also ordered the crème brûlée. I think everyone should start their order with this dessert, that's how good it was! I honestly would not mind just coming here for the crème brûlée. It was made with perfection. We love the over all ambiance of the restaurant, I just wish we got better service. read more

See all

The ambiance was awesome. The server not so much. She was seemingly a bit annoyed that we had inconvenienced her with any of our questions and when my 85-year mother was not pleased with her prime rib being more on the medium side instead of the medium rare that she had ordered. It was my mother's 85th birthday dinner and I feel the server should have been more accommodating. read more

Expensive, BUT, my out-of-town family from Marin was paying for it. I had not been there in over 15 years. It was excellent food. The staff was awesome and attentive to your needs. I had sautéed scallops. The margaritas, were good but my homemade margaritas are stronger. I usually never want dessert, but their cheesecake was awesome. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. It was a great experience for my sister who is used to fine dining. read more

Warm greeting at the door, fantastic food and service- highly recommend and we will be back! read more

My girlfriend and I had our date night here. Our server was friendly but he spoke really quickly and was a bit hard to hear him over the chatter in the restaurant. We were in the mood for steak and seafood. They were out of the ribeye, which was very strange especially for a Friday night, so I settled for the filet mignon (medium rare) with veggie medley and a loaded baked potato. My girlfriend also had the filet mignon (medium rare) with veggies and fries. We started with the calamari, which was far below our expectations. It was a bit soggy and did not taste fresh. It tasted like it had been sitting in the freezer and was then microwaved and brought to the table. Our steaks were both over cooked and closer to a medium well temperature. We were hesitant to even pack our leftovers, but I opted to take the leftover steak home and repurpose it. My baked potato was a sad representation of "loaded" and was also very dry. Overall, sure, maybe I'd give Sea Grill another opportunity but it is definitely not at the top of my list and I would've given it a 2.5 for food but our server was kind. read more

Eureka Sea Grill - Filet mignon - Seafood Near Me - Eureka, California