Really good food. Casa Garcia's on a Wednesday night. The food was wonderful. My friend, who is picky about her guacamole, gave theirs an enthusiastic thumbs up. My burrito was loaded, great flavors and plentiful ingredients. Both co-eaters enjoyed theirs as well. Small mishaps. Dishes delivered to wrong diner. Asked for additional water, and never arrived. Nothing major. We got there at 5. They quickly got busy. It was a pleasant, humming environment. The place was painted and decorated well, but the food is the main attraction. read more

Super disappointed, just got home with a take out no rice super burrito and guess what... crap tons of rice. Ugh...

Really nice people and really good food. The new bar is pretty amazing, too. There's plenty of room to park, too, you don't have to drive around the block. read more

Chips and salsa - Fantastic. Crunchy taco - good. Packed full of meat. Barria Ramen - Amazing. Service - Great. We came here because our other go-to Mexican restaurant was closed, and I'm so glad we did. Great food and great service. read more

Casa Garcia's - Chips and salsa - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Ambiance was ok. Server was very prompt, friendly and helpful with suggestions. When one guest had a special request, it was accommodated. The food, a chile relleno, chicken enchiladas smothered in a nice thick mole sauce topped with queso fresco, cilantro, and onions, and a cheese enchilada. Each dish came with very generous servings of rice and beans. Each dish was excellent. We would have them again. Price, we had three lunch plates, and a take home bag of chips, the cost was $41 before tip. I consider this excellent value. We will be back. read more

See all

New Mexican restaurant in Eureka. Bright cheery interior. Good attentive service. Nice selection of beers.. just no liquor so if you were set on a marg.. nope! I had chicken mole sauce was delicious chicken tender and falling apart. Ordered the flair as and they were also tasty Worth a visit read more

The service was excellent. We got busted à la mexicana and it was very good lots of flavor. Also we got enchiladas mineras and they were ok it had too much shredded chicken to my liking. The ramen birria was blend it needed more flavor on the consome but with limon and spicy salsa made it better. Over all it was a decent meal for the price and very good service. read more

See all

We loved this place! They serve wonderful homemade foods. We had homemade mole, tortilla chips (the best I've ever tasted), and homemade salsas, both hot and mild. There's an authenticity here that I haven't seen in a restaurant since I lived in Mexico. The ambiance is very Mexican; basic and not too fancy. The portions are huge which is very American. I had a very good cheese enchilada and a chili relleno that could have been better. Rice and beans were perfect. Often times Mexican restaurants serve undercooked rice and I don't know why. The sopapillas for dessert were perfectly dusted with cinnamon and sugar and drizzled with honey. One order was enough for two. They have an amazing selection of domestic and Mexican been ON TAP! Our waiter was friendly and attentive. read more

I really wanted to love this place. The lady was nice, looked good inside, but I'm disappointed. I paid $17.28 for a bowl of menudo, and while the broth tasted good and it came with all the usual stuff (lime, cilantro, onions, tortilla, and salsa), the main reason you order menudo was almost nonexistent. I didn't realize how little tripe there was until I got all the way home and started digging through the bowl. Most of it was small pieces, with only about three larger pieces in the entire serving. For nearly $18, that's just not acceptable. I was still hungry after finishing it and actually had to add my own chicken at home just to make it a complete meal. I wish I would have checked before driving off..:( read more

Casa Garcia's - Menudo...muy poquito carne - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

Everything was delicious! We each had the chicken enchiladas, one red and one with green sauce and they were excellent. We also had one enchilada and will definitely order again. Our only minor complaint was that the food could have been hotter. It Just needed a few more minutes of heating. The server was attentive and checked up on us regularly. The ambiance was cute and the music was great and not too loud. They have their own parking lot which is needed on Harris. Btw the salsa and chips are homemade and really delicious! In a town with too many Mexican options we think we have a new favorite place! read more

Casa Garcia's - Chicken enchiladas- one red, one green - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

This place has no business being THAT FREAKING GOOD!! lol. I never imagined I'd come find the most amazing chicken fajitas in Eureka, CA. I'm out here for work. No food options catch my eye. Casa Garcia's has good ratings so I stop by for dinner. Robert (that's the name on the receipt) was great. Quick with chips, drinks, salsa. Food came out quickly... and man! This is some authentic Mexican food Definitely come try this place. Also, ask for the spicy green salsa. IYKYK The ambiance was nice too read more

Delicious food hit the spot during a Redwoods road trip with my family. 6 adults and 5 kids and the staff were all so friendly and accommodating. read more

As soon as we walked in we knew we had picked the right spot to eat at. The decor was vibrant and authentic with lively colors and fun music. The service was also excellent and our server was very attentive, checking on us to see how our experience was going. We decided to get the molcajete and it was SO GOOD. Different meats like carne asada, chicken, shrimp, and spicy sausage. It also had nopales, charred green onions, and an unforgettable very spicy salsa. I'm still thinking about that salsa. The molcajete also came with rice and beans on the side. We left feeling super satisfied. Mexican approved! read more

Casa Garcia's - Molcajete - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Very nicely portioned mimosas! I say 4.8 stars! I just rounded it up to 5. Excelente customer service! The place is clean and beautifully decorated. I got a burrito and it was good. I needed a spicier salsa and they brought this little jug of green salsa and it was soo good!! I love spicy read more

Casa Garcia's - Drinks and salsa - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

The Food and the service and the ambience was really good. We'll be going back soon. I had a tamale with green chili and a crêpe with cheese. They were so good. read more

See all

We have visited Casa Garcia twice in a month. Service is fast and friendly. Food is freshly prepared. My husband thought the chile rellano had too much cheese - I don't understand those words. What is too much cheese? On the second visit he had spinach enchiladas which were more to his liking. I had a taco salad with shredded beef and on the first visit, a burrito with carne asada. Prices are quite reasonable. If I had one ask, it would be for hotter table salsa, but other than that, it's a nice neighborhood place. read more

See all

Chili rellanos are great! Great service and food! You should check it out! My second time here and everything was perfect.

The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Would recommend. Just past winco in Eureka

Delicious food & attentive service. We live nearby so this has become one of our go-to spots for good Mexican food. I would honestly say it's the best in town. We decided on takeout tonight & ordered the Super Burrito & the Fajitas Quesadilla. Portions were huge & the flavor was excellent. Can't wait to try more of the dishes here as everything is always amazing. read more

Casa Garcia's - Super Burrito - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

The food was wonderful. The service was not. We waited for an hour for our food. Yes, was busy but I know you can do better.

Food was great and so was the service! Will be going back there for sure when we are in Eureka!

We were spending the day in Eureka and wanted Mexican food. I'm glad we wound up at Casa Garcia's. They have a parking lot, but we were able to park our vehicle and travel trailer on the street. The staff were welcoming as soon as we entered the restaurant. There was a table tent showing a fermented pineapple beverage that we had to try. They also had a variety of beers. The menu has some interesting items, including house made mole and some regional items from Guanajuato and Mexico City that we don't normally see. We settled on the Azteca nachos and La Chantla (the flip flop). The nachos were made with very good chips and generously topped. We ran out of chips before toppings. La Chantla was like a very large, platter-sized, sope topped with beans, nopales, and meat or veg of your choice. It was a big plate that would have been enough for us to share. The server was very nice, and she was flexible about what ingredients would be in our dishes. There is a bar to sit at and a good number of tables. The overall ambience was cheerful. Whether you're local or passing through town, give this place a try. It's a bargain for what you get, and they're nice. read more

Oh so delicious! First time coming here and we're very happy with our choice! All our meals were very big good. You can't go wrong with homemade tortillas. We had posole, enchiladas, tacos, and burrito. Everything was so good! Chips and salsa was good too. Great service! New family friendly place and I'm glad they have good food! read more

This was our first visit and we had a great dinner. The food was delicious authentic Mexican food. My boyfriend got the costillas which were so good. I got mole enchiladas with beef. We also ordered a cup size of pozole, this was honestly my favorite dish from everything we ordered. The salsa that was brought with the chips was amazing! We couldn't stop talking about it. We will most definitely be coming back. read more

Casa Garcia's - Costillas - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

My new go to spot. Great service and delicious food with a welcoming family atmosphere!

My wife and I ate lunch here today. Wow! Very clean, good vibe (even early in the day when we went), and friendly, attentive service. I had the Cochinita pibil tacos (a slow roasted pork) with habanero and pickled red onion while my wife had the Birria tacos. Both popped with flavor and were excellent. Normally I struggle to find truly spicy food at restaurants but the habanero here did the job. They have a full bar which we didn't try today due to it being early and my being on call for work. But we'll definitely be back to try. Safe to say we've found our new Mexican spot in Eureka! read more

We just had an amazing first dining experience here. The food is obviously homemade and super flavorful. Our service was sweet and timely. We'll becoming here on the regular!! read more

The service was great, the staff was so kind and attentive. The ambience is very clean and lively. It's a very cute place I tried really hard to like it and even took some decent pictures but...but.... The food was absolutely terrible. It's the worst Mexican food I have ever had. From the salsa, to the drinks to the main dish. Everything tasted so bad. No flavor. The meat was slimy (I got sick) and the pozole was so dry and flavorless. read more

Casa Garcia's - Steak ranchero - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

Amazing place to eat! Delicious food and drinks. Plus the service is amazing with friendly people!

Food, service and ambiance was fantastic! Will definitely be going back. Server was very polite and actually seemed to truly enjoy his job. Hard to find that these days. read more

New lively restaurant that offers delicious traditional Mexican food as well as Cajun Seafood Boil! Full bar with beer on tap as well as bottles and a wine selection. Ample seating and attentive staff. Plenty of parking available. This will definitely become a regular stop for me. read more

See all

Such an epic gem in Eureka! The chicken mole enchiladas were so bomb, the wet burrito was delicious. Chicken tinga tostada was super yum. My dad got the garlic shrimp and it was bomb. Love the family vibe, they were super friendly and good service. And the flan!!! It was super creamy and rich, and my daughter licked the plate clean! Come check them out! read more

Food was excellent! Service was great and Server was personable! Will come again next time I am in Humboldt! Thanks.

The food was delicious, the staff were constantly checking in on you, and this whole place was beautifully decorated with lively music. I would definitely recommend!! I ate the carne asada plate with their special green pozole read more

Casa Garcia's - Traditional Carne Asada - Mexican Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

The service here is amazing. They were very nice and helpful with my order! I ordered for pick up and offered water while I waited.

Without a doubt the best Mexican food I've had in Humboldt. I got the mole burrito and it was phenomenal

Hubby's dinner salad was served with his dinner (should have been served prior with time to enjoy). One large 12" tortilla to scoop his chili verde into to eat instead of several smaller ones. The cheese in my cheese enchiladas were not melted. The enchilada sauce was not to my liking. We travel quite a bit in our travel trailer and always choose a Mexican restaurant wherever we are camped, this one was a bad choice. read more

My wife had a taco and enchilada and I had fish tacos. Everything was fresh and delicious. Not your ordinary Mexican food. Highly recommend. Service was fast friendly. read more

We went yesterday, Sunday evening at 5 o'clock. It was beautiful. The place is beautiful and lively, and there are a few people there. It's only their second day I had the mole enchilada chicken enchiladas was the best mole I've had in a long time. We really enjoyed the food. We enjoyed the service. It's a family place. It's just lovely. read more