Flaming cheese and hummus were excellent. Greek chicken, Lamb chops, and,Mousska were fantastic. Ann our waitress was friendly and knowledgeable about their dishes. Great value and good service. Will come back read more

Anyone who knows me knows that one of my favorite places in Florida is St. Augustine specifically the historical part of the city. I love the street lined with vendors, I love the "Oldest in America" buildings, I love the history. However, I also love the eclectic array of food it has. From historical fare given a modern twist to more specific preferences, there are just so many choices to choose from. However, there seems to be one place (well one I know of) that serves Greek or Mediterranean food: Cafe Athena. I am happy to say they do a great job in their fare. The restaurant is located north side of the park in the midst of historical St. Augustine, at the end of the main street. It is a quaint little place and easy to spot thanks to the employee standing outside handing out pamphlets promoting the place. As for the restaurant itself, it is a quaint establishment with elements promoting the Greek and Mediterranean areas. Do mind there is a bit of a decline near the entrance especially for those in wheelchairs. Where Cafe Athena stands out is the food. It isn't the most beautiful looking plates of food you've ever seen but they are delicious. My family started out with an appetizer we always try out: calamari. To be frank, it was good but given our experience eating calamari everywhere, it was not the best but surely not the worst. As for what I had for lunch, I had the roasted lamb. Once again, no decorum but it was really good. The lamb was tender and juicy and the sides were cooked well. Also, I could tell it was cooked from scratch, a huge plus in my book. Overall, a good place to go if you want your Greek or Mediterranean food in St. Augustine. The prices are moderate (by Yelp standards) as the major dishes are $10 to $30. Appetizers and breakfast food however are generally under $10 so take that into account. Summarized, if I ever decide to eat Greek or Mediterranean food in St. Augustine again, I will go here. But to be frank, it may take awhile because the area has a lot of restaurants and well... I like to keep my Elite status strong you know. :D read more

See all

Went here for lunch last week. My friends ordered gyros. I had the baked chicken. My portion was very large. It was almost half of a chicken ! Baked, with sides of veggies and potatoes. Those potatoes were amazing. I wish I had taken pictures. I will definitely dine here again. It's pricey but we loved it. read more

Looking for a quick, easy dine-in restaurant, we found Cafe Athena at the heart of Saint Augustine. It is located right off the A1A bridge, about four shops down from the first one. Parking can be difficult to find around the restaurant depending on time and day. I believe it is metered parking but free after some point of time. We were seated quickly once we arrived with our waiter coming with the menu and drinks. There are tables in the middle with about 6 booths at both sides of the restaurant. FOOD: Gyro Greek Combo (3/5): Gyro was slightly on the dry side. There were plenty of gyro slices layered above the pita bread. The Greek salad took about half of the plate, which was pretty good in my opinion. The thing that threw me off was the Tzatziki sauce that was included in this dish. It was more of a sour cream like taste for me, so I avoided the sauce after my first bite for lunch that time. Gyro Sandwich (4/5): The gyro was much better this time, for it was delicious! Vegetables in this were very fresh as well. I devoured this whole thing. If you are looking for gyro dishes, I would order this dish instead of the Gyro Greek Combo. They are essentially the same thing but served differently without the sides. If you are looking for a Greek salad option, then order the one above. Otherwise, you can order the Gyro Sandwich with a side of fries for an additional cost. Service was like how everyone else stated. Our first time there, service was on the better side with water drinks available for to-go because we were the only table dining at the time. My recent visit at Cafe Athena was decent on a Sunday, which means more families/patrons within the restaurant. My water was down twice and had to ask both times for a refill. Overall, I like Greek cuisine. Is this the best? No, but it is a nice spot to dine in Saint Augustine if you are looking for some Greek. I know there are few other Greek spots throughout this great city though. read more

Athena Restaurant - Gyro Greek Combo - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Walking around in the old City looking for something to eat. This is when we remembered this place. It was a while since we had Greek. Looking in, the place was mostly empty. But the hostess welcomed us in. Shortly after us, several different groups came in. Were we the trend setter? Was it my check in on Yelp? LOL Overall, this was a good choice. The food was hot and tasty. Definitely will be back again. read more

Amazing dinner! The quality of the food was superb! Wait staff was accommodating during a very busy time!

This place was absolutely amazing. Food was great. Service was fast. Waitress was soooo nice!!!! Get the Tsantasli blanc wine.

Great authentic Greek food and atmosphere at a reasonable price. The chicken Souvlaki and Gyro was excellent. I would recommend this restaurant read more

Athena Restaurant - Gyro with fries - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I loved this restaurant. The Saganaki was my favorite. I order the Gyro and was delicious. For my kids, the cheese pizza and the chicken fingers with fries. Big size plates, excellent service. We enjoyed our visit. Thank you!! read more

Athena Restaurant - Saganaki - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Reheated food. Horrible. I don't recommend this restaurant. The salad was okay. Worst Greek in town. read more

Athena Restaurant - I don't recommend this restaurant at all. The food came cold. They don't do it from scratch it was Reheated. - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I returned last Sunday and the Tzatziki sauce was much more flavourful than my previous visit. Now I'm wondering if it was me and my taste was off on the day of my first visit. That Gyro was VERY tasty! read more

UPDATE: Both staff and management reached out to me and made things right. I appreciate their initiative and willingness to correct things when they go wrong, which happens to everyone. It speaks volumes of their integrity and business sense. We have been refunded for the overcharge. THANK YOU.!!! read more

Athena Restaurant - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This restaurant has the best Greek food we've had in a long time. We will definitely be returning. I had the pork schnitzel which was absolutely amazing, perfectly cooked and wonderful flavor. My wife had the combo platter which was definitely a great choice. We got to try three amazing dishes. We would recommend this place to everyone!! read more

Wonderful Greek restaurant in the heart of downtown St Augustine. I got the saganaki and gyro platter with a glass of red wine imported from Greece. They were short staffed and unable to seat people at all their tables, but still friendly despite the shortage. Would definitely return here! read more

We stopped in St. Augustine's on our way South. I love this town and we happened to eat at Athena's and glad we did. Serving portions were very generous, food delicious. I had the gyro and my husband had the beef slauvakia (sorry spelling) and eggs. Restaurant sanitized staff wore masks. read more

Very cute spot; cozy. We stopped for lunch and shared the hummus platter with pita, tomato, cucumber, olives and pepperoncini. Very tasty starter. Both got gyros which were very nice and meaty with lettuce, tomato and tzatziki sauce. A couple of beers and that was a delightful lunch.very efficient wait person even though she was solo! read more

As a Greek, I assume my rating is a little more tough than others. This restaurant is very small and we had to wait 10 mins for a table but it was worth it!! We had the dolmathes, Greek salad, saganaki, and lemon soup. The dolmathes were very authentic tasting and reminded me of our family recipe. The saganaki was amazing and the Greek brandy set it apart in flavor. The lemon soup was very very delicious!! I would highly recommend this to anyone looking for a quick, Greek dish!! read more

See all

I am from a Greek family, so finding food that holds up to my standards. Athenas restaurant had some of the best Greek food I've had in years, and it was seemingly the only place with no wait. Strongly suggest. read more

Athena Restaurant - Appetisers - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Stopped in this restaurant for a quick bite while walking around St. Augustine. It's nothing fancy but the gyros are good and they serve wine so it's everything we needed! It was not busy the day we dined here and our server was helpful and always there when we needed him without hovering. We shared the gyro platter which was definitely enough for two. Everything was tasty and we were in and out in no time as we had limited time in St. Augustine. read more

Athena Restaurant - Gyro platter - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Stopped in for a refreshing Greek Salad, I saw the Gyro Combo and order that. Great presentation, topped off with a Greek Dolmades. The Salad was crisp, refreshing and salad dressing was pleasant. The Gyro was very generous portion. I shared some with my wife. My Grand daughter even enjoyed the Greek Salad Best Greek Salad in town !! read more

Athena Restaurant - This the amazing Souvlaki combo, out of this world, Great Greek Salad with a Gyro - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Came in on a Wednesday around noon, got right in. Although we only got breakfast the menu looked absolutely delicious for lunch and dinner (and the lunch plates coming from the kitchen looked amazing). The service was good and the food was of great value for the price!! It's also nestled in the perfect spot between down town and the water so whatever reason you're stopping for wether a local or a tourist, this is the spot for you! read more

First I have to start with the Baklava cheesecake it is there hidden gem. It was great something that you can't really describe until you try it. It has the best thing of both world the top portion is your traditional baklava the middle portion is a A blend of the creamy softest cheesecake ever combined with the nuts of the baklava and the bottom is not your normal cheesecake cookie it is a soft cake with the correct amount of moist and juices. I recommend this place 100% they serve breakfast and lunch. read more

Athena Restaurant - Baklava cheesecake - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Worth it!! Their speciality, the Gyro platter. Friend ordered the classic gyro sampler and it was also amazing. All of these dishes are large sized and could be shared. The kids had tenders and fries and they liked them. Service was great. We were warmly greeted and our server was helpful and very nice to our kids. Highly recommend this spot! read more

Athena Restaurant - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This restaurant is St Augustine's best kept secret! It is 100% authentic, priced right, excellent service....amazing.

Simple, casual. We had salads they were fresh and plentiful. Gyro meat sliced. Thick and was crispy. I really enjoyed it. read more

Athena Restaurant - Greek salad with gyro - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This place is one of the more authentic places I've been to in the U.S. The menu is small and the prices are high but if you're looking for delicious saganaki, spanakopita, pastitsio, and moussaka, this is the place. I recommend getting the combo plate so you can try every everything. read more

We come here every summer and it never ever disappoints. I've never had anything that wasn't 10/10 good.

We stopped off here during a trip and the food and service was amazing. Great choice of wines for a reasonable price. I would recommend it and found it to be a terrific experience. You have to like Greek food. If you do, you will like it. read more

visited here during the busy holiday season between christmas and new year's. decided on this place because of its convenient location on the plaza and its relatively short wait time of 20-25 minutes. the server and host were nice and cordial. food was good, but nothing extraordinary! one of those places that i'm content with checking out once but probably would never go to again. read more

Athena Restaurant - combo/sampler plate and lamb/pork chops - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I was honestly surprised by how good the food was here. It may seem like an older restaurant, but don't let the appearance of the place fool you. Their lemon chicken rice was good, albeit a bit cold. I got their Greek Special (I forget the name) that came with moussaka, spanikopita, pastisio, Greek salad, and grape leaves. It was all very tasty and filling, with large portion sizes. The moussaka and pastisio were a bit sweet for my taste, but still delicious. The roasted chicken my mother got was phenomenal: flavorful, juicy, and succulent. Cafe Athena was definitely worth going to! read more

Athena Restaurant - Moussaka, spanikopita, and pastisio with Greek Salad and grape leaves - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Athena's is a nice restaurant in a very nice area. Not all of their Greek food is as good as it probably should be. A true Greek Chef would not be proud of the pasta sauce being poured on top of items like Pastisio and Moussaka in the combination plate. Galaktoboureko was too firm and not served a little warm. The Saganaki was okay and the Spanakopita (spinach pie) was good. read more

We took my father in law here, he has never had Greek food before. We ordered the open face Gyros and Greek fries. Very generous portions, very tasty fare. We had the cheesecake baklava it was really good too. My father in law really enjoyed the meal, as did we. Definitely recommend this place. read more

Quiet restaurant right in the heart of things! I was looking for seafood but we had a bay cruise and no time to wait. The flounder at Athena was perfect! My husband had mousaka and loved it. The price was very reasonable, good portion size and quick! Our waitress was so fantastic! We actually went back for dessert after the cruise! read more

Dinner was delicious. Walked right in with no wait. Maddie was our server and she was nice and very attentive! We had the gyro combo plate and the Greek combo plate - highly recommend both!! read more

This place is a little Greek gem. On our visit to St Augustine, we parked on the main square in downtown and saw a restaurant with a Greek flag waving on the storefront and decided to check it out. They had all Greek favorites like spinach pie, pastitsio, flaming cheese and grape leaves. We ordered calamari, grape leaves and a Greek salad. Along with very nice Chardonnay to drink. It was all excellent! The salad had house made dressing and fresh ingredients. The calamari was cooked to perfection and served with tomato based sauce that was not too heavy and added a nice spice to the crispy squid. The grape leaves were just the way I like them chilled and served with Kalamata olives, pickled peppers, and tomato wedges with the yummy house dressing Peter our waiter was attentive and just nice! He offered great service and was always there just when we needed him. He put in extra effort when we wanted something sour to cut the sweetness of the baklava we had for dessert. They didn't have any extra yogurt, but offered sour cream and it made the dish. Honestly, we wanted to kidnap Peter and the chef. Speaking of the chef. His name is Morris and he is wonderful. He took the time to come out and speak to us, that made us feel special. The Athena is a great place to eat I recommend it highly. read more

Athena Restaurant - Greek Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

As a tour guide, Athena is one of the restaurants where I frequently take my guests. The staff is truly amazing, friendly, and enthusiastic! They make my guests feel welcomed and like they're home! The food is always delicious and filling! We start out with Saginaki, followed by a lamb gyro, washed down with the most perfect red wine! Last night, The Tasting Tours hosted a corporate group of 70 people. We split into groups, and I chose to take my group to Athena. They were excited about having Greek food, but were more amazed once we arrived! Susan really put on a "flaming" show when lighting the Saginaki! The service was on point and the food was scrumptious! My guests couldn't get enough of the fresh, homemade tzatziki sauce! Thank you, Athena, for being such an awesome stop on my tour, for being so fabulous to our guests, and for serving us such amazing food! Y'all ROCK!!! read more

This place is so cute! A huge Greek mural on one wall and the most delightful server, Tonya, who makes you feel like her only guest. We arrived in St. Augustine later than anticipated due to road construction so we had a VERY late lunch. I had the Athena platter of 3 types of dips and pita, while hubby did the full gyro platter. He devoured every bit of his meal and mine was so filling, I don't think I ate 1/2 of it. Probably due to the 1/2 carafe of pinot grigio!!!!!! Couldn't finish that either! It was such a nice meal, in air conditioning, watching all the masked people go by (full Covid protocol observed here also), and the pouring rain made it even more enjoyable. The menu had just about every known Greek dish, appetizer, dessert, whatever you want that's Greek. Definitely recommend this charming eatery to those who hum Zorba the Greek theme song periodically! read more

We decided to try this restaurant when we were visiting the nights of lights, service was good, We ordered the calamari for our appetizer, it was a very small portion, half of it was overcooked, seemed to be mixed in with some newer calamari, we both had the lamb gyros, the lettuce on our gyros was not fresh, actually mostly brown. The flavor was fine, meat portion small. Overall our meal was nothing special , hope to find some better restaurants in Saint Augustine. read more

I was walking around St Augustine and spotted Athena Restaurant. I love Mediterranean food and decided to stop in for a late lunch. It is nice inside, clean and has cool murals and atmosphere. The hostess was friendly and cute too. We were seated right away. The waiter was patient while I was trying to decide on what to have. The Amstel draft beer was cold and tasty. The tomato barley soup was fantastic. The small Greek salad was delicious and fresh. The Gyro was very tasty and the meat had great flavor. I really enjoyed Athena Restaurant. I'm looking forward to visit this place again on my next trip through St Augustine. (There is a Yelp listing for Cafe Athena and it is the same place.) I've posted some photos from my visit. read more

See all

Quaint restaurant; moderately priced and nice service. I ordered the Gyro; it was ok. Unfortunately, my husband totally disagreed. His pita was over toasted and hard. It was not his greatest experience. read more