Sydney was our server she was great she gave us recommendations since it was our first visit. We appreciated that very much we had refills did not have to ask for anything she stopped by twice we ordered the hot Sicilian and the pizza and breadsticks lunch special. Everything was delicious could not have asked for better service or better food. read more

Met my brother there for a pleasant dinner on the outdoor patio. The nachos were a bit too melded together for my liking, but the service was courteous and price was right. read more

Thanks to my fellow Yelpers for recommending this hidden gem off of 96th St.. I'm a sucker for pizza- to the point that I probably need to go into rehab for my food addiction. In all serious though, I was impressed by the experience at Arni's. We were greeted by the hostess and seated in a large booth that could hold five or six easily. There's something about a booth I like. Maybe because it feel like you're separated from the rest of the diners. I don't know, but this along with the contemporary casual atmosphere was good. Our server Nancy was excellent. She was informative, timely, and an asset to the restaurant. In fact, I would ask for her again the next time I'm there. We started off with the spinach nachos. They were loaded with cheese, spinach dip, tomatoes, mushrooms, and onions. Not bad at all for a starter. Then the pizza and salads came. A thin crust topped with mushrooms, marinated chicken, and red peppers on top of a good amount of mozzarella. Loved it. Chewy, not too crispy, and at $10 off with a Yelp check-in you can't go wrong. We walked out of there with leftovers for later. Expansive menu with lots of homemade choices make this establishment a new favorite. Don't forget to check-in to get the deal. They love Yelpers! In fact, there's a TV ad that plays in the dining room encouraging people to check-in. That's one smart business! read more

Arni's - Spinach nachos - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I had a ridiculous craving for Arni's, since my roommate from Purdue and I now live in the Indy area. We didn't have time to sit-in and eat because we had our puppy with us. Nevertheless, we had to have something to-go. So we both decided to have the Arni's Sr. Salad w/ Ranch (of course!). We decided against pizza because it would have gotten cold by the time we got home. Anyways, this location is very different from the Lafayette ones. Much more "swanky" and upscale. Maybe that's why the price was so exorbitant. It was a little over $20 for our salads. I guess it was worth it, since it's probably my favorite "meal" salad because everything goes together perfectly. It's nice that that they have a carry-out window that has a separate entrance near the bar. I hope to return in the near future to have a pizza with friends again. read more

This was my second time here and I really wanted to like it. I was there with a group so I'm not sure if that was the issue or not. The service was good and the menu selection is pretty good as well. The issue was the food. I didn't have anything complex. I went with a Meatball sub and fries. When the food came out it looked good. The problem was when I ate it. The food was cold. It was as if maybe my order was cooked and then sat for a while to be served with the rest of the groups food. The sub being a bit cool wasn't as big of a deal but the fries were a big disappointment. Nothing is worse than cold fries. I didn't hear anyone else in my group complain about their food so I'm assuming they liked what they had. read more

Ordered curbside instead of carry out because I have a sick kiddo. Got there 10 minutes early but tried to call to let them know I was there but no rush. It rang and rang and then voicemail. I called back over and over, with the same outcome. When it was 15 minutes AFTER the time my curbside order was scheduled, I finally went in. I found they had the phone off the hook, on the counter. I understand being busy, but you can't turn off your phones when orders require to be called when they arrive. Three other customers parked beside us had the same issue. Just got home and we are missing multiple items. read more

They were very accommodating when we told them we were in a hurry. The Pizza is so very good...I had forgotten how much I liked it. We enjoyed the fact that they use ground pepperoni, and the other toppings were nice and small, too. The large Caesar salad was definitely enough to share. read more

Arni's never disappoints! Their food is always delicious and the Deluxe pizza no cheese (dairy allergy) is my usual go to. They have amazing salads as well. This location also perked up the decor with a new face lift. Love the bar area. Usually a nice line up of beers on tap. They've added some more bourbons as well. I highly recommend if you haven't had Arni's, it's a must try!! read more

Now to be fair, no Arni's can quite compare to the Mothership in Lafayette, as this spot lacks the charm and atmosphere of the original location. However, if you're looking for a spot to entertain a large group of people, this location can certainly accommodate. When we came for our visit they hosted a party of 60 with ease. We appreciated the variety of options in pizza and sandwiches- so much more to offer than your typical pepperoni and cheese (I personally recommend the buffalo chicken). They also have great drink specials, which just pairs well with any pizza. read more

It took a little bit of driving around to finally decide on a dinner spot this evening. I considered the new Bubba's, but was irritated that all of their accessible parking spots were taken. I drove by Stacked Pickle, but just wasn't in the mood for a sports bar atmosphere. Then, I spotted Arni's. This Arni's is one of nearly 20 Arni's Restaurants in Indiana after having started in Lafayette, Indiana in 1965. This particular location actually relocated from 86th & Michigan a few years back, but truth be told this is the first time I've actually been to this location. Arni's is mostly known for its pizza and has some fame for its burgers. They continue to be a family owned chain, now owned by two sons of the original owner. I was a big fan of the Arni's at 86th & Michigan Road, though I've had some mixed results at other Arni's locations around the state. I've never had what I'd consider to be a "bad" experience, but there's no question that some locations are simply better than others. Things started off great here. As I was wheeling up to the door, an employee entering the building noticed me and intentionally waited upon my arrival. It was basic customer service, but it was much appreciated. As I was arriving in the early dinner hour on a Friday night, I figured things would be busy and they definitely were. I was impressed by the hostess who had planned to take me to one table, but she quickly realized it could be a bad situation for the wheelchair. She changed course and got me into an appropriate 4-top table that left me free to come and go as I might need. The restaurant is a tad on the smallish side and definitely packs in the tables. My server was Eric. He was quick to take my drink order, the usual unsweetened iced tea. I was ready to order by the time he came back and went with a breaded tenderloin sandwich that comes with one side. I chose fries. The meal was $9.99 plus drink. I have to be honest and say that I was fully expecting this Arni's to be a solid four-star restaurant. Quite simply, it wasn't. Arni's never went above a 3-star experience and very nearly dipped down to a two. The breaded tenderloin was incredibly disappointing, easily the worst part of the experience. It tasted like a frozen patty and had no distinct flavor at all, though it was of decent size and the meat itself was of a decent thickness. After one bite, I was feeling like I'd picked badly. The flavoring was inconsistent throughout the sandwich, and the bun itself was quite average. The fries were fairly typical fries - not quite shoestring, but of a thinner variety with a light seasoning. It wasn't a bad meal, but it wasn't a good meal. I definitely won't order it again. The service? Eric was generally attentive, though he lost points for never offering a drink refill (which we know is a major faux pas in my world) and generally the service was right along the 3-star range. It wasn't bad, but it didn't make me want to rush back either. I did stick around a few extra minutes to finish reading, which gave the perfect opportunity for a drink refill. I also waited a few minutes for the check, though it wasn't unreasonable. The atmosphere is casual, the restaurant was rather loud but manageable, and the restaurant is definitely family friendly. I could easily fall within the 2-3 star range here. While I'm tempted to go with two, the simple truth is that I was impressed with the initial experience, the hostess, and the food was decent. Eric was friendly and I definitely wouldn't consider his service below average, so a 3-star rating feels exactly right. If I return, which would likely be a while given there are other restaurants in the area I'm anxious to try, I'd definitely try a different meal and maybe go at an off-time to see how service is when it's a tad slower. read more

My favorite pizza by far. The Arnis Jr. and pizza combination is the best it gets. Also amazing breadsticks.

Good food, prices a little steep... Love their "Arnie's Jr. Salad" -- their pizzas... are just OK. read more

I met up with my friend here last Monday, and was not disappointed! The chicken enchilada soup was out of this world, not too spicy, but not too bland either. Their Asian salad was HUGE but refreshing, and equally delicious. My 2 hour drive down for dinner was definitely worth it, and next time I'm in Indy, I'll think of this place again! read more

Arni's - The Asian salad - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Grew up eating this great pizza in Lafayette, IN. And now have found it again in Brownsburg!! Still great pizza, Great service thanks to Jennifer!! Everything was just great!!! read more

Kind of bad policy when you take someone's takeout order over the phone and don't bother to tell the customer you're out of a major part of their order until they show up to pick it up. read more

Arnies is the place to be if y'all want the BEST PIZZA in town! Been eating at Arnies, either In Lafayette or Rossville, since the 80's! We moved to Texas 11 years ago and come home once a year. I tell my family here it's to come to Arnies and seeing them is just a plus! Now that I see they have Pizza Kits I'm getting a few, packing them on dry ice and flying them back to TX with us!!! read more

I remember Arni's from wayyyyyy back when it was at 86th and Michigan. It was so delicious as a kid so everytime I come here as an adult I hope I get that feeling of nostalgia...And it's good but it's not the same. Service is usually good and the food is usually good. They've got cheese fries and good pizzas. The kids like it and sometimes that's all I can ask for. It's pretty inexpensive so if you want to go somewhere where you will get decent food at a decent price and have decent service, you should give it a go. read more

Arni's is a great spot to grab a bite to eat! The staff is always friendly and they always seem to make an extra effort to get thing just right! I could eat their sandwiches everyday! You can get them exactly how you want them every time! One thing I especially like is their consistency, which is one of the biggest things I look for in a restaurant. read more

Our server Michael was the best server we have ever had at Arni's and we have eaten here many many times

Excellent lunch! There was so much on the menu that no one could decide! Everyone ended up ordering something different....chicken nachos, boneless wings, lasagna, fish tacos and.a couple of great burgers. Glad we picked Arni's! read more

Arni's treats their customers right!! We ordered takeout (during the pandemic) like most have and it was DELICIOUS and fresh. However, upon opening our food at home we realized that 2 of your orders of boneless wings had the wrong sauce on them. When I called to let them know, they were not only apologetic and extremely polite but also offered a credit for future orders. Thanks Arni's for taking care of your customers! Makes us want to come back over and over again!! read more

Arnis has been one of my all time favorite restaurants since the bikes and motorcycles hanging off the ceilings and walls.. I was super sad to find out after returning since covid hit to find they took away their Italian dressing? My favorite salad is the Arnis Junior salad and you took away a staple dressing. Now when my husband suggests it - it just doesn't sound as good. The other options of dressing are gross. Please bring back the Italian. read more

Many years ago when I traveled Lafayette IN as a salesman and I used to eat lunch at the original Arni's and it was very good. Well, I made a mistake, I went to the Arni's on 96th tonight. Don't waste your money. read more

Good food and hostess but the server we just had, Amy in the bar, seemed to forget about us. I had to go to a table that had just left to get their pepper and hot peppers. I never got a refill and was out. We had to flag down The other server that just came in to get our servers attention. So when she did come over I told her we needed a to go tea, to go box and bag for our bread sticks. I left a $1.00 tip under the peppers to make her rethink for next time. read more

This used to be a go-to for a late lunch. Not anymore. Service was at best slow and rude, food was cold and subpar. It should have struck a cord that something is amiss with overall quality when "Help Wanted" signs are posted everywhere; front doors, windows, bathrooms, in the bar area. I wanted to have an enjoyable lunch with my son and ended up eating the celery from the boneless chicken wings. The chicken nachos I ordered were cold. Cold to the point that the cheese had started to solidify and chips broke trying to separate into bites. So sad. I won't be returning any time soon, if ever. read more

Great food, but once again, sadly, they messed up the to go order. With the current no dine in policies everywhere, we tried again to get a to go from Arnis. They messed up on my sons order for no cheese on his burger (he hates cheese on burgers) and out of no where they added mushrooms ( also not a fan of that). This happens 100% of the time for our family. The dine in experience is always so much better. They just can't seem to get our to go orders right. They were nice enough to call on my last review and offered some compensation, which I did not take, as that's not the reason I write reviews. I would just like them to start paying attention to the issues they are having. Maybe we are the only ones that have bad luck on the take out? Again, great food, just do the dine in when it comes back. read more

HAVE AGAIN: The meat pizza was very good. I'd only been to Arni's once before and had the cheese pizza which was just OK. The peat pizza was thin crust and just crispy enough. Delicious Arnold Palmer. read more

The food here is good. I only had the chicken salad as a late lunch. The place wasnt crowded at all and the service was friendly. The place is large and it seems like a popular place. read more

Had their famous pizza as carry-out. Staff was courteous and quick. The pizza of course was delicious as always.

This Arni's location is close to my office. I like going here for a quick lunch. Lots of seating and a huge menu to choose from. This is the perfect place for those folks that prefer salad or pasta over pizza. I love that they offer white and pesto pizza sauces as I am not a big fan of tomato bases. Today I had the pesto chicken. They didn't skimp on the artichoke, pepper or mushroom toppings on my 7"! My normal pizza is the Thai... I love the fresh ingredients. My only complaint today is that the server switched our cards during checkout and they had to be voided an ran again... so not the quickest lunch ever. It happens. I will say that for some reason this spot is very popular with mom/nannies with lots of kiddos. So if you want a really quiet lunch spot this may not be it. read more

Great food, awesome variety, so-so friendly staff. Awesome coupons emailed (like FREE birthday pizza!) if you enroll in the Arni's club (slips for this at the tables). read more

Arni's - 7-Inch pizza w/ pepperoni & onion - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Not sure about the pizza, but the rio grande bbq chicken salad is great! They have a nice sized outdoor seating area for days with pleasant weather. read more

The absolute best place to eat in Crawfordsville!!! Always great service very friendly staff delicious food our family loves this weekly!!! love Arnis read more

Fabulous pizza and the Arnie's salad junior is plenty to share for two ! Great service and would recommend! read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We've ordered carry out at the Greenwood store on many occasion. Our order has been correct probably 2 out 10 times! The manager was nice enough to comp me this time with a $10 coupon, but the whole situation really has me questionIng why I keep going back. My order took 45 minutes! My patience is worn. On my last visit I saw a staff member actually stick his two gloved hands into the trash can to push down the trash and not change his gloves when he finished. it will probably be a long while before I try them again and that's a shame. The food is tasty once I get it! read more

Fabulous. We ordered a wide variety of things for carry out. Everything was perfect, and it was all ready to go when we got there (which was less than 15 minutes after we ordered). Very impressed, we will definitely be ordering again soon! In fact, now that we know how fast they are, we may just dine in, or order our carry out there while we grab a beer from what looked like a nice selection at the bar. read more

We had delicious pizzas. The carry out order was correct and ready at the time that was quoted. It was a wonderful change from Christmas leftovers. read more

we drive 45mins to come eat here because there website shows they didn't close until 10:00, once we got there about 8:50pm we called to place our order and the lady said they couldn't take our order because they was going to close in 10 mins! This was complete BS!!!!!! will never waste my gas to go eat there again!!!!!!!!!! The manger was such a joke also! read more

We asked for our pizza to be remade while we went to get the cash because there credit card machine suddenly went down. so we went to go get cash when we picked the pizza up and got home we realize they never remade our pizza so we called to have them fix it and they told us our only option was to bring the pizza back and pick up our money read more

Arni's - This is the pizza gave to me - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Credit card machine broke. After making us wait 1/2 hour, they tell us we can either leave them our credit card number or one of us could leave and go get cash because they have to have someone come out tomorrow and fix it. They wouldn't take a check. We had to go get cash. No offers of a free pizza or reduced bill. I have eaten at several different Arni's and never had an issue like this or been treated like this. read more