My friend and I ran into Anthony's for dessert after having dinner at a place nearby. The place is clean and modern, featuring a gleaming counter that calls to you when you enter. They have nice seating and a pleasant staff. We ordered a slice of slutty brownie cheesecake and a slice of apple crumb cheesecake. We also got a couple of drinks, I had a chai tea and my friend had the blend of coffee and espresso they call The Godfather. The cheesecake was fantastic. Nothing like the door stopper that you get from a certain chain place that weighs you down with cloying sweetness and density. The cheesecake at Anthony's is like the cheesecake made by an older relative that knew what they were doing in the kitchen, only taken to another level of professionalism. Lighter and creamier with the pops of flavor from the toppings. The drinks were also quite nice. Great selection of desserts and drinks. Will definitely look to return. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - Apple crumb cheesecake was fabulous! - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

It's been a while since I've been here - usually, it's for their famous cheesecake. Today, my wife and I tried their dinner and were not disappointed! We started with the split pea soup with ham, perfect for warming us up on a chilly day. Then, onto the main course: my wife had the Tortelloni Alfredo with Shrimp and Bacon - a fantastic dish (of course, I had to try some). I ordered the Spicy Rigatoni Vodka with Crispy Chicken, Prosciutto, and Burrata - absolutely incredible! The chicken was cooked perfectly, and the spicy vodka sauce was delicious. We finished this amazing meal with cappuccino and Cherry Cheesecake, leaving full and satisfied. I told Anthony we'll definitely be back for another round of their delicious food. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

You could not ask for more gracious hosts than Anthony & Phil. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It is evident from the moment you enter their restaurant that you are being welcomed into their home.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The staff is engaging and thoughtful. Their menu is diverse, and their offerings are delicious. The desserts are fantastic, the cheesecake is stellar, the best I've ever had. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I appreciate the tremendous effort they have put into creating a welcoming environment where people can gather and share a meal.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Went here for date night, and the only downside was finding parking. The food was amazing, large servings so we had a second meal or snack for later! My boyfriend loves their cheesecake brownie. We also had the pleasure to meet the owner, he was going around the tables to ensure everything was ok. The owner was very nice and we even made some small talk too about how he started. We will be back hungry and ready! read more

Anthony's Cheesecake has the most delicious food! My friend and I went for dinner the other night. I enjoyed every single bite. I had a Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla, which came with rice & beans and a yummy green dip. I wanted seconds. We sat outside, of course, and the ambiance of Washington St was wonderful. It was a small side street with little traffic. They also had a live singer who did great. For dessert I had the Brownie Peanut Butter Mousse Cake. It was delectable. My friend had Apple Pie with Gorgonzola on top and he enjoyed it as well. This place is a must-try and I definitely recommend it to anyone in the Bloomfield area. read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Loved the place and the owner was super friendly.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Cheesecake is delicious and I was actually really pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food. Highly recommend! read more

I can't express how great Anthony's is. Everything we've tried off the menu is amazing. We live walking distance and we love the $10 dinner take out menu for days we don't feel like cooking!! We've gotten catering as well and that was also phenomenal. Brunch is also excellent. Aside from the great food, Anthony himself is so nice and personable!! And of course, you can't go The Anthony's without leaving with a slice of cheesecake! read more

See all

Great spot for something the same but different. Special made with a twist. Place is very cozy. The waitress and waiters were very busy. Great communication. Treat you well. And make sure you get seated. In the center of Bloomfield on Washington street. Alotta stores out there. And byob. Store is around the corner there's an entrance across the street from pizza depot. You remember that. Lol. I know right. But cool place for date night. Enjoy. read more

Had dinner there and brunch. Both awesome meals. Highly recommend. Desserts were amazing and [[HIGHLIGHT]]outdoor seating is delightful this time of the year.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

We have been going to Anthony's Cheesecake for at least 12 years. My husband is a culinary graduate and was in the industry in every aspect for over 30 years. We both agree that the food is among the best we've ever had, always a culinary delight. Their menu is always accurate and mouthwatering in description and the deserts are the absolute best and keep getting better. The staff is extremely friendly, knowledgeable and personable. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant is intimate enough for date night yet family friendly with occasional entertainment.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]During the warmer months, there's outside dining with umbrellas and heaters provided as necessity demands.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Anthony and Phil always make the time to chat with their guests and are extremely generous in supporting all of the local charities. We've never been disappointed and hope they plan on staying in our neighborhood for a very long time. read more

Ive had this place on my Yelp for sooo long. A family member convinced me to do brunch on a Sunday. I was excited. It took up a while to find since we had to park and walk. The place is VERY small but intimate. They had a cute valentines day theme set up. We were immediately seated and a guy with a sling on his arm sat us and was very attentive and helpful. He even opened our bottle of wine. So the food... this is where my 3 stars come in. I ordered the chicken and waffles with everything on the side, also with eggs. My family member ordered the apple pancakes with an omelet and potatoes. The food took a while to come out, but for quality food, thats what happens. BUT the quality of my food fell short. When the food was brought to the table, it looked delicious and plentiful. My food also came with fries. They were the best fries I ever had. My cousin enjoyed her food to the max. But mines was luke warm and my hard waffles. The chicken was flavorful but cold, the waffles were hard. I had to wait a while to get a servers attention but I dont blame them, they were busy. I asked the waiter to warm my food up and he did. Just to be served with the disappointment of a hot plate, luke warm food (still) and harder waffles. I gave up and just ate my egg and fries. To make up for everything, I decided to get some desserts to go. Since its in the name, I had to get cheesecake. I also got oreo tres leche, a birthday cake, and a plain cheese cake slice. LET ME TELL YOU, that tres leche oreo was BOMB! The birthday cake was really dry and the cheesecake was standard. All in all, I want to give this place another try in the future. I would suggest others to visit as well. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

The owner is nice, but hovers and checks on you in an awkward way. Just let me eat. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The entire room is way too cramped. The tables are on top of each other and the people waiting to be seated have no place to stand.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] There's no front person, so it's a free-for-all until someone notices you. Even when someone does notice you, they'll blow right past you since they work in the back. They care more about getting a photo of the outside than helping someone who has reservations. Oh yeah - and the food is garbage. Who has cheese that doesn't melt? Gross. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Simply the best all around- food, service and ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Anthony is the consummate host.

So I've given this place several tries and unfortunately don't think I will be back. Cute ambiance and decent food, but the service is just awful! My boyfriend and I came in this morning after making a reservation for brunch and were promptly greeted and ignored as one of 3 servers took a table's order while we stood waiting to be seated. 5 minutes later someone finally sat us at one of the 9 tables. There were no QR codes or menus, but we were able to order a couple interesting items off their online menu. The coffee and french toast were very good and the baked goods on display looked amazing. The bacon, egg and cheese sliders were just okay. Food came promptly, but our server never came back to check on us. The restaurant had 3 servers as well as bussers for an extremely small space, so I'm not sure why we were completely ignored. We finished our meal and waited over 10 minutes for someone to notice before I flagged down the owner/manager to bring us a to-go container and the check. He quickly took care of us and seemed pleasant enough, but the staff just sucked! There is definitely potential here, but a big part of dining out is the service and this place epically fails in that department. Hope it improves. read more

My wife and daughter visited Anthony's for lunch and of course cheesecake! Anthony and his staff were great and the sandwiches and cheesecakes were delicious. Highly recommended!! read more

I visited Anythony's Cheesecake because a friend had recommended this place for me to try. Oh wow, it did not disappoint! Our entrees were delicious and portion sizes were super generous we definitely had to pack the rest to take home. We were so full we couldn't eat dessert but we brought a slice home for later. I wasn't super impressed by the slice and for the price I thought it would be a bit bigger but I'll definitely be coming back for the brunch menu items alone. We dined outside and it is a good experience. There were heat lamps that helped to keep us warm a bit. The server/owner was very nice and accommodating! PS. Street parking only via meter. It was a little bit confusing on whether we had to pay but we filled the meter regardless just to be safe. read more

See all

My favorite spot in town! We love coming for brunch. The empanada & eggs meal is my go-to but everything on the menu is delicious. The waiters are so friendly and attentive. We like to eat outside in the summer to bring our puppy with us. They are so kind to her as well! read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

Small eatery and bakery. Very tasty. Good sized portions. Very friendly staff. Alfredo sauce was not too heavy and was delicious. Burrata and eggplant appetizers were large and delicious! read more

See all

came here on father's day sunday without a reservation. was able to be seated pretty quickly even though the restaurant was busy. food was soooo good! will definitely be back for brunch read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - outside seating available - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

Finally went for my first time today to pick up the infamous cheesecake. Everything looked so delicious I had a hard time choosing so I had try a couple flavors and even tried a few slices of cake to go! read more

My wife and I ate here for the first time. I had the kielbasa onion egg tots skillet ....... Oh My Goodness. Heaven on a plate!!! Big thanks to our server for the recommendation for this. Wife shared the bacon egg and cheese biscuits with her mom. Also top notch! Brought home cheesecake and had the Cookie Monster piece first. So creamy and flavorful. Definitely worth the drive and will be back. Even spoke to Anthony for a while. Very nice man and very accommodating to all. 10 out of 10 stars all around...... read more

The place was vibrant and since it was Sunday brunch, all the tables were taken. However, Anthony literally pulled a table and a couple chairs out and made some room for us. That was top notch service. He was very welcoming and really took his time with us. The food was so good with a healthy portion size as well. And if we weren't so full we would've had the desert right there, but instead we got some to go since it looked so good. Thank you Anthony and staff, we will definitely be back! read more

I've seen all of there tasty cheesecakes online for some time now and once I saw they were participating in the Bloomfield Center restaurant week (7/13-7/19) I had to make my visit! Reservations: You can call or email Anthony (email on the website). On a Thursday at 5pm was a perfect time; no wait. Ambiance: For briefly seeing the inside of Anthonys, it's super modern and put together. They have tables outdoors; some with umbrellas. My friend and I walked in, stated we have a reservation and the host walked us back outside to show us the tables in which we got to choose. Food/Drink: You start off with complimentary bread and butter. Since it was restaurant week, we choose the pre-fixe menu which included an appetizer, entree, and a slice of cheesecake for $27.95! For the appetizer, I initially wanted the empanadas but they were only serving beef at the time (i'm a vegetarian) so I opted for the eggplant and sauce. I wish it was clear on the menu which kind of empanada it was because by it saying "house empanadas" i'm assuming I can order at least cheese. Even though I was bummed about that, the eggplant and sauce were AMAZING! I didn't want to order it at first but it's literally addicting; YOU HAVE TO GET IT! I was almost full but I had to make room for the rest of my food. For my entree, I ordered grilled shrimp fajita over spaghetti squash. I never ordered anything like this before so I was excited to try it. It's definitely that healthy dish that doesn't make you feel sluggish; I wish I wasn't so full so I could finish it but I did take it home for leftovers! The entree had cauliflower, bell peppers, broccoli, grilled shrimp, and more. Now for what I was waiting for, the cheesecake. The dessert menu was on a chalkboard easel so when it was time to order I went for the turtle brownie moose cheesecake. Again, they only had certain cheesecakes included with the pre-fixe menu which I wish was detailed on the menu which ones were. As the waitress went through the options my selection was the salted caramel cheesecake! When I say creamy and dreamy, this cheesecake is it! I finished the whole thing full and all LOL. Pricing: The pre-fixe price of $27.95 was great for all the food we received. We did order food to go in which none of the cheesecakes had pricing so I couldn't tell you how much each one was. When the bill came out it was a bit confusing because they handwrite them. We received two bills, one for the pre-fixe and one for the food to go. When I gave the waitress my card she then said that the bill is "plus tax," which made sense because the total was more than what I initially thought. Parking: Since outdoor dining takes up part of the street, street parking is limited. There is a parking garage right in front of the restaurant or a parking lot at the end of the block where I paid $1 for parking (free parking starts at 6pm) All in all, I cannot stop talking about that eggplant and sauce! I will be back! read more

See all

I recently had my birthday brunch here- it was a fabulous experience enjoyed by all. The menu is creative, innovative and delicious! Service was outstanding and the owner was attentive to every detail-the decor is charming and comfortable---highly recommend. I would add that the regular menu is fabulous too! And the desserts- decadent and delicious!!! read more

Great food and the friendliest owners and wait staff. Beyond great desserts are their yummy main courses (this place is a lot more than cheesecakes) read more

Best...cheesecake...ever! Fresh, homemade cheesecake. Made with love. I am in love with Anthony's Cheesecake. Super friendly owner. Small yet inviting place. Lot's of quality cheesecakes to satisfy anyones sweet tooth. They also serve savory food which we did not try. Will be back ASAP for more menu (savory/sweet) items. ENJOY! read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - Coconut Cream Pie - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

It's a small restaurant, great for brunch! The food is good, the staff is pleasant & the owner is very nice. The desserts are to die for! read more

See all

Love the cappuccino! The chicken and cannoli waffles were amazing! The pupusas could you a little more cheese and crispiness to them. I prefer a fluffier pupusa. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

#AnthonysCheesecake is a must! I knew I had to return after my visit because there are so many options. During my first visit we took the recommendation that was provided by staff. We had the Triple Layer Chocolate mousse cake. It was everything I expected and more! - delicious, fresh, perfect amount of sweetness. We also had a slutty brownie cheesecake (nickname) topped with orea cookies! You could def taste more of the cheesecake in this one. It's one of the most popular choices and I can see why. The next time around I tried the confetti cake. There are so many choices that I do plan on coming back. They take orders as well which is nice especially during the holidays. They have an extensive food menu but i have only stopped by for dessert. Staff is super friendly! read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - Triple Chocolate Mousse Cake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

I hate to do this to a small mom and pop shop but I have to be honest. That's just who I am. So I read the reviews and was excited about trying it. I did go Easter Sunday so the place was packed at around 11:30 am. I was by myself and their were three empty two top tables. One of the owners told me that he had a list of reservations so unfortunately they couldn't seat me. I said ok and ordered to go. So while waiting for my meal I noticed that a couple came in who were not on the list of reservations and was seated. Hmmmmm. No sweat. Then I overheard a customer who called in and wanted to come and have breakfast. The owner stated that "yes we can take you if you come in now". Hmmmmm. I could be very sensitive to things because I'm pregnant. But I didn't see why I couldn't have been accommodated at that time when I literally sat at a two top the entire time that my meal was being prepared. Food: sigh.......... I ordered the cornbread griddle cakes. It was just alright. Nothing to write home about. I literally only enjoyed my chicken sausage. I ordered the short rib with eggs for my husband. Although the short ribs were very tender, it was bland and lacked flavor. I did Enjoy the potatoes. I thought I ordered a coconut custard pie slice. But it was like a coconut cream pie. Unfortunately I found something grey on the side of the slice. Don't know if it was a metal stain from the knife or mold. But I threw it away. 6.95 for a slice of pie that I threw away because I wanted to be cautious. All in all I really like small mom and pop shops and I'm sure they have great food. I just wasn't awarded the experience. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

I was not at all impressed with either of the two sandwiches I ordered as take-out. When I had to put my clothes back on, and return to exchange an Anthony's "diet" rootbeer for what I had originally handed the girl behind the counter, I was quite annoyed. I do like the little, round, cheesecake bites. My favorite is the one with the caramel topping, and pecan pieces. Unfortunately, my last three (3) visits turned up empty. They were not available; again & again. I settled on a piece of carrot cake that turned out to be dry. I know about moist cake. My son is a Pastry Chef having graduated from Johnson & Wales in Rhode Island; dean's list. I know about dark chocolate, too. read more

Another amazing meat at Anthony's cheesecake ! Took my bestfriend this time, and we left completely happy with full bellies I had the rice balls and eggs skillets with vodka sauce. The sauce was delicious , the eggs were perfectly over easy, and the rice balls were fantastic ! The meat and the rice were so flavorful ! My partner and my bestfriend both had French toast special (which were both amazing.) my partner had the banana read French toast which had a nice buttery thin crusted layer. My bestfriend had the apple fritter French toast which he loved. For dessert, we had two orders of carrot cake (my favorite) and I tried the chocolate pudding pie. Literally should be illegal for tasting that delicious. Y'all simply can't leave without dessert. read more

See all

Decent brunch. I thought the iced coffee was a bit weak but the food was tasty. I tried: + apple fritter French toast (special) + pear grilled cheese with home fries + sweet potato hash and chicken sausage + cookie pie and cookie cheesecake The French toast was definitely the best but SUPER sweet so I'm glad I shared. Grilled cheese and hash were great. I didn't care for the desserts (not a cookie dough lover) but the rest of my party loved them. Service wasn't great at times (had to ask twice for water, etc) but overall it was a nice experience. Make a res if you can as the place is pretty small! Edit 8/2018: Returned and tried a few more dishes and pastries for brunch: + chicken and waffle sandwich + breakfast burrito + sausage egg and cheese croissant sandwich + German sticky bun, coconut cake and cherry pie The entrees were all delicious; I'd recommend any of them. Out of the pastries, the sticky bun was the best, followed by the coconut cake. Unfortunately the cherry pie was kind of terrible - really gloppy and just didn't have good flavor. read more

See all

I've been a customer of Anthony's for some years now and I love it! The food is always good and the menu changes keep it interesting. It's nice to have new options at a place you love. Their cheesecake, of course, is AMAZING. they always have new, fun flavors. It's a small place but that adds to its charm. Definitely get reservations especially around holidays! read more

Good food, love the pizza and the meatballs. Also the fried chicken wings are great. The service has always been very accomodating. I would recommend giving this place a try. read more

It's a bit tricky to find since the street is short. Street parking is available but limited. Looks like there's a public lot in the back. We were able to find one a block away. The place is cozy, very small town New Jersey. Mostly tables holding 1-4 people. Not too may people at the time we came. There are a couple of benches outside, guessing there are long wait times. The kitchen separated by a red curtain. Bathroom door is in a bit awkward position facing the eating area. Good amount of choices and specials for breakfast and lunch. We ordered coffee, Anthony's BLT and chicken and waffles. We were looking forward to the cheesecake. The BLT was good. Arugula instead of lettuce, bacon was not overly cooked or charred, comes with avocado with a good choice of sliced wheat bread. The chicken and waffles was ok. The waffles were a bit soggy, chicken was well made, not dry and with a good amount of herbs. Both came with a macaroni side but with too much celery for my taste. Coffee was not bitter or stale. Service was up to par, very nice and helpful. We took the plain cheesecake to go instead. It was ok, creamy, not too sweet but needs a touch of citrus. Overall I'm stuck between a 3-3.5 stars. I see it as close to average than excellent. I'm rounding up to 4 for the nice people. We did come out with our coats smelling like food. But I would give Anthony's a recommendation. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

See all

First time eating at this place. The service was excellent and the host was accommodating even though we didn't have a reservation (Sunday peak brunch time). The food was excellent and the portions were very substantial. I think you can BYOB, I saw 2 tables with bottles of champagne/sparkling wine on ice, but they do not serve alcohol. I had the chicken and waffles which were very good, although I would have preferred a whole wing or thigh instead of a boneless chicken breast. Overall, good vibe, will definitely visit again. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - Cappuccino - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Finally got to try this place out for brunch on Sunday as it's been in my bookmarks for months. It is about 45 minutes from home but after reading their great reviews and seeing all of the delicious pics I was determined to go. The restaurant is very cozy but we were able to get a table for 4 upon arriving around 12pm. Now I already knew what I wanted before arriving but still looked over their menu specials and everything sounded delicious. Everyone else was struggling to make a decision because they had so many great things to choose from. I ordered the Cinnamon croissant French toast topped with strawberries and bananas with a side of cannoli cream. It also came with a side of crispy fried potatoes and some watermelon. This dish was so good... it definitely did not disappoint. Everyone else enjoyed their food as well and we talked about what we wanted to try when we came back which is always a good sign. Of course I plan on trying some desert next time because the carrot cake looked delicious! Also the service was excellent, everyone was very welcoming and friendly. They definitely deserve all 5 stars and I can't wait to return! read more

See all

My boyfriend and I came here for breakfast one weekend. It didn't seem entirely busy when we entered and there were a couple of tables empty but, the restaurant is terribly small. It didn't take long for us to be seated, crammed in with the other customers. However, it took more than ten minutes for a waiter to approach us with menus and to take our drink order. I had already researched the restaurant and knew what I wanted, it didn't take my boyfriend long to figure out what he'd like. We again waited awhile for the waiter to return to take our orders. By this point, we weren't too pleased with the lack of attention as other customer who came in either at the same time or after received faster service. Eventually, we received our orders. I ordered the crispy buttermilk chicken and waffles. I thoroughly enjoyed my dish, especially the inclusion of the pears. My boyfriend ordered a skillet dish that I can't remember the name of. He didn't really seem to care for the dish and picked over it. Overall, I would try the restaurant again but, am in no rush to get back. read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - Crispy Buttermilk Chicken & Waffles in the front. - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey

Nice little place. Someplace that can be considered a simple place with a decent menu selection, but definitely laid back with some Yacht Rock music in the air. The food is 3 star, but the deserts is 5 star. The coconut cake and blue very pie was so delicious. I have not been here for breakfast or brunch. But I hear it's better then dinner. I'll definitely try that one day. Stay tuned for a brunch review soon read more

Anthony's Cheesecake - American Near Me - Bloomfield, New Jersey