This review is for the new Poughkeepsie location. Unfortunately I don't think this location will survive. We walked in for dinner 8 pm Saturday night and maybe 3 tables were filled. The inexperienced waitress was sour from the start and it continued to go down from there. Was served cold French Onion soup, when we asked to be hot she made an irritated face. She didn't refill drinks for the table and didn't check on food the entire visit. The food was very average, salmon had no flavor and tomato soup tastes like canned soup. Between the lack of good service - and mediocre food I would not revisit. So many other better option in the Vassar College area. read more

Continues to be one of my favorite places for breakfast or lunch ! The bruschetta special changes and they are all amazing. Get the Florentine breakfast sandwich- *chef's kiss* read more

Very good service and menu variety but not much for gluten free. The service is great and the outdoor rear patio is very pleasant.

We have eaten at the tomato cafe about 4 or 5 times since we moved to the Village of Fishkill about a month ago and I can honestly say everything we have tried here has been delicious. Their cheesesteak sandwich is the best I've had outside of Phily and their lemon cream cake is amazing. Also, they are the nicest group of people you could find. Every single time we've spoken to someone there they have always been super friendly and helpful. Highly recommend read more

I ate here last night and got food poisoning. For an active restaurant they should really keep their food fresh and make everything daily. I had one tiny bite of a meatball (it was hard) and within 10-15 minutes I felt sick. They other people in my group felt fine but they also had a salad and a fried chicken parm. I couldn't even split the meatball with my fork. It must of been days days old! I do not recommend coming here, for an $80 dinner I would go somewhere else. read more

Good place , a little pricey but the staff is very nice and the food is on point , I personally love the Reuben. Panini needs some work. Pizzas are perfect read more

Away for a girls weekend and found this cute spot. Defiantly eat here! Brie Bruschetta special- B+ breakfast pizza-A brunch sandwich with an egg (to die for!!!)! -A++ Sweet potato fries are crispy!-A Egg Frittata- A Chicken parm sandwich -B- (lot of bread) Their pizzas looked great too. Only downside was service was a little slow. They do have cute outside eating though. read more

I've been going to the Tomato Cafe for years. I'd like to say I've tried many things on the menu, but I'm hooked on the penne a la vodka. I don't even know how many times I've ordered it, but it's a lot. If you're in Fishkill and looking for a comforting, delicious meal, I'd go to the Tomato Cafe. read more

Typical American Brunch place. We ordered the Cappuccino, Classic Bruschetta, Lemon Ricotta Pancakes and tomato soup. The cappucino was average, not what I expected, but again this could be a personal thing. The pancakes were really nice and fluffy, and went well with the lemon ricotta and canadian bacon. The classic brushetta was also average, something I don't think I would recommend to anyone else. The ambiance and service of the place were decent. The place is alright if you want a quick bite, but don't expect the food to blow your mind. read more

Stopped in for lunch with a friend, street parking was hard to find so we found a municipal lot and had no issues. I ordered a calzone, it was a standard calzone but didn't look appealing on the plate, it could have used some kind of garnish or color. My friend got a salad and was very happy. read more

Delicious food, breakfast all day-perfect place! And judging from the crowd, popular too!

I ordered a few slices of pizzas and hot subs here back in the summer of 2020 they all came out pretty good they weren't burnt. The meatballs and chicken that were in the subs were reheated or bland tasting. The sauces they on the subs and pizza is pretty good. I'll have to come back here again in the near future. read more

We loved this place. Outdoor dining, great server, friendly owner, delicious grilled vegetable salad, BBQ chicken pizza and Mac & cheese, reasonable prices. Win. read more

Very nice atmosphere. Relaxing and historical. they have olive oil as a dressing ( the do have a large selection) which is a plus if you like to eat healthy read more

See all

The Tomato Cafe. Ok we've been here in Fishkill, NY for 7 days and we've eaten here 4 times. I've haven't had the same meal twice, because I want to try as many deal as possible. So yes, it's a 5 Star rating from us. We're waiting now for our fourth order to be delivered. Yes they deliver. And the desserts are the best. Especially their homemade ice cream. Yum. Tomato Cafe our favorite restaurant in Fishkill, NY. Make sure you drop by when visiting the sites up state New York. Or better yet have them deliver the goods to your hotel. read more

Great lunch place with terrific food. Decor was nice with wooden floors and a luncheonette feel but with more oomph. Food was surprisingly good. I had tomato soup with a grill cheese sandwich with gruyere on sourdough rye. If this simple meal was this delicious, I can only imagine what the fancy stuff is like. Service was friendly and prices were fine. Definitely will go back. read more

Found this place on our way home from Monticello. Food, service, and atmosphere was all excellent. If we lived here we would probably eat here several times a week. So many delicious choices on the menu. Bookmarked this gem and can't wait to come back! read more

Best pizza within a 500-mile radius! Amazing salads as well - my husband and I brought home a menu to try to replicate the salads but they never come out as great as the Tomato Cafe's - fantastic place for the whole family! read more

We have been looking forward to getting here for quite some time. We left disappointed, primarily due to the lackluster and under enthusiastic service. We were able to get out for an impromptu Election Day lunch, without the kids. Upon being shown to our booth, our waitress asked us if we wanted drinks. We asked what type of beer was on tap. She said she didn't know and said she'd be right back. Never got her name because she never introduced herself. Upon her return, she placed a handwritten list of 4 beers that were scribbled down on a receipt and then stood there so we could figure it out. From that list, we both selected the IPA. She left and returned 5 minutes later with two beers that we didn't order and an explanation that she did not have the beers we ordered and that she didn't realize until she had already poured the ones she brought us, but that they were IPA's. We did agree to take them, but mostly because we are easy like that. Appetizers were great. Lunch was Salmon of the day and Fishkill CheeseSteak. The salmon and sauce were both over cooked and lacked flavor. Very disappointing for $24. Was advertised as a 10oz portion, but came out obviously less than that. My wife asked if that was a 10oz portion and was told "yep". Fishkill cheesesteak was good. When I asked for ketchup for the fries, I get a "yep" and then waited another 5 minutes for it. Didn't see the waitress again until she asked us if we were done and then presented us the bill very quickly. Must make note that the place was not busy, she just apparently did not want to be there. We normally tip at least 20%, but I struggled leaving 15%. A bit pricey considering the service and over cooked salmon. We will give it one more chance as we had heard so many good things about it, but only one more chance. read more

Delicious dinner. We ordered and have enough for dinner for 2 nights. Food was out quickly, hot, and tasty! I would highly recommend the Fishkill Tomato Cafe! read more

We had a super jolly breakfast here. Everyone happy. Kids all fed and accommodated. Like a slightly fancier diner. Great stuff. read more

One of the nicest customer service experiences I've had in a while! The servers were great, everyone else in the place offered a smile, and the food came out FAST, even on a fairly busy night! Did not try a pizza because I wasn't having a splurge day, but I was able to have a meal that included a lean protein, green vegetables, some roasted potatoes, and a bean salad that were all wonderful. We split it between two people and each had some lentil soup beforehand (which was VERY tasty). This was satisfying because the portions are good! Sister had the pizza and said it was good. Lots of cheese that oozed off of it, which is always a great sign for pizza! Would definitely come back. read more

I ordered a takeout sandwich the other day $16 for two thin slices of eggplant on a roll the role probably cost more than the egg plant itself. I calculate the total cost for the sandwich and since you're doing it on a larger scale than an individual $.45 on the upside . I made it myself tonight and purchased all the ingredients locally two egg whole plants from Adams market $2.75 / 1 freshly made mozzarella from Adams market $6.75 / A bottle of Newmans tomato sauce marinara from Walmart $2.75 / One container of Progresso Italian bread crumbs $1.85 / 2 cups of pompeain robust olive oil from Walmart $ 2 / 10 Fresh rolls from Adams $10 / total cost for ingredients $27 including tax / 20 minutes prep time and 25 minutes cooking made 10 full sandwiches with a half a plate left over . How your kitchen Could let that go out the door in any good conscience and I understand there's hotels nearby but please that is an excusable read more

The Tomato Cafe - The egg plant breaded and fried sandwich two slices for $15 need I say more there's more bread than there is eggplant - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Only been here for Sunday brunch but it was AWESOME! Large and satisfying portions. Strawberry cream cheese French toast was to die for!!! Just a quaint and simple restaurant. I prefer this place as an alternative to the "diner" environment. It's cozy, simple and tasty. read more

Ok, we stopped in for a bite to eat, as we were starving!! The service, atmosphere all seemed ok. We got a classic burger, grilled cheese, and a BLT. Everything seemed ok. I asked for the check, paid it and while walking out, I just happened to look over at the kitchen area, as you can readily see into the kitchen...that's how the place is set up. What do I see????????????? One of the cooks shoving food into her mouth WHILE STANDING OVER THE COOKING LINE AND THE FOOD SHE'S SHOVING IN, FALLS OUT OF HER MOUTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I WANTED TO ABSOLUTELY THROW UP AND THOUGHT I WOULD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I RAN OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I think the health department will need to visit them and bring them up to date on proper kitchen codes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NOT TO MENTION COMMON SENSE, MORAL CODES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DON'T EAT HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

I don't understand the 4 and 5 star reviews of the food here. I ordered for lunch simple dishes where they had an hour or more to prepare. a simple grilled eggplant salad, the caprese and cafe parm dinner (with grilled eggplant). It tasted like they just threw it together without a care in the world. Food should be prepared with care and love. This missed the mark on all dishes. The eggplant on the cafe parm was cut way too thickly and not cooked. It had some grill marks on it for show. There was not taste at all. Eggplant should have herbs, garlic and olive oil prior to grilling so it tastes good. We will have to fix it and cook it later. The penne was good. the eggplant on the salad was much the same, a bit more cooked, absolutely NO taste what so ever. The caprese at lease had fresh mozzarella, the tomatoes cut took thickly, the capers a nice touch. I will not return there. Don't bother. read more

Can't go wrong here! Frequent Pok. location. Thoroughly enjoyed every meal I've tried. Every Friend I've taken left full, happy & looking forward to returning. Food is fresh, presented well and delicious. Servers attentive & knowledgeable. Very clean restaurant. Quality on all levels consistently great. Especially love 1/2 portions, which in my opinion is the perfect portion. Daily Salmon specials scrumptious! Always perfectly done. Enjoy it with spinach which I always ask to be sautéed with garlic. They pleasantly accommodate. They will accommodate any dietary needs in their power pleasantly. More of my favorites have to be Beef stroganoff. Tender beef delicious sauce over perfectly done rigatoni. Such a comfort food! Pasta and meatballs another favorite. Wonderful tomato sauce. Burgers juicy & flavorful. Chicken Paillard another tasty & healthy option. Soups outstanding. Pizza fabulous. All salads fresh & delicious. Fresh warm bread basket very good. Variety daily specials make choosing even more difficult! So many yummy options. Lemon cake lovely dessert treat. Great selection of reasonably priced wines and wonderful beers. I'm comfortable relaxing at bar or sitting at table inside. Decour is lovely. In nice weather enjoy large stone patio outside. Just go, you'll be glad you did. I don't typically give a five star but I believe the Tomato Café deserves it. It is not often you find such consistent good food, service, atmosphere. And all at reasonable prices. Give it a try, I bet it will become your favorite place! It has become mine! read more

This review is being made 90% for the consistent delivery guy alone. He is absolutely fabulous and the most genuinely nice (I think? I hope!) delivery man I have ever met in my entire life. To boot, ordering on a Friday night and legitimately getting my food in just under 35 minutes is pretty stellar. Also, they have fantastic food. The calzones are one of a few select reoccurring cravings. Thankfully, they deliver! read more

Delicious but pricey I will say the pricing is on the higher end of what I would expect to pay for slightly better diner-quality-ish food. The service can sometimes be slow but in the grand scheme of things, these are small issues. This place does not disappoint but there are more affordable places for a comparable meal in the area. read more

The Tomato Cafe straddles the line between casual pizzeria and classy sit-down eatery. A front booth in view of the plasma screen is a safe bet, and the candlelit back area is great for a more intimate occasion. You can also sit in the front window or outside with a cold beer or glass of wine. They have specialty pizzas, sandwiches, and salads, and the day's specials are featured on a chalkboard. Once they had the "secret" favorite sandwich of Philly, which involves roast pork, broccoli rabe and provolone on a toasted roll. I can't say how close to authentic they actually got, but it sure was good. Try the Spinach Salad with sauteed mushrooms and real bacon, or their signature Tomato Soup, with a flavorful kick. You can usually get a warmed-over slice from the counter in a pinch, but you're better off ordering a fresh pie. If you've got room, peep the pastries in the glass case or try some of their delicious gelato. They've got lots of good flavors and fresh fruit add-ins. The waitstaff is nice and professional, and service is good even on busier nights. Steven is great, and once braved torrential downpours and lightning strikes to serve us our food. I recommend it as a great little place for pretty much any occasion. We go all the time! read more

Great place! We enjoyed a very good brunch here. The service was nice, the food selection is good, slightly european.

Pretty good sandwiches here, nice to sit outside on Main Street. Server was real nice and efficient. Too many bad chain restaurants in Fishkill, I mean on every freakin corner. I like to support the local restaurants when I travel. Why do people critique chains? I keep seeing McDonald and bad chain reviews. I don't even consider them real restaurants, who would? read more

My friend and I visited the Tomato Cafe this morning for brunch. So happy we found this hidden gem! The place itself has a great ambiance and top notch service: attentive, but not annoyingly so. The brunch menu was extensive, with many unique and delicious sounding choices. I had the special of eggs benedict with smoked salmon and asparagus and my friend had a caesar salad and a cheese calzone. My food was delicious, crispy potatoes and well poached eggs; my only complaint being that there should have been more asparagus since that was listed as a main ingredient. It came with what seemed like less than one stalk that was sliced up and dropped over top. My friend loved her salad and calzone and finished both! Unfortunately, this cafe is not near me, so I don't anticipate going back soon. I hope to have a reason in the future though so I can try some of their other menu options! read more

Even with the lack of restaurant selection, Fishkill does pretty well for brunch. After a morning hike on Fishkill Ridge, we were famished and needed some hearty food to replenish all those calories. We must've gotten in right before the rush because tables quickly filled up after we got seated. The specials are scribbled on a giant chalkboard in the back, and we ordered away. Everything came out at the same time. We first dug into the pumpkin ravioli, which were divine. The sauce thought wasn't my favorite. I loved how creamy and nutty (pecans) it was, but it was sweeter than some maple syrups I've eaten. I thought it overpowered the delicate ravioli, which were thankfully still able to shine. My crab and spinach omelette was tasty as well, although the crab flavor didn't mesh well with me, and the omelette wasn't cooked too well. (It looked like how I cook omelette, let the egg cook for too long on both side, browning it and giving a rough and chewy texture). The portion was adequate and I gobbled everything else right up. I tried a little of the bf's croque madame, and I instantly regretted my order. The restaurant had a fairly high level of quality, and I'm sure their menu is full of other treasures. Their menu also provided enough options for multiple weekends, so it's no surprise its a town favorite. PS- #400! read more

Good food, and timely service with a smile. What more do you need from an eatery like the tomato cafe? Love the fact that they are super kid friendly also read more

We stopped and picked up a pizza to take out. I was a bit disappointed by the dark cave-like interior. The pizza was "okay" - but it certainly hasn't lured me back. read more

This little neighborhood gem was packed! We had to wait 25 minutes for a table but it was worth it! Days later we were talking about the food! We ordered pizza, pasta, and an appetizer sampler! The wine was good too! read more

See all

The food here is awesome!! We ordered the salmon (cooked perfectly) with rice and spinach, the chicken mushroom wedge (delicious and fresh) with awesome fries, and a personal white pizza (their ricotta mixture is incredible). Portions were really good and everything was fresh and appetizing! The only reason we don't give 5 stars is because the service was a little slow/lackadaisical (besides one gentleman who seemed to be the owner). We would come here again! read more

I love this place! Great food, nothing too fancy, and very well priced. The environment is very comfortable/open and the staff is always super nice. A great place to grab lunch or a quick dinner. I have been here multiple times and have yet to be let down so I highly recommend you try it out! Ps the "Arugula/Prosciutto Pizza" is crazy good! read more

Love this place! Always friendly staff! Food never disappoints. Inside seating as well as few outside tables. I liked their Poughkeepsie location as well but heard that it recently closed. Always a good choice in Fishkill. read more