The Tomato Cafe
Order The Tomato Cafe Takeout or Delivery
THE TOMATO CAFE · YELP ASSISTANT
Ask Yelp Assistant
The Tomato Cafe Photos
Business Info
The Tomato Cafe Popular Dishes
THE TOMATO CAFE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
Recommended Reviews - The Tomato Cafe
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
I had a bowl of the fantastic Butternut Squash with apple soup and a grilled cheese sandwich. Wonderful service, thanks Kathleen!
Food was good. Prosciutto tasted fresh. The French fries were super crunchy and delicious. Plenty of searing. Service was attentive and fast.
Very friendly staff and very attentive as well, keep up with taking plates and helping with questions on the menu. This place does have half portion options which great if you're hungry but don't need a full meal or want to feel bloated afterwards. Tomato soup was definitely the best I ever had, so savory and well seasoned, appreciate that it was very mellow in acidity. Glad the places named for tomatoes did it well. For the linguini pomodoro, I was bit mixed, loved the pomodoro sauce, but I think the dish would better with different type of pasta, since linguini is better for seafood or cream sauces. Meatballs I had added were pretty large, meaty and plenty of flavor, wish you got three instead of two. For what worth I liked the place, and rusty look of place, like dipped floor and the place look like I had probation vibe.
Food is fresh and consistent every time. Staff is friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is my favorite part of it all. Whether you want a booth or table inside. Or that nice nook by the window is my favorite. I sat outside under the beautiful umbrellas lit by string lights. Watching the busy life drive by. I've never sat out back in the patio. I'll have to do that next time. Great menu, many choices. Very accommodating.
First time we'd been, and overall we liked it. My partner had the eggs benedict, and really enjoyed it. I got a BLT with a cup of tomato soup. The sandwich was excellent; the tomato soup kind of tasted like pizza sauce as a soup (which, if that's your thing, you'd really like it!) For me, it had a little too much oregano and possibly some pureed bell peppers in it? I could be wrong, but there was some taste that sort of overpowered the tomato taste. Going on a Sunday morning for brunch, it was pretty crowded -- we'd definitely like to try it for dinner another time. Our server was very nice, as were the other folks we encountered who worked there.
Stopped in for lunch today. A lot to choose from on the menu. We just had a pizza but it was delicious. Fresh ingredients. Crispy crust the way I like it. Friendly service and it was pretty quick. I'd recommend The Tomato Cafe and will be back.
Very nice place for a casual lunch or dinner. Friendly & quick service, and a menu with lots of diverse choices. Ordered the chicken parm as half portion, but it was still too much for me to finish. Make sure to order it with home made pasta though, as that's not included in geh regular dish. Also had a tomato juice which I felt was a bit watery.
First time ordering takeout lunch for a client. Had a chicken and mushroom wedge with fries. Mushrooms were fresh halved mushrooms and chicken was grilled. The chicken was sliced/chopped again, the same as my eggplant in another sandwich from a different restaurant. Must be a regional thing where the fillings are not served whole, which I prefer. Fries were fresh. A bit on the salty side as I think they are brined before frying. Pizzas looked great. Looking forward to going back!
The food is always consistently good here. I like to go here for lunch. I ordered the turkey Reuben with sweet potato fries. My son ordered the grilled cheese. My husband ordered the chicken bacon ranch sandwich. Overall my husbands was the best but we all enjoyed our food and it was good priced. The waitress was also very friendly. We sat outside and it was very peaceful and the wood and brick walls out there were lovely. It was a perfect lunch to a perfect day.
Super cute restaurant, nice staff, decent food. Not the best food around but a nice quaint place to eat. The drunken pasta was great, burger was decent, definitely good pesto (can taste the pine nuts), cheese steak was decent and the last pasta was a little dry. However, I WOULD try this place again!
THE TOMATO CAFE - Fishkill, NY I've been waiting to eat at this establishment. In the past I ended up going to the Greek restaurant and the German restaurant that are literally a few walking feet away on the same side of the block, mostly because the Tomatoe Cafe closes at 3pm on sundays. But, arrive in time as it is worth going for lunch!!!! The menu was WONDERFUL! Many delicious choices with options that are vegetarian friendly! Most importantly, the food is delicious and FRESH! First off, beverages were ordered. As usual my sweetheart ordered green tea with lemon and honey. I ordered coffee with half and half and Splenda. The coffee was watery. ( I guess I prefer strong coffee and will select a different option next time. The wait staff/ waiters and staff whip around the place with energy and enthusiasm! The young man that welcomed us at the front door was so friendly and welcoming! It was very very nice to receive such a warm welcome. The front counter display is wonderfully full of desserts, pecan crusted honey buns, cream cheese iced carrot cake, cheesecake and more. What an amazing sight. I knew I wanted dessert just from seeing that case! At the counter is a also container of m&m's for visitors to take a scoop when at the counter. How awesome is that! I could see all of this from where our table was. (See pic) The tables and atmosphere overall is country kitchen meets picnic table church pews. It is country cozy. I kinda was transported to my "Big mom" (grandmother) kitchen nook. Sunday the place closes at 3pm and people came in up until that time, with one group coming in after 3pm but were turned away. The food is freshly prepared so I do understand. People, arrive before 3pm!!! So the food... I ordered grilled cheese on wheat sourdough with salad, and my sweetheart ordered cheesesteak sandwich and fries. I had wanted the quesadillas on the special but it was sold out. The crispy fries that came with my sweethearts meal were so good I almost ordered my own because they were super delicious! The side salad of fresh greens was very fresh!! And the croutons were homemade with rye bread. I so LOVED the grill cheese sandwich. I selected wheat sourdough and it was scrumptious! This bread is extraordinary. So overall, food=9.5, atmosphere 7.5, beverages 6.5, service greeted enthusiastically so greet gets a 10, and waiter was attentive but with one part snarky so he gets an 8. Food arrived on a timely manner which was awesome. Although my first choice of Barria quesadillas was sold out , my second choice was very good. I recommend and will go back for more grilled cheese sandwiches and to try other options also. Oh yes, the food is moderately priced and affordable. This place is great! Thank you to the tomato cafe for a great affordable and fresh meal!
Great place with plenty of space for family with kids. Love the taste of their pizza dough! It's yummy itself eating the dough so whatever else you put in their would add to the combo. Bruschetta of the day was good but didn't like the salads. I just didn't think salad goes well with the bruschetta. Anyways lovely place great service :) minus one star - wish they could tell us we could park behind the restaurant and there was a direct entrance to the restaurant from the back.
1 month ago
Finished with my appointments and other chores and didn't feel like cooking. Got lucky finding a spot in front of the establishment. There's a sign that Wednesday's a large pizza is $15, seemed like serendipity. It was ok, enough for a few people. There are prepackaged seasonings to adjust the taste to your liking. read more
We stopped into Tomato Cafe on the way to a Renegades game, and I'm glad we did. We were seated quickly by the pleasant wait staff. We saw all the seats were taken on the front patio, so figured we would have to sit inside. We were pleasantly surprised more outdoor seating in the back patio. Very nice set-up, made us feel like we were in our own backyard. Very comfortable setting. The turkey rueben and fries were delicious, and only $12. Caesar Salad was very fresh and not too overly dressed. The Creamy Potato soup was chock full of flavor, but a little pricey at $8 for a cup. Parking is always challenging on a nice day in the Village of Fishkill. read more
10 months ago
I had a bowl of the fantastic Butternut Squash with apple soup and a grilled cheese sandwich. Wonderful service, thanks Kathleen! read more
Very friendly staff and very attentive as well, keep up with taking plates and helping with questions on the menu. This place does have half portion options which great if you're hungry but don't need a full meal or want to feel bloated afterwards. Tomato soup was definitely the best I ever had, so savory and well seasoned, appreciate that it was very mellow in acidity. Glad the places named for tomatoes did it well. For the linguini pomodoro, I was bit mixed, loved the pomodoro sauce, but I think the dish would better with different type of pasta, since linguini is better for seafood or cream sauces. Meatballs I had added were pretty large, meaty and plenty of flavor, wish you got three instead of two. For what worth I liked the place, and rusty look of place, like dipped floor and the place look like I had probation vibe. read more
Food is fresh and consistent every time. Staff is friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is my favorite part of it all. Whether you want a booth or table inside. Or that nice nook by the window is my favorite. I sat outside under the beautiful umbrellas lit by string lights. Watching the busy life drive by. I've never sat out back in the patio. I'll have to do that next time. Great menu, many choices. Very accommodating. read more
4 years ago
First time we'd been, and overall we liked it. My partner had the eggs benedict, and really enjoyed it. I got a BLT with a cup of tomato soup. The sandwich was excellent; the tomato soup kind of tasted like pizza sauce as a soup (which, if that's your thing, you'd really like it!) For me, it had a little too much oregano and possibly some pureed bell peppers in it? I could be wrong, but there was some taste that sort of overpowered the tomato taste. Going on a Sunday morning for brunch, it was pretty crowded -- we'd definitely like to try it for dinner another time. Our server was very nice, as were the other folks we encountered who worked there. read more
Stopped in for lunch today. A lot to choose from on the menu. We just had a pizza but it was delicious. Fresh ingredients. Crispy crust the way I like it. Friendly service and it was pretty quick. I'd recommend The Tomato Cafe and will be back. read more
11 months ago
Very nice place for a casual lunch or dinner. Friendly & quick service, and a menu with lots of diverse choices. Ordered the chicken parm as half portion, but it was still too much for me to finish. Make sure to order it with home made pasta though, as that's not included in geh regular dish. Also had a tomato juice which I felt was a bit watery. read more
10 months ago
First time ordering takeout lunch for a client. Had a chicken and mushroom wedge with fries. Mushrooms were fresh halved mushrooms and chicken was grilled. The chicken was sliced/chopped again, the same as my eggplant in another sandwich from a different restaurant. Must be a regional thing where the fillings are not served whole, which I prefer. Fries were fresh. A bit on the salty side as I think they are brined before frying. Pizzas looked great. Looking forward to going back! read more
2 years ago
The food is always consistently good here. I like to go here for lunch. I ordered the turkey Reuben with sweet potato fries. My son ordered the grilled cheese. My husband ordered the chicken bacon ranch sandwich. Overall my husbands was the best but we all enjoyed our food and it was good priced. The waitress was also very friendly. We sat outside and it was very peaceful and the wood and brick walls out there were lovely. It was a perfect lunch to a perfect day. read more
3 years ago
Super cute restaurant, nice staff, decent food. Not the best food around but a nice quaint place to eat. The drunken pasta was great, burger was decent, definitely good pesto (can taste the pine nuts), cheese steak was decent and the last pasta was a little dry. However, I WOULD try this place again! read more
3 years ago
THE TOMATO CAFE - Fishkill, NY I've been waiting to eat at this establishment. In the past I ended up going to the Greek restaurant and the German restaurant that are literally a few walking feet away on the same side of the block, mostly because the Tomatoe Cafe closes at 3pm on sundays. But, arrive in time as it is worth going for lunch!!!! The menu was WONDERFUL! Many delicious choices with options that are vegetarian friendly! Most importantly, the food is delicious and FRESH! First off, beverages were ordered. As usual my sweetheart ordered green tea with lemon and honey. I ordered coffee with half and half and Splenda. The coffee was watery. ( I guess I prefer strong coffee and will select a different option next time. The wait staff/ waiters and staff whip around the place with energy and enthusiasm! The young man that welcomed us at the front door was so friendly and welcoming! It was very very nice to receive such a warm welcome. The front counter display is wonderfully full of desserts, pecan crusted honey buns, cream cheese iced carrot cake, cheesecake and more. What an amazing sight. I knew I wanted dessert just from seeing that case! At the counter is a also container of m&m's for visitors to take a scoop when at the counter. How awesome is that! I could see all of this from where our table was. (See pic) The tables and atmosphere overall is country kitchen meets picnic table church pews. It is country cozy. I kinda was transported to my "Big mom" (grandmother) kitchen nook. Sunday the place closes at 3pm and people came in up until that time, with one group coming in after 3pm but were turned away. The food is freshly prepared so I do understand. People, arrive before 3pm!!! So the food... I ordered grilled cheese on wheat sourdough with salad, and my sweetheart ordered cheesesteak sandwich and fries. I had wanted the quesadillas on the special but it was sold out. The crispy fries that came with my sweethearts meal were so good I almost ordered my own because they were super delicious! The side salad of fresh greens was very fresh!! And the croutons were homemade with rye bread. I so LOVED the grill cheese sandwich. I selected wheat sourdough and it was scrumptious! This bread is extraordinary. So overall, food=9.5, atmosphere 7.5, beverages 6.5, service greeted enthusiastically so greet gets a 10, and waiter was attentive but with one part snarky so he gets an 8. Food arrived on a timely manner which was awesome. Although my first choice of Barria quesadillas was sold out , my second choice was very good. I recommend and will go back for more grilled cheese sandwiches and to try other options also. Oh yes, the food is moderately priced and affordable. This place is great! Thank you to the tomato cafe for a great affordable and fresh meal! read more
Great place with plenty of space for family with kids. Love the taste of their pizza dough! It's yummy itself eating the dough so whatever else you put in their would add to the combo. Bruschetta of the day was good but didn't like the salads. I just didn't think salad goes well with the bruschetta. Anyways lovely place great service :) minus one star - wish they could tell us we could park behind the restaurant and there was a direct entrance to the restaurant from the back. read more
1 year ago
1 year ago
3 years ago
We came bc our friend recommended. He was last here 2019. He said the menu had changed. He ordered standard BLT & fries. We ordered vegan grilled veggie pizza & side of fries. The fries were oily & tasted old.. small leftover pieces. The vegan pizza was ok. We had up add lots of seasonings & salt. The BLT was mediocre...he only ate half of it. The service was great! They were quick & friendly but the meal was very disappointing. We wouldn't recommend it for anyone who is eating plant base. Only 3 things on the menu plant based...veggie wrap, protein bowl & veggie pizza. read more
2 years ago
4 years ago
4 years ago
2 years ago
4 years ago
Food is always delicious! This restaurant keeps everything clean and in compliance with the recent Covid guidelines. Our table and chairs were thoroughly cleaned with disinfectant and they provide disposable menus. All staff wears mask and gloves. The food: delish! I ordered the harvest salad and added grilled chicken. Balsamic dressing on the side really complements the salad well and as the right amount of tang to counterbalance the mild soft and mellow flavor of the goat cheese. The grilled chicken was cooked perfect and had great grilled flavor. My friends had the Philly cheesesteak With all the trimmings and they were raving about it. Every time I come here the food is good so I expect that on each visit. read more
2 years ago
The Tomato Cafe provides a great option for local delivery and curbside pickup during these strange COVID-19 times. It was as easy as calling in, putting an order for a couple of pizzas, and paying over the phone via credit card. 20 mins later I was able to pick up my pizza curbside with zero hassle. Thanks, Tomato Cafe! The pizza itself is solid for the area but doesn't quite touch the quality of pizzerias in Brooklyn or Manhattan. Overall I give this place a solid 4 stars for solid pizza, ease of ordering, and seamless pickup. read more
3 years ago
3 years ago
4 years ago
Stay comfy in your hotel or home because The Tomato Cafe has free delivery to your door.The food was hot and fresh. We ordered Mozzarella triangles, Beef Stroganoff and of course pizza with meatballs on top. For the dinners you can get full sized entrees or half. The Beef Stroganoff had an authentic German sauce with sour cream, a very hearty amount of beef tips and served over pasta. The mozzarella triangles were great and served with homemade sauce. Lastly, the pizza.....after two slices I was full, the meatballs were homemade and plentiful and the taste of the pizza was delish. This was our first time trying The Tomato Cafe but will not be the last. read more
7 years ago
Quick, courteous and the food is divine. Michael was our waiter this evening. He was very pleasant and accommodating to us. We had the Tomato Soup, a Cafe cheeseburger, Bacon Egg and cheese on a roll. Chicken parmigiana sandwich, salad (dressing to die for..all freshly made in house), and also the Tuna Nicoice. The fries were nicely, well done, just the way I like them. Music is in good taste and not too loud that we couldnt talk. For dessert we had the Apple turnover a la mode. Presentation was beautiful! Thanks Tomato Café and Michael to a job well done. read more
3 years ago
8 years ago
6 years ago
Went here for dinner. Had to go up to the counter to ask for our soup the waiter forgot to bring it to us.Started with the butternut squash soup with apples it was not good. It was like a mushy soup almost like baby food and was cold. The waiter didn't serve it right away so it sat in the window waiting to go to our table. My friend had the tomato soup it was on the colder side too but we couldn't bother to complain Bc the waiter didn't come over until he brought the main course whatever. There tomato soup is more like a marinara sauce. It needs some cream! The waiter was not attentive and there was no one else in the restaurant! Next came the Gouda grilled cheese and fries. Like how can you mess this up right? The cheese was not fully cooked in the grilled cheese it was such a turn off. French fries were ok but tasted like old oil. My friend had the chicken Alfredo she said it was ok. Waiter never even came over to refill our drinks. Yea no thanks I'm skipping this place next time. read more
2 years ago
Page 1 of 8
More info about The Tomato Cafe
1123 Main St
Fishkill, NY 12524
Directions
(845) 896-7779
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
https://www.tomatocafeny.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - The Tomato Cafe
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
25 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
10 years ago
8 years ago
10 years ago
12 years ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
13 years ago
15 years ago
12 years ago
5 years ago
9 years ago
4 years ago
11 years ago
4 years ago
11 years ago
9 years ago
14 years ago
10 years ago
15 years ago
