Cancel

Open app

Search

Fishkill Prime

4.3 (16 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

Order Fishkill Prime Takeout or Delivery

FISHKILL PRIME · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

Fishkill Prime Photos

Business Info

FISHKILL PRIME ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Fishkill Prime

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Steak
Neha P.

Great food, staff, and service. Went here for dinner and was greeted with several dining options. Endless specials with quick service. Vast amount of dining seating with a full bar.

Bone-in Ribeye
Samantha R.

Our dinner plans on Mother's Days fell through and we called around to find somewhere to go to celebrate Mother's Day with my family. We were able to get last minute reservations for prime dinner time at Fishkill Prime. Upon arrival we saw that they had decorated nicely for the occasion. We were given a choice of which dining room to be seated in. Sadly, I was on medication that I can't mix with liquor, so it was just a Diet Coke for me. They were offering complementary wine spritzers to all the mothers. We ordered the escargot and Brussels sprouts to start. The escargot was good, but the Brussels sprouts were the star of the show! My husband makes incredible Brussels sprouts at home, even he had to admit that these were far superior to his own. For our entrees I ordered the duck and it was amazing. My husband ordered the ribeye. He said it was very good but a little on the salty side. Our daughter ordered the sea bass and said it was very good. This is definitely a great place for a date night or to celebrate a special occasion. We will definitely be back and I will try their cocktails when we do.

Oysters
Adam C.

The staff is amazing and genuinely exceptional while the food was some of the best ive had for a while ESPECIALLY their sushi and service was great as well will definetely come back as we were shut out of our original plans for dinner that night and had to make due and this establishment pulled through beyond our expectations

We were intending to go to a different restaurant in Fishkill on a Sunday night and found Fishkill Prime - it looked classy and comfortable. Bottom line it lived up to the appearance. Had the salmon per the recommendation of the waiter who knew the menu. It was soft, well prepared and mouth watering. The following week tried the Chilean seabass and it was equally light and delicious. We brought guests here twice now and look forward to coming again!

4 cheese ravioli with bolognese sauce and spicy rigatoni topped with barrata and pesto.

See all

Photo of Chad L.
12
230
670

1 month ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Sara D.
192
1014
5465

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

4 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 2
Photo of Matt W.
14
198
249

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 3
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 4
Love this 4
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Fishkill Prime

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Seafood 495 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Joe Willy's Seafood House - Fisherman's platter of broiled lobster tail, shrimp and cod.

Joe Willy's Seafood House

3.7(149 reviews)
5.4 mi
•$$

First time dining at Joe Wily's. We were greeted and seated right away The staff were very…read morefriendly, courteous and efficient. The menu had a large variety The seafood was very fresh and large portions. I had shrimp stuffed with crab-meat and I could actually taste the crabmeat it was not all bread crumb. The space was bright and decorated very nice. There was plenty of room between tables and we did not feel we were sitting on top of everyone. We are from Long Island where you get some of the freshest seafood. The quality was as good as we have eaten on Long Island. We definitely will be going back.

We were warmly greeted upon arrival at the restaurant by a very kind gentleman, who we later…read morelearned was the owner. The space is tastefully decorated with nautical and ocean-inspired elements, featuring navy blue and white walls. Our waiter was immediately aware of my food allergies and my husband's celiac condition. He guided us through the menu with confidence, offering thoughtful recommendations based on our dietary restrictions and personal tastes. Many of the dishes could be customized in terms of preparation and side choices, which we appreciated. For drinks, my husband ordered his usual--a margarita--while I decided to try something new and went with the Backyard Iced Tea. His margarita was freshly made and even better served in a Yankees glass. The Backyard Iced Tea was fantastic--refreshing, not too sweet (which I loved), and it truly tasted like iced tea with a hint of lemon. Unlike a Long Island Iced Tea, it wasn't overly alcoholic or sugary, which suited my preferences perfectly. For dinner, my husband ordered one of the specials: Cajun-style red snapper with a side of sautéed spinach and a house salad (no croutons, with blue cheese dressing). I chose the broiled trio--lobster tail, shrimp, and cod--along with sautéed spinach and a house salad dressed with balsamic vinaigrette. Everything was delicious. The salads were fresh, and the balsamic dressing was excellent. My seafood was perfectly cooked and seasoned with salt, pepper, garlic, and paprika, then served with lemon and clarified butter. My husband's snapper was outstanding--probably the best I've ever tasted--and the sautéed spinach complemented both of our dishes beautifully. Overall, our meals were phenomenal. When we're craving seafood, we'll definitely be coming back.

Photos
Joe Willy's Seafood House - Bar area

Bar area

Joe Willy's Seafood House - Zuppa de Pesce

Zuppa de Pesce

Joe Willy's Seafood House - The entrance to the best seafood in Dutchess County.

See all

The entrance to the best seafood in Dutchess County.

Captain Jake's - Buffalo wings

Captain Jake's

3.7(389 reviews)
5.8 mi
•$$

Captain Jake's is one of our favorite spots on the Newburgh waterfront! The location is hard to…read morebeat, and the views of the Hudson River are absolutely beautiful--especially if you're lucky enough to sit outside. It's the perfect place to relax, enjoy a meal, and take in the scenery. The seafood is always fresh and delicious. We especially enjoy the raw bar, the lobster rolls, the New England clam chowder, and the Oysters Rockefeller. They also have great cocktails, making it a wonderful spot for lunch, dinner, or a special night out. The service has always been friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere is casual, welcoming, and perfect for families or a date night. If you're looking for great seafood with one of the best waterfront views in Newburgh, Captain Jake's is definitely worth a visit. We'll absolutely be back!

I have read many past reviews. I think this is a place that few areas have. It's a unique place,…read morethat serves thoughtfully crafted dishes. The main theme seems to be fresh fish, seafood, and it seems fresh everything else. (Confirmed that they get fresh shipments daily). With reservations for 9 at 6:30 on a Monday, where many places are closed, we walked into a fully booked restaurant. Our giant table stood out amongst all the other full tables that were in various stages of dining. So, we took up a decent amount of the restaurant space. A reunion with family and so were happy to talk and have some bread, and drinks while they were wrapping up their other patrons also enjoying themselves. The main purpose seemed to be to time taking our orders in a way that they would come out properly. As the food came out, it was one wonderful dish after another. I could name and describe eschar one, but fresh and flavorful is the best way. I can imagine that at the time when we arrived that the kitchen was hopping. The chefs seemed to focus very well on each individual order, so of course it took some, but not excessive time. As it took a little while to start we also were not rushed out. Perhaps if we had gotten there at 5 then I suppose we might have been moved along some, since restaurants need to get some turnover at the peak hours, we were happy to offer some well rewarded patience, which was reciprocated with polite, warm, service and great food. This is a regular place for locals who know what they like. It is well worth putting some effort in to explore the various foods and drinks offered, as they were all exceptional. So, I must give it 5 stars. The food is fantastic, the atmosphere is unique and actually stunning, especially during daylight where you are overlooking the Hudson and into the mountains across the river. Thus, it is a great landmark establishment of the Newburgh area.

Photos
Captain Jake's
Captain Jake's - Rings and tentacles

Rings and tentacles

Captain Jake's

See all

Riverview Restaurant

Riverview Restaurant

3.9(349 reviews)
8.5 mi
•$$

A bunch of Friends came to Cold Spring New York for a fun day trip to see the fall foliage colors…read more We had lunch at Riverview Restaurant. MAKE RESERVATIONS! We all thoroughly enjoyed our food. The pizza was exceptional. There were 5 of us so we shared a sweet sausage peppers onions and mushroom pie. Do try! I had the big bowl of mussels made with butter garlic and lemon. Delish. One woman had the burger which was perfectly cooked. But the best part was the side of fries. Shoe string perfectly salted. OMG! See photos The wait service was wonderful. So friendly. So cheerful. Our only comment is that it's a bit tight seating. Otherwise great experience. MAKE RESERVATIONS!!

Had a wonderful dinner with good friends at The Riverview last weekend. We had never visited Cold…read moreSpring before and arrived early to walk Main Street and check out the place. We chatted with a couple of store owners, and they all recommended Riverview as the place to eat. We had already made reservations there weeks before. We loved the town and enjoyed the afternoon; we highly recommend spending a sunny summer or fall day there. Now about the restaurant. We were given a very good table in a private corner so that we could talk freely without disruption. The service was friendly and attentive without being intrusive. We never felt rushed. The ambiance is not the feature here, but there are nice river views and outdoor dining. We sat inside. The food was very good, even if not what I consider haute cuisine. For the first course, I had the watermelon and feta salad; it was nice and refreshing, even if the watermelon was a bit old. For the main course, I had a pork chop with a potato croquette, and my wife had the fish. We both enjoyed our dinners. We finished with two desserts: bread pudding and a Peach melba. Overall, I recommend the Riverview and will probably be back the next time we visit. If you do stop in, say hello to the bartender, Shauan-Michel.

Photos
Riverview Restaurant
Riverview Restaurant - Fish and shellfish stew

Fish and shellfish stew

Riverview Restaurant

See all

The Lobster Shack - Lobster grilled cheese

The Lobster Shack

4.3(499 reviews)
57.5 mi
•$$$

Took a trip for some lobster with some out of town relatives who wanted lobster rolls. There was…read more10 of us. Went in no reservations and thought we'd have to wait if need be. The hostess was quite accommodating and had a table for 10 made up for us and seated us rather quickly. The waitress was so nice and quick to get us our drink orders. We were in about 12-1230 on a Sunday. You can't not order the lobster bomb when you come here if you were a lobster fan. It's honestly the most delicious thing ever! We ordered the clams casino, and it's not the traditional clams casino with the bacon and the peppers and the stuffing sort of breadcrumbs it had all of those items in it, but it was came out with dipping bread and very flavorful. so good. Majority of our table got lobster bombs and lobster rolls. and everybody was thrilled with them. We actually came back another day, just my husband and myself. I got another lobster bomb and he got the fried combination. No complaints. Flavorful, delicious. This place is a must try. There's great views of the water, plentiful parking, and lots of places to sit if you get a nice day, sit up on the deck outside!

We visited recently - Fried Cod Fish was great…read more Plenty of Off Street Parking in their lot. Mikey the Waiter was very good and attentive - thanks. Rick the Chef did a very nice job on our meal.

Photos
The Lobster Shack - Seating area

Seating area

The Lobster Shack - Mussels

Mussels

The Lobster Shack - Vanilla persecco martini with pretty flowers

See all

Vanilla persecco martini with pretty flowers

Danny's Table - Oysters, Rockefeller

Danny's Table

4.6(46 reviews)
0.0 mi

Been coming back to this restaurant and every experience has been sensational. The environment is…read morecozy, the service is impeccable and the food is insatiable. Brought some friends with me and they couldn't get over how good the food and drinks were. I highly recommend you try this restaurant out. Parking in the back too. One of Fishkill best in my opinion!

Figured I'd try the place earlier this week based on the yelp reviews. Restaurant is in a space…read morethat's had a lot of turnover through the years, but reviews were good and it looked updated. Sat at the bar and ordered a strawberry mojito. Fresh strawberries and mint were nice to see, but there was hardly any alcohol in the drink and the straw was far too narrow to be able to take a sip without it becoming obstructed. Poured woefully short as well, topped with even more ice and seltzer. Had the tempura shrimp to start. Generous portion, well seasoned. Slightly rubbery but not detracting from the dish. Aioli was great, but could have used a little more. Chili sauce was also good, but could barely get any in the ramekin it was in. Bacon cheeseburger with mushroom for my main followed. Looking back, there was actually NO bacon on the burger. Not sure if the kitchen overlooked it, or what. $4 for added mushrooms seemed a bit exorbitant at first, but they were oyster mushrooms. Fries were crisp and wonderfully seasoned. Ordered the burger medium - came out medium and juicy.... But absolutely flavorless. If their head chef loved salt like their fry cook, this burger would have been spectacular. The mushrooms never got to drive off extra water because of the lack of salt, and the meat just fell flat without seasoning. I wanted to love this burger, but I just couldn't no matter how hard I tried. Had the crack pie, advertised to be similar to Monofuku Milk Bar... for someone who had crack pie multiple times before it became the phenomena it is now, this falls short, by a lot. The chess pie filling is far too dense, lacking caramelization. The pie crust was undercooked and anemic. Sugar decoration on top added zero value to the dessert, and coconut ice cream is far too competitive a flavor to put against this dessert. Sauces on the plate were weak and boring eye service. Paid my $80 bill, tipped (even though the bartender was rarely seen or asking how things were), and headed out. For a quiet weekday, the service and quality of food were severely underwhelming.

Photos
Danny's Table
Danny's Table
Danny's Table - Blue Fin Tuna Pizzetta

See all

Blue Fin Tuna Pizzetta

Fishkill Prime - seafood - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...