I have read many past reviews. I think this is a place that few areas have. It's a unique place, that serves thoughtfully crafted dishes. The main theme seems to be fresh fish, seafood, and it seems fresh everything else. (Confirmed that they get fresh shipments daily). With reservations for 9 at 6:30 on a Monday, where many places are closed, we walked into a fully booked restaurant. Our giant table stood out amongst all the other full tables that were in various stages of dining. So, we took up a decent amount of the restaurant space. A reunion with family and so were happy to talk and have some bread, and drinks while they were wrapping up their other patrons also enjoying themselves. The main purpose seemed to be to time taking our orders in a way that they would come out properly. As the food came out, it was one wonderful dish after another. I could name and describe eschar one, but fresh and flavorful is the best way. I can imagine that at the time when we arrived that the kitchen was hopping. The chefs seemed to focus very well on each individual order, so of course it took some, but not excessive time. As it took a little while to start we also were not rushed out. Perhaps if we had gotten there at 5 then I suppose we might have been moved along some, since restaurants need to get some turnover at the peak hours, we were happy to offer some well rewarded patience, which was reciprocated with polite, warm, service and great food. This is a regular place for locals who know what they like. It is well worth putting some effort in to explore the various foods and drinks offered, as they were all exceptional. So, I must give it 5 stars. The food is fantastic, the atmosphere is unique and actually stunning, especially during daylight where you are overlooking the Hudson and into the mountains across the river. Thus, it is a great landmark establishment of the Newburgh area. read more

See all

The service was long, like 25 min waiting on a coctails, after 20min to order. And another 20 min for the food to come out. The portions were big. That probably the only great going going for them. It felt like a decent diner cook was given a fancy menu and they let him figure it out on his own. On a positive side coctails had decent amount of alcohol in them. That saved the night read more

Captain Jake's - Pollock fish with crab stuffing with some kind of sauce that frankly didn't taste like much. - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

This place is delicious! We were up visiting our daughter at West Point and had the pleasure of dining here on a Saturday night- made a reservation earlier that day and we were lucky they could accommodate us. All of the servers were prompt and so friendly. Super accommodating. The food was delicious. The specials were all great. Menu is large! I love having a lot to choose from. There is patio seating but it was chilly when we were there ( October ) so we had a table inside. I feel like it's a place a lot of locals hang out as the bar was super crowded. I would highly suggest checking it out! The flounder with crab on top and a saffron cream sauce was delicious! The salmon with ginger glaze was great. The penne with mozzarella on top was a special and we licked the plate! Check out Captain Jake's! It's a great date night restaurant! read more

Ate here last night and it was okay. No frills thrill. I ordered lobster bisque and it was too thick and salty. My husband ordered the mussels and he said they were the best he had eaten. I ordered a New England lobster roll with butter and it was okay. The bread was a bit soggy from the butter and I had mostly claw meat in the sandwich roll. My husband ordered baked cod stuffed with crab meat. He said the crab meat was mixed with a lot bread crumbs and it was okay. However, he loved the broccoli and mashed potatoes. I ordered lemonade and it was decent and my husband ordered a glass of wine. They had a variety of desserts but we didn't order any. The servers were nice and the food came out quickly after it was ordered. read more

Always a good time at Capt. Jake's. Food, service and dock side view, the best. I can't remember a time where I left Capt. Jake's unhappy with my meal. Love it there. read more

See all

We are from out of town and wanted a place in the water. The playlists is good. Nicole was our server and she was "dynamite!" Very attentive, bright, and fast. The food has a few complaints: the potato croquet was cold in the middle (they solved that problem) , chicken parmigiana the pasta was great the chicken tasted microwaved. The dessert the brownie wasn't hot. Restaurant is clean, warm and a homey feeling read more

See all

The food is always good I have dined here a few times now. Very fresh. I usually sit at a table but I sat at the bar and was disappointed by the service. Felt totally ignored. Next time I will sit at a table. read more

Our waitress was amazing. The scenery was amazing. The food was amazing. The deciding factor for me is always "Will I come back?" The answer here is absolutely read more

Captain Jake's - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

After coming from Blu pointe , I have to say we were really impressed . They had a nice bottle of Cabernet. We sat out on the patio and for March is was quite warm . I ordered the margarita steamers and Caesar salad . My hubby had the surf and turf with a market price of 56.00 and I have to say the mignon was simply grilled and cooked to perfection and I was totally amazed at the size of lobster tail that came with it . The meal was very good and we would return . read more

On the Newburgh waterfront Captain Jake has been a fixture here for many years. My first time trying this establishment and I found it to be a very eclectic ambience. The service is excellent and the food was fantastic. There was no wait today and plenty of outside seating. I highly recommend this restaurant and I will be back to try it again in the near future. If you ever find yourself in the Newburgh area, pay a visit down to the waterfront and stop in at Captain Jake's. You'll be glad you did. read more

See all

It's been a while I only been there twice* had the haddock* dinner twice to-go I don't remember the meal lol haddock anything is usually delicious anywhere on the east coast much more tastier going north read more

Captain Jake's at the Newburgh waterfront offers great views, great food & drinks! Never a long wait when I visit & all the staff are friendly. read more

See all

Good food, good service, great view. What more can you ask for? They had a special when I went ... the wasabi shrimp wrapped in bacon. Wow to say the least. Steak was cooked perfectly and sides were just as enjoyable. read more

My friends took me out for a seafood dinner; it was my birthday. This place is closer than City Island in the Bronx. There's a view of the Hudson. A nice touch. Initially, I would've given it a much higher rating. It was the final minutes of our celebration; that changed my mind. More on that later*. Two appetizers, three double shots of Don Julio reposado, 2 glasses of wine, large bottle of S. Pelegríno, four entrées, four desserts, double espressos, and cappuccino. The portions were ample, not over the top. The sauce on the cod with crab meat was a little dry from being under the broiler too long. I asked for some on the side. It was closer to lobster bisque, it made a big difference in the palatability. * Some tips for the management: the waitstaff hangs out by the pass schmoozing, instead of attending to their patrons, the idea of shooting up a flare to get their attention came to mind. When they bring the check - it's signed and they come back for it. Then we're done and ready to leave. It's a form of age discrimination. The hostess that seated us; came over and very RUDELY and VERY bluntly told us she needs our table and HAVE to LEAVE! The ink on the paper had barely dried; when she suddenly showed up. THERE WERE TWO AVAILABLE tables on the patio and a few empty ones inside. With that UNPROFESSIONAL attitude; it definitely would have cancelled the servers gratuity. Then they wonder why Boomers sometimes don't tip them well?! It's a self-fulfilling prophecy. read more

See all

We have been coming to Capt. Jakes for 14 yrs. Not one bad thing of Capt. Jakes. Everything from the hostess, waiters, etc. They are great. Trained very well. Polite, accommodating, friendly and service always with a smile. As for the food. NOT one bad dish. Thank you Capt. Jakes for everything. read more

Amazing service always the food is amazing. The staff is amazing. I cannot remember our server name that we have all the time, but we have been there with parties of eight and parties of six during the day and actually on Monday nights and she has always taken care of us. She has light brown hair probably about 58. I just feel bad. I can't remember her name, but she is always amazing. The food there is way better than Blu Pointe. Who charges you three times the amount. Go to Captain Jakes and get food that's worth the money and don't get ripped off. We used to go to Blu Pointe but they just became so snobby and Captain Jake is so much more friendly. read more

Nice seafood joint on the Hudson River. Sat in the heated potch and enjoyed a blood orange mule and a bubbly sangria before meals of Sole with a lemon sauce and fish and chips. Both were good service was a little relaxed but good. read more

Captain Jake's - Fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

one cool place to just sit catch a break have a mean by the water break open a beer crack a lobster too

Come for the drinks and the view. If you're hungry, get the cheeseburger. Kitchen doesn't know how to cook seafood or what "pan-seared" means. Rest of the house is good. read more

I love visiting this place! The food and ambiance are both amazing. Excellent views of the water, even in the winter months. Love sitting outside on the heated patio. I am NOT a seafood eater, yet there are several food items that on my list of all time favorites. First, I love the Cajun chicken Caesar salad. I meant to snap a pic, however I devoured it too quickly. Second, the chicken parm is really amazing. There is something in the breading (which is just the right amount) that has a lil kick and how tender the chicken is that makes it one of my favorite chicken parm of all time - and it's not even an Italian restaurant!!! Others who I dine with love the mussels and the Kung Pao shrimp. Definitely one of my favs! read more

Captain Jake's - View of the river through the enclosed patio. - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Amazing delicious place. Good vibes views and seafood. Papoaderlle and lobster. Waterfront in Newburgh.

Love this place! Food is delicious. Prices are what you'd expect from a waterfront seafood restaurant. I've usually gone off-peak hours, so I never had trouble getting a table. I've heard it gets really packed during prime-time dinner. Worth it! read more

The food and service were outstanding! The view also can't be beat. Will definitely be back.

The view from the patio is wonderful (5 stars). The food was okay (3 stars). Our server happened to be exceptionally slow, but it is unclear if that is true of all the servers. read more

Part of the self mini pub crawl we did at Front Street, Captain Jake's never disappoints. I love IPAs and unfortunately, they only have 1 or two on tap. I always try and hunt for the best calamari, Buffalo wings, among some of my favorite appetizers and these weren't bad. read more

See all

My daughter and I had lunch here this week. The service was the worst I've ever had at any restaurant. We were seated at 1:00 and saw no one until 1:20. Finally, the bartender came to get our drink and food orders. Still no server. "He was supposedly "busy". After waiting another 25 minutes, our "server" showed up and flung our food on the table and said he was really busy. We had no other interaction with him, till the bill came. I had a lobster roll with lobster that was pretty tasteless and a "salad" that was a huge bunch of arugala. The table next to the water was nice, but otherwise a very disappointing dining experience. read more

Great food! Never had an issue with waiting for a table. We love their drinks and fresh seafood. Love sitting outside by the water. read more

Captain Jake's - lazy man's lobster and stuffed fish! - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Tried & true seafood restaurant with the best water views. Our waitress Brianna was amazing, she was so attentive, remembered things we asked each other about the food in passing, and the food is fairly fast. We tried both their split pea with chorizo soup and French onion soup, the French onion was great but I found the split pea to be so-so. The halibut special was delicious, had a great crust and the lemon sauce was very rich. Our friend loved the seafood fra diavolo and the fried calamari appetizer is delicious as well. Love this place! read more

See all

I can't comment on all the food my family got but I can say that the clams were good and so were the fries and NE clam chowder. however the lobster rolls were cold. I was expecting the buns to be nice and warm and the lobster to also be that way, but because it was quite cold, I didn't enjoy it that much. My dad later took it home and heated it up in the toaster oven, which I think made for a better meal. The service from our waitress was exceptional though! read more

See all

When we got to Jake's I love how we were seated right by the water front. The waitress was kind and very attentive. The establishment was a very comfortable and casual place to have dinner. I immediately started with drinks and appetizers, I didnt want a drink too strong so I ordered a wine (Rosè) it was perfect! and for my appetizer I decided to try for the first time oysters Rockefeller and it was absolutely delicious!!!! The little neck clams was extremely fresh and the calamari was too. I would come just to order appetizers all day! For my main meal I ordered the surf and turf with the butternut squash risotto and it's safe to say the filet was tender and was made with the correct temperature (medium well) and it was also well seasoned, however my lobster did not taste good at all, didn't care too much for the risotto as well. This is Definitely a place where I would eat at again, but like I said "I'll stick to just the appetizers"! read more

See all

Another fantastic meal at Captain Jakes. Sesame tuna, Jalepeno margarita & a steamed lobster on the Hudson with a full moon. Wonder staff, all are so friendly. ​ read more

Place was nice food wasn't bad was different service could of been better drink were on point nice view and ambiance read more

See all

I enjoyed everything and it was reasonably priced. Lobster was fresh and the Buffalo wings were cooked just right. Views by the water are available and definitely the best seat in the house read more

See all

A nice place to get a meal. Lobster rolls++ Great service. Nice veiw of the water and marina. read more

They weren't afraid to set up their outdoor din in g on a cloudy day, and it was perfect bro watch the storms roll by today under their trusty canopy with stunning views of the Hudson. Yummy beet salad with grilled shrimp, With just the right amount of dressing. My daughter had a delicious salmon burger. We shared the chowder , which was good but nothing imaginative. Friendly and prompt service. read more

See all

Well it is okay la, not to impressed expect the water. Blue pointe was packed . Sushi next door was empty. Three Restaurants are closed down read more

Captain Jake's - people sitting at a bar - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

SLOW?!?! The place is empty inside and a few on the porch and we have been here an hour with only drinks and soup....very good food but plan for a long wait :( Note: I have been reviewing restaurants on Yelp for a very long time and I have NEVER had someone call from the restaurant to argue with my review?!! I've had one owner or staff member argue with my review on Yelp...,but never a phone call to argue with my review :( We have been coming to James for Fathers Day and birthdays for a long time and have always gotten excellent food and good service....so when the place was sparse this afternoon I was totally shocked at how slow everything was. The lobster bisque was very good with a god amount of lobster chunks.....and my scallops were tender but slightly on the salty side....my husbands tuna was perfect and he enjoyed it!! Even tho we have been coming here for several years we won't be back as we don't spend money at establishments that call their customers after they leave and argue about the review?!?! Totally unacceptable!! Now I can also add RUDE and outrageous to the adjectives I've used here?! read more

So awesome.The food was excellent and very large.A great place to visit with family and has an excellent view of the river. Our waitress was very friendly and accommodated our needs without hassle. read more

This was our first time coming here and the place itself is really nice. Great views of the Hudson! Our service and food was pretty good too. My husband had the treasure chest appetizer which was huge! He enjoyed it. We also had the calamari which was good too. For dinner we ordered the stuffed lobster, salmon and shrimp with fries. Everything was tasty. The tarter sauce, which they say is homemade was good. A tad watery for what I'm used too. I also had the margarita which was really good! Strong though but still good. read more

Captain Jake's - Fried Calamari was really good! - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Captain Jakes is a fun place , lots of locals at the bar. The oysters are always fresh and change from time to time and enjoy trying anything new. The buffalo shrimp is a delicious app. Their soups are always good. Try the fish and chips or fish tacos! Recommend for a good food and great view of the Hudson River. read more