Literally picked this place based on proximity and yelp reviews. Walked in to a rustic home, with food beyond expectations. One plays was more delicious then the next. Our waiter was completely attentive, professional and efficient. Will be back for sure! read more

See all

Great dinner tonight! Had the Branzino. Prepared perfectly, flaky and crispy skin, excellent seasoning. To top it off, had the apple tartin with crème fraiche, excellent!! You need to stop in for dinner, meet Todd the manager, Ed the mixologist, and Monica, an excellent wait staff. You will not be disappointed. read more

The four of us had 6pm reservations, but really didn't seem like they were needed. Three of us ordered the special (scallops), and one the filet. All food was excellent and well priced. The tavern itself is a haven for history: one must make their way to the bar to see all the artifacts. I will certainly be back. read more

Wow! Getting stuck in traffic gave us the idea to just stop & eat & Yelpers helped us out! What a great dinner & dessert! Also great service! Can't wait to come back! No traffic necessary! read more

North Plank Road Tavern - Adorable garden! - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Dessert's here always hit the right spot. I Definitely recommend the Bread pudding. The staff is always great and at they're best. read more

See all

The food is amazing. I ordered the Truffle Stuffed Burrata Caprese for appetizer and Hanger Steak for main meal and the food was amazing and very tasty! The steak was a win win! For dessert I got the crème brûlée and again, did not disappoint. The staff was very friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

North Plank Road Tavern - Crème Brûlée - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

The food is the best I've had in this area! Flavors and presentation were magnificent! Filet mignon cooked perfectly! The service was wonderful! Monica is a superlative server, attentive and friendly! The restaurant is full of history, clean, comfortable, and cozy. Recommend highly.100% read more

Wonderful little secret of Newburgh, try a little taste of prohibition pleasure good food, great martinis, personal service, amazing music and decadent desserts! read more

See all

Gosh this place is just fantastic. Visited for their New Years Eve pice fixe and it was amazing. Carefully chosen menu with options for the adventurous and the play it safe. All noted with wonderful detail. Each course served was beautifully plated & perfectly prepared. I had the HV fois gras, cream of cremini mushroom soup, seared scallops (OMGGGG PERFECTION!) and crème brûlée. My husband had the smoked meat plate (duck Prosciutto!!), seafood stew, duck breast w blackberry reduction and chocolate mousse. It was just wowzers from start to finish. And not to be overlooked, the Service is top notch. Each staff member encountered was so friendly, professional and courteous. Great wine list too! Was also so pleased to see elevated mocktails on the menu as well! NA cosmopolitan & a NA mojito. Cannot wait to visit again! Thank you for such a wonderful experience! read more

Had this restaurant bookmarked a while and finally made it. We recieved a warm greeting by the owner upon arrival. Lenny waited on us and provided fabulous service. The food was delicious. I had the pork shoulder and burrata and my co-worker had the salmon. We also learned the tavern was originally a 13 room hotel off the highway in 1801. The current owner has turned the upstairs rooms into 4 rooms which are available to Airbnb. They are quite cozy and have a lovely ambiance and reasonably priced. I highly recommend a visit. They are closed on Mondays. read more

See all

Let me start by saying this restaurant has always been my favorite place to go for a special night out. Tonight was so disappointing. The manager was rude from the second we walked in even though we had a reservation. The pre-set Valentine's menu was $65 per person for 4 courses and the food was not good. The service was awful. After an hour and a half we had only gotten our first 2 courses. It took an hour to get soup! Our drinks never came. The food was cold. My favorite mushroom raviolis came drowning in a plate of butter. Everything was off. I'm beyond disappointed. I'm sorry but for that much money the food shouldn't be inedible. I don't know what went wrong. I tried so read more

A great historical gem! Great atmosphere with rustic charm. Amazing service and staff. Food was delicious and fabulous cocktails. Local history with a rich backstory. read more

Our party of 5 enjoyed an excellent meal, surrounded by rustic charm and attentive service from Shay. The tavern, built about 1801 has lot of history, the narrow entrance opens to a comfortable dining area. The inn, from stagecoach stop to bootleg booze, a little gambling, to fine restaurant has in interesting history. The current menu is not large, but add a few specials and we had a nice selection to choose from. We all enjoyed the well prepared selections, from perfectly cooked tender veal chop and light sauce with green beans, hanger steak ( cooked medium as requested) with rich gravy & potatoes to seafood selections. All at reasonable prices. The deserts were just as good. This is our new go to in the area. read more

See all

Wonderful food. The Smoked Chicken Carbonara was perhaps the best Carbonara aI've ever had- so rich and creamy and flavorful. The way the chicken was smoked was incredible. The salad we ordered had almost no dressing, and the entrees took a little bit from the kitchen. Otherwise the food was incredible and the tavern qas quaint, historic and wonderful. read more

My review will be in two parts. Pros & Cons. Pros: The food was delicious! I had an Old Fashioned. It was great! The complimentary bread & butter were so good! I ordered the Hanger Steak and it was perfect! However, My husband ordered lobster bisque soup and it was lukewarm. We should've sent it back. BIG PRO: they gave my daughter a kids meal AND a kids activity booklet! Cons: I love a building with history, but I still believe in upkeep! Peeling paint, exposed containers for moisture control and buckled wood on the walls all scream for maintenance! Considering the price of our meal I would've expected more. Our server let our water and bread run out and they didn't return for a long while (even though the restaurant was pretty empty) In summary, good food poor service & atmosphere. read more

See all

A bit disappointing. Good news Short rib entree was delicous. Tender with a wonderful rich sauce. Mash potatoes creamy. Our server (I think Monica is her name) was delightful. Charming spot. Medium news Onion soup was good. Bemelli, Carbonara style with smoked chicken. Pasta and sauce was good, thick, tasty and creamy but the chicken was very chewy making it inedible. (BTW, authenic carbonara doesn't use cream, that is alfredo). Harvest Salad A small arugula salad with just a "trace" amount of goat cheese (barely noticable) a few cherries and nuts. Dressing was light and flavorful. Not worth $13. Dark chocolate mousse. A nice flavor but dense and grainy. Bad news They had listed one vegan entree on their PDF menu. We went to this restaurant because it had a very good vegan option. It was for our daughters birthday! They no longer have a vegan entree option. So our daughter had a salad for her birthday dinner! Would have been important to update their online info! Glass of wine was expensive. $16 for a glass of chardonnay. read more

Ok, I am from out of town and a friend suggested we go to this restaurant. I love to eat out, and do not mind paying for a nice meal. The place itself is beautiful. My friends and I made a reservation and the place was practically empty at 6 pm. We ordered and the food which took about 45 minutes. All three of us ordered the Filet Mignon, one of the specials. So two of the meals came out fine. My steak was ordered medium, and came out well done. So, since it was a 40.00 plate, I sent it back. The next plate was barely rare. I sent it back again, and the steak was finally correct on the third time...but the sides were not even warm. It's like they just put a new steak on the same plate. By this point, we had been at the restaurant 2 hours. Ok, fine. So I ate a few bites of the steak and gave up. The owner came back and said, with a complete attitude...I took half of the meal off the bill. Seriously? I was completely shocked. I've had experiences before where they apologized profusely and paid for the dinner. We had to argue to get my meal removed. Originally the bill for the 3 of us was 242 dollars. This was not a cheap dinner. Our waitress was very nice. The cocktails were amazing. The dessert was fair. I was really looking forward to this. So, in the end I paid 100.00 including tip for my drinks, appetizer, and dessert. I'm not sure I could have been more disappointed. read more

North Plank Road Tavern - Filet Mignon, Sweet Potato, Green Beans - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Last night we attended an Argentine wine pairing. It was outstanding with courses based on Argentinian cuisine paired with excellent wines. I had never had a white Malbec before. It was great! The event was sold out. read more

North Plank Road Tavern - Short rib stuffed portobello mushroom - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Had a tremendous meal here, my wife and I were both very happy with our food and the service was fantastic

We LOVE the North Plank Tavern....great food, ambience and history all rolled into one! Everything we have had is good!!

Stopped tonight and saw on the special menu "cockles in a butter garlic cream sauce" and had to have them. OUTSTANDING!!!! read more

North Plank Road Tavern - a bowl of clams - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Ive wanted to try this place forever. Tonight we finally did. Such a beautiful place with friendly servers and the food was amazing! Lovely waitress told us all anout the history of this building. We just loved it Food was superb. read more

North Plank Road Tavern - Filet mignon . - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

A wonderful place! It's intimate feel, impeccable service, and everything was honestly delicious. And if you like French Onion soup, you MUST get it there! read more

Took a chance based on the reviews and were just so glad we did. This cute gastropub had the most wonderful staff and some seriously delicious eats. Appetizer: Chicken Caesar Salad - yummy Soup - butternut squash, maybe the only thing we could have done without Entrees: Brick Chicken - Cooked really well, mushroom sauce was AMAZING! Potatoes were also quite delicious Ribeye - cooked perfectly, flavorful and delicious. read more

After a year of moving up here from the city, I finally convinced my husband to go to North Plank Tavern! We decided to check it out during restaurant week and we were pleasantly surprised! We will definitely be visiting the tavern again! We started of with some great cocktails! I had a French martini and my husband had the special cider drink- which was soooo good. For appetizers I had arancini which were killer! They were topped with an amazing marinara sauce. They outside was super crispy and the inside warm and gooey. My husband had the grilled Caesar salad which was such a nice and different take on it. The dressing was great! For mains- I had the steak with mashed potatoes and asparagus! Yum! The steak was cooked a perfect medium with a delicious sauce. Everything was seasoned perfectly. My husband had the salmon which he loved! For desert I had creme brûlée- really good and my husband had the strawberry shortcake which was also great! The service was really good too! read more

See all

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! Started off with a Mrs. Sauer's cider and a jalapeño margarita. I honestly wasn't expecting anything great, and they were phenomenal! Christina is a fabulous bartender and takes great care of all her customers! James was also incredibly sweet. We just had the best time! Charcuterie board was great, but the entree took the cake! The filet- HOLY COW (Ha!) Cooked perfectly, flavors were exquisite, and potatoes and green beans were unreal. I am waiting on dessert now as I write this. Got the affogato and Irish coffee. I just couldn't wait to write a review. I am from Virginia and will make it a point to come back time and time again. See you in January, North Plank Road Tavern! read more

We stumbled upon this quaint restaurant that is loaded with history by accident. The owner couldn't be more accommodating, friendly and genuine. The food was beyond delicious and exceeded our expectations. The service was exceptional. The rich history and woodwork is fascinating. We are planning on coming back! read more

When we went to this place and hardly anyone was there, which was nice. Drinks were ok. I ordered the grilled Hanger steak with chimichurri sauce and it was sooo good! the appetizer special was tomato salad with burrata and truffle oil and that was delicious too! I order the beignets and they were too hard to cut or to eat, that was disappointing, but other than that it was an old type restaurant with a nice restaurant feel to it. We would go back there and maybe sit out in their patio next time. read more

See all

Call ahead for a reservation. We were visiting from out of town and would absolutely come back. The food was fantastic, all 7 people in our party loved their meals and it was well worth the wait. The service was also top notch, so attentive to us throughout the whole night. read more

So after a very brief pause The North Plank Road Tavern is back!!!! (9/22/2022) After hiring a new chef, the food is better then ever! Short Ribs fall off the bone. Appetizers and entrees are pure art on a plate. Tom and his staff have reinvented a new menu. Cannot wait to go back! Make sure you try the Ahi Tuna and or watermelon appetizer!!!! read more

Pros: unique and romantic ambiance delicious food with fresh ingredients Cons: Slow service Unable to split the group dinner bills (I think this is server dependent. We had a lady in her 50s) Specialty salad: garden tomato is sweet and delicious. Thumbs up. Mussels: delicious sauce, but the mussel size is a bit small and no toasted bread to supplement it. Salmon: such an elegant presentation, tastes like a comfort home meal Chocolate cake: not a molten lava cake, kinda dry for my taste read more

See all

O my gosh. Can you find a place that meets your frame of mind with a place in time with a menu/chef/owner/servers/heaven? Yes you can. It's here. Stop. Choose. Enjoy. Need I share what my taste buds required? No. You visit. You chose. I ate. well. This is a destination to enjoy. read more

See all

I was in Newburgh for the week, and this was a great find in a city that was lacking in interesting food options. The owner was a very nice gentleman, and I mentioned to him that it's a shame not too many people know about his establishment. I ended up going back a second time to take my cousin who took the train up from the city. Decor is cute and cozy; small and intimate with Rat Pack-type music playing--definitely apropos for the environment. Things I tried: (a) Mussels--portion was much bigger than I expected...quite delicious! Make sure to dip the bread in the broth! (b) Spicy crab bisque-- a bit nondescript. I do remember that the chives took away from the flavor of the crab. (c) Lamb--the crust was quite good, though it was better the first time around. (d) Creme brulee--nothing special I do hope this place lasts. There aren't a lot of what you would consider "fine dining" for the area, and since they don't market too much in the neighborhood, they mainly rely on word of mouth and Yelp to get diners in. I do know I would come back if I ever make it back in the area. read more

The history in this building alone makes it worth the visit. Sit at the bar and converse with the bartender who is the son of the owner. He can tell you stories about how it used to be and the many businesses it's been over the years. Bar, boarding house, brothel and even a moonshine operation run by notorious gangsters. He also serves up some delicious specialty cocktails. Antique pictures and memorabilia abound on the walls and that alone is worth the visit, but not to forget the food and service were also top shelf. Excellent attentive service keeping water glass or other beverages topped off and a smooth transition between salad apps and the meal followed by a generous dessert selection. All in all I've been there three times and will definitely return. read more

So thankful they were able to accommodate our family. We were in town for a memorial and had forgotten to reserve a restaurant for dinner, they accommodated 10 of us and served fabulous food. The octopus appetizer was fab! The beet salad was too. read more

What an excellent experience. The atmosphere was excellent and the food was delicious. The owner went out of his way to ensure that my dining experience and stay in the apartment above was a great one. I would highly recommend this place. read more

The food is fresh, in perfect portion sizes. I suggest trying the daily specials which, according to Hudson Valley Magazine are inspired by and made with ingredients that chef Tibor Kogler bought that day/week: bit.ly/19lfwdR Thoughtful Historic Newburgh decor - make sure that you see the bar! Great service. Overpriced for location and lack of a Hudson River view. read more

Excellent! The decor is trendy, yet comfortable. The noise level was perfect for conversation. The food was delicious and their customer service was incredible. Our server was attentive as well as efficient. He didn't even write down our orders yet he was spot on down to the choice of dressing on our salads! We were impressed. read more

I was recommended to come here by a friend. I brought my girlfriend. When we drive up we didn't know what to expect. The location was a little unusual (almost in a suburban area), the building was a house. We walked into a very narrow hallway and once we got to the main area, we were blown away. The decor was very nice and "cool". It had a classy but anitque ambience. The servers were very friendly, we had a reservation but showed up late. Most importantly the food was delicious. read more

North Plank Road Tavern - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Had a fabulous night at North Plank Tavern with friends - the vegetarian- friendly entrees were wonderful - had a lovely dessert. We'll return! read more

North Plank Road Tavern - Had a wonderful meal at North Plank Tavern! As vegetarians we had amazing tastes and textures. Thanks! - New American Near Me - Newburgh, New York