The Tomato Cafe

Absofuckinglutely love their pizza!!! Makes stay takeout , only couple of small tables inside…read more Service is always great and prices are good!!

Wife and I were visiting from Chicago. We both craved NY style thin, slightly soggy cheese pizza…read morewhile in the Beacon area. We found Pizza and Stuff via Yelp. Pizza was great, and the prices were throw backs to 20 years ago; 4 slices plus a Snapple for $15! Delicious and brought back memories of our time on the Upper West Side of Manhattan.

Inside

USD for comparison

See all

Sal's Pizza & Pasta

3.4(82 reviews)

0.5 mi

Everything they make is excellent. Fresh, high quality ingredients prepared perfectly. Placed a…read morelarge to delivery order and everything arrived piping hot. Staff is very friendly and helpful if you decide to eat on premises. The place has been in business for many years for a reason. Would highly recommend.

Tried the Penne Vodka pizza slice from Sal's Pizzeria in Fishkill in between meetings my mom and I…read morehad and wow... I was skeptical at first because I'm very picky when it comes to pizza, but this slice was absolutely delicious. The crust was crisp, the vodka sauce had great flavor, and the penne on top made it such a fun and satisfying twist on a classic slice. Definitely exceeded my expectations and I'd order it again! Our waitress was really sweet and attentive. The restaurant was had a nice rustic vibe.

There's a full bar, where you can also eat.

Mid August 2026 slice with sweet sausage

See all

The bar and beer taps

Florina’s Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

4.2(179 reviews)

2.8 mi

Wonderful pizza, pasta and more. One of our faves! We usually pick up ourselves, but we…read moreunderstand that they do deliver as well.

This place is a major player in the pizza scene of the southern Dutchess area…read more Who knew, you could find Brooklyn pizza in Dutchess County. I don't think the owners are even aware they make good Brooklyn pizza. They're just eager to please their clientele. They offer a broad variety of pizza combinations and the talented pizza slingers will create a pie to suit your taste with any combination from their arsenal of flavorful toppings. The pizza is on point from first bite to crust, also there is nothing disappointing about their menu from appetizers to entrees... WELCOME TO FLAVORTOWN oh I meant Florina's. They put most of their effort towards the menu rather than decor. The place is a simple pizzeria decor and exceptionally clean. It's a 4 table establishment and the locals know it, so they pump out massive amounts of deliveries and pick up orders. Their pride is proven in every bite. It's road trip worthy and if passing through it's a must stop by. YUMMY TUMMY!

9/14/25 - new dining area

Garlic knots

See all

9/14/25 - new tables and beverage case

Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.4(130 reviews)

0.3 mi

It was over 102° and with 4 pizza ovens on and the kitchen going it was too much for the AC. It was…read morea bit warm in the dining room. You usually need a sweater or long sleeves in the dining room. Otherwise, everything came out well. The shrimp scampi had enough pasta to feed three people, and it was al dente and excellent. Plenty of juicy succulent shrimp. The salmon Mediterranean style was moist and flavorful and also quite a substantial survey. Sean, the server, tries to make everyone feel comfortable and appreciated. It seems everybody knows him, by name. They have delivery and do catering.

We decided to come here, their slices are enormous and good. The cheese melts in your mouth, which…read moreI happen to love For all the times we have been here the service gets to know you.

4/7/26 - beer, wine, and glassware with their logo.

9/4/25 - Stromboli

See all

12/26/25 - Shrimp Scampi over Linguini

AMA Wood Fired Kitchen And Bar

4.0(82 reviews)

1.8 mi

Despite being a Beaconite and able to walk to the one on Main Street, we opt to drive to this…read morelocation far more frequently. The menu is much larger and more interesting - the pastas are solid. One of my dining compatriots even went way off brand once and had a burger and the review (positive) was surprising! While AMA isn't full on Italophile Italian, it is excellent hybrid Italophile/Italian American. The pizzas are great (be prepared for a liberal dose of garlic, which is never a bad thing in my book.) The staff is attentive and service is good - not rushed, not fussy. It is a big space and comfortable.

We stopped by Wood Fired AMA Kitchen & Bar after a fun day of apple picking nearby, and it turned…read moreout to be a great choice. The staff was warm and welcoming, and they went out of their way to accommodate our large group of eleven, which was much appreciated. I was admittedly a little distracted watching my New York Yankees get mollywhopped by the Blue Jays on TV, so I forgot to snap a picture of the bread strips served with marinara sauce. But they were a pleasant surprise ; warm, soft, and perfect for dipping into that flavorful sauce. For my main dish, I ordered the L'Americano burger. It wasn't the best burger I've ever had, but it was still really enjoyable and satisfying. The fries on the side were classic and hit the spot. All in all, I had a really good time here. Between the friendly service, solid food, and relaxed atmosphere, I'd definitely come back the next time I'm in the area.

Lasagna

Entrance of Restaurant

See all

Beautiful room and open wood oven in back

Pizza Phil

3.4(35 reviews)

1.6 mi

I would like to commend Pizza ville for there. Great service and delicious food…read more My brother is in Taconic nursing home and I placed an order for fried calamari and it was delicious They are so accommodating and could not be nicer. . His calamari was hot and delicious. And the Pizza was equally as good. Thank you, Pizza, phill.

I've been stopping in over the years; Phil is always there…read more It's the kind of place where you don't realize it, but you're acquiring happy memories. It's like going back to the old neighborhood, and finding some things are still the same. That doesn't happen too often. My old neighborhood; 60 miles south of here, is no longer there in a sense. The streets and avenues are, but none of the people or the businesses exist anymore. The inside doesn't seem to change much, same tables and chairs, and art work on the walls. There's table service, plenty of parking outside, when the weather is nice, you could sit out there under the overhang, and watch the world go by. I can't say much about the other items on the menu; I stick with the special: 2 slices & a fountain soda. It's more than enough for me. There's catering, and delivery.

Dining area

2 slices and a soda special $9.

See all

12/11/25 - menu

Trattoria Locanda

4.1(271 reviews)

0.0 mi

Food was superb! The bread was homemade with an eggplant relish in extra virgin olive oil! The…read morepumpkin ravioli in roasted red pepper sauce was exquisite! My New York strip steak was well seasoned but I should have ordered the rare instead of medium rare! My friends had Zuppe de Pesce which was succulent with mussels, shrimp and calamari! The other friend had whole wheat penne on a vodka sauce and the chicken parmagino! For desert dark chocolate gelato with a hazelnut biscotti! Red wine and water was plentiful! Randy our server, bartender and Maitre'Dee was from Queens but knew Fishkill Revolution art history about the battle of Boston and the fight at Fort Green! His knowledge of the Fishkill Church's that served as prisons and supply depot was impressive! Service was above excellent. Cordial, friendly and helpful! Ambiance with Swing music, Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin was comforting on a sunny afternoon at the front window table! A great place to bring your friends as parking is amble in the back! I was lucky and got Main Street parking in the right direction! I would definitely go again as this is fine dinning

Excellent food, great service, relaxing atmosphere. I tried this place because it had good reviews…read moreon Yelp. Glad I did. It was one of the best Italian meals I've had in a long time.

See all

Laby's Pizzeria

3.7(28 reviews)

2.0 mi

We go here all the time..This is our favorite pizza place.We usually eat here a few times a week.We…read morestop on the way home for a quick piece of pizza.One pice is all we need.I get pepperoni and my friend gets just cheese.It is sooo good.And the people that work there are so nice to.They know us now.so they know what we what. I like going in there because it is friendly.You can talk to anyone.I am a talker.I come from Tennessee and I am friendly.So I like to talk to people.That is one thing i like.Some of the people especially the ones that work there talk to you. If you love pizza try this place.And if you like a cozy place to eat it come here.They deliver too.Or you can pick up.They have a whole variety of food you can get not just pizza.They do italion.It is good.

It's your neighborhood pizzeria, nothing fancy, and not too expensive either. $3.50 a slice. It…read morewas crisp and hot. The owner(?) will bring your order over to the table. Still a $10. minimum on credit cards.

6/12/25 - counter

Chick parm - STUFFED w/chicken

See all

6/12/25 - tables, there are tables outside, too.

Red Line Diner

3.9(945 reviews)

0.7 mi

It's been a while since we were here last. I don't know what I will order. Something different…read more It's crowded today so we are waiting for a table. I ordered a Manhattan Clam Chowder and a salado. I went light today But still filling.

Stopped for lunch, on the way back from an appointment…read more This place is always busy; varied menu, great food, attentive service, need I say more? The portions are more than ample, service is impeccable and friendly. I don't know what else to add. They never disappoint

12/1/25 - another dining area

Fettuccine Carbonara

See all

1/28/26 - lunch counter

Domino's Pizza

1.7(30 reviews)

0.1 mi

Really is a shame this place currently has a 1.6. Honestly, it is the best Domino's pizza I've ever…read moreordered from. Definitely a 5 star Dominos. Now the reviews complain about delivery and to be fair pizza delivery in Dutchess County has been terrible for decades. I don't recall my family getting pizza delivered after about 1995. Pickup is the way to go, and clearly true here as well. In any case I've been ordering on and off from this branch since 2020, and really the last year or so they are on point. Pizzas baked quickly (like 10 minutes tops) very nicely crisped. And you can tell the staff is just cranking them out. Highly recommend this Domino's.

Trying to start a new scam. They cancelled part of my order and refuse to credit me back. Good…read moreluck finding someone who cares and you have to take it up with your credit card and start a fraud claim. Horrible business.

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

25 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kris C.

10 years ago

Solid food and drinks served at Tomato cafe. We go quite often and are always satisfied with our meals, although never "wowed!" Service is usually good (some servers are much better than others) and sometimes the kitchen goes a little crazy banging on that bell for the servers (which drives me absolutely nuts) I wish they were open later during the week, we like to go out around 8 but I've found that when we go to the Tomato at that time the staff is always pushing us out and even sits down behind us and eats all together instead of paying attention to paying customers. read more

Elena R.

8 years ago

Went for dinner....VERY small portions , food is good but you may need to order something else. Pizza is OK, I wouldn't recommend pizza. Salads are good and portion is OK. The entrees are very small. I think it may be good for lunch. We are not very big eaters but we left hungry. read more

Eliza M.

10 years ago

DELICIOUS! Coffee was fantastic, pancakes were perfect, (had a little citrus twist, but I loved it) and the bacon was perfect. Service was good and we were seated immediately on a Sunday morning. They have outdoor and indoor options and prices were very reasonable. read more

Marinna Y.

12 years ago

Always a good meal, never had anything I didn't like. I would recommend Tomato Cafe as a consistenetly great lunch spot. You know what your going to get and it's going to be good. read more

M S.

5 years ago

You get to choose full or half portion, that's a plus. Good breakfast menu. Parking at the back or side street. You might have to walk a bit. Recommend. read more

Anthony A.

6 years ago

Amazing service and amazing food! The staff is extremely pleasant to be around, and everything on their menu tastes very good. 10/10 recommended! read more

Robert B.

13 years ago

Great place - food is top notch! We have never had a bad meal here! I will say it is definitely a lunch or casual meal place though! read more

Jon H.

15 years ago

When I have people visiting I always take them here. Great service. Great food. Best of all reasonably priced.

Martin B.

12 years ago

great food!! very reasonable!! great service!! pesto pasta is a must have!! will definitely return again !!! read more

Thomas O.

240

119

1284

5 years ago

Fantastic food. Very large portions. Very good service. Inside and outside seating! Desserts are excellent.

Steve G.

211

9 years ago

Been here three times. The food and the service have been top notch each time! Definitely recommend it.

Susan H.

4 years ago

Very good. Service is fantastic. Selections are good but could be a little more varied. Very reasonable

Michael E.

11 years ago

Good pizza and more. Love there salads and sandwiches to. Nice place to get good food at a good price.

Connor L.

4 years ago

did not give me my full order do not remmcomebs this place i do t think they even gave us a recit.

Jackie H.

11 years ago

My daughter loves to stop here with me for lunch... we both enjoy the food

Gwen B.

Elite 19

13 years ago

The "almost famous" eggplant cakes are THE BEST! Good salads, too.

Lilly D.

192

9 years ago

Family Favorite. You cant go wrong with anything on the menu.

Becky R.

14 years ago

Best restaurant on main st in Fishkill! Delicious and fresh!!

C A.

10 years ago

This place has great service, is clean and good food.

Meghan W.

15 years ago

I have dreams about their rice balls - soooo good!

The Tomato Cafe - pizza - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Fishkill, New York Restaurants near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Coffee near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Parking near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Things to Do near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Breakfast near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Desserts near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Dinner near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Burgers near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Shopping near The Tomato Cafe

BEST of Fishkill, New York Movie Theatre near The Tomato Cafe

Best of Fishkill

Things to do in Fishkill

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed The Tomato Cafe also viewed

Lola's Cafe

4.5

(302 reviews)

To borrow a phrase from one of the merch shirts they had, Lola's is a joint you won't want to pass…read moreon. I visited Lola's Cafe with my sister while walking on the Walkway over the Hudson Trail, in fact, if you're on the trail and go down the staircase that points to downtown Poughkeepsie Lola's is right to your left when you get off the staircase. We ate the autumn, chicken salad, wrap, and the Baja chicken wrap. My sister is gluten-free and was delighted they had menus with their gluten free, vegetarian and vegan options. The staff member who took our orders was kind and generous in his service. Interestingly they also sell coffee beans, merch, and to-go foods from their kitchen. On my next visit, I look forward to trying the cheesecake and one of their bowls, paninis, or salads!

We've been here a few times and have enjoyed the food, casual atmosphere, friendly staff and…read moreproximity to the Walkway. This is a local chain and the one in New Paltz is also great. You order at the counter and take a seat at the counter or tables. Their menu offers reasonably priced sandwiches, salads, and grab and go baked goods, including separate menus for vegans. We enjoyed the special chicken tzaziki wrap, salmon salad (tender and tasty), the vegan quinoa bowl was ok but a bit small and not too exciting. They also were preparing catering offers and there was a pretty constant stream of customers. The space is rather small but we got there at a good time to find seating. They also have a tap water station. There's only gender neutral bathroom, which makes for a little wait at times. Street parking and a small lot a short walk away.

Patsy’s Pizzeria

3.8

(76 reviews)

Just like the original in New York City, Patsy's Pizzeria in Wappingers Falls serves quality…read moreItalian fare with fresh ingredients and excellent service. My wife is a vegetarian and wanted a risotto. But she hates mushrooms, so they made a fresh vegetable medley risotto. I had the large Margherita pie which was PERFECT. The coal oven here is phenomenal. The ambiance is a bit dated, but tried and true works in this environment! Overall brilliant experience with just incredible food.

We just had a 35 person wedding at Patsy's restaurant and it was a phenomenal time. Clif, Philip…read moreand Lori were absolutely wonderful from the planning to the day of. They were so kind to our vendors and helped them load in and get settled in the space that was new to all since they were from out of town. They helped with so much, set up note cards, napkins, correct table settings, and really made the room shine. We had the time of our lives dancing all night. Dinner was 5 courses and could not have heard more compliments from my guests. Clif made the best tiramisu cake and it was gorgeous with our stencil! They made the night SO special for me and my husband!!!! So many of our guests said it was the best and funnest wedding they have ever been too... given the intimate nature and intentionality of it. The staff was so friendly and so attentive to each table they were assigned. The kitchen did amazing and we did delicious to go pizzas at the end of the evening! IT WAS PERFECT! We are so grateful for the amazing help in planning and choosing the perfect menu. Our day was so special and we are forever grateful to the team!!!

Cosimo's Poughkeepsie

4.1

(456 reviews)

Food quality / price (value) rating 9. The atmosphere is contemporary modern. The menu is Italian…read more/ pub fusion with modern twists on tavern favorites. The venue itself is art deco style, kept immaculately clean (including the restrooms). I had the Grilled Chicken sandwich with avocado and aioli sauce, with Tuscan fries (house cut I'm told) both of which were very good. The wife had the Honey Chicken Ginger Salad and we both agreed that it was excellent. Our server, Jenny, deftly handled the full bar, the bar dining area, and the drink orders for the entire restaurant. There was a dessert special of Italian Lemon Cake offerred, but unfortunately, I couldn't convince my wife to split it. The prices were very reasonable, and the food was very good. We'll definitely come back.

It slightly pains me to write this review, as my first experience at Cosimo's was soooooo good…read more Let's get on with it tho. We visited on the Friday before V-day, the house was packed around 18:30. The wait was 45 mins which wasn't too bad for a Friday night. We decided to wait in the lobby after trying to find a cozy waiting spot near the bar and missing. My wife attempted to order me a mocktail, but of course the bar was crazy busy. When the bartender finally acknowledged her, the mocktail requests obviously threw the bartender for a loop because I ended up with watered down ginger beer and a sprig of mint. My advice for anyone looking for a virgin drink at this bar would be to order a club soda with lime and call it a night. We were seated at the 45 min mark, and were escorted to the packed bar, where they have some exterior tables for diners. My seat was in the middle of the couch split, which I found mighty uncomfortable so we opted to request a seat in the main dining room, which the staff happily obliged. With dinner we ordered hot tea and were given lukewarm water and a choice of Stash teas. Our beverage experience here was very disappointing. The calamari arrived and may have been the only highlight, although we didn't find it to have that fresh calamari texture. My wife ordered a ravioli with mushroom, and felt the pasta and veggies were just swimming in butter. I ordered my steak medium and it was okay, but the juices from the greens made the croquettes soggy, and unenjoyable. The server did his best, and all the staff here are so kind. Coulda been an off night but I doubt we'll be back anytime soon. The Mocktail Madam.

Beacon Quality Eats

4.4

(418 reviews)

Such an unique and fun experience. A rotation of delight. Very clean, friendly staff and nicely put…read moretogether dishes.

stopped here after taking a hike for some refreshing sandwiches. I got the spicy turkey wrap which…read moreI thought was really yummy and filling, but it wasn't very spicy and my boyfriend got the Reuben. He really liked it, but he thought it could have more meat. The service here was really great. Everyone was super friendly and offered suggestions and we loved sitting in the outdoor area outback..

Pizza E Birra

4.1

(32 reviews)

Had not been here in a while but stopped in for dinner last night. Focaccina sandwich chicken…read morecutlet was breaded and fried to perfection. So food is still consistent. Nice atmosphere. Bright, clean , airy. Prices are reasonable. I would highly recommend this place .

We came in on a rainy day, and were sat right away. Wasn't sure what to expect but it was…read moredelicious, and our waitress was very friendly. There's a lot of seating and it's a great spot to watch sports. We ordered BBQ wings and 2 rounds of Hawaiian pizza. My kids do not like pineapples on pizza but they devoured these!

Mamma Mia Cafe & Pizzeria

4.5

(6 reviews)

My husband and I had dinner at Mamma Mia earlier this week, and it was hands-down the best pasta…read moresauce we've ever had. Rich, perfectly balanced, and clearly made with love--it's the kind of sauce you remember long after the meal is over. I ordered the special with eggplant rollatini, chicken parm, and penne vodka, and it was incredibly generous--so generous that we happily enjoyed leftovers the next day. Every bite was comforting, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. My husband had the pasta Bolognese, which was equally outstanding--hearty, savory, and deeply satisfying. Beyond the food, the café itself feels warm and welcoming, the kind of place you want to linger. The owners are absolute delights, adding a personal, family-style touch that makes the whole experience even more special. We can't recommend Mamma Mia enough and are already looking forward to our next visit.

I now have a favorite salad! Was in the area for a networking event and decided to try out a salad…read more I had the Asian Mandarin salad and it was amazing-- it has mandarin and almonds, radish, fresh greens, their famous grilled chicken and a delicious sesame dressing. The greens are super fresh. The grilled chicken is well cooked but super juicy. The owner is wonderful. The service was great, everyone was kind and helpful. The ambiance is friendly.

The Dutch Crown

4.2

(55 reviews)

Very good pizza with fast and friendly service. Great craft beer selection. Has a cross between a…read morerestaurant and a dive bar vibe inside. Great place.

We found Dutch Crown through the Karpo App, which highlighted their excellent sourdough crust, so…read morewe decided to give it a try. The restaurant is a small establishment with street parking only, but we were able to find a spot without too much trouble. Walking in, the atmosphere was pretty simple and straightforward. There wasn't anything particularly memorable about the décor, and it reminded me of a neighborhood bar from the 1980s. That said, it was clean, comfortable, and felt like a casual local spot. The service was one of the highlights of our visit. Everyone was friendly, our order was taken quickly, and the staff was attentive throughout our meal. We both ordered build-your-own pizzas, and while they were good, the crust wasn't quite what we expected. The sourdough crust was actually the thinnest pizza crust I've ever had and didn't have the fermented sourdough flavor or texture I've experienced elsewhere. I was also a little disappointed that there wasn't a vegan cheese option, especially considering the extensive menu and variety of toppings available. That said, the pizzas were enjoyable, but both of us tend to prefer a slightly thicker crust. If you're a fan of ultra-thin crust pizza, Dutch Crown will likely be right up your alley. While it wasn't exactly what we were expecting based on the sourdough description, the friendly service and quality ingredients still made for a pleasant dining experience.

Aloy's Italian Restaurant

3.9

(66 reviews)

Best shrimp scampi ever! Service is speedy and friendly…read more I'll be back with more friends.

I love going to this restaurant! My dad went here as a kid and it's always nice to stop by when I'm…read morehome in NY

Leo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.3

(91 reviews)